← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Secondary Breast Cancer — [Mr Clive Betts in the Chair]
11 June 2026
Lead MP
Clive Jones
Responding Minister
Sharon Hodgson
Tags
NHS
Word Count: 11504
Other Contributors: 8
At a Glance
Clive Jones raised concerns about secondary breast cancer — [mr clive betts in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
The lead MP asks the Minister to outline a timeline for implementing the national cancer plan's commitment to defining and counting recurrent cancers, starting with metastatic breast cancer by 2026. Additionally, he enquires about plans to make data from the national disease registration service publicly available and measures to support patients missing out on life-extending medicines due to pricing barriers.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
The speaker is concerned about the under-recognition and poor tracking of secondary breast cancer in the UK. He highlights that approximately 61,000 people are living with this disease but exact numbers remain uncertain due to insufficient data collection. This lack of reliable information hinders proper planning of NHS services and allocation of resources. The speaker also mentions delays in treatment and access issues for life-extending medications like Enhertu.
Adam Jogee
Lab
Newcastle-under-Lyme
I am here to add my voice to the calls for action, support the More Time to Live campaign, and pay tribute to Breast Cancer Now.
Ashley Dalton
Lab
Liverpool West Derby
Discussed the realities and myths surrounding secondary breast cancer, highlighting its incurability and the importance of accurate terminology. Acknowledged the need for better data collection to understand patient numbers and improve services. Called for progress on developing world-class research facilities and access to new drugs through NICE criteria changes.
Caroline Johnson
Con
Sleaford and North Hykeham
Caroline Johnson congratulated MPs on securing the debate and praised Ashley Dalton's speech. She highlighted the uncertainty around data for secondary breast cancer, calling for an update on data collection from 2026 and asking how frequently it would be published. She inquired about plans to expand screening services, workforce needs, and genetic testing availability. Johnson also raised concerns about the reorganisation of integrated care boards due to budget cuts and NHS England's abolition under the Health Bill, questioning if this is slowing progress on the cancer plan. She asked for updates on research funding for lobular breast cancer and discussed issues facing hospices regarding national insurance contributions and staff shortages.
Helen Maguire
Liberal Democrats
She highlighted that secondary breast cancer is the leading cause of death for women aged 40 to 49 in the UK, with around 1,000 people losing their lives each month. Helen called for better data collection and publication on secondary breast cancer cases to ensure accurate assessment of needs and appropriate planning of services. She noted that over 23% of respondents had to see their GP three or more times before diagnosis, while only 53% received sufficient information about clinical trials.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Each month in the UK, around 1,000 people die from secondary breast cancer, which equates to one life every 45 minutes. The drug Enhertu is available in Scotland and other European countries but not in England, Wales or Northern Ireland. There are also significant wait times for urgent referrals in Northern Ireland with only 6.8% seen within the 14-day target.
John Milne
Lab
Basingstoke
Mr Milne highlighted the lack of data and research on secondary lobular breast cancer, which affects 22 people daily in the UK. He noted that this form of cancer often goes undetected due to its unique growth patterns and is under-researched compared to ductal breast cancer. Mr Milne also emphasised the importance of dedicated treatment pathways and called for £20 million over five years for research into lobular breast cancer, which currently relies on medications designed for other cancers costing up to £3,000 per month.
Mary Foy
Lab
Worcestershire South
Mary Foy highlighted the importance of secondary breast cancer data collection and accurate recording across the country. She raised concerns about inconsistencies in treatment access, particularly with NICE's assessment methods for life-extending treatments like Enhertu. Foy also praised hospice support but noted that one-third of people do not receive end-of-life care needs. She called on the Government to ensure consistent data collection, patient access to named contacts, and equitable treatment availability.
North East Fife
She thanked the hon. Member for West Lancashire and congratulated her colleagues on securing the debate, sharing her personal experience with breast cancer. Wendy highlighted the specific challenges of lobular breast cancer, noting that 22 people are diagnosed daily but may not be detected by standard tests. She called for dedicated research funding of £20 million over five years and urged devolved governments to contribute as well.
Government Response
Sharon Hodgson
Government Response
The minister highlighted the importance of data in empowering patients and researchers. She committed to improving data collection for recurrent cancers, starting with metastatic breast cancer as part of the national cancer plan. The National Disease Registration Service is working on this issue by developing new algorithms and collaborating with NHS trusts and charities. A health data research service will be established by the end of the year to provide a secure single access point for researchers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.