Thirlwall Inquiry Terms of Reference

Opened the debate

The MP raised serious concerns about the Lucy Letby case, highlighting institutional self-preservation over justice. He discussed the Thirlwall inquiry's narrow scope and called for a broader examination of staffing crises, poor clinical management, and environmental risks. Davis emphasised that systemic NHS failures must be addressed to prevent future tragedies and miscarriages of justice. The speech detailed staff shortages, hospital contamination issues, and infections affecting newborns, calling for the inquiry to examine credible alternative hypotheses.

Government Response

The Minister responded on behalf of the Government, expressing sympathy for families affected by the events at the Countess of Chester hospital. She highlighted that Lucy Letby’s convictions are judicial decisions and emphasised the independence of the legal process. The minister stated there is no case to amend or expand the Thirlwall inquiry's terms of reference based on current information. There is a separate CCRC review, and the Government will not intervene in this independent process. She reaffirmed that the inquiry will proceed without suspension, aiming for transparency and timely resolution. The Minister also mentioned ongoing work to support NHS leadership development and accountability through legislative measures.