House of Commons · Westminster Hall
26 June 2025 · 1 other contributor · 1,915 words
Opened by Alex Sobel Labour (Co-op) Leeds Central and Headingley
Responding minister: Seema Malhotra
Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.
Alex Sobel raised concerns about legislative scrutiny: border security, asylum and immigration bill in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key points
Key requests to Government
The Committee proposes amendments to address issues such as clarity of clauses, introduction of mental elements in certain offences, and recommendations for repeal or amendment of specific sections to ensure compliance with human rights obligations.
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.
Opened the debate
The Committee welcomes the intention of the Bill to prevent loss of life at sea and deter organised immigration crime. However, it is concerned that some new offences pose a risk of criminalising refugees and other vulnerable groups, which may interfere with rights under the refugee convention and the European convention on human rights. The provisions could extend beyond the Government’s stated legitimate aim and inadvertently criminalise persons who should be protected.
Sobel acknowledged an increase in asylum claims related to religious persecution but did not have specific figures. He suggested that the Government should review its list of safe countries with regard to individuals' ability to practise their religion safely.
Government Response
Seema MalhotraThe Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Home Department
Minister Seema Malhotra thanked Jim Shannon and acknowledged the Committee's work on the report. She assured that the Government is reviewing the report in detail and will respond formally at a later date.