Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

NHS Funding: South-west

11 June 2025 · 19 other contributors · 9,164 words

Opened by Steve Darling Lib Dem Torbay

Responding minister: Karin Smyth

NHS

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Steve Darling raised concerns about nhs funding: south-west in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • NHS funding situation includes a 6.6 billion budget shortfall for hospital programmes.
  • Steve Darling asks the Minister to address funding for Torbay Hospital and provide guidance on ICB mergers.
  • The Minister confirms additional investment of 889 million and a 10-year health plan.

Key requests to Government

Steve Darling asks for the Minister to address the wave 2 mitigation bids, particularly regarding funding for Torbay Hospital and guidance on ICB mergers in the area.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Steve Darling Lib Dem Torbay

The NHS funding situation is dire, with a £6.6 billion hole in the hospital programme's budget and significant challenges at Torbay Hospital, including outdated facilities, sewage leaks, and structural issues. The pressures on staff are immense due to these conditions.

Other contributors (19)
  • Alison Bennett LD Mid Sussex

    The Liberal Democrats believe that people deserve better access to care and are introducing plans to invest early in community health services, GPs, pharmacists, and dentists.

  • Andrew George LD St Ives

    Discusses funding issues in Cornwall, including a £108 million cost improvement which is seen as a budget cut, and highlights value-for-money projects like the Helston Gateway project.

  • Ben Maguire LD North Cornwall

    Appalled at the Chancellor’s spending review, highlighting crumbling hospitals in North Devon and cuts to bus routes affecting cancer patient access to Derriford hospital. Proposed a rural fund for GPs, dentists, and pharmacists.

  • Caroline Voaden LD South Devon

    It is much more expensive to provide services in rural areas than in urban areas due to factors such as footfall for pharmacies, which struggles with reaching the national payment threshold.

  • Caroline Johnson Con Sleaford and North Hykeham

    The hon. Member discusses the need for efficient use of NHS funding, particularly in underserved regions like the south-west. She questions how efficiencies worth £9 billion will be achieved and expresses concern over the restructuring of ICBs.

  • Edward Morello LD West Dorset

    NHS Dorset is being asked to cut staff by 50% on top of previous cuts of 30%. The trust has requested £14 million in additional financial support but remains £22 million short of its funding target. There is a pressing need for capital investment in digital infrastructure.

  • Fred Thomas Lab Plymouth Moor View

    The hon. Member raises concerns about patient access to ADHD assessments in Plymouth, questioning whether some GPs are blocking access through shared care agreements.

  • Gideon Amos LD Taunton and Wellington

    Highlights the pressures on Musgrove Park hospital due to closures, with staff facing extreme conditions. Agrees that NHS staff are crucial.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Supports Steve Darling's initiative and asks about potential savings through administration in the south-west trust area.

  • Discussed funding allocations for Devon and Cornwall, exceeding regional averages. Mentioned the debt write-off for NHS England in Torbay's constituency.

  • Lloyd Hatton Lab South Dorset

    Welcomed the investment of £100 million for rebuilding the emergency department and critical care unit at Dorset County Hospital, emphasizing its importance in driving down waiting lists.

  • Martin Wrigley LD Newton Abbot

    Highlights the crisis in GP funding, noting that practices are struggling due to inadequate global sum and quality outcomes framework payments.

  • Noah Law Lab St Austell and Newquay

    Welcomes comments on ICB mergers, noting unique challenges for Devon and Cornwall. Emphasizes the importance of considering local specifics like rurality and deprivation.

  • Rachel Gilmour LD Tiverton and Minehead

    Addressed funding shortfalls in GP practices and dental deserts in coastal west Somerset. Emphasized the need to provide locally based training colleges for healthcare professionals.

  • Rebecca Smith Con South West Devon

    The Devon Integrated Care Board is not funding fertility treatment in line with NICE guidelines, limiting women under 40 to only a portion of one cycle rather than the full three recommended cycles. This creates a postcode lottery for patients.

  • Richard Foord LD Honiton and Sidmouth

    ICB funding formula overemphasises the size of each ICB and the registered population but does not account sufficiently for age-related costs, which vary by region. Asked if the Minister would give way.

  • Ashley Fox Con Bridgwater

    Expressed concerns over the difficulty of getting GP appointments and NHS dental care. Suggested that pay increases must come with improved productivity and service quality.

  • Tom Hayes Lab Bournemouth East

    The Government has recruited 1,700 new GPs and delivered 3.5 million new appointments, reducing waiting lists by over 200,000. Dorset ICB has seen significant improvements with extra urgent dental appointments and a public health grant increase.

  • Wera Hobhouse LD Bath

    Points out that independent sector providers have capacity but are not being fully utilised, leading to wasted slots for NHS patients.

Government Response

Karin Smyth

The Minister for Secondary Care

The Minister acknowledges the importance of addressing challenges in NHS funding and restructuring. She highlights a £29 billion increase in day-to-day health spending and a £2.3 billion real-terms increase in capital spending over the review period, aiming to put the NHS on a sustainable footing. Confirmed additional investment of £889 million and a10-year health plan. Mentioned allocations totalling £448 million in operational capital, £238 million from the constitutional standards recovery fund, and £83 million from the estates safety fund for vital improvements. Highlighted specific amounts such as £7.3 million for Torbay hospital, £10 million for primary care estate improvements, and almost £5 million to help reduce inappropriate out-of-area placements.

Get updates like this by email
▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy