Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Rural Communities: Government Support

12 March 2025 · 22 other contributors · 10,076 words

Opened by Caroline Voaden Lib Dem South Devon

Responding minister: Daniel Zeichner

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Caroline Voaden raised concerns about rural communities: government support in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Ten million people live in rural areas with settlements under 10,000 residents and lower work-based incomes compared to urban areas.
  • The average age in South Devon is 30%, significantly higher than the 17% average age in urban areas.
  • Only 47% of rural premises had access to gigabit-capable broadband last year, compared to 84% in urban areas.

Key requests to Government

The Government must ensure equitable support for rural communities, including addressing the issue of free school transport for all ages and resolving the challenge of limited opportunities for young people due to a lack of rural transport. The median full-time salary in South Devon is below the national average while house prices are above it.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Caroline Voaden Lib Dem South Devon

The rural-urban divide is one of the deepest in the UK. Ten million people live in rural areas, where settlements have fewer than 10,000 residents and work-based incomes are lower compared to urban areas. The average age in South Devon is higher at 30%, compared to 17% in urban areas. Additionally, access to healthcare is challenging due to cut community services and hospitals being far away. The proportion of rural premises with access to gigabit-capable broadband was only 47% last year compared with 84% in urban areas.

Other contributors (22)
  • Cameron Thomas LD Tewkesbury

    Addressed broadband connectivity and mobile reception problems, highlighting the need for better infrastructure support in Tewkesbury's fast-growing borough, including road and rail infrastructure improvements.

  • Caroline Voaden Con South Devon

    Secured the debate and highlighted challenges in rural communities.

  • Charlotte Cane LD Ely and East Cambridgeshire

    Discussed the need for transport investment in rural areas, including cycleways, footpaths, regular buses, and routes connecting villages. Highlighted issues with bus services not reaching neighbouring villages.

  • Chris Hinchliff Lab North East Hertfordshire

    Mr Hinchliff asked the Minister a question but did not receive an answer due to time constraints. He focused on the need for skills development and better integration of services in rural areas.

  • Daniel Zeichner Lab Cambridge

    Mr Zeichner discussed the roll-out of Project Gigabit, housing reforms, energy costs, and the need for more affordable homes in rural areas. He also highlighted the importance of skills development and the challenges faced by the health service in rural regions.

  • Roz Savage LD South Cotswolds

    Highlighted public transport issues such as cancelled bus routes impacting students' ability to attend college, illustrating the broader impacts on education and economic opportunities in rural areas.

  • Gregory Stafford Con Farnham and Bordon

    Highlights infrastructure challenges including gaps in health services, broadband access, banking facilities, and transport in rural areas such as Farnham and Haslemere.

  • Helen Morgan LD North Shropshire

    Focused on three key issues: public transport funding cuts in Shropshire, cultural opportunities impacted by poor local authority funding, and inadequate sports facilities like Greenfields in Market Drayton due to lack of funds.

  • Ian Roome LD North Devon

    Grateful for the debate on supporting rural communities.

  • Jade Botterill Lab Ossett and Denby Dale

    Supports the Government's efforts to improve connectivity through 5G expansion, address potholes with £1.6 billion funding, and introduce better buses Bill for reliable public transport.

  • James Naish Lab Rushcliffe

    Thanked Caroline Voaden for securing the debate and highlighted the Government’s work on broadband, buses, roads, and the rural England prosperity fund. Pleased with the GP contract agreement ending the 8 am scramble for appointments.

  • Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross

    Pointed out higher delivery costs in remote areas compared to cities like Glasgow or Edinburgh, advocating for a level playing field on delivery charges.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Highlighted issues such as bus service inadequacies and bank closures, suggesting an obligation for banks to open banking hubs upon branch closure.

  • John Lamont Con Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk

    Agrees that decision makers need to better understand the unique challenges of rural areas before implementing policies.

  • Lee Pitcher Lab Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme

    Highlights the struggles faced by small rural schools, surgeries, broadband services, and businesses in his constituency due to budget cuts and lagging infrastructure.

  • Angus MacDonald LD Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire

    Called for rural communities producing electricity to be paid 5% of revenue from new renewable energy generation. Also suggested equalising environmental taxes on electricity and gas to reduce heating costs.

  • Rachel Gilmour LD Tiverton and Minehead

    Discussed the dental desert issue in her constituency, highlighting statistics on adults and children's access to dental care, as well as gaps in sixth-form provision.

  • Robbie Moore Con Keighley and Ilkley

    Supports the call for rural-proofing policies and unlocking unique funding streams to tackle uniquely rural challenges such as banking hubs, post office services, and connectivity issues.

  • Sarah Dyke LD Glastonbury and Somerton

    The sudden closure of the sustainable farming incentive has left thousands of farmers cut off from funding, impacting nature-friendly farming and flood management measures.

  • Steve Barclay Con North East Cambridgeshire

    Asked for clarification on when the decision to close SFI was made.

  • Vikki Slade LD Mid Dorset and North Poole

    Agreed that increasing the age of participation from 16 to 18 without also extending free school transport ages creates financial burdens for families in rural areas.

  • Wendy Chamberlain LD North East Fife

    Emphasised the importance of connectivity for rural communities, discussing poor phone signals leading to energy management issues and a lack of cash and banking services. Also pointed out that burgh towns are central hubs for community services.

Government Response

Daniel Zeichner

The Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs

Addressed concerns regarding rural services, funding cuts, and crime. Emphasised commitment to addressing rural challenges through visits and initiatives, including £33 million directed to the rural England prosperity fund and £5 million in capital grants for community assets.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy