-
Argued that reducing capacity in the independent sector would exacerbate problems for state schools, mentioning excellent local independent and state institutions.
-
He is concerned that removing the VAT exemption for independent schools will lead to an increase in school fees, causing many parents who barely afford current fees to lose their options. He calculated a local high school could lose 20% of its students if the change happens. Smaller schools would struggle and may close, resulting in job losses and reduced choice for families. The impact also extends to non-fee-paying schools with potential class size increases and resource strain. Military families moving mid-year might be particularly affected. Schools that currently provide their facilities at no cost will face challenges due to VAT introduction.
-
He highlighted the impact of VAT on small independent schools providing specialized education for children with special educational needs. These settings are legally registered but often not charitable trusts, raising concerns about the cost implications for both local authorities and parents. He fears that introducing VAT would jeopardize highly specialised private provision, affecting families who have found suitable settings after years of searching.
-
Discussed the impact of independent schools on state education, mentioning initiatives like the London Challenge that improved state school performance. Cited a report suggesting VAT levied on private schools would generate £1.3 billion annually without affecting pupil numbers significantly. Addressed concerns about special school exemptions and discussed funding disparities between state and independent schools.
-
Taxing private schools out of existence is not the right approach, as it would limit access for many families who seek a better education and could harm the local economy by reducing international student enrollment.
-
Asked how the Labour party perceives innovation within the independent sector, citing examples like Steiner, Bedales, and Summerhill schools that could only exist in private settings.
-
He congratulated his hon. Friend on the debate and raised concerns from headteachers in his constituency about potential school closures due to unaffordable fees with the VAT increase, which could lead to a surge of students moving into state schools.
-
Liberal Democrats oppose taxing education, including independent schools. They support choice but advocate for a high-quality state sector and partnerships between state and independent sectors. Taxing independent schools would reduce such collaboration and affect parents who opt for them due to unmet needs in the state system.
-
He congratulated his hon. Friend on securing the debate and emphasised the importance of independent schools' outreach work, including access bursaries and sports facilities for local communities. He expressed concern that Labour's policy on VAT would compromise these schools, leading to parents pulling their children out and increasing pressure on state schools.
-
Economically and educationally, the VAT on independent schools is not sensible. The policy threatens fragile prep schools and could lead to collapses in rural areas with small state schools lacking capacity.
-
The Chair of the Education Committee highlighted concerns about Labour's policy proposal, noting a lack of support from Back Benchers in previous debates. He worried about the financial implications for publicly funded schools and questioned whether Labour had adequately calculated costs associated with expanding state school capacity. The MP also raised issues regarding SEND pupils and called for clarity on exemptions for specialist settings.
-
Labour's plan to charge VAT on independent schools is based on politics of envy, intended to harm both sectors without proper consultation. In Hastings and Rye, the quality of state education has improved significantly since 2010 due to positive government policies. Highlighted how major private schools provide 100% bursaries to children from disadvantaged backgrounds, enabling them to benefit their communities.
-
The MP criticised Labour's proposal to remove VAT from independent schools, describing it as a cynical move aimed at political gain rather than addressing educational needs. She highlighted the economic contributions of independent schools, including £16 billion to the economy and supporting 300,000 jobs contributing £5 billion in tax revenue. The MP also expressed concern over the impact on pupils with special educational needs and fears that removing VAT would harm social mobility.