Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women — [Julie Elliott in the Chair]

01 December 2022 · 12 other contributors · 14,372 words

Opened by Karin Smyth Lab Bristol South

Responding minister: Leo Docherty

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Karin Smyth raised concerns about international day for the elimination of violence against women — [julie elliott in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Number of women murder victims is at a 15-year high.
  • Domestic violence reports surged with 260,000 offences reported between March and June 2020.
  • Minister committed to writing to relevant ministers for updates on specific issues.

Key requests to Government

The Minister should agree to implement some measures: put a rape and domestic abuse specialist in the police force; overhaul the police standards system; bring in a domestic abusers register; set up specialist rape courts. The issue of financial abuse as part of abusive behaviour must be recognised in the Government's strategy to address violence against women and girls.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Karin Smyth Lab Bristol South

The number of women murder victims is at a 15-year high, with rape prosecutions and convictions also at historic lows. Domestic violence has skyrocketed during the pandemic, with 260,000 domestic abuse offences reported between March and June 2020 alone. Women in Bristol South face a variation from 7.1 per 1,000 in Redland to 79.9 per 1,000 in Hartcliffe and Withywood. The cost of living crisis is worsening the situation for women who are predominantly employed in low-pay sectors.

Other contributors (12)
  • Anthony Mangnall Con Crewe and Nantwich

    Mangnall highlighted the UK's role in creating the Preventing Sexual Violence in Conflict initiative in 2012, emphasizing its importance in addressing overlooked issues of sexual violence in conflict zones. He noted that while there has been some progress since then, including prosecutions and fund establishment, more is needed to meet survivors' needs and deter perpetrators.

  • Caroline Nokes Con Romsey and Southampton North

    Caroline Nokes emphasized the need to address privilege in media coverage of violence against women, highlighting cases like Julia James's murder. She called for legislation on public sexual harassment and praised efforts by police forces such as Nottinghamshire Police in collecting statistics on misogyny as a hate crime. Nokes also mentioned the work of the Women and Equalities Committee, focusing on areas including schools, colleges, universities, and the music industry. I join the Minister in his comments about my right hon. Friend the Member for Chelmsford, but I will not let him gloss over what she said about women's right to reproductive health, which is a crucial part of preventing violence against women and girls.

  • Charlotte Nichols Lab Warrington North

    Ms Nichols highlighted the increase in domestic abuse arrests by 76% and high charge rates for stalking, sexual offences, and rape. She expressed concerns over the confidentiality of survivors' counselling notes and the inadequate support services for PTSD sufferers. She called for more funding for specialist services and a renewed focus on sex education and workplace dignity to prevent violence against women.

  • Fleur Anderson Lab Putney

    Ms Anderson highlighted the pervasive nature of violence against women and girls, expressing disappointment that younger generations face greater risks. She called for sustainable funding for specialist gender-based violence services, a code of practice on tech abuse under the Online Safety Bill, an emergency domestic abuse fund to address economic control by perpetrators during the cost of living crisis, mandatory in-depth training for criminal justice practitioners, and quicker return of phones to rape victims after evidence collection. Additionally, she stressed the need for increased humanitarian relief funding and conflict prevention efforts globally.

  • Gavin Newlands SNP Paisley and Renfrew North

    The hon. Member highlighted the ongoing issue of violence against women, citing statistics such as the £2.6 billion annual cost to the Scottish Government for addressing domestic abuse. He also stressed the importance of challenging misogyny on social media platforms and encouraged more men to become White Ribbon ambassadors.

  • Jackie Doyle-Price Con Thurrock

    Ms Doyle-Price expressed concern over the Government's emphasis on tackling violence against women and girls without significant action, highlighting the poor day-to-day lived experience of women. She noted that female MPs receive more abuse than their male counterparts and called for collective action to tackle it. She also discussed the issue of sexual violence in conflict zones such as Ukraine, where up to 30% of Ukrainian women have been victims of sexual crimes. Additionally, she criticized the NHS's failure to deliver on its commitment to provide a lifetime therapeutic care pathway for victims of sexual violence.

  • James Daly Con Bury North

    The charge rate for rape in the UK is a national scandal at 1.7%, and only one in 100 rapes recorded by police results in a charge, let alone a conviction. There has been a general view that children in care are not worthy of protection, especially girls. The prosecution rates for other offences such as harassment are also dire.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Jim Shannon highlighted the persecution of women belonging to faith groups, especially in conflict zones like Nigeria and the Central African Republic. He cited cases such as Leah Sharibu's forced marriage and rape by militants, and noted that 2,763 Yazidi women and children are still missing after Daesh's genocidal campaign. Shannon called for the Government to ensure funding targets vulnerable women based on their faith. Intervention stating hope for long-term improvement.

  • Lyn Brown Lab Tottenham

    Labour believes that women and girls must be free from violence to achieve justice. The UK sees a woman killed every three days, with only 1.5% of rapes leading to criminal charges since 2015. Lyn Brown highlighted testimonies of sexual violence against women in Ethiopia, urging the government to ensure accountability and consistent resources for international action. She also noted that legal advice for survivors is needed along with support for local leaders to fight gender inequality and empower women within militaries, police, and judiciaries.

  • Margaret Ferrier Ind Rottenrow East

    Earlier this year, the UK ratified the Istanbul convention but decided to opt out of article 59, which protects migrant women. The hon. Member agrees that this defeats the point of the convention and creates a hostile environment for vulnerable women. Ms Ferrier intervened, asking Ms Doyle-Price whether she agreed that respecting the choices women make in expressing their faith is an important aspect of empowering them. Asked Ms Anderson a question but具体内容未给出,根据指示仅包含提供的内容,此处不进行推断或补充。

  • Rachel Maclean Con Wythenshawe and Sale East

    Violence against women and girls is a widespread issue affecting half the population. The Government has increased funding for projects to improve safety, passed new laws against stalking and coercive behaviour, and launched a multimillion-pound campaign called Enough. In Rachel Maclean's constituency, over £400,000 in funding has been provided for community safety on the Greenlands estate. She requested the Minister to complete the Home Office review of spiking laws and consider introducing a new offence.

  • Vicky Ford Con Chelmsford

    In Chelmsford, £500,000 from the Government's safer streets fund improved safety in Bunny Walks. The Everyone's Invited campaign highlighted abuse suffered by girls; VAWG strategy progress is noted but concerns remain about delays and smear campaigns affecting rape victims' willingness to report crimes. Delays in prosecuting cases are significant, with only 70 out of over 2,500 reported cases reaching court last year.

Government Response

Leo Docherty

Responded to the debate by acknowledging concerns raised and committing to write to relevant ministers for updates on specific issues such as specialist rape courts, therapeutic care in the NHS, and protections for rape victims. Acknowledged the £10 million allocated to the Ukraine fund and the £27.6 million annually for bilateral violence against women and girls spend. Additionally committed to updating MPs on spiking laws and acknowledged the importance of community initiatives like Bunny Walks. Reaffirmed the Government's commitment to gender-based violence as a core priority with new funding and political declaration endorsements from 54 states.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy