Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Neighbourhood Policing: West Midlands

14 December 2021 · 7 other contributors · 8,382 words

Opened by Preet Kaur Gill Labour (Co-op) Birmingham Edgbaston

Responding minister: Kit Malthouse

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Preet Kaur Gill raised concerns about neighbourhood policing: west midlands in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • The West Midlands has the fourth highest rate of crime in the UK, with declining charge and conviction rates for violent offences.
  • The region has lost over 2,000 police officers since 2010 and faced budget cuts of 175 million.
  • The Minister acknowledged a significant funding increase for West Midlands Police (655.5 million) and urged investment in neighbourhood policing.

Key requests to Government

Will the Minister give West Midlands police the fair funding they need, ensuring that victims of crime receive timely advice, care, and support? Will he hear the pleas of constituents who feel let down by the Government?

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Preet Kaur Gill Labour (Co-op) Birmingham Edgbaston

The west midlands has the fourth highest rate of crime in the country, with a significant drop in charge rates and conviction rates for victims of violent offences. The region has lost over 2,000 officers since 2010 and had £175 million slashed from its budgets. In addition to cuts to youth clubs and mental health services, police are increasingly dealing with complex crimes like human trafficking and child sexual abuse.

Other contributors (7)
  • Khalid Mahmood Lab Co-op Birmingham Perry Barr

    Commended the debate's importance for his constituents and highlighted issues such as gangs with weapons in Birmingham. He emphasised that police were unable to attend due to insufficient numbers, leading to fears among residents who wish to open businesses or improve their lives. The Minister did not clarify the point about the management of West Midlands police. The force is good at strategic planning, organisational management and providing value for money, according to Her Majesty's inspectorate of constabulary and fire and rescue services.

  • Marco Longhi Con Dudley North

    Mr Longhi highlighted the recruitment of 11,053 additional police officers by the Government and a 5.8% increase in West Midlands Police's budget to £36 million. He criticised the Labour PCC for closing numerous police stations and spending heavily on refurbishing offices at Lloyd House. Mr Longhi expressed frustration over the delayed promise of a new police station in Dudley, noting that Dudley residents have been without a central police station since late 2017. Dudley Council is ready to sell the land if the police and crime commissioner signs the contract, and planning permission does not depend on property ownership. He suggests speeding up local decision-making processes.

  • Sarah Jones Lab Croydon West

    The west midlands is experiencing a rise in serious violence and other crimes due to cuts in policing, youth services, drug addiction support, and services for children with special educational needs. The force will be 1,000 officers short compared to 2010 levels despite the government's pledge of more police funding.

  • Steve McCabe Lab Birmingham, Selly Oak

    I hear from constituents that the small number of prosecutions for burglary and car theft is frustrating. I argue that falling police numbers contribute to this problem. Even with promised funding restoration, there will still be 1,000 fewer officers in the west midlands compared to 2010. There is an unfair formula driving up council tax and giving us a smaller share of Government grant than neighbouring areas like Warwickshire.

  • Tahir Ali Lab Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley

    Mr Ali highlighted the success of a recent police operation in Sparkbrook, emphasising the importance of partnership between local councils and police. He noted that despite this success, resources are stretched thin due to austerity measures and an increase in complex crimes. Mr Ali urged the Government to allocate more funds for neighbourhood policing to address community issues. £175 million has been cut from west midlands policing since 2010, resulting in a deficit of 1,600 officers on the street. The government needs to explain this shortfall.

  • Taiwo Owatemi Lab Coventry North West

    Over a decade of Conservative budget cuts have severely impacted neighbourhood policing in the west midlands, with crime rates rising by 21% overall and 41% for violent crimes. The number of police community support officers has been cut in half, leaving residents like Maureen Crealey feeling unsafe and abandoned. Taiwo Owatemi called for more funding to restore neighbourhood policing and strengthen youth services.

  • Valerie Vaz Lab Walsall and Bloxwich

    Ms Vaz briefly intervened, asking if she could speak next.

Government Response

Kit Malthouse

The Minister dismissed Labour Members' criticisms as a 'naked political manoeuvre', emphasizing that difficult financial decisions were necessary. He highlighted the impact of previous decisions by police and crime commissioners on the current performance of different forces, particularly in the West Midlands. The Minister acknowledged the significant funding increase for the West Midlands Police force (£655.5 million next year) and urged investment in neighbourhood policing. He noted that a new funding formula is being developed to replace the outdated one.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy