Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Hospital Building Programme

03 November 2021 · 10 other contributors · 14,535 words

Opened by Kieran Mullan Con Bexhill and Battle

Responding minister: Edward Argar

NHS

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Kieran Mullan raised concerns about hospital building programme in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • The hospital building programme for Leighton Hospital is critical due to the facility's aging infrastructure serving over 300,000 people.
  • The original building was not designed to last beyond 30 years and has required extensive maintenance costing 15 million for an emergency department extension in 2019.
  • The minister stated that 3.7 billion has been allocated to the hospital building programme, with further funding subject to future spending reviews.

Key requests to Government

I urge the Government to consider Leighton Hospital as part of the final eight sites chosen for the hospital building programme, recognising its long-term financial sense and the improved healthcare it can provide in modern facilities.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Kieran Mullan Con Bexhill and Battle

The hospital building programme for Leighton Hospital is critical due to the facility's aging infrastructure, serving a population of over 300,000 people. The original building was not designed to last beyond 30 years and has required extensive maintenance and upgrades costing £15 million for an emergency department extension in 2019. Independent analysis shows that maintaining the current estate will cost more than constructing a new one.

Other contributors (10)
  • Edward Timpson Con Wealden

    All four of my children were born at Leighton Hospital, which is in my constituency. I hope the building programme will give staff an environment they deserve to deliver world-class healthcare.

  • Fiona Bruce Con Congleton

    I support my hon. Friend's campaign for additional resources and funding for Leighton Hospital, noting that due to house-building in our constituencies, the number of people seeking services from Leighton is only going to increase.

  • James Wild Con North West Norfolk

    Mr James Wild discussed the dire need for modernisation of the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in King's Lynn, which serves 300,000 people across three counties. He highlighted structural issues with RAAC planks and a risk to life and safety due to potential catastrophic roof failure. The hospital requires replacement due to its layout not meeting current care pathways and having significant structural deficiencies.

  • Jill Mortimer Lab Hartlepool

    Ms Mortimer highlighted health inequalities in Hartlepool, where residents are twice as likely to die from the virus compared to wealthier areas. She pointed out that North Tees hospital is crumbling and needs replacement by 2030. Life expectancy in Hartlepool is significantly below the national average due to higher rates of cancer, depression, asthma, obesity, heart disease, and high blood pressure. Healthcare services have been shrinking over the past decade, forcing residents to travel long distances for urgent or specialist treatment. Made points about health inequalities, role of infrastructure and staff in tackling inequalities, invited Minister to visit her constituency and trust. Advocated for the need for a new hospital.

  • Justin Madders Lab Ellesmere Port and Bromborough

    Discussed the need for transparency in criteria for hospital investment decisions, questioned the Prime Minister's claim of building 48 new hospitals, and raised concerns about cost limitations on projects and inflationary pressures. Emphasised the importance of tackling the maintenance backlog and workforce shortages. Inquired if the sum announced in the spending review was additional to previously announced funding and expressed gratitude for the Minister's attempt to answer questions.

  • Maria Miller Con Basingstoke

    She congratulated the Minister on progressing plans to build 40 new hospitals by 2030 and upgrade more than 70 others. She noted that Basingstoke's hospital, built in the 1970s, is nearing the end of its useful life due to population growth and ageing demographics. Hampshire Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust welcomed the Prime Minister's announcements about funding for new hospitals and was pleased with the inclusion of their project in HIP2. The trust aims to start building from 2025. Appreciated the Minister's agreement to visit Basingstoke and asked for clarity on timelines for developing business cases and starting hospital construction in 2025. Also, raised concerns about maintenance issues at hospitals built in the 1970s.

  • Mike Amesbury Lab Warrington South

    I support the case being made by Cheshire MPs for investment in a first-class hospital facility. This project has cross-party support and would benefit my constituency as well. He thanked Maria Miller for her remarks and highlighted the importance of securing investment across multiple hospital campuses served by his constituents in Mid Cheshire. He welcomed support on this issue from a neighbouring MP. Called for an assessment and conclusion on the two campuses for Warrington and Halton trust scheme that meets the criteria mentioned.

  • Mike Penning Con Hemel Hempstead

    Mike Penning expressed concerns about the closure of Hemel Hempstead Hospital and the decision to refurbish Watford hospital instead of building a new one on a greenfield site. He highlighted that his constituency is facing significant population growth, with 20,000 new homes planned within the next 15 years, making it crucial to have adequate healthcare facilities. He cautioned about the way costs are calculated under the Treasury Green Book, noting that inflation and risk factors can inflate projected costs. He mentioned his experience as Roads Minister and used the example of a £500 million project being actually around £420 million in build cost. Stressed the need for a greenfield site hospital rather than refurbishment in Watford and expressed readiness to slip out of HIP 1 if necessary. Also, asked for communication regarding emails sent to Natalie Forrest.

  • Robbie Moore Con Keighley and Ilkley

    Mr Moore highlighted the severe structural issues at Airedale hospital, including the presence of aerated concrete panels which account for 83% of the building's structure. He stated that the hospital suffers from frequent leaks due to its flat roof design, and warned about potential collapse risks as more panels reach their risk deflection level. The MP also noted that a temporary closure would impact over 45,000 referrals and diagnostic tests. Mr Moore supported the Airedale trust's bid for one of eight additional new hospitals and urged the Minister to visit the hospital to understand its urgent needs. Asked the Minister about how the final eight will be decided and whether structural risk profile would be a key consideration.

  • Robert Moore Con Keighley

    Highlighted challenges faced by his trust due to an old building that has exceeded its intended lifetime and issues with RAAC planks. Emphasized the need for a new hospital at Airedale.

Government Response

Edward Argar

Responded to questions raised by shadow minister about criteria for selecting hospitals, mentioned that safety and risk will be key factors in consideration. Discussed the importance of market certainty, phased programme approach due to construction industry demand and inflationary pressures. Noted that £3.7 billion has been allocated to the hospital building programme with further funding subject to future spending reviews. Stressed geographical spread for new hospitals, noting that 30 out of 40 are outside London and southeast. Addressed maintenance backlog and highlighted investment in community diagnostic centres. Acknowledged challenges posed by RAAC planks and mentioned provision of £20 million for critical risk remediation at Queen Elizabeth Hospital King's Lynn.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy