Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Baby Loss: Covid-19

05 November 2020 · 9 other contributors · 13,875 words

Opened by Cherilyn Mackrory Con Truro and Falmouth

Responding minister: Nadine Dorries

NHS

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Cherilyn Mackrory raised concerns about baby loss: covid-19 in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • MP shared personal experience of losing a baby to spina bifida and highlighted the emotional toll of pregnancy and baby loss in the UK.
  • Pandemic has exacerbated challenges for women experiencing pregnancy or baby loss, including restrictions on partner presence at appointments and scans.
  • MP called on NHS England to establish minimum standards for partner involvement in pregnancy and baby loss scenarios and to reinstate provisions for choices and support for women.

Key requests to Government

The MP called on NHS England to initiate a minimum acceptable standard for involving partners when pregnancy or baby loss is anticipated or occurs, whether in relation to attendance at scans or appointments. She also asked for the swift reinstatement of provisions providing choices for women facing pregnancy or baby loss and requested support from health professionals and baby loss charities.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Cherilyn Mackrory Con Truro and Falmouth

The MP shared her personal experience of losing a baby to spina bifida and described the emotional toll it had on her. She highlighted that one in four pregnancies ends in miscarriage, and 14 babies are stillborn or die shortly after birth every day in the UK. The pandemic has exacerbated existing challenges for women experiencing pregnancy and baby loss, with partners often excluded from appointments and scans, restricted visiting rights at neonatal settings, and a lack of time and space to make memories after a stillbirth or neonatal death.

Other contributors (9)
  • Angela Richardson Con Reading West

    Ms Richardson shared her personal experience of baby loss during the SARS outbreak in 2003, raising concerns about a potential link between viral illnesses and increased miscarriages. She discussed the profound impact on mental health and the importance of support systems for those experiencing grief.

  • Ian Paisley Jnr DUP North Antrim

    Ian Paisley Jnr shared the story of a constituent, Donna, who experienced consecutive miscarriages and pregnancy loss during the pandemic. He highlighted that each year, 14 babies are stillborn or die shortly after birth in the UK. Due to restrictions imposed by the pandemic, Donna was unable to have an early reassurance scan, which led to further distress when her twins were lost. Donna is now on a waiting list for nine months to see a specialist due to shielding measures. Paisley emphasised the emotional and mental health impact of these experiences and called for support for vulnerable individuals. Ian Paisley Jr. thanked Olivia Blake for addressing the impact on expectant fathers, highlighting the need for comprehensive services that address the needs of both mothers and fathers during pregnancy complications.

  • Jeremy Hunt Con Godalming and Ash

    Jeremy Hunt expressed gratitude for the contributions of Cherilyn Mackrory and Sarah Owen, highlighting their work on baby loss issues. He pointed out that the UK loses about 3.9 babies per 1,000 births in neonatal deaths compared to Sweden's rate of around half. Hunt advocated for an expansion of testing facilities during the pandemic and emphasized the importance of changing from a blame culture to a learning culture within the NHS.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Expressed understanding and empathy for the Chair's grief, mentioning similar experiences in his own family. Jim Shannon thanked members for their contributions and highlighted the impact of baby loss, citing statistics from 2018 where daily in the UK there were 2,060 babies born alive, 515 miscarried, 144 born pre-term, and eight stillborn. He shared personal experiences with miscarriage and emphasised the importance of support for those experiencing such losses.

  • Olivia Blake Lab Sheffield Hallam

    Olivia Blake shared her personal experience of miscarriage during the pandemic, highlighting issues such as partners not being allowed to attend appointments and the lack of emotional support. She urged the government to increase investment in covid-secure provision for all parents and called for more mental health support and protection of spaces for memory making.

  • Patricia Gibson SNP North Ayrshire and Arran

    I thanked the hon. Member for Truro and Falmouth for her opening speech and shared my experience of a stillbirth in 2009, highlighting the impact of such losses on parents who often feel robbed of their child's potential. I raised concerns about increased stillbirths during the peak of the pandemic and the isolation grief brings to those losing a baby, especially with restrictions limiting funeral attendance and support from charities due to social distancing measures.

  • Rosena Allin-Khan Lab Tooting

    Ms Allin-Khan highlighted the importance of breaking down stigma around baby loss and praised fellow MPs for sharing their personal experiences. She emphasised the need for immediate mental health support for bereaved families and stressed that maternity and neonatal care should not be curtailed during the pandemic.

  • Saqib Bhatti Con Meriden and Solihull East

    Mr Saqib Bhatti highlighted the emotional impact of baby loss, noting statistics from his constituency in the west midlands where 12% of perinatal deaths and 14% of neonatal deaths occur. He discussed initiatives like the Woodland House appeal at Birmingham Women's Hospital aiming to raise £3.5 million for a tailored bereavement suite and the Lily Mae Foundation providing memory boxes and one-to-one support to grieving families.

  • Sarah Owen Lab Luton North

    She thanked and paid tribute to Cherilyn Mackrory for initiating the debate, emphasising the importance of emotional support during pregnancy scans due to coronavirus restrictions. Sarah highlighted the critical role of Luton and Dunstable University Hospital in allowing visitors at scans and urged the Government to continue supporting such practices. She shared her personal experiences with miscarriage and the significance of having someone's support during difficult times. Expressed gratitude towards Patricia Gibson for her bravery in sharing personal experiences of baby loss and thanked her for representing constituents who have gone through similar situations. Expressed sadness over the loss of Mary Agyapong, a constituent, and called for continued Government support for her family. Raised concerns about black, Asian and minority ethnic women experiencing higher rates of stillbirths and miscarriages during pregnancy, exacerbated by the pandemic.

Government Response

Nadine Dorries

I thank the hon. Member for Tooting (Dr Allin- Khan) and all hon. Members for their contributions. The minister highlights the increased number of stillbirths from 24 to 40 weeks, acknowledging that while it has gone up, the reasons behind this are not fully understood yet; a thematic review by the Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch is underway to determine the cause. She also addresses concerns about partner and parent presence during scans and births, noting that new guidance was issued on 8 September allowing for partners and parents to accompany mothers where possible. The minister mentions the introduction of lateral flow tests in Liverpool from tomorrow, which will provide quick results (15 minutes) and ensure a safer environment within maternity units. She underscores the importance of balancing safety measures with the emotional needs of expectant families. Additionally, she discusses the establishment of the maternity inequalities oversight forum to address disparities affecting women from black, Asian, and other minority ethnic backgrounds, aiming to reduce stillbirth rates among these groups. The minister also notes the tragic case of Mary Agyapong, a pregnant nurse who died after delivering her baby at Luton and Dunstable University Hospital, expressing hope that findings from the oversight forum will help address such issues.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy