Philippa Whitford
MP for Central Ayrshire
SNP
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
The NHS in England has just had its longest-ever junior doctors' strike and consultants go on strike tomorrow for the first time in 50 years, yet so far Scotland has had no NHS strikes. That is not by chance; it is because our Health Secretary and First Minister have kept working with the British Medical Association to try to address the pay erosion faced by doctors since 2008. Workforce shortages are the biggest challenge facing healthcare, and the Prime Minister just mentioned the importance of staff retention. Does he really think that refusing even to talk to health unions will stop doctors leaving the NHS?
Context
The NHS in England has experienced its longest-ever junior doctors' strike, followed by consultant strikes. Scotland has not seen such strikes.
Rishi Sunak
We did talk to health unions, but we also respected the independent pay review body process, which is the right way to resolve these issues and means that a typical junior doctor will see a 9% pay rise as a result of this deal.
Assessment
Did not address engaging with unions beyond the pay review process
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Yesterday, the UK turned 100 years old. Neither the Prime Minister nor the Labour leader recognised the challenge posed by the Supreme Court ruling regarding the nature of the Union. Can the PM clarify whether he still believes the UK is a voluntary Union and explain how Scotland can choose to stay in it or not?
Context
The United Kingdom turned 100 years old, but the Prime Minister did not acknowledge the Supreme Court ruling on the nature of the Union. The question arises from this context.
Rishi Sunak
We respect the Supreme Court decision and believe strongly in the United Kingdom. We will work constructively with the Scottish Government to deliver for Scotland.
Assessment
Did not clarify whether he believes UK is a voluntary union or explain democratic route for Scotland's status within it
Hedging Language
Vague Commitment
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
During the 2014 referendum, we were told that Scotland was an equal partner in a family of nations, yet the disaster that is Brexit was forced on Scotland against our will, and we have seen devolution wound back by legislation such as the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020. So if the Prime Minister still claims that the UK is a voluntary Union, can he explain the democratic route by which the people of Scotland get to make a choice over their own future?
Context
Scotland voted against Brexit in the 2014 referendum, but the UK's exit from the EU was imposed on Scotland. The United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020 has been criticised for limiting Scottish autonomy.
Rishi Sunak
The UK is a collaborative and constructive Union that is delivering for the people of Scotland, even in Ayrshire itself, where we are working collaboratively with the Scottish Government to invest in aerospace, advanced manufacturing and space. Those are the types of activities that will bring tangible benefits to the people in the hon. Lady's region, and that is the right focus for the Government.
Assessment
The democratic process for Scottish independence was not addressed.
Changed Subject To Economic Benefits
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
It took just five working days for the Prime Minister to crash the pound, damage pension funds and send people's mortgage costs spiralling. Her new Chancellor may have reversed almost all of her policies, but the damage has been done, and we now face yet another round of Tory cuts and austerity. I would like to ask the Prime Minister and those sitting behind her: why is she still at the Dispatch Box, and when will voters get their say on this disastrous Government?
Context
The Prime Minister has caused significant damage to the economy, leading to questions about her leadership.
Elizabeth Truss
We are facing very, very difficult economic times. I took the decision I had to in the interests of economic stability. What is important is that we work together, including with the SNP, to get through this winter and grow the economy.
Assessment
Why she is still at the Dispatch Box and voter input timeline
Broad Statements
No Concrete Actions
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
This session shows how much of a distraction the Prime Minister's behaviour has been. After a recent survey showed that 37% of small businesses felt totally unprepared for the introduction of import controls, rules of origin and the upcoming sanitary and phytosanitary checks, will he listen to the Federation of Small Businesses and introduce financial and technical support for those small businesses?
Context
A recent survey showed that 37% of small businesses felt totally unprepared for the introduction of import controls, rules of origin and the upcoming sanitary and phytosanitary checks.
Boris Johnson
What we are doing is offering financial and technical support to businesses, which are responding magnificently. As we come out of the pandemic, as I said to the House earlier, we are seeing record numbers of people in work and youth unemployment at a record low.
Assessment
The specific ask was partially addressed but did not directly commit to listening to FSB or providing support.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Cases of the delta variant are surging due to failure to maintain strict border quarantine and adding India to the red list. Will the Prime Minister extend full furlough and business support beyond September for geographical areas and businesses most affected?
Context
Due to the Prime Minister's failure to maintain strict border quarantine and delay in adding India to the red list, cases of the delta variant are surging across the UK. This is impacting sectors such as hospitality, entertainment, and aviation.
Boris Johnson
No, because although the delta variant is seeded in at least 74 countries, including this one, protection by immunity against it here is the highest. That is why we are going to continue with our cautious but irreversible road map.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
During the Brexit referendum the Prime Minister promised no change to the rights of EU citizens in the UK, yet now they face losing work, rental housing, and free healthcare access without settled status. Given repeated grace periods during Brexit negotiations, will he extend this deadline?
Context
During the Brexit referendum, the Prime Minister promised that EU citizens would retain their existing rights in the UK. However, those without settled status are facing losing key rights such as working and accessing healthcare.
Boris Johnson
The EU settlement scheme has been a success with 5.6 million applications; it was initially estimated at 3.2 or 3 million. Everybody knows what the deadline is and I hope people will come forward like those who have already done so.
Assessment
extension of the deadline for EU citizens to apply for settled status
Everybody Knows What The Deadline Is
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
In 2019, the then International Development Secretary pledged £400 million to the Global Polio Eradication Initiative. Will the Prime Minister now reassure that this commitment will be honoured?
Context
Concern over honouring the commitment to fund polio eradication.
Boris Johnson
UK aid for polio eradication since 1995 is £1.37 billion; success due to British taxpayer support.
Assessment
Did not confirm the specific £400 million commitment.
Acknowledged The Programme'S Success But Did Not Commit To Funding
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will the Prime Minister commit to protecting vital aerospace jobs and invest in a green aviation recovery?
Context
The aerospace sector is threatened by the pandemic.
The Prime Minister (Boris Johnson)
The hon. Lady has an extremely important point. It is one that we are working on very intensively now in Government, so that we use the opportunity of this crisis to bounce forwards with new low-carbon technology that will continue to drive the UK's formidable aerospace industry.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Given that the UK has defunded UNRWA, continues to supply arms to Israel, and often defends Netanyahu's policies, is there anxiety about undermining international law?
Context
The UK has defunded UNRWA, supplies arms to Israel, and often defends Netanyahu's policies. This may undermine international law and harm patients facing starvation.
Andrew Mitchell
Britain's diplomacy worked towards a common position in respect of UN Security Council resolutions 2720 and 2728, focusing on getting aid into Gaza and releasing hostages.
Session: Conflict in Gaza Iran
View All Questions -->
Does the Chancellor accept that delays in introducing changes to import checks are contributing to the cost of living crisis? The Government has delayed import checks on animal and food products for the fifth time because the costs would add to inflation.
Context
The Bank of England warned that Brexit would damage the UK economy, weakening the pound and causing inflation. Import checks on animal and food products have been delayed multiple times.
Jeremy Hunt
No, but of course we are sensitive about the timing of introducing those changes. An extra £14.6 billion is being directed to public services every year because of Brexit.
Session: Brexit Economic Impact
View All Questions -->
Energy storage is vital to managing demand as we switch to renewable electricity. Pumped storage hydro is the most efficient large-scale storage method. UK capacity could be more than doubled by six projects across Scotland that have been shovel ready for more than five years. They take a long time to build, so why are the UK Government not supporting investment in infrastructure that is critical for our future energy security?
Context
The questioner asks why the UK Government is not supporting investment in critical infrastructure such as pumped storage hydro.
Grant Shapps
I have discussed this matter with SSE in relation to that particular hydro storage project, and my hon. Friend the Under-Secretary of State met MSPs yesterday to discuss the subject as well. We are keen to have this kind of hydro storage, which is why our plans allow for it to be taken forward.
Session: Energy Transition Projects Scotland
View All Questions -->
The London School of Economics has shown that a third of food inflation in the UK is due to Brexit. With the loss of freedom of movement and European workers, Brexit has also caused £60 million of Scottish fruit and veg to rot in the fields, threatening farms and further increasing the cost even of domestic produce. As a Brexiteer, should the Secretary of State not apologise to the Scottish public, including his own constituents, for driving up food prices, and maybe explain why he still supports the proven liar who was one of its main architects?
Context
The London School of Economics has shown that a third of food inflation in the UK is due to Brexit. With the loss of freedom of movement, European workers are no longer available, leading to £60 million of Scottish fruit and veg rotting in fields.
John Lamont
We do not accept the SNP's analysis. As I have already explained, food inflation is an issue in many parts of Europe. It is a bit rich for an SNP Member to bring up food price inflation and rising costs, especially when leaked papers this morning revealed that SNP Ministers in Edinburgh are discussing raising council tax by up to 22.5%, meaning that some people will end up paying £751 more per year. Under the SNP in Scotland, local government funding has been gutted, forcing councils to slash local services and impose large tax hikes. I will take no lessons from the hon. Member about bringing prices down for households in Scotland.
Session: Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
I thank the Secretary of State for his kind words about Winnie Ewing and Craig Brown. Let me pay my own personal tribute to Winnie Ewing, who was such an icon for our party and, almost uniquely, served in three Parliaments—our own Madame Écosse. At over 19%, food inflation in the UK is 50% higher than among our EU neighbours, yet both the Government and the Labour party seem to be in complete denial about Brexit's contribution to this cost of eating crisis. With 28% of the UK's food coming from Europe, how will the UK Government prevent a new surge in food prices next winter, when extra post-Brexit checks are introduced at the border?
Context
At over 19%, food inflation in the UK is 50% higher than among EU neighbours, with 28% of the UK's food coming from Europe.
John Lamont
As the Chancellor has said, food price inflation has been a problem in many parts of Europe. In Germany, Sweden, Portugal and Poland, food price inflation is around 20%, so this is not a UK-only problem. The Government are doing everything they can to deal with Putin's invasion of Ukraine and the aftermath of the pandemic. We have one central focus, which is bringing inflation down. We are ensuring that is this Government's one priority.
Session: Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
When the UK co-chaired the UN pledging conference, the Minister described the situation as “one of the most devastating humanitarian crises in the world”, yet he has cut funding compared with previous years and pledged less than 20% of the contribution that was given by the UK during the 2017 droughts. With over 70 million people now classed as at threat of starvation, is he not rather ashamed of the UK's meagre response?
Context
During the UN pledging conference, the Minister described the situation as one of the most devastating humanitarian crises in the world but has since cut funding compared with previous years.
Andrew Mitchell
If I may say so, the hon. Lady's response to what I said is not fully comprehensive. We have allocated something like £400 million to east and central Africa, and although it is true that the bilateral spend is slightly below last year's level, as I said, we do have some flexibility. It is the starting point for our spending this year, and of course, we will keep all these matters very much in our minds.
Session: Hunger East Africa
View All Questions -->
What recent steps his Department has taken to respond to hunger in east Africa and the horn of Africa.
Context
The question arises from the recent food crisis and humanitarian needs in east Africa.
Andrew Mitchell
On 24 May, the United Kingdom co-hosted an international pledging conference for the horn of Africa that helped mobilise nearly £2 billion to help nearly 32 million people across the region.
Session: Hunger East Africa
View All Questions -->
Pump storage hydro has been around since the '60s and lasts a long time but needs time to get built. Despite planning to take £40 billion in windfall taxes from Scotland's oil and gas sector, neither this Government nor Labour have committed to invest in Scotland's carbon capture, pump storage hydro, tidal stream or hydrogen potential, or to reform the situation whereby Scottish generators pay the highest transmission charges in Europe. Is it not clear that Scotland's immense renewable resources would be better in the hands of the Scottish Government?
Context
The MP highlights the long-standing technology of pump storage hydro and argues that despite taking £40 billion from Scotland's oil and gas sector, there is no commitment to invest in Scotland's renewable resources. She mentions high transmission charges for Scottish generators compared to Europe.
John Lamont (Roxburgh and Berwickshire) (Con)
Absolutely not. At the Budget, the Chancellor announced £20 billion of funding to store as much carbon and create as many jobs as possible through track 1 and beyond—unprecedented investment in the development of carbon capture, usage and storage. The Government have also announced around £2 billion in investment for CCUS, hydrogen and industrial decarbonisation technologies. We have already confirmed that the Acorn project in the north-east of Scotland seems to meet the track 2 criteria, and we look forward to working with the project to ensure that we get some good news as soon as possible.
Session: Renewable Energy
View All Questions -->
Energy storage is vital to managing demand as we switch to green electricity, and Scottish Renewables has called for UK capacity to be more than doubled by investment in six shovel-ready projects across Scotland. Why are this Government refusing to support investment in infrastructure that is critical to future energy security?
Context
Importance of energy storage infrastructure like pump storage hydro to manage demand as we switch to green electricity.
John Lamont
I simply do not accept the hon. Lady's analysis or conclusions. This Government are committed to infrastructure investment needed for new technology to evolve, and we will continue to work with the sector on this issue.
Session: Renewable Energy
View All Questions -->
As in the NHS, workforce is the biggest single issue. The Nuffield Trust has identified that, post-Brexit, dentists are among the key staff we are losing. On top of that, while Scotland and Wales have childhood dental health programmes, England does not. When will England have a national childhood dental health programme, and when will the contract in England be reformed to reward preventive work, rather than just dealing with emergencies?
Context
Post-Brexit, dentists are among key staff being lost. Scotland has more funding per head than the rest of the UK.
Neil O'Brien
We passed legislation last month to make it easier for international dentists to come to the UK by reforming the General Dental Council to speed up the flow from abroad. The hon. Lady mentions an additional service that is available in Scotland. Of course, Scotland has 25% more funding per head than the rest of the UK, which is just one benefit of being in the UK, and it is one reason why people in Scotland voted to remain in the UK.
Session: NHS Dental Services
View All Questions -->
Is the Secretary of State planning to repeatedly hold back the devolved Governments to avoid making his Government look bad? Or is he just seeking every chance to attack devolution and enforce Westminster rule?
Context
The question arises from concerns about the Secretary of State's actions towards devolved governments.
Alister Jack
The Secretary of State referred to comments by Tesco's chief executive about the need for a single solution to recycling problems across the UK, citing consistency in the drinks industry.
Session: Devolution Settlement
View All Questions -->
Why are there no derogations in the UK Internal Market Act 2020, given that similar policies have been implemented successfully with EU single market divergence?
Context
The question arises from discussions about innovative policies led by devolved governments and their subsequent implementation across the UK.
Alister Jack
Opportunities for derogations exist but do not work when different schemes in various parts of the UK have conflicting requirements. The Secretary of State cited plastic cutlery as an example where a derogation was allowed to align with the rest of the UK.
Session: Devolution Settlement
View All Questions -->
Because of the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2022, goods made in the rest of the UK cannot be kept out of Scotland, even if they do not meet future Scottish standards on quality, safety or environmental impact. Does the Secretary of State not recognise that the combined effect of both pieces of legislation will drastically increase the degree of direct rule by Westminster and drive a coach and horses through devolution?
Context
The UK Internal Market Act 2022 allows goods made in the rest of the UK to enter Scotland even if they do not meet future Scottish standards. This has raised concerns about increased direct rule by Westminster and undermining devolution.
Alister Jack
That is not true. We are respecting the devolved settlement. If we look at precision breeding and gene editing, for instance, the Scottish farming industry, the National Farmers Union of Scotland and all the other farming unions in the UK want to be part of the Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill, but we have respected the Scottish Government saying that they do not want to be part of it. Their dogma desires them to carry on with the EU rules and we respect that. As regards the UK internal market, it is absolutely right that trade can continue seamlessly across the United Kingdom, because 60% of Scotland's trade is with the rest of the United Kingdom.
Session: Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill
View All Questions -->
The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs alone has identified more than 1,700 pieces of retained EU law, with the majority in devolved areas such as agriculture, forestry and fishing. What happens if the Scottish Government want to maintain some of the EU standards that his party wants to ditch? Does he think it would be right for UK Ministers to change regulations in devolved matters without consent? How does that respect devolution?
Context
The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has identified over 1,700 pieces of retained EU law in devolved areas like agriculture, forestry, and fishing.
Alister Jack
We are working constructively and collaboratively with the Scottish Government on those retained EU laws. Where we have agreement on a cross-UK piece of policy, we will legislate on behalf of the devolved Administrations. Where it is in a devolved area, we will respect that and allow the Scottish Government to do as they see fit. If they want to remain in line with EU regulations, they can.
Session: Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill
View All Questions -->
I thank the Secretary of State for his warm welcome, but I must point out that June Raine, the head of the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency, has said innumerable times that the accelerated roll-out was under European Medicines Agency legislation. With the Labour party having now lashed itself to the mast of the floundering Brexit ship, does the Secretary of State at least recognise that the only route back to the EU for Scotland is as an independent country?
Context
Question arises from disagreement over the role of EU regulations in UK's accelerated vaccine programme.
Alister Jack (Secretary of State for Scotland)
The deficit in Scotland is considerably higher than 3%, which is the Maastricht criteria, so that is not the route back. The currency is a problem as well—as we know, the Bank of England is the bank of last resort, and there would have to be a new currency in Scotland following membership of the EU.
Session: Impact of Leaving the EU
View All Questions -->
My colleagues have highlighted just some of the negative impacts of Brexit on individuals, businesses, universities and public services in Scotland. Does it therefore come as a surprise to the Secretary of State that a poll last year showed that 69% of Scottish voters want to rejoin the EU?
Context
A poll showed that 69% of Scottish voters want to rejoin the EU, highlighting negative impacts of Brexit.
Alister Jack (Secretary of State for Scotland)
Opinion polls come and go; we have seen that. Last week, we saw that 59% of Scots want to remain in the United Kingdom—I notice that that opinion poll was not quoted. As for the benefits of Brexit, we can make our own trade deals, and we have made 71 to date. The SNP has never seen a trade deal it liked—it has never voted for a trade deal in the European Parliament or in this Parliament.
Session: Impact of Leaving the EU
View All Questions -->
Scotland has a quarter of Europe's marine energy potential, but generators in the north of Scotland are charged 15 times the rate to put electricity into the national grid. When will this team, supposedly defending Scotland's interests, actually get that sorted?
Context
The MP questioned about high grid charges for renewable energy generators in the north of Scotland.
Iain Stewart
As the hon. Lady knows, that is a matter for Ofgem, which is currently conducting a review into that.
Session: Government’s Energy Security Strategy
View All Questions -->
A family who are still in Ukraine have been reporting back to their Homes for Ukraine sponsors in Halifax that they have been able to hear the bombs getting closer every day of their 29-days-and-counting wait for a visa. The family in Ukraine have twins under the age of 10 who have, remarkably, had their visas processed at different speeds. A Home Office whistleblower has described the scheme as “designed to fail”. Government figures show that 40,000 visas have been issued under the Homes for Ukraine scheme, yet just 6,600 Ukrainians have actually arrived in the UK, because families who need to travel together cannot do so because the visa of just one family member, often a child, is delayed. Will the Home Secretary explain why, if 40,000 visas have been issued, so few Ukrainians have arrived in the UK? What is she doing to correct the situation?
Context
A family in Ukraine, sponsored by individuals in Halifax, has reported difficulties due to delays in visa processing. The scheme is criticised for its inefficiencies.
Priti Patel
I thank the hon. Lady for her question because she makes an important point. There are a number of points to make in response. First, on the reason why low numbers have come to the UK, as I have already said, more than 71,000 visas for both schemes have been granted. The Minister for Refugees, Lord Harrington, went to the region just 10 days ago to find out why and what more could be done to bring over families who have been granted their visas to come over. First of all, those families want to stay in region. That is a fact and that is exactly why we are working with the various Governments in region. The hon. Lady made an important point about families and younger children. Much of that is down to the checks, because they are not always travelling with parents. Safeguarding checks are being undertaken to ensure that they are all linked members of families.
Session: Safe and Legal Routes to UK Nationals of Ukraine and Afghanistan
View All Questions -->
What steps her Department is taking to increase the number of safe and legal routes to the UK for nationals of (a) Ukraine and (b) Afghanistan. Members from throughout the House have called on the Government to make it easier for people from Ukraine to seek sanctuary in the UK. Will the Home Secretary explain why the schemes for those who try to flee the Taliban are so limited and why, according to her own Department, the Nationality and Borders Bill does not establish safe and legal routes for those fleeing war, conflict or persecution?
Context
The question arises from the need to address safe passage for individuals fleeing conflict zones. The MP raises concerns about the number of Ukrainians seeking refuge and the comparably limited efforts for Afghans.
Priti Patel
First, the new plan for immigration spells out absolutely the Government's approach to safe and legal routes. As I have said many times in the House, every safe and legal route needs to be bespoke, based on the crisis that we are seeking to address. Secondly, in response to the hon. Lady's question about Afghanistan, she will know that under the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme we will welcome up to 20,000 at-risk people who have been affected by the most appalling events in Afghanistan. That scheme was announced last year and will include women and girls and members of minority groups, given their vulnerability.
Session: Safe and Legal Routes to UK Nationals of Ukraine and Afghanistan
View All Questions -->
Does the Minister not recognise how disrespectful it is to the victims of this disaster to delay publishing the report and then announce the Government's response and decision without hearing their views?
Context
In the five years since agreeing to a public inquiry, 90 victims have died in Scotland alone. The questioner highlights the need for sufficient time for the inquiry team and victim groups to review the report.
Michael Ellis
It is extremely important that all those who have suffered so terribly can get the answers they have spent decades waiting for. The hon. Lady knows that it was my right hon. Friend the Member for Maidenhead (Mrs May) who initiated this inquiry after 30 years of successive Governments not doing so, and it is Her Majesty's Government who commissioned proactively the study we are talking about today. I will consider the matter very carefully, all due and appropriate considerations are being given to all factors mentioned.
Session: Contaminated Blood Products Sir Robert Francis Report on Compensation for Those Affected
View All Questions -->
When will the Government publish Sir Robert Francis's report on compensation mechanisms for those affected by contaminated blood products?
Context
Sir Robert Francis delivered his report to the government on March 14th, and there is a need to publish findings in time for the infected blood inquiry.
Michael Ellis
Sir Robert Francis delivered his report to me on 14 March, and I will carefully consider his findings and recommendations. It is my intention to publish the compensation framework study alongside the Government's response as soon as possible, and in sufficient time for the infected blood inquiry and its core participants to consider them before Sir Robert gives evidence to the inquiry.
Session: Contaminated Blood Products Sir Robert Francis Report on Compensation for Those Affected
View All Questions -->
A recent report highlighted that the Department for Work and Pensions is not carrying out investigations of claimants who have suffered serious harm. With concerns about the cost of living crisis driving people to such situations, will the Department instigate independent reviews of those affected in the claims process?
Context
A report by Rethink Mental Illness highlights that the DWP does not investigate claims from individuals who have suffered significant harm, including mental health crises, self-harm, or suicide attempts.
Therese Coffey
The hon. Lady raises an important point. I am confident that my Department and officials will undertake their duties carefully and considerately, responding to local investigations by social services and learning from broader themes through the Serious Case Panel.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Instead of the 70,000 seasonal agricultural workers needed across the UK, the Government are limiting visas to 30,000, which is less than half of what is required. Will the Secretary of State explain why the UK Government are not providing enough of the visas required?
Context
The National Farmers Union of Scotland has warned that insufficient visa numbers will result in millions of pounds-worth of crops going unharvested, as the government's scheme only allows for 30,000 visas compared to the estimated need of 70,000.
George Eustice
As the hon. Lady may know, I worked in the soft fruit industry before coming into politics, so I am very familiar with the soft fruit industry in Scotland. It is one of the reasons why the Government have put in place the seasonal workers scheme, and we have had such a scheme since the second world war. Last year, we had a scheme with 30,000 visas, but only just over 25,000 were required. Many settled EU citizens will also continue to return to do seasonal work and we judge that 30,000 is probably the right number.
Session: Seasonal Agricultural Workers Scheme
View All Questions -->
What assessment has been made of the potential effect of winding down the seasonal agricultural workers scheme on the food and drink sector?
Context
The seasonal agricultural workers scheme supports both edible and ornamental horticulture, with currently 30,000 visas available. However, the National Farmers Union of Scotland has warned that millions of pounds-worth of crops may go unharvested due to insufficient visa numbers.
George Eustice
We are not winding down the seasonal agricultural workers scheme; in fact, we have now extended it until 2024 and it supports both edible and ornamental horticulture. There are 30,000 visas already available, with the potential to increase that to 40,000 if there is demand.
Session: Seasonal Agricultural Workers Scheme
View All Questions -->
I welcome the Foreign Secretary's constructive approach to the negotiations, but two years on from Brexit, can she confirm that disputes cannot go unresolved forever and that this situation has to be brought to an end sooner rather than later?
Context
Two years after Brexit, concerns remain about unresolved disputes and the need for resolution.
Elizabeth Truss
I completely agree with my hon. Friend on the urgency of this situation, which is why we have been holding intensive talks with the EU to resolve the very real issues there are for traders in GB and Northern Ireland.
Session: Northern Ireland Protocol Dispute Resolution
View All Questions -->
Does he not recognise that riding roughshod over devolution will force people in Scotland and Wales to choose between direct rule by Westminster or independence?
Context
The levelling-up fund has been used in ways that some perceive as undermining the autonomy of devolved administrations, raising concerns about the UK Internal Market Act's implications for governance.
Michael Gove
I acknowledge that there is a point made but want to highlight successful collaborations with both Scottish and Welsh Governments on funding allocations, noting that we can work together despite differing views on governance structures.
Session: Increasing Devolution Across the UK
View All Questions -->
What plans his Department has to increase devolution across the UK. Unfortunately, the levelling-up fund is already being used to bypass the devolved Governments, and the UKIM Act 2020 could enable UK Ministers to overrule the decisions of the Scottish and Welsh Parliaments. Does he not recognise that riding roughshod over devolution will force people in Scotland and Wales to choose between direct rule by Westminster or independence?
Context
The levelling-up fund has been perceived to bypass devolved governments, and concerns exist over the United Kingdom Internal Market Act's potential to override decisions made by Scottish and Welsh parliaments.
Michael Gove
I appreciate the point made but note that several Scottish constituencies received funds through the levelling-up fund, with support from SNP MPs and councils. We work collaboratively with the Scottish Government to advance shared interests despite differing views on constitutional issues.
Session: Increasing Devolution Across the UK
View All Questions -->
Commercial access to patient data may undermine public trust in digitisation within the NHS. Can you guarantee that the Department for International Trade will not use the UK Internal Market Act 2020 to force commercial access to patient data from Scotland's NHS? Also, why is DIT advertising access to health data of 65 million people?
Context
Concerns about commercial access to patient data from the NHS in England, potentially affecting Scotland's NHS through the UKIMA.
Jo Churchill
We do not allow data use for commercial purposes. NHS Digital will only approve requests for research or planning purposes, excluding marketing. The hon. Member would expect me to respond on behalf of another Department. We are communicating and building trust through a public information campaign and working across professions and research to ensure appropriate access.
Session: General Practice Data for Planning and Research
View All Questions -->
The Government's plan for pharmaceutical firms to have access to pseudo-anonymised data is causing public concern, similar to the failed care.data project. Patients support better communication within the NHS but are worried about commercial access to their data. Will you halt the process to allow time for genuine debate and public consultation?
Context
Public concern and distrust over commercial use of anonymised data from GP practices.
Jo Churchill
The hon. Member and I are passionate about using data to enhance patient care. We have listened to concerns, but this is an important agenda that we need to get right for better care delivery. The data will only be used by organisations with a legal basis and legitimate needs. NHS Digital will publish details on their data release register. We aim to build confidence and trust through communication.
Session: General Practice Data for Planning and Research
View All Questions -->
How will the Minister get academics to commit time and energy in the future when they cannot trust this Government to honour their commitments?
Context
The UKRI's global challenges research fund was set up to promote international collaboration on global issues, but the funding promised in 2019 has now been cut in half due to a reduction in overseas aid.
Michelle Donelan
The changes to the level of official development assistance quality-related funding made available to universities has been applied equally across the four nations of the Union. The Government's research ODA spend includes the global challenges research fund, which has been allocated in line with the thematic rather than geographic priorities of the strategic framework for UK ODA, prioritising high-value-for-money projects and existing legal commitments.
Session: Funding for Academic Research
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has he had with Cabinet colleagues on the allocation of Government funding to academic institutions for research?
Context
Recent discussions on the allocation of Government funding to academic institutions for research.
Michelle Donelan
The Government are investing £14.9 billion on research and development in 2021-22, the highest level for four decades. The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy provides funding for academic researchers through UK Research and Innovation and the national academies, and published detailed allocations in May.
Session: Funding for Academic Research
View All Questions -->
Having ignored the Scottish Government's call for all arrivals to undergo hotel quarantine and delaying adding India to the red list, is he concerned that removing social distancing will cause a surge among those not fully vaccinated?
Context
There are concerns about delayed actions by the UK Government regarding hotel quarantine and adding India to the red list, which allowed more infectious variants to enter and become dominant in the UK.
Matthew Hancock
As I was saying, Mr Speaker—
Session: Covid-19 Support for Scottish Government
View All Questions -->
Last September, he refused to follow Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies advice for an urgent lockdown. How can he explain why he did not follow scientific advice?
Context
There are concerns that the Secretary of State's decision-making has negatively impacted Scotland's ability to combat the pandemic.
Matthew Hancock
The attempt at division within the NHS is deeply regrettable and does not align with what people want across the country. The UK Government are guided by science but take all factors into consideration when making difficult judgments based on uncertain data.
Session: Covid-19 Support for Scottish Government
View All Questions -->
On top of the impact on our local fishing fleet, Brexit is driving businesses to move operations to Europe. Foxglide, a sportswear company, is not just facing shipping delays and having to pay VAT on the materials it imports, but, due to rules of origin, facing tariffs on the garments it exports to the EU. So does the Minister accept that, contrary to the Prime Minister's claims, the deal does not deliver tariff-free trade and is damaging local economies?
Context
The MP is concerned about the impact of Brexit on local businesses, specifically mentioning Foxglide and issues such as shipping delays and tariffs.
Penny Mordaunt
I thank the hon. Lady for raising that particular case. As she will know, we are always happy to talk directly to businesses, or through their Members of Parliament, to see what we can do to help their particular circumstances, but all the issues that she raises are being worked through by my noble Friend Lord Frost. We are also setting up new structures to work with our counterparts in the EU. We have opportunities with member states to resolve these matters.
Session: Barriers to Trade Between EU and UK
View All Questions -->
More vaccine-resistant strains, such as the South African variant, could risk undermining the UK's vaccine programme. As they could come via any country, does the Secretary of State not agree that all travellers should undergo strict quarantine?
Context
The MP is concerned about the impact of vaccine-resistant strains.
Matthew Hancock
Yes, I do. All those who arrive in this country as passengers need to undergo quarantine, and we have both the hotel quarantine and home quarantine; all need to be tested; and all the positive test results are sent for sequencing so that we can spot any new variants.
Session: Covid-19 Vaccination Programme
View All Questions -->
Will the Secretary of State ensure that staff can get vaccinated when second doses are delivered to care homes?
Context
The MP is concerned about the uneven vaccine distribution to care home staff.
Matthew Hancock
Yes, when the vaccination programme goes to a care home, vaccines are offered both to residents and to staff, of course. We want to support the ability of more and more people to access the vaccine, and that includes care home staff. People who work in a care home can now go on to the national vaccination site and book themselves an appointment.
Session: Covid-19 Vaccination Programme
View All Questions -->
Yesterday, the Secretary of State revealed that only a quarter of care home residents in England had been vaccinated against covid, despite being the No. 1 priority group. Can he explain why they were not the first cohort to receive the Pfizer vaccine in December, as was the case in Scotland?
Context
The Secretary of State previously disclosed that only a quarter of residents in English care homes had been vaccinated, despite being the highest priority group. This is significantly lower than Scotland's efforts.
Matthew Hancock
That is not quite right. I am glad to report that care home residents have been receiving the Pfizer jab. That is harder—logistically more difficult. Looking at the total roll-out of the programme, I am delighted that, as the hon. Lady says, over a quarter of people who are residents in care homes are now able to get the jab, and that number is rising sharply.
Session: Covid-19 Vaccine Roll-out
View All Questions -->
As the Secretary of State highlighted earlier, primary care networks will play a major role in rolling out the vaccine in England, but we have heard previously from MPs that not all areas are covered by such networks. How does he plan to avoid a postcode lottery and ensure equitable access, with outreach into vulnerable ethnic or deprived communities?
Context
The MP raised concerns about potential postcode lottery in vaccine rollout and asked for measures to ensure outreach into vulnerable ethnic or deprived communities.
Matthew Hancock
Some 99% of GP surgeries are members of primary care networks. The very small minority that are not are being dealt with to ensure that we have fair access to vaccines, and they will of course be covered by invitations to the large vaccination sites as well. I agree strongly with the hon. Lady that it is vital that we reach into and support those communities who may be more distant and harder to reach both geographically and, in some cases, culturally. The NHS is very well placed to do that and is one of the most trusted public services in encouraging those from all backgrounds to take the jab. Pharmacists, too, will play a vital role in the outreach programme.
Session: Covid-19 Cancer Diagnosis and Treatment
View All Questions -->
Can he clarify whether we will hear an announcement from the Chancellor in the near future on supporting the installation of such systems? What is his strategy to control covid over the coming year?
Context
The MP has highlighted previously that COVID-19 is spread not just by droplets but also by airborne particles, emphasizing the importance of good ventilation. She raised the issue of VAT on ventilation and air-purification systems.
Matthew Hancock
Our strategy is to suppress the virus and support the NHS and the economy until a vaccine can make us safe. Increased ventilation can help reduce transmission.
Session: Covid-19 Economic Effect
View All Questions -->
Can he clarify what discussions he has had with the Chancellor about removing VAT from ventilation and air-purification systems to make them more affordable?
Context
The MP has highlighted previously that COVID-19 is spread not just by droplets but also by airborne particles, emphasizing the importance of good ventilation. She raised the issue of VAT on ventilation and air-purification systems.
Matthew Hancock
There has been work on promoting ventilation in government. The scientific evidence on aerosol transmission of coronavirus has strengthened over recent months.
Session: Covid-19 Economic Effect
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Pathways Study: Puberty Suppression
22 June 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill 2025-10-20
20 October 2025
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
I beg to move amendment 1, page 1, line 7, leave out subsection (2) and insert—(1A) The Treaty and sections 2 to 4 of this Act do not come into force until the duties outlined in section [The addition...
Making Britain a Clean Energy Superpower
26 July 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Government's plan aims to address the challenges of energy insecurity, skyrocketing consumer bills, job creation in industrial heartlands, and climate change by investing in clean energy. The Ener...
NHS
23 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Infected Blood Compensation Scheme
21 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Scottish Affairs Committee
18 September 2023
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Committee of Selection has deliberated and moved a motion to discharge Deidre Brock and Dr Philippa Whitford from the Scottish Affairs Committee, and to add Alan Brown and Ms Anum Qaisar.
Hong Kong Pro-democracy Activists
06 July 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Violence in the West Bank
04 July 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Winnie Ewing
04 July 2023
Adjournment Debate
Contributed to this debate
The SNP MP Ian Blackford celebrated the remarkable achievements of Winifred Margaret Ewing. He highlighted her election to Parliament first for Hamilton in a by-election in 1967, then for Moray in 197...
Israel (Promotion and Implementation of Divestment, Boycotts and Sanctions) Bill - First clause of the Bill
03 July 2023
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities moved that the bill be read a Second time. He paid tribute to Lord Kerslake who passed away recently. The Bill's purpose is to honour a...
9
PMQs Asked
50
Ministerial Questions Asked
119
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
1
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1370 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+146% above average
This MP:
9
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+273% above average
This MP:
50
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+2349% above average
This MP:
119
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-89% below average
This MP:
1
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-100% below average
This MP:
0.0
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Philippa Whitford's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.