Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Making Britain a Clean Energy Superpower

26 July 2024 · 45 other contributors

Opened by Michael Shanks Lab Rutherglen

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Michael Shanks raised concerns about making britain a clean energy superpower in the House of Commons. Other MPs contributed to the debate.

Key points

  • The Government's plan aims to address energy insecurity, high consumer bills, job creation, and climate change through investment in clean energy.
  • The Energy Minister introduced the Great British Energy Bill to increase national ownership of renewable projects and achieve decarbonisation of power supply by 2030 and net zero across the economy.
  • GB Energy will invest 8.3 billion in wind, solar, nuclear, tidal, and other clean energy sources, collaborating with the Crown Estate to unlock billions in investment.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Michael Shanks Lab Rutherglen

The Government's plan aims to address the challenges of energy insecurity, skyrocketing consumer bills, job creation in industrial heartlands, and climate change by investing in clean energy. The Energy Minister has introduced the Great British Energy Bill to increase national ownership of renewable projects, aiming for decarbonisation of power supply by 2030 and net zero across the economy. GB Energy will invest £8.3 billion in various technologies and collaborate with the Crown Estate to unlock billions of investment, focusing on wind, solar, nuclear, tidal, and other clean energy sources.

Other contributors (45)
  • Michael Shanks Lab Rutherglen

    Emphasised the urgent need for a green energy future that tackles multiple challenges such as energy insecurity, consumer bills, job creation, and climate change. He introduced GB Energy's plan to invest in renewable projects across the UK, aiming at decarbonisation by 2030 and net zero by the end of this Parliament.

  • Richard Holden Con Basildon and Billericay

    Asked for clarity on how much GB Energy will save or cost British households by the next election, questioning Labour's claims during the general election campaign.

  • Andy McDonald Lab Middlesbrough and Thornaby East

    Supported the Minister’s plans for Great British Energy, praising the initiative as a priority that can drive down carbon emissions and energy costs through public ownership and private investment. He sought details on GB Energy's controlling stake in new projects and its approach to energy storage.

  • Deirdre Costigan Lab Ealing Southall

    Celebrated the plans for Great British Energy, contrasting it with the Conservative party's support for foreign governments owning UK infrastructure. She questioned if GB Energy will deliver lower gas prices and highlighted how the current model of international ownership limits benefits to the UK.

  • Harriet Cross Con Gordon and Buchan

    Questioned whether the plans to ban new oil and gas licences put up to 90,000 jobs at risk in Scotland. She asked if this was supported by the Government.

  • Seamus Logan SNP Aberdeenshire North and Moray East

    Asked how GB Energy would deliver lower gas prices when one of his colleagues admitted that international markets determine gas prices. He sought clarity on reducing reliance on fossil fuels.

  • Ellie Chowns Green North Herefordshire

    Highlighted the importance of tackling demand-side issues in addition to supply, questioning if new buildings would be constructed to net-zero standards and whether there was a timeline for this. She also inquired about the need for a nationwide street-by-street insulation programme.

  • Henry Tufnell Lab Mid and South Pembrokeshire

    Asked for assurance that there would be binding commitments to local content and addressing skills gaps in the supply chain, particularly concerning floating offshore wind projects off the coast of Wales and Scotland.

  • Meg Hillier Lab Co-op Hackney South and Shoreditch

    Inquired about conversations across Government to resolve capacity issues within the construction industry to deliver on the net-zero agenda.

  • Catherine Fookes Lab Monmouthshire

    Expressed interest in community energy projects mentioned in the Bill, asking for an update on when these projects could start bidding into the process.

  • Ben Obese-Jecty Con Huntingdon

    Questioned the Government's commitment to rural communities regarding large solar farms. He expressed concern over the scale of developments and their impact on local areas.

  • Brian Leishman Lab Alloa and Grangemouth

    Asked for an update on the next meeting of the Grangemouth future industry board leadership forum, focusing on steps taken to address potential refinery closure issues.

  • Barry Gardiner Lab Brent West

    Asked for updates regarding carbon capture, usage and storage projects. He highlighted uncertainties in funding and the need for swift financial decisions on track 1 CCUS proposals.

  • Carla Denyer Green Bristol Central

    Welcomed much of what was said but questioned the Government's commitment to ending new oil and gas licences, particularly regarding the Rosebank field. She inquired about future plans for oil and gas.

  • Claire Coutinho Con East Surrey

    Welcomed the Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero. Praised Conservative Government's record on energy security and net zero, criticising Labour's promises as unrealistic and harmful to economic stability.

  • Meg Hillier Lab Co-op Hackney South and Shoreditch

    Congratulated Claire Coutinho on her chutzpah but criticised the Conservative Government’s record on net zero policies, including stop-start feed-in tariffs and failed competitions for carbon capture.

  • Barry Gardiner Lab Brent West

    Responded to Claire Coutinho's call for balanced sources by citing the World Economic Forum, which stated that renewables are now undercutting fossil fuels as the world’s cheapest source of energy.

  • Mary Glindon Lab Newcastle upon Tyne East

    Advocates for the expansion of green industries to support job creation. Emphasises the importance of supporting oil and gas workers transitioning into new sectors, highlighting the need for a stable and predictable energy industry to fund opportunities such as floating offshore wind and carbon capture and storage.

  • Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem Bath

    Community energy projects like Bath and West Community Energy in her constituency highlight the importance of local control over energy resources, raising £11 million from nearly 1000 members to donate back to the community for various initiatives. She criticises previous governments' lack of support for renewables and calls for a net zero delivery authority to streamline decision-making and resource allocation between central and local government. Hobhouse also urges the Government to address grid connection delays affecting renewable energy projects, advocating for significant infrastructure development while ensuring community engagement.

  • Richard Holden Con Basildon and Billericay

    Asked if she agrees with adopting a 'underground first' approach for new energy transmission infrastructure similar to Germany’s model to avoid the construction of overhead pylons, reflecting a concern about visual impact on the landscape.

  • Mark Hendrick Lab Co-op Preston

    Clarified that Labour's manifesto does indeed include provisions for community energy under their 'Local Power Plan', addressing Wera Hobhouse’s earlier claim that it was not mentioned in the manifesto.

  • Barry Gardiner Lab Brent West

    Suggested an alternative to undergrounding power lines, proposing the use of screening methods which are less costly and could help create biodiversity corridors for wildlife connectivity and adaptation to climate change.

  • Jessica Asato Lab Lowestoft

    Jessica Asato, a Labour MP for Lowestoft, paid tribute to her predecessors and expressed gratitude towards the people of her constituency. She emphasised that politics should focus on serving those who feel neglected or at the periphery. Asato highlighted numerous issues affecting her constituents including sewage pollution in rivers and seas, lack of flood protection, coastal erosion, food poverty, access to NHS dentistry, and childhood inequalities. She also commended Labour's plan for increasing emergency dental appointments and introducing supervised toothbrushing in schools. Additionally, she endorsed the GB Energy project as crucial for addressing energy challenges and fostering economic growth.

  • Richard Holden Con Basildon and Billericay

    Welcomed the new Deputy Speaker and congratulated Jess Asato on her maiden speech. He praised Peter Aldous and urged new Members to engage with their neighbours across party lines. He highlighted the previous Government's progress in renewable energy but also noted the ongoing need for oil and gas, particularly in constituencies like Aberdeenshire. Richard Holden emphasised the importance of private sector investment in energy infrastructure and raised concerns about community-owned energy companies such as Robin Hood Energy which had cost taxpayers significantly. He called on the government to provide clarity regarding costs associated with net zero plans and warned against ignoring local considerations when implementing new renewable energy projects.

  • Polly Billington Lab East Thanet

    Discussed the historical context of East Thanet, acknowledging previous MPs and their contributions. Highlighted local landmarks and cultural significance, including the Turner art gallery in Margate, Ramsgate tunnels, and renewable energy projects. Addressed challenges such as sewage pollution affecting tourism and economic development, advocating for a year-round economy supported by infrastructure and community initiatives.

  • Pippa Heylings Lib Dem South Cambridgeshire

    Congratulates colleagues on their appointments and acknowledges the historic change in her constituency. Emphasises the importance of a clear framework for local climate action and supports community energy initiatives. Discusses challenges such as poverty, affordable housing, and environmental protection, particularly concerning chalk streams.

  • Mark Hendrick Lab Co-op Preston

    Highlights the historic partnership between Great British Energy and the Crown Estate aimed at clean power investment. Supports job creation, energy independence, and economic revitalisation through renewable energy capacity expansion. Emphasises the need for collaboration with the private sector and the importance of accelerating infrastructure investment. Raises concerns about woody biomass burning practices and calls for sustainable subsidies.

  • Greg Smith Con Mid Buckinghamshire

    The speaker argues for a cautious approach to solar energy deployment, highlighting concerns about its impact on food security and rural landscapes. He emphasises the need for smaller-scale stand-alone solar installations that provide additional income for farmers without harming local infrastructure or community consent. Smith advocates for nuclear power, particularly small modular reactors, as a more land-efficient solution compared to large-scale solar farms. Additionally, he supports synthetic fuels as an alternative to electric vehicles for heavy and long-distance vehicles, advocating for government support in scaling up production of these clean fuels.

  • Torcuil Crichton Lab Na h-Eileanan an Iar

    Congratulates the Deputy Speaker and fellow new MPs, discusses his constituency's connections to energy transition and community involvement. Emphasises the importance of wind energy in powering Britain’s future while preserving the power of local communities. Acknowledges historical contributions from previous Labour Government initiatives and looks forward to continued support for land reform and community energy units.

  • Adrian Ramsay Green Waveney Valley

    I am honoured to follow the maiden speeches of other Members, particularly those from my constituency and neighbouring areas. I express gratitude for being elected as a Green MP representing Waveney Valley, a new constituency in Norfolk-Suffolk border. The area is known for its vibrant market towns, historical significance, natural beauty including rivers, and rich cultural heritage. Despite this, residents face challenges such as lack of access to essential services like dental care, with some making four-hour round trips or resorting to pulling out their own teeth due to inadequate NHS provision. Concerns over environmental degradation, including sewage in rivers, rural isolation due to reduced bus services, and loss of local GP appointments are prevalent. I aim to represent my constituents by advocating for the restoration of local services and defending the environment while working constructively across political lines. My primary focus is on climate action, urging a comprehensive approach that includes scaling up renewable energy, mitigating carbon emissions from fossil fuels like Rosebank oilfield, enhancing public policy for adapting to climate change, and addressing nature depletion alongside these efforts.

  • Zubir Ahmed Lab Glasgow South West

    Welcomes the Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero. Thanks his predecessor Chris Stephens and acknowledges local history, heritage trusts, and companies such as BAE Systems and Thales in defence, fintech and medtech companies like Barclays and Cohesion Medical, TV and film companies like Firecrest Films. Discusses BBC Scotland headquarters and Sunny Govan radio station’s role in the community. Acknowledges concerns about job security and quality of life but asserts commitment to making the economy work for working people and restoring intergenerational covenant through diligent analysis, patience and discipline to deliver enduring change.

  • Sarah Bool Con South Northamptonshire

    Pays tribute to former Members of Parliament and discusses concerns over the destruction of agricultural land for solar farms. Highlights the importance of clean energy but argues against current proposals that threaten food security and rural landscapes, suggesting alternative solutions such as rooftops and transport corridors. Emphasises the need for respectful debate and advocacy for those with hidden disabilities.

  • Alan Gemmell Lab Central Ayrshire

    Mr. Gemmell congratulates the Deputy Speaker and honours his predecessors, including Dr Philippa Whitford, Sandra Osborne, and Brian Donohoe. He highlights the importance of community service and acknowledges his constituency's rich history in energy, aerospace, and cultural heritage. He mentions the economic impact of events like the Open golf tournament and local initiatives such as the Friends of Broadway Prestwick and Troon lifeboat station. Mr. Gemmell also talks about Robert Burns' connection to Central Ayrshire and highlights the contribution of businesses like GE Caledonian, NATS, and Spirit in the aerospace sector. He expresses concern over poverty and lack of opportunity in his constituency and advocates for Labour policies to improve jobs, reduce bills with GB Energy, increase funding for the NHS and schools, and ensure better living conditions for working people.

  • Harriet Cross Con Gordon and Buchan

    Emphasises the negative impact of the Government's plan to cover agricultural land with energy infrastructure. Highlights the importance of the oil and gas sector for jobs, expertise, and investment in renewable energy. Criticises the ban on new oil and gas licences as it risks losing vital skills and increasing reliance on imported oil and gas from more volatile markets. Condemns Labour’s plans to end new oil and gas licences and remove the windfall tax allowance, arguing that this will cost £20 billion in tax revenues and risk up to 100,000 jobs.

  • David Baines Lab St Helens North

    I am delighted to be able to make my maiden speech as the Member of Parliament for St Helens North during this important debate. I highlight the challenges faced by teachers and staff in schools, thanking them for their hard work and commitment. I pay tribute to my predecessor, Conor McGinn, and express gratitude towards my family, especially my wife Helen and children, who support me in this role. My constituency is rich in history and industry, with a focus on regeneration efforts such as Parkside in Newton-le-Willows and the development of Glass Futures, which aims to decarbonise the global glass industry. I emphasise the importance of tackling climate change through initiatives like HyNet and Mersey Tidal, while also creating jobs and opportunities for workers. Furthermore, I advocate for a whole-Government approach to address child poverty, economic stability, affordable energy, new social housing, inclusive growth, investment in town centres, public services, and high aspirations for education. Education is crucial for social mobility and personal fulfillment, and it is imperative that all children have access to quality education with adequate support and adjustments.

  • Alison Bennett Lib Dem Mid Sussex

    The Liberal Democrats advocate closer ties with European allies and neighbours for global stability. Mid Sussex, her constituency, faces issues such as infrastructure development alongside housing growth, similar to concerns raised by Baron Renton in 1974 regarding Gatwick airport expansion. She emphasises the importance of a robust care system that supports carers and individuals with disabilities, advocating for policies that ensure people can live their best lives regardless of health or life stage. Bennett highlights local efforts in her constituency towards mental health support, food security, and climate action through community initiatives such as solar panel installations on schools and wineries to generate renewable energy. She calls for Government intervention to ease the transition to renewable energy by speeding up grid connections and utilising underused spaces like rooftops and railway sides for solar arrays.

  • Kirsteen Sullivan Lab Co-op Bathgate and Linlithgow

    Sullivan expressed gratitude for the opportunity to make her maiden speech during a debate about Scotland's role in green energy. She highlighted the natural beauty of Bathgate and Linlithgow, emphasising the importance of reaching net-zero targets while protecting the environment. Sullivan paid tribute to her predecessor Martyn Day and former MP Michael Connarty. She mentioned the constituency’s industrial heritage and its resilience through past challenges like the miners’ strike. Concerning local issues, she addressed barriers to employment, high living costs, child poverty, underfunded services, and infrastructure pressures. Additionally, Sullivan discussed tourism growth due to TV productions and the co-operative economy's potential. She also acknowledged the importance of intergovernmental cooperation in Scotland.

  • Seamus Logan SNP Aberdeenshire North and Moray East

    Mr. Seamus Logan emphasised the importance of his constituency's role in Scotland’s energy transition, highlighting its potential to lead a renewable energy revolution despite current limitations. He criticised the UK Government for scaling back on their ambitions to invest £28 billion towards clean energy goals and called for urgent action to address issues such as unrealistic contract pricing for offshore wind development. Logan stressed that his constituency is well-positioned due to existing ports, skilled workforce, and proximity to renewable resources but urged the government to ensure a just transition for workers in the oil and gas sector by considering the impact of policies like the energy profits levy on jobs and productivity. He also advocated for supportive fiscal measures and recognition of North sea operators' investment in renewables.

  • Douglas McAllister Lab West Dunbartonshire

    In this maiden speech, Douglas McAllister congratulates the hon. Member for Aberdeenshire North and Moray East on his eloquence and passion and acknowledges the Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero. He expresses pride in representing West Dunbartonshire and outlines its unique history and natural resources. McAllister emphasises the need to regenerate Clydeside, creating jobs and new employment opportunities, especially for young people. He pledges to fight for affordable homes and access to energy security through a publicly owned GB Energy company. Additionally, he highlights ongoing projects like the West Dunbartonshire energy centre on former John Brown’s shipyard site and its role in addressing fuel poverty. McAllister also touches upon legal aid funding issues, local government struggles, the importance of community organisations and charities, as well as personal experiences with the NHS.

  • James MacCleary Lib Dem Lewes

    It is a privilege to represent the Lewes constituency, and I will campaign for electoral reform. My predecessor Maria Caulfield was instrumental in introducing baby loss certificates. Lewes hosts one of the largest bonfire celebrations on 5 November, celebrating independence and history with effigies that include political figures. Newhaven needs a new health centre and has unique historical claims to fame. The constituency includes the South Downs national park, known for vineyards, breweries, and cultural events like Glyndebourne opera house. Concerns about sewage dumping in rivers and support for renewable energy projects such as community ownership of solar power and offshore wind arrays are highlighted.

  • Olivia Blake Lab Sheffield Hallam

    Welcomes the Government's plan to launch Great British Energy, a publicly owned company funded by making big oil and gas companies pay their fair share. Emphasises the importance of economic growth through clean energy, addressing cost of living crisis, and making Britain energy-independent. Highlights the need for increased training opportunities in maritime apprenticeships and unlocking potential of community energy projects.

  • Joy Morrissey Con Beaconsfield

    Morrissey welcomes new Labour MPs, congratulates the Minister on his position and expresses disappointment at the Secretary of State's absence. She criticises GB Energy for not generating energy or reducing bills despite taking £8 billion from taxpayers and setting up a company without a business plan. Morrissey argues that this is a dangerous experiment that will damage the countryside, wreck livelihoods, and increase energy costs.

  • Michael Shanks Lab Rutherglen

    Discussed various aspects of the green energy transition including fuel poverty, economic growth and environmental strategy. Acknowledged concerns about North Sea oil and gas but emphasised the importance of a just transition now. Criticised scaremongering about solar farms impacting food security.

  • Greg Smith Con Mid Buckinghamshire

    Expressed concern over the cumulative impact of solar applications on food security in his constituency, despite current figures being low.

  • Carla Denyer Green Bristol Central

    Called for the Minister to consider research from Exeter University which suggests renewable energy could be increased 13 times over using less than 3% of UK land without affecting high-grade agricultural land.

Get updates like this by email
▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy