John McNally
MP for Falkirk
SNP
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
Following on from the Prime Minister's earlier answer, as he knows, an eat out to help out scheme was introduced in August 2020. It increased demand for eating in restaurants by some 216% compared with 2019. With figures now showing that over 17,500 retail chain stores closed in 2020 alone, affecting nearly 35,000 employees, has the Prime Minister considered a similar scheme for bricks and mortar retail—bricks versus clicks, if you like—as part of a wider plan to regenerate local high streets and town centres?
Context
An eat out to help out scheme increased demand in restaurants by 216% in August 2020. Over 17,500 retail chain stores closed that year, affecting nearly 35,000 employees.
Rishi Sunak
The way we are supporting high streets and town centres is through making sure we cut business rates in England—obviously, the Scottish Government will receive Barnett consequentials from those actions—and now hundreds of thousands of local businesses on our high streets do not pay any business rates at all. On top of that, through the levelling-up fund, towns fund and others, we are investing directly in local communities, including the hon. Gentleman's own, where council leaders described our investment of £90 million as very welcome and a real boost for economic recovery.
Assessment
Did not address considering a similar scheme specifically
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
This month, the Scottish child payment marks its two-year anniversary. In a cost of living crisis, that policy has been a lifeline for hundreds of thousands of people in Scotland. Will the Prime Minister therefore follow the leadership of the Scottish Government by introducing an equivalent child payment?
Context
Scottish child payment marks its two-year anniversary, providing support to hundreds of thousands of people in Scotland during cost of living crisis.
Rishi Sunak
The best way to ensure that children do not grow up in poverty is to make sure that they do not grow up in a workless household. That is why I am proud that, under the record of the Conservative Government, there are almost 1 million fewer children growing up in workless households and hundreds of thousands fewer children in poverty. That is because this Government are on the side of parents and will make sure that they have the jobs they need, because ultimately the best poverty strategy is to have everybody in work.
Assessment
Did not address whether an equivalent child payment would be introduced.
General Principles
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Prime Minister had a holiday in Birmingham; your Government is now flirting with disaster financially and socially. How will you cope with an increase in mortgage repayments and resultant rise in homelessness?
Context
The speaker criticises the Government's approach to managing energy price increases, raising concerns about resultant increase in homelessness.
Elizabeth Truss
We have acted decisively to deal with the severe energy crisis. We are also facing a slowdown in economic growth globally, and not acting is not an option.
Assessment
Specific measures or commitments regarding homelessness were not addressed
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Twice in recent months, I have asked the Prime Minister about his and his Transport Secretary's commitment to delivering the Prime Minister's pledge to invest in UK-built ZEBs—zero-emission buses. I did not receive a clear answer. Worrying reports in the media of Treasury cuts to bus-buying plans highlight a conflict between the Prime Minister and his Chancellor. Is the current Chancellor denying the current Prime Minister the right to fulfil his pledge to buy 4,000 zero-emission buses?
Context
Previous questions about the Government's pledge to invest in UK-built ZEBs were not answered clearly. Reports suggest Treasury cuts to bus-buying plans.
Boris Johnson
There has never in the history of this country been such a bonanza for buses. I am personally a bus fanatic. We are putting £5 billion into buses and cycling during this Parliament, and there is £355 million of new funding for zero-emission buses—and yes of course we want to see the benefits of that funding spread right across the whole of the United Kingdom.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not directly address the conflict or the pledge to buy 4,000 ZEBs but referenced significant investment in buses and cycling.
Referencing Existing Commitments
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Prime Minister, we hear a great deal about the rule of law and justice. Can you tell me what you will do about the injustice my constituents face because of the retrospective loan charge? The hounding by HMRC has managed to mislead Treasury Ministers and appears to lack legal basis or justification. Therefore, will you accept this matter needs further immediate investigation?
Context
Many constituents in Falkirk and across the UK are facing financial hardship due to the retrospective loan charge imposed by HMRC, which is causing widespread distress.
Boris Johnson
I am acutely aware of the pain suffered by those who entered into loan charge schemes, but I think the line taken by the Treasury is right on this.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not accept the need for further investigation as requested.
The Line Taken By The Treasury Is Right
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I thank the Minister for that answer; that is far too many people who have died. Many gruesome deaths have occurred following cosmetic surgery in Turkey. The family of my constituent, 28-year-old Shannon, witnessed the most agonising, horrific death as she lay on a table convulsing for some nine hours. As far as I am aware, not once have Foreign Office Ministers raised those needless deaths with Turkish Government officials. Furthermore, a pitiful byline of travel advice on the gov.uk website is simply not good enough. Will the Minister investigate an advertising suspension, in collaboration with Cabinet colleagues and regulators, for countries known for dangerous health tourism as a possible way to avoid further deaths like Shannon's?
Context
A constituent, Shannon, died at age 28 after undergoing cosmetic surgery in Turkey. Her family experienced a painful death of nine hours.
Leo Docherty
We raise that issue with our Turkish counterparts at many levels. We will always look at what more we can do, but the head of mission in Ankara is seized of the urgency and importance of the issue and is working in close collaboration with the Turkish authorities.
Session: Turkey Surgical Procedures
View All Questions -->
What information does his Department hold on the number of UK nationals who have died following surgical procedures in Turkey in the last 10 years?
Context
28 British nationals have died in Turkey after undergoing elective medical procedures since 2019. The question arises from the need to understand government actions and support for patients.
Leo Docherty
We are aware of 28 British nationals who have died in Turkey following elective medical procedures since 2019. The UK Government continue to engage actively with the Turkish Government on how to support the safety of patients who travel to Turkey for medical treatment.
Session: Turkey Surgical Procedures
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for his answer. It is fast approaching the sixth anniversary of Captain Dean Sprouting being killed in a road traffic accident in 2018 by US servicemen who did not adhere to standard operating procedures or health and safety regulations. Despite efforts, Linda continues to suffer consequences daily due to complicated jurisdictional procedures.
Context
Captain Dean Sprouting was killed in a road traffic accident on operational duties caused by US servicemen who did not adhere to standard operating procedures or health and safety regulations. The widow, Linda, continues to seek resolution.
James Heappey
The hon. Gentleman raises a very complicated case and the widow, to whom I send my condolences, is obviously keen to see the matter resolved. I suggest that the hon. Gentleman and I meet to discuss the issue in appropriate detail.
Session: Armed Forces Non-combat Incidents and Jurisdictional Constraints
View All Questions -->
What discussions has he had with his US counterpart on increasing awareness of (a) non-combat incidents and (b) jurisdictional constraints affecting the armed forces?
Context
There are ongoing discussions regarding the impact of non-combat incidents and jurisdictional issues faced by UK armed forces, particularly in relation to interactions with US counterparts.
James Heappey
Defence Ministers have close relationships with our US colleagues and discuss such issues on a case-by-case basis.
Session: Armed Forces Non-combat Incidents and Jurisdictional Constraints
View All Questions -->
Given that the economy is flatlining and interest rates are at 5.25%, surely the Chancellor agrees that mortgage interest tax relief must be reintroduced to support households facing high interest rates alongside inflation?
Context
The economy is experiencing stagnation, with mortgage interest rates at 5.25% likely to stay above 5% in the coming year. This situation is causing a squeeze on households' disposable incomes.
Bim Afolami
As the hon. Member has already heard from the Chancellor, the economy is still growing. The latest labour market data shows that incomes are going up at a higher rate than inflation, so I do not recognise the picture that he paints.
Session: Mortgage Interest Rates
View All Questions -->
What recent assessment has been made of the implications for government policies given the current level of mortgage interest rates?
Context
The question follows recent trends in mortgage interest rates, which have implications for the government's policies. The MP is concerned about the impact on household finances.
Bim Afolami
The Government's mortgage charter is providing support to vulnerable households, and arrears and repossessions remain at historic lows. Government support has helped real household incomes rise by 2.7% year on year in the latest data.
Session: Mortgage Interest Rates
View All Questions -->
Will the Minister commit to expanding the eligibility criteria for existing cost of living payments to include those on housing benefits and receiving council tax reductions?
Context
In the Falkirk constituency and across the UK, many older people are struggling to meet basic needs due to high costs. Research shows that expanding eligibility for cost of living payments could help these individuals.
Guy Opperman
We have committed to a £900 further cost of living payment, doubled the winter fuel payment, and provided the highest state pension ever. The Government is passionately supporting pensioners and the most vulnerable on an ongoing basis.
Session: Pensioners Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
What recent assessment has been made of the adequacy of Government support for pensioners in light of rises in the cost of living?
Context
Rises in the cost of living have prompted concerns about the adequacy of government support for pensioners.
Guy Opperman
April saw the biggest ever rise in the state pension by 10.1% due to the triple lock. Every pensioner receives a winter fuel payment and cost of living payment this winter. The poorest pensioners receive a £900 further cost of living payment.
Session: Pensioners Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for that answer but, in the last academic year, English students graduated with £30,000 more debt than their Scottish counterparts. Despite this, both the Government and the Labour party refuse to follow the Scottish Government's lead by abolishing tuition fees in England. With over 16,000 undergraduates dropping out of higher education this year, will this Government admit that their policies are pushing students into debt and often out of university?
Context
English students face higher debt compared to Scottish counterparts, leading to concerns about the government's policies.
Robert Halfon
Actually, we are being fair both to students and to all those taxpayers who do not go to university. Low-income students living away from home will qualify for more living cost support over the coming year than low-income students in Scotland.
Session: Tuition Fees Social Mobility
View All Questions -->
What assessment her Department has made of the potential impact of tuition fees on the social mobility of young people. The introduction of tuition fees did not lead to fewer disadvantaged young people going into higher education, but in the last academic year, English students graduated with £30,000 more debt than Scottish counterparts.
Context
Tuition fees impact disadvantaged students' access and debt burden.
Robert Halfon
The introduction of tuition fees has not led to fewer disadvantaged young people going into higher education. The 18-year-old entry rate for disadvantaged students in England increased from 14.4% in 2011 to 25.1% in 2022. Low-income students living away from home will qualify for more living cost support over the coming year than low-income students in Scotland.
Session: Tuition Fees Social Mobility
View All Questions -->
Given the struggle of women and children due to budget cuts affecting holiday hunger payments and free school meals, can the Minister explain why these groups are being forced to suffer for the economic challenges created by his party?
Context
Research found that women are disproportionately affected by poverty, with high percentages struggling to afford basic necessities like food and utilities. The research highlights cuts to holiday hunger payments and free school meals.
Chris Heaton-Harris
The budget is fair and allows statutory obligations to be met. The Minister meets women's groups regularly and understands the implications of the budget but believes it should be addressed by Northern Ireland Ministers.
Session: Public Services Budget
View All Questions -->
What recent assessment has been made of the adequacy of the budget for public services in Northern Ireland?
Context
The MP is assessing the sufficiency of current funding levels for public services.
Chris Heaton-Harris
The UK Government have recognised the unique challenges that Northern Ireland faces since 2014, providing around £7 billion in additional funding. The per capita spending is about 20% higher than in other parts of the UK.
Session: Public Services Budget
View All Questions -->
Will the Minister consider replicating this successful Scottish policy in England?
Context
The Scottish Government supports more than 50 million free bus journeys for under-22s, encouraging a shift away from cars to public transport in the next generation.
Richard Holden
UK Government money is providing £1 fare cap for under-22s in the north-east and a £2 fare cap in combined authorities like Greater Manchester. On free bus travel, it is about getting the balance right; we want a service that is respected by people when they use it.
Session: Bus Services
View All Questions -->
How does the Secretary of State justify the clawing back of £155 million from the Welsh Government budget when they failed to spend that amount during a pandemic?
Context
The UK Government has recently clawed back £155 million from the Welsh Government budget, leading to questions about its impact on Wales and whether it aligns with best interests.
David Davies
The money was not spent by the Welsh Government; they managed to fail to spend £155 million during a pandemic. The UK provides more NHS funding per capita than Wales, but Wales has longer waiting times and less access to treatment compared to England.
Session: Funding Settlement
View All Questions -->
I wish the Minister would slow his answers down—that was a bit of a blur. Just last week, Harbour Energy announced that it is cutting 350 highly skilled and valued jobs in Aberdeen, directly linking that to the poorly implemented energy profit levy. We warned many times that it would disproportionately affect Aberdeen and Scotland and, unfortunately, we have been proven right. Will the UK Government commit to matching the Scottish Government's £500 million just transition fund, and protect our energy workers?
Context
Recently, Harbour Energy announced job cuts in Aberdeen linked to the poorly implemented energy profit levy.
Andrew Bowie
I am afraid I have to take all that with a massive pinch of salt. Now it turns out that the SNP is against a windfall tax on the oil and gas industry, when it had been campaigning for such a tax for weeks and weeks, months and months. We have introduced the energy profits levy to deal with the immediate crisis regarding energy bills, but we have built into that investment opportunities for companies to continue to innovate, create jobs and develop our offshore oil and gas fields, because we will be reliant on them as a transition fuel for many months to come.
Session: Energy Transition Projects in Scotland
View All Questions -->
What steps he is taking to support energy transition projects in Scotland. The questioner noted that there are 44 renewable electricity projects contracted in Scotland out of a total of 161. He also highlighted the £81.1 million funding allocated to 81 locations in Scotland as part of the net zero innovation portfolio, and mentioned the commitment for Aberdeen energy transition zone and the global underwater hub.
Context
Concern about the support for energy transition projects, especially in light of recent announcements and the impact on Scottish organisations.
Andrew Bowie
We are supporting Scotland's energy transition through the North sea transition deal. Additionally, 44 of the 161 projects awarded contracts for difference for renewable electricity are in Scotland. More recently, we have allocated £81.1 million of funding to 81 locations throughout Scotland—I have a list, but I will not go through them—as part of the £1 billion net zero innovation portfolio, from 2021 to 2025. Furthermore, we have committed to funding the Aberdeen energy transition zone by £27 million, and the global underwater hub aimed at diversification for the subsea sector by £6.5 million.
Session: Energy Transition Projects in Scotland
View All Questions -->
At the last Education questions, the Minister for Skills, Apprenticeships and Higher Education noted that he is very proud of the UK's intake of 600,000 international students every year. International students, as we know, inject billions into our economy, bring huge value to our campuses and enrich our wider society. Can he therefore confirm on the record that the Government will not introduce an illogical policy designed to restrict foreign students?
Context
UK's current international student intake of 600,000 per year injects billions into the economy and enriches society.
Robert Halfon
What I can confirm to the hon Gentleman is that our target was 600,000 international students per year, we currently have 680,000—or just under—international students per year and that 600,000 annual target remains. Obviously, visas are a matter for the Home Office.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for her answer, but the Government are again showing their disregard for the vulnerable of our society by failing to increase state benefits adequately for those who need them most. All the while, the Government disproportionately reward the most affluent areas with their so-called levelling-up grants. Their disregard for the common people, and pensioners in particular, is plain to see. Can the Minister confirm whether there are any plans to reduce the levels of poverty suffered by people caused by her Government's failure to support them adequately?
Context
The Minister's initial answer highlighted government support for pensioners, but the question challenges this by pointing out insufficient benefit increases compared to levelling-up grant disbursements.
Laura Trott
May I remind the hon. Gentleman that under the Conservatives, absolute pensioner poverty has gone down and the state pension has gone up. This Government do deliver and will continue to deliver for pensioners across the United Kingdom.
Session: Cost of Living Pensioners
View All Questions -->
Can the Minister commit to striking a deal before April next year and ensuring it does not hamper Good Friday Agreement celebrations and UK's international relations with America and the EU?
Context
There is uncertainty about the timeline for a UK-EU deal and its impact on international relations.
Chris Heaton-Harris
The atmosphere in relationships between the European Union and the United Kingdom Government has changed dramatically in recent weeks and months, which is the basis for all good things.
Session: Northern Ireland Protocol Assembly Elections
View All Questions -->
Given that Wales has persistently had the highest child poverty rate in the UK, does the Secretary of State not agree that welfare powers should now be devolved to Wales so that the Welsh Government can introduce a targeted child payment?
Context
The Scottish Government has introduced the Scottish child payment to tackle child poverty.
Simon Hart
Even the Welsh Government have not made that argument. I think they recognise proper distribution of welfare is done effectively UK-wide, and the money used in Scotland via Barnett formula.
Session: Costs of Living Households and Businesses
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for her answer. As she knows, the Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition has recommended mandatory folic acid fortification of flour. The UK Government launched a public consultation that closed in 2019. In September last year, the UK Government announced that folic acid will be added to non-wholemeal wheat flour across the UK to help prevent life-threatening spinal conditions in babies. Therefore, can the Minister update the House on the UK Government's timeline to implement the decision in a wee bit more detail, please?
Context
The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition has recommended mandatory folic acid fortification of flour to prevent neural tube defects in babies. A public consultation closed in 2019.
Maggie Throup
I thank the hon. Gentleman for raising this important issue, because fortifying non-wholemeal wheat flour with folic acid will help prevent hundreds of neural tube defects in foetuses every year. I regret that I cannot commit to a specific timetable, but we need to consult on the draft legislation and will look to give industry appropriate notice. All four nations are working together on the timetable and hope to deliver this important policy as soon as possible.
Session: Folic Acid in Flour
View All Questions -->
What recent steps the Government have taken to progress the introduction of mandatory folic acid supplementation in flour to prevent spinal conditions in babies?
Context
The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition has recommended mandatory folic acid fortification of flour to prevent neural tube defects in babies. A public consultation closed in 2019.
Maggie Throup
Following consultation last September, we announced that we would legislate to fortify non-wholemeal wheat flour with folic acid. We are working at pace to move this policy forward and have engaged with industry as part of a cross-Government review of bread and flour regulations. All four nations are now working closely together to develop the draft legislation and impact assessment for future consultation.
Session: Folic Acid in Flour
View All Questions -->
Will the Minister urge her colleagues in the Department for Work and Pensions to match the Scottish Government's offer of an additional payment?
Context
Carers UK recently called for additional payments to unpaid carers due to their financial concerns. In Scotland, there is already a carer's allowance supplement.
Gillian Keegan
There is a carer's allowance in the UK as well, but in most cases financial incentives are not the main driver for those providing unpaid care. However, we may see a shift towards less intensive caring activities or a reduction in the hours spent caring as people become more eligible for state support and we push through some of the reforms. Charging reforms bring an end to the unpredictability of care costs for care users and will do the same for those who provide unpaid care for them, allowing them to make informed choices.
Session: Unpaid Carers
View All Questions -->
The British Dental Association has raised concerns that punitive financial penalties for not meeting the Government's unrealistic activity targets are pushing NHS dentists in England to prioritise quick check-ups rather than catching up on the backlog of more time-consuming symptomatic cases. Will the Minister consider a more realistic approach to service recovery and commit to reforming the dental contract in England so as to promote preventive dental care in future?
Context
Concerns have been raised by the British Dental Association about punitive financial penalties and unrealistic activity targets that may push dentists to prioritize quick check-ups over complex cases, affecting service recovery.
Jo Churchill (Minister for Patient Safety, Transformation and Efficiency)
As anybody will know, I have been heavily engaged with the dental profession over recent months, because I agree that a preventive approach to dentistry is certainly one that we need to be moving towards. The activity target is based on careful modelling and takes into account guidance on infection prevention and control and social distancing measures. We recognise that there may be exceptional circumstances, which is why there are exceptions to the target level.
Session: Covid-19 Dental Services
View All Questions -->
What steps his Department is taking to support dental services during the covid-19 pandemic. I am concerned about the financial penalties for not meeting unrealistic activity targets, which may push dentists towards quick check-ups rather than handling more complex cases. The British Dental Association has raised concerns about this issue.
Context
The question arises from concerns about the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on dental services and funding.
Jo Churchill (Minister for Patient Safety, Transformation and Efficiency)
We are committed to supporting all NHS dental services through the pandemic. NHS practices receive full funding for the first three quarters of the year, minus agreed deductions in England, and NHS dental contractors will continue to be supported while they meet reduced activity targets. The activity target is expected to increase availability for patients based on careful modelling and takes into account guidance on infection prevention and control and social distancing measures.
Session: Covid-19 Dental Services
View All Questions -->
When will the Minister confirm a date on our attaining equivalence on seed products? If he cannot give us a date, is that not more evidence that the Government do not care about Scotland's farming communities?
Context
Discusses the importance of equivalence between UK and EU standards for seed potatoes, crucial for Scottish farmers exporting to Northern Ireland.
Brandon Lewis
Through the Joint Committee, we are working with the European Union on some of these final issues to ensure that we do have that free flow. We delivered £315 million last week to farmers across Northern Ireland and Scotland as evidence of our commitment.
Session: UK-EU Future Relationship Businesses
View All Questions -->
What assessment has been made of the effect on businesses in Northern Ireland of negotiations on the future relationship between the UK and the EU? In fact, Northern Ireland businesses have a huge potential under the Northern Ireland protocol, and of course Northern Ireland will continue to enjoy tariff-free access to the EU market.
Context
Discusses the impact of negotiations between the UK and EU on Northern Ireland's trade relationships, specifically focusing on the potential benefits under the Northern Ireland protocol.
Brandon Lewis
We want a relationship with the European Union that is based on friendly co-operation between sovereign equals and centred on free trade. The whole of the United Kingdom, including Northern Ireland, stands to benefit from such a trading relationship with the European Union. In fact, Northern Ireland businesses have huge potential under the Northern Ireland protocol, and they will continue to enjoy tariff-free access to the EU market alongside unfettered access to the entire UK.
Session: UK-EU Future Relationship Businesses
View All Questions -->
What guidance has the Secretary of State given to devolved Assemblies and local authorities regarding holding remembrance services this Sunday?
Context
Royal British Legion branches are preparing for Remembrance Sunday, with local authorities needing guidance on conducting remembrance events.
Johnny Mercer
This is a very important time of year. We encourage people to remember in their own way. Remembrance events will go ahead, and there will be a small national ceremony at the Cenotaph that we encourage people to watch on television.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Will DEFRA Ministers go further and insist with their counterparts in the Department for International Trade on high standards for animal welfare, phytosanitary and food production imports to protect our domestic food producers?
Context
The MP is concerned about the potential compromise of high standards for animal welfare, phytosanitary measures, and food production as part of upcoming trade deals. He specifically asks whether DEFRA will insist on maintaining these high standards with their counterparts in international trade.
George Eustice
The Government are clear about maintaining high food and animal welfare standards as we approach trade agreements. The UK will set its own domestic standards for SPS issues, such as food safety, at a UK level without compromising these standards in response to other countries' demands.
Session: Financial Support for Food Producers
View All Questions -->
The International Rescue Committee highlights that hand-washing facilities are crucial for disease prevention in developing countries, noting NGOs' effectiveness during previous crises like Ebola. Welcoming recent funding to organisations such as the Red Cross, McNally asks about plans to increase support for local NGOs working within communities.
Context
Hand washing with soap and water is crucial in preventing the spread of coronavirus. The UK has expertise in this area.
Wendy Morton
Good hygiene is crucial in preventing covid-19 transmission, and water sanitation and hygiene are key parts of DFID's work during humanitarian crises. Since 2015, DFID has helped over 51 million people gain access to safe drinking water or toilets for the first time. However, there is still more to be done.
Session: Developing Countries Sanitation and Hygiene
View All Questions -->
The Scottish Government has invested around £85 million in a state-of-the-art college campus in Falkirk where students from all over Europe attend Forth Valley College. EU students bring significant economic benefits to the college, Falkirk, Scotland, and the UK, enriching institutions culturally and academically. What steps is the Department taking to ensure that the UK remains open, attractive, and competitive for EU students in the years ahead?
Context
The UK is negotiating its future relationship with EU educational and research programmes post-transition period.
Michelle Donelan (Minister of State for Universities, Science, Research and Innovation)
We are committed to remaining open to participating in elements of the Erasmus scheme. The Government are very positive about the benefits of students coming to this country, which is why the Prime Minister announced that there will be a graduate option from 01 January 2021 so that graduates will be able to work in this country for two years following their degree.
Session: EU Educational and Research Programmes
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Backbench Business
16 May 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The debate urges the UK Government to deliver prompt compensation to women born in the 1950s who had their state pension age raised. The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman report highlights th...
Hunting Trophies (Prohibition) Bill - Second Reading of the Bill
22 March 2024
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
The lead MP, John Spellar, is advocating for the Second Reading of the Hunting Trophies (Prohibition) Bill. He emphasises the need to prohibit importing hunting trophies from endangered animals, highl...
Backbench Business
18 January 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The debate focuses on the harmful effects of the Loan Charge imposed by HM Revenue and Customs, including suicides due to financial pressure, failures in supervision by HMRC, and perceived unfairness ...
Hong Kong Update
13 July 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Prime Minister
20 July 2022
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Asked the Prime Minister to reflect on the seven principles of public life during the summer recess, highlighting low trust in politicians and urging a personal review of why public confidence is at a...
Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy
12 July 2022
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Action on Climate Change and Decarbonisation
05 July 2022
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Mr Dunne thanked the Chair of the Backbench Business Committee and other members for supporting the debate to discuss the Government's spending plans on climate change and decarbonisation. He noted th...
COP26
15 June 2022
General Debate
Led by this MP
John McNaly questioned the Government's commitment to their COP26 climate promises, noting that investment in new fossil fuel production was considered 'moral and economic madness' by the UN Secretary...
Tackling Short-term and Long-term Cost of Living Increases
17 May 2022
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Reminds Members about the importance of attending the debate from start to finish, advises on courtesy during debates, and informs the House that Mr Speaker has selected an amendment by the Leader of ...
Civil Service Appointments
30 June 2020
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Asked the Home Secretary to make a statement on the appointment of the National Security Adviser and other senior civil service positions. Raised concerns about the politicisation of the National Secu...
5
PMQs Asked
31
Ministerial Questions Asked
13
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1457 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+37% above average
This MP:
5
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+131% above average
This MP:
31
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+167% above average
This MP:
13
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-100% below average
This MP:
0.0
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks John McNally's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.