Alistair Carmichael
MP for Orkney and Shetland
Lib Dem
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
I have always respected the Prime Minister as somebody who was in politics because he wanted to give service to his country. In my constituency, those who volunteer as coastguard rescue officers also do so from a wish to give service to their community. Will the Prime Minister ensure that the money paid to them properly reflects the respect they earn for their service?
Context
In Alistair Carmichael's constituency, volunteer coastguard rescue officers face a question of proper recognition for their service through adequate compensation.
Keir Starmer
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for this really important question and pay tribute to every volunteer; they show incredible bravery in putting their lives at risk to save others. Our guiding principle is ensuring that we respond to this complex case by properly recognising their vital work. Ministers will continue to work with all parties, the coastguard rescue service and volunteers to respond to their concerns and get this right.
Assessment
No specific commitment on funding or compensation
Under Review
Working With Parties
Session: PMQs 2026-07-15
View Full Session -->
With unanimous support from cross-party members, the Select Committee and those on his own Benches want to tackle tax evasion while supporting farmers producing food for the nation's table. Will the Prime Minister listen to these requests and pause current inheritance tax reforms?
Context
The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee published a report on the Government’s vision for agriculture. The committee raised concerns about inheritance tax proposals affecting family farms.
The Prime Minister (Keir Starmer)
The right hon. Gentleman knows the very limited impact of the inheritance tax, only on farmers at a very high level. He will also know the record amount of money in the Budget that we put into farming and the measures taken yesterday with the EU deal, which will massively help farmers who sell their product into the EU market.
Assessment
No specific response to the request for pausing inheritance tax reforms or addressing committee concerns.
Commitment To Farming
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I know that you, Mr Speaker, want to join me in sending condolences to the friends, family and colleagues of our former colleague, Lord Andrew Stunell, who served with exceptional diligence and grace as MP for Hazel Grove in this House, and who passed away very suddenly on Monday. When the BBC ends longwave radio transmission next year, that will also end access to electricity tariffs such as Total Heating Total Control, which is relied on by almost 1 million households across the United Kingdom. Switching to smart meters will not fix that for most people, not least because the roll-out programme is so far behind. Will the Prime Minister, or possibly the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, get energy companies, the regulator and customer groups together, so that we can stop passing the blame around, and find a solution that does not yet again leave people in the highlands and island behind and out in the cold?
Context
The MP noted the end of longwave radio transmission, affecting access to electricity tariffs relied upon by almost 1 million households.
Rishi Sunak
I understand that an agreement has now been reached to ensure that radio teleswitch services will continue until June next year. Ofgem is also engaging with energy suppliers on their plans to support consumers through the transition. While households currently covered by the service should not be disadvantaged by the switch-off, energy suppliers are best placed to advise on tariffs for those who have been switched to a smart meter. However, I will ensure that the right hon. Gentleman gets a meeting with the relevant Minister, to ensure that his constituents are not left behind during the transition.
Assessment
The PM did not commit to convening a meeting now but promised one later.
Households Should Not Be Disadvantaged
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Last week, the Home Office announced that it would not be setting up a bespoke visa scheme for the fishing industry of the sort that is already available for people working in fish farms and in offshore wind farms. It also told skippers that crew previously employed by them under a temporary scheme had to stop working immediately. As a consequence of that announcement, in fishing ports around the coast today, many fishing boats are tied up unable to go to sea. What is the point of a sea of opportunity if they cannot get crew to fish in it?
Context
The Home Office announced it would not set up a bespoke visa scheme for the fishing industry, affecting crew availability in fishing ports around the coast.
Rishi Sunak
We are proud champions of the UK's fishing industry, not least with our £100 million investment in fishing communities. We are always looking to engage with those communities to make sure that they get the support that they need.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Appeasing murderous despots will never be the route to security of energy supply. Would it not make more sense for the Prime Minister to be here talking to UK energy industries? Should he not be talking to renewable energy developers about what they can do to bring their product onstream quicker? Should he not also be speaking to our offshore oil and gas industry about what it can do in the here and now to improve security of supply and to assist in the journey towards net zero?
Context
The Prime Minister is in Saudi Arabia for an investment deal.
Dominic Raab
The Prime Minister did that on Monday evening, and it is now Wednesday. Yes, he is out in Saudi Arabia to close a £1 billion investment deal that will create 700 jobs in the north in renewable energy. I think the Lib Dems need to keep up.
Assessment
Did not address specific industries or UK needs mentioned, instead criticized the opposition party.
Criticized The Opposition
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Prime Minister met my constituent Ronnie Norquoy on his crab boat and discussed problems caused by the Migration Advisory Committee classifying deck hands as unskilled. The MAC now classes them as skilled labour. Will he put the Home Secretary straight on this?
Context
The Migration Advisory Committee has recently changed its advice, classing deck hands as skilled labour eligible for visas.
Boris Johnson
I am grateful to the right hon. Gentleman. I will make sure the Home Secretary is seized of the matter and that we take it forward, thanks to taking control of our immigration system.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Last week the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland said that the UK Internal Market Bill would breach our obligations under international law. Yesterday the Advocate General for Scotland said that the Secretary of State was wrong to say that. Today the Secretary of State says that the Advocate General was wrong to say that he was wrong. It is of course possible that they are both right in saying that the other is wrong, but surely an important matter such as this requires clarity. For that reason, will the Prime Minister now undertake to publish the advice he has had from all his Law Officers so that the House can make an informed decision on the question of legality, come Monday?
Context
The question is prompted by conflicting statements from various government officials regarding the legality of the UKIM Bill. It seeks clarity on whether it breaches international law.
Boris Johnson
I thank the right hon. Gentleman. I think he asked substantially the same question last week. As he knows, we do not publish the Attorney General's advice—Governments do not normally publish such advice—but what I can certainly say is what I have said to the right hon. Gentleman the leader of the Scottish nationalists: that, of course, this Bill is intended to uphold the economic, political and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom, and I believe it should be supported by every Member of this House.
Assessment
Did not agree to publish legal advice
Stating Government Does Not Normally Publish Such Advice
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
If you think it is acceptable for your Government to ignore international law, on what basis would you oppose a wildcat independence referendum?
Context
Some Scottish nationalists advocate for an independence referendum similar to Catalonia's, which is illegal.
Boris Johnson
My job is to uphold the integrity of the UK and protect the Northern Irish peace process. We need a legal safety net to protect against extreme interpretations of the protocol that could lead to a border down the Irish sea, which would be prejudicial to the Good Friday agreement.
Assessment
Did not specify basis for opposing an illegal referendum beyond upholding UK integrity and peace process
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
He notes that current UK labelling laws allow beef from any country to be labelled as British if packaged here and asks whether the Prime Minister will take action on this issue to maintain food standards post-Brexit.
Context
Carmichael mentions the importance of high-quality beef produced in his constituency, stressing the necessity for clear traceability.
The Prime Minister (Boris Johnson)
Johnson acknowledges Carmichael's concern but suggests it is governed by EU laws and implies Scotland would revert to the EU if it were independent. He states this side of the House intends to use Brexit freedoms to protect Scottish beef farmers.
Assessment
The loophole in labelling legislation
Implied Reference To Eu Laws
Suggestion Of Returning To Eu If Scotland Were Independent
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The largest sector of the manufacturing base is food manufacturing, but it was deliberately left out of the industrial strategy. With the benefit of hindsight, do the Government think that it was possibly a mistake to exclude food manufacturing from the industrial strategy?
Context
Food manufacturing is a key sector in Orkney and Shetland, but it was excluded from the Government's industrial strategy. This has led to concerns about rising input costs and lack of assistance for food manufacturers.
Chris McDonald
At the time that the industrial strategy was established, the Government carefully selected those sectors that had the greatest growth potential for the economy. However, they were also clear that other important sectors, like food manufacturing, are still crucial. The Government is aware of issues around food prices.
Session: Industrial Strategy
View All Questions -->
Airlines are already adding fuel surcharges to ticket prices as a consequence of current events. Does the Secretary of State agree that they should publish trigger points for when these surcharges will be removed?
Context
Concerns over airlines adding fuel surcharges without clear removal triggers.
Heidi Alexander
The right hon. Gentleman raises an interesting question, but I reassure the House that in recent conversations with airlines and airports, we have not been told of any immediate disruptions to jet fuel supply.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Some 40% of flight diversions from Stornoway, Benbecula and Barra airports could have been avoided if we were part of EGNOS. This has significant social and financial implications —schedules are cut, people reconsider living arrangements due to lack of connectivity. Will the Minister consider rejoining EGNOS?
Context
Since losing access to EGNOS, island communities have faced increased flight cancellations, higher ticket prices, and potential issues with air ambulances landing.
Keir Mather
I am cognisant of the fact that air connectivity in the Scottish highlands is not a “nice to have” but an absolute necessity. My officials would be keen to engage with stakeholders as part of the review, obtaining evidence on EGNOS benefits.
Session: European Geostationary Navigation Overlay Service
View All Questions -->
Since we lost access to EGNOS, the number of cancellations to island communities has trebled, putting up the cost of tickets, and occasionally air ambulance flights are unable to get in. That has been the cost of coming out of EGNOS. Will the Minister meet me and his colleague to find a way of progressing this without any further delay?
Context
Since the UK lost access to EGNOS, there has been a significant increase in flight cancellations and higher ticket prices for island communities. The issue is exacerbated by occasional inability of air ambulances to land.
Keir Mather
I would be very glad to meet the right hon. Member and our colleague. We intend to review the role that technologies such as EGNOS can play, especially for remote airports susceptible to adverse weather conditions.
Session: European Geostationary Navigation Overlay Service
View All Questions -->
Obviously, there are real opportunities to be had from the completion of an SPS agreement, but those who import fresh produce are concerned that imports from countries outside the European Union will become more difficult and more expensive. May I encourage the Secretary of State to engage more vigorously with the Fresh Produce Consortium?
Context
Concerns about imports becoming more difficult and expensive as a consequence of an SPS agreement.
Emma Reynolds
The Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs is more than happy to meet the consortium. As the right hon. Gentleman said, there is a big prize here, because we do more trade with our nearest trading market and, as he knows, there have been significant delays at the border.
Session: EU-UK Sanitary and Phytosanitary Agreement Negotiations
View All Questions -->
Has the Minister had the opportunity to consider the report by the Andersons Centre for CropLife UK? It estimates that if a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement with the European Union was implemented without a suitable implementation period, it could result in steep drops in UK crop production and a total loss of income of up to £810 million. That is why the Select Committee is today asking for an implementation period of 24 months. Will she impress upon her colleagues in the Cabinet Office the need for that suitable implementation period?
Context
The Andersons Centre for CropLife UK report estimates that the SPS agreement could result in steep drops in UK crop production and a total loss of income up to £810 million.
The Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs (Dame Angela Eagle)
The first thing to say is that the SPS agreement is attempting to put right the Tories’ botched Brexit deal, which made it almost impossible for many people to export to our largest market. The idea is that this should be a new, mutually beneficial agreement to remove barriers, and I hope the right hon. Gentleman supports it. I know that the Select Committee report came out last night, and we will certainly respond to it in more detail. We are aware of the potential downsides if wrong deals are done, but we will not sign a deal that is not in the UK’s interests.
Session: Farming Sector Productivity
View All Questions -->
With space being identified as a priority in the strategic defence review, will the Government now reassess the significance of Shetland and its waters as we look to the developing situation in the far north?
Context
The RAF radar station at Saxa Vord was an important part of UK defences during the Cold War. It has since been repurposed, but recent activities by Russian vessels like Yantar and Bella 1 have raised concerns about regional security.
The Secretary of State for Defence (John Healey)
We deeply value the role that Shetland—and Scotland in general—plays to reinforce the security of the United Kingdom. There are 9,500 full-time troops in Scotland; around 3,000 civilian defence personnel based in Scotland; and over £2 billion was put into the Scottish economy last year to support defence and economic growth throughout the UK.
Session: High North Defence Resources
View All Questions -->
Will the Minister speak to mobile phone operators and telecoms companies about why they are not fulfilling their commitments to maintain connectivity?
Context
Telecoms companies have not met their promises regarding the withdrawal of copper landlines, leaving constituents without connectivity during power outages.
Dan Jarvis (Minister of State, Cabinet Office)
The Minister is looking forward to meeting the Member soon to discuss these issues. He acknowledges that more than 900 engineers were deployed during Storm Goretti to reconnect homes in the south-west.
Session: Emergencies Rural and Coastal Areas
View All Questions -->
Obviously, one of the biggest challenges to farming profitability is the market fact that farmers are price takers. The farming campaigner Olly Harrison was this week highlighting that Lidl and Aldi are selling carrots at 8p per kilo, well below the cost of production. What is the Secretary of State doing to ensure that when supermarkets sell under the cost of production, that cost is borne by the supermarkets, not the farmers?
Context
Supermarkets selling produce below the cost of production, leading to financial strain for farmers. Olly Harrison highlighted that Lidl and Aldi are selling carrots at 8p per kilo, well below the cost of production.
The Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Emma Reynolds)
As the right hon. Gentleman will know, we have already introduced fair dealing regulations for pig and dairy farmers, but I agree with him that we need to look to go further.
Session: Farming Profitability
View All Questions -->
T4. May I take the Security Minister back to the subject of the security of undersea cables? He may know that in Shetland we have had two catastrophic breakages this year as a result of fishing boats breaking the cables. It has now become clear that there is no basic sharing of information between the Government and cable companies, and the cable company in that case had to submit a freedom of information request to get VMS—vessel monitoring system—data. Surely we can do better than that.
Context
Concerns over the lack of information sharing between government and cable companies.
The Minister of State, Cabinet Office (Dan Jarvis)
I am grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for raising this issue. I will look carefully at what he has said and will be happy to meet to discuss it further.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I am sure we all understand the reasons for the Paymaster General’s absence today, although I am less clear on his reasons for being absent from the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee next Tuesday; he has declined our invitation to attend. A bold deal is indeed something to be wished for, but only if it does not bring with it lots of unintended consequences for the farmers, food producers, chemical companies and others whose work will be impacted by it. If Ministers will not engage with the Committee, will the Minister give me some assurance that there will at least be engagement with those vital industry interests?
Context
The UK government is negotiating an SPS agreement with the EU which aims to reduce unnecessary border checks, cut costs for businesses by around £200 per shipment, and boost the economy by about £5 billion annually. The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee has invited the Paymaster General to attend a meeting but he declined.
Chris Ward (Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office)
I understand that the Minister for the Cabinet Office has offered to meet directly with the right hon. Gentleman, the Chair of the Committee, on this—he will get back to the Committee. We will obviously be engaging on this matter and showing scrutiny across Parliament as much as possible. This is an incredibly important part of the deal; the benefits of the agreement are potentially very important; it will be of real benefit to farmers and other communities.
Session: EU SPS Agreement
View All Questions -->
The Secretary of State is right that any threat of an imminent increase in US beef imports in particular is clearly not the problem, but it has not gone away either. The US Department of Agriculture has a foreign agricultural service with 100 different offices, embassies and trade missions. They work with US farming groups around the world to promote their product, and they are not spending that money just to stand still. What will the Secretary of State be doing to ensure that our farmers have the same opportunities, so that they can see free trade agreements not just as threats but opportunities too?
Context
Discusses concerns about increased US beef imports threatening UK farmers despite assurances. Mentions the US Department of Agriculture's extensive foreign agricultural service promoting US products globally.
The Secretary of State for Business and Trade (Peter Kyle)
I am grateful for the right hon. Member’s insightful and thoughtful contribution. As I said, striking trade deals is vital. That is why we put so much energy into it and have had so much success, and there will be more to come. It is very important that the whole British economy and Government make sure that we exploit the full opportunities that all these agreements offer. The Department for Business and Trade has embedded highly talented trade experts right across the world, and they are trying to do just that on the frontline of all the economic opportunities we perceive around the world, and that includes agriculture. If there are specific areas where the right hon. Member perceives that the agricultural sector, either in his patch or across the United Kingdom, has an opportunity that is not yet being exploited, I want to hear from and work with him to make sure that British farmers benefit.
Session: Farming Sector US Trading Relationship
View All Questions -->
If food security genuinely is national security, is now the moment to consider including within the remit of the Climate Change Committee the maintenance of food security?
Context
Despite a commitment by the Scottish Government not to pursue a deliberate policy of reducing livestock numbers, livestock numbers in Scotland continue to fall. This has led to concerns about maintaining abattoirs, hauliers, vets and merchants across the UK.
The Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs (Daniel Zeichner)
The right hon. Gentleman makes an important point. We absolutely recognise that food security is national security. He is right about the decline in herd sizes, but of course, there are other aspects here: we have seen higher productivity and changed genetics. It is a complicated picture, but I am happy to have further discussions with him on that.
Session: Climate Change Food Security
View All Questions -->
If the last nine years have taught us nothing else, they have surely taught us that it is much easier to agree about the need for an agreement than it is to reach an agreement. The SPS agreement will be critical for food and drink exports. We are only going to get one chance on this, so to get it right we need maximum engagement with the companies and businesses doing the exporting. What is the Minister doing to ensure that their voices are heard in these negotiations and that the agreement suits them?
Context
The MP emphasizes the importance of engaging with exporting companies during the negotiation process to ensure their voices are heard.
Nick Thomas-Symonds (Paymaster General and Minister for the Cabinet Office)
The right hon. Gentleman is absolutely right, which is why I have engaged throughout. The domestic advisory group under the previous trade and co-operation agreement contains a range of stakeholders, and I regularly speak to them, but I go beyond that in my work with stakeholders. He is right that it is hugely important that their voice is heard in the process of agreeing the legal text on the SPS agreement.
Session: Relations with the European Union
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions he has had with the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on the potential impact of his trade negotiations with the US on the farming sector? Before signing any trade deal with America, will he check in with DEFRA and run the rule over what it is doing on farm incomes so that he does not undermine its efforts?
Context
The UK is engaged in trade discussions with the US, which could have implications for the British farming sector. The Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has appointed Baroness Batters to lead a profitability review.
Jonathan Reynolds
We regularly engage with the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on ongoing trade discussions. The moves to review farming business models and profitability are welcome. DEFRA is closely involved in conversations about UK agriculture's export opportunities. I assure that Government efforts across departments are coordinated.
Session: US Trade Negotiations Farming
View All Questions -->
Mr Carmichael asked if press reports linking EU security and defence talks to fisheries are accurate, seeking confirmation from the Paymaster General that there will be no linkage between those negotiations.
Context
Press reports indicated that negotiations with the EU on security and defence were linked to the review of trade and cooperation agreement, specifically access to fisheries. The question seeks clarity on these reports.
Nick Thomas-Symonds
There is no such link, and the current arrangements will end in 2026. The Government will negotiate in the interests of fishers and consider responsibilities to the marine environment.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I thank the Chancellor’s human shield for that answer, but the fact that the Chancellor—who is sitting on the Front Bench—was not prepared to stand up and answer for herself demonstrates a distinct lack of respect for farmers, bordering on contempt. Will she not meet the farming unions, the banks, the professional organisations, and even the supermarkets themselves to hear why they all think her calculations are wrong? If the Minister wants to ask her before he stands up, I am sure we will all allow him a second or two.
Context
Mr Carmichael is concerned about changes to tax reliefs that may adversely affect farmers. He references previous discussions and meetings but notes the Chancellor's absence.
James Murray (Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury)
That was not the most dignified question from the right hon. Gentleman. On the Chancellor’s behalf, I have met numerous organisations about this matter, including those I listed a moment ago. I met the right hon. Gentleman himself when he came to the Treasury, and of course there have been extensive debates in this place. We may not agree on the way forward, but I do not think anyone can accuse us of not having listened.
Session: Farmers Tax Reliefs
View All Questions -->
If that first space launch happens, and I believe it will, it will happen at SaxaVord in Unst. For the UK space sector as a whole to recognise the full opportunities we have, we need to get serious about the delivery of the Government’s space strategy. Last year, the National Audit Office identified a number of challenges that the strategy faces. When will we hear the Government’s response?
Context
The MP inquires about the Government's response to challenges identified by the National Audit Office related to the UK's space strategy.
The Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology (Peter Kyle)
I agree with the right hon. Gentleman that, when we came into office, we did not inherit a clear strategy for delivering on our priorities for space. That strategy is now being developed. The investments we are making as a Department and a Government into space, and the way we are making sure that our relationship with the European Space Agency is delivering for the British sector—we have more grants being delivered in the UK in the latest round of funding than any other country—show that we are delivering. I share his enthusiasm and certainty that a launch will happen this year, and I very much look forward to being there alongside him to witness it.
Session: UK Space Launch
View All Questions -->
The Secretary of State spoke about a plan for change including a commitment to public sector procurement, but it is now March. With the closure of the basic payment scheme and the ending of the sustainable farming incentive, farm incomes are under real cash pressure in the here and now. When will we hear more detail about these commitments?
Context
The MP references the Secretary of State's commitments at the Oxford farming conference in January, expressing concern about farm incomes under pressure due to recent changes.
The Minister for Food Security and Rural Affairs (Daniel Zeichner)
As I said in response to my hon. Friend the Member for St Austell and Newquay, the first thing we needed to do was establish how much we are actually buying, and that is now in progress. I absolutely get the point about the urgency.
Session: Prioritising British Produce Public Bodies
View All Questions -->
The impact I hear from SMEs in my constituency, predominantly in the visitor economy, is that they are anticipating cutting the hours of part-time staff or laying them off and reducing the number of seasonal employees that they will take on. Will the Minister take those concerns seriously and work with Ministers in the Scottish Government to ensure that the legitimate concerns of SMEs in my constituency do not blossom into a full blown crisis of confidence?
Context
SMEs in Orkney and Shetland, particularly those in the visitor economy, are concerned about potential negative impacts from changes to employer national insurance contributions.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Business and Trade (Gareth Thomas)
I am always happy to work with the Scottish Government and other devolved Governments on how we can improve the business environment. I am sure the right hon. Member will join me in encouraging the Government in Scotland to mirror the changes we have made to business rates relief. Given the sizeable increase in the Scottish budget, it is somewhat surprising that the SNP has not been willing to support the retail sector through an extension of retail hospitality relief.
Session: National Insurance Contributions SMEs
View All Questions -->
I am delighted to hear that those meetings are scheduled, because the review of the TCA is seen by fishing industries around the UK as an opportunity to undo some of the damage that was done by Boris Johnson at the end of the Brexit negotiations. I met the EU Commission official who will be leading the EU side of the negotiations and it is clear that she is informed of their industries’ priorities and has a plan for achieving them. The EU sees this as an important piece of work. The Minister can only do what needs to be done if he is prepared to engage with and listen to the views of our fishing industries and communities.
Context
Discussions about the UK-EU trade and cooperation agreement, particularly concerning fisheries post-Brexit. The previous government's negotiations are seen as causing damage to fishing industries.
Nick Thomas-Symonds
I understand and recognise the strong interest in what happens in 2026 when the arrangements that were negotiated by the previous Government end. I say to the right hon. Gentleman that I will listen and engage. We will protect the interests of our fisheries, and also fulfil our international commitments to protect the marine environment.
Session: EU Trade and Co-operation Agreement Fishing
View All Questions -->
Surely, even in these febrile times, it should not be difficult to build a consensus around the proposition that foreign money should not be in British politics. Can we not get the parties together now to make the strongest possible package of reforms, rather than reacting when it is too late?
Context
There are concerns about the adequacy of current rules regarding donations from non-UK citizens to political parties, especially given recent controversies involving foreign billionaires.
Jeremy Wright
As I mentioned, there is a consensus in this House that foreign donations should not play a part in British politics, but there are gaps in the law. As I mentioned, the Electoral Commission believes that those gaps can be properly closed through further legislation. It is speaking to the Government about that, and I know that it would be happy discuss the matter further with the right hon. Gentleman, if he so wishes.
Session: Foreign Donations to UK Political Parties
View All Questions -->
It would be helpful if the Secretary of State encouraged Sir Jon to engage with parliamentarians across the House. The necessary changes that he has outlined will take time, however. The truth of the matter is that if those who currently have responsibility were to change their culture and focus on outcomes for customers, rather than their own internal processes, we might see earlier improvements.
Context
Sir Jon Cunliffe has been appointed to lead a commission reviewing water governance and regulation.
Steve Reed
There will be an opportunity for Members to engage with Sir Jon Cunliffe's commission in January, and I am sure that the right hon. Member's Committee will want to do precisely that.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I take it that genomics databases will not be designated as critical national infrastructure, then, which was the question. As the Government seek to reset the relationship with China, will Ministers be mindful of the old maxim that you need a long-handled spoon to sup with the devil, and of the fact that Chinese genomics companies such as BGI do not behave as normal commercial competitors? Will the Secretary of State ensure that the interests of British genomics are not left vulnerable as a consequence of any reset relationship?
Context
In light of resetting the relationship with China, questions about ensuring British genomics interests are not left vulnerable.
Pat McFadden
The right hon. Member asks a very important question about the twin interests of national security and economic growth. In this territory, we work with UK organisations that hold genomic data to make sure that they have robust data protection systems in place, and our security services give them advice on these matters on a regular basis, so that our pursuit of growth does not conflict with our very important national security objectives.
Session: Genomics Databases
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has he had with the Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology on the potential merits of designating genomics databases as critical national infrastructure?
Context
Discussions on the potential merits of designating genomics databases as critical national infrastructure.
Pat McFadden
Genomics is a great British success story, and our genomics databases are vital for world-leading life sciences and health research. The organisations that have such databases have to provide data protection and security training, and have to make sure that researchers can access data only for approved purposes. The opportunities come with risks, which is why the Government will always try to minimise the risks of biological data to protect our bio-economy. We are working on this issue across Government Departments and through our national security structures.
Session: Genomics Databases
View All Questions -->
There are ongoing activities by Russian research vessels around UK cables. What measures is the government taking to ensure proper protection of these essential national assets?
Context
Russian research vessels have been active near undersea cables, raising concerns about the protection of critical infrastructure.
Luke Pollard
The United Kingdom and our armed forces will defend our critical national infrastructure, including undersea cables. We have a strategy in place with allied support.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I congratulate the Secretary of State, and indeed the Chancellor of the Exchequer, on the achievement of the Budget: in 23 years in this House, I have never seen such a degree of unity among farming organisations in their response to it. One point on which there seems to be no disagreement is that the removal of the ringfence around agricultural payments to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland is a bad move. Nobody asked for it. Why did the Government do it, and what do they expect to achieve with it?
Context
The removal of the ringfence around agricultural payments to devolved regions was a point of disagreement. Alistair Carmichael inquires about its purpose.
Steve Reed
We have announced the biggest Budget for sustainable farming—£5 billion over the next two years—in history. We believe in devolution and that devolved Administrations should take decisions about their own countries.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
What will the Government do to ensure that their industrial strategy helps marine renewables reach full commercial deployment?
Context
The question addresses the need for an industrial strategy to support marine renewables reaching full commercial deployment.
Sarah Jones
The right hon. Gentleman makes a good point. Marine renewables are a huge opportunity for us, and Scotland is uniquely placed to take advantage of this.
Session: Industrial Strategy
View All Questions -->
Getting the SaxaVord project across the line will bring benefits to many projects across the United Kingdom. The MP asks if the Minister will meet him and the developers of SaxaVord to discuss what the Government can do, directly or indirectly, to help this project succeed.
Context
The Shetland spaceport project, SaxaVord, is a significant initiative in the UK's space sector. It has advanced beyond other similar projects.
Chris Bryant
The Minister expresses willingness to meet with the right hon. Gentleman, as well as companies like Orbex today, highlighting the UK's unique advantage in the launch sector and its potential impact on businesses across various sectors including mission control and technological support.
Session: UK Space Sector
View All Questions -->
What steps he is taking to help support the UK space sector. The questioner emphasises that this sector offers massive economic and strategic opportunities for the United Kingdom. He mentions that the SaxaVord project in Shetland is ahead of other projects, highlighting its potential benefits not only locally but across the UK.
Context
The UK space sector is a key area of potential economic growth, with the development of projects such as the Shetland spaceport at SaxaVord.
Chris Bryant
I am very happy to meet the right hon. Gentleman, as well as other companies in the sector such as Orbex. The Minister believes that we have a specific geographical and skills advantage in the launch sector which needs to be exploited for the whole UK economy's benefit, including businesses involved from mission control to technological support.
Session: UK Space Sector
View All Questions -->
If we continue to see this as a matter of legality, nothing will ever change, and certainly not in any decent timeframe. We have to focus on what we can do practically to end the sort of attacks that trawlers from Shetland, such as the Alison Kay and Defiant, have been subject to in recent years. Will the Minister look at the experience of authorities in Ireland, who have managed to tackle the reckless conduct of trawlers like the Pesorsa Dos and keep their fishermen safe?
Context
Trawlers from Orkney and Shetland, such as the Alison Kay and Defiant, have faced attacks in recent years. The questioner asks about practical steps to address these issues.
Mike Kane
I will undertake to look at the authorities in Ireland. I had a recent visit to the Orkney Islands in the right hon. Member's constituency. I would wish to catch up with him about that and I am happy to meet him to discuss this matter further.
Session: Maritime Coastguard Agency Safety Breaches
View All Questions -->
What discussions has she had with the Maritime and Coastguard Agency on maritime safety breaches which occur outside UK territorial waters but within the exclusive economic zone?
Context
Discussions are ongoing regarding maritime safety breaches outside territorial waters but within the exclusive economic zone. This issue was previously discussed during a Westminster Hall debate on maritime safety last April.
Mike Kane
The Secretary of State has met the chief executive of the Maritime and Coastguard Agency, and this matter was discussed. The MCA will continue to monitor this important issue, as well as follow up on the actions already taken since the Westminster Hall debate on maritime safety last April.
Session: Maritime Coastguard Agency Safety Breaches
View All Questions -->
In my constituency we are about to hold regular water quality summits, alongside my hon. Friend the Member for Southend East and Rochford (Mr Alaba), with the aim of ending the scourge of sewage dumping. Does my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State agree with me that this is a good local model and a good blueprint to be used nationally?
Context
Regular water quality summits are being held in the constituency to address sewage dumping issues.
Mary Creagh
We are announcing a review into water. I urge him to participate and feed into that review. The sort of innovative model that brings partners together is certainly one we will be looking at.
Session: Environmental Land Management Schemes
View All Questions -->
Will the Secretary of State focus his ministerial colleagues' minds on the potential development of tidal stream generation, providing an opportunity for our manufacturing sector to create a UK-based supply chain?
Context
No specific background event or incident is mentioned. The question is about the potential for development of tidal stream generation.
Ian Murray
We hope to emulate much of the work that he did. I have met the European Marine Energy Centre and those involved with tidal resources in his constituency. This is critically important to our net zero ambitions and will be top of the agenda when I visit his constituency.
Session: Industrial Strategy
View All Questions -->
This seems to be an appropriate moment to acknowledge that in Orkney and Shetland we are blessed with some very good-quality local media: The Orcadian, The Shetland Times, Shetland News, SIBC, BBC Radio Orkney and BBC Radio Shetland. For communities such as ours, a strong local media presence is an important bulwark against the relentless centralisation of control, power and government in Edinburgh, which is why we need to protect our media.
Context
Local media such as The Orcadian, The Shetland Times are important bulwarks against centralisation. A coherent strategy covering advertising and other aspects is needed to ensure the strength of these outlets.
Julia Lopez
I certainly agree, and we have been putting forward that strategy, but it is a very dynamic market. We are now seeing challenges to local reporting from artificial intelligence, and we are considering how we can protect some of these publications, because we agree that they are such an important part of our local democracy.
Session: Local Journalism
View All Questions -->
If she will make an assessment of the effectiveness of Government support for local media. This seems to be an appropriate moment to acknowledge that in Orkney and Shetland we are blessed with some very good-quality local media: The Orcadian, The Shetland Times, Shetland News, SIBC, BBC Radio Orkney and BBC Radio Shetland. For communities such as ours, a strong local media presence is an important bulwark against the relentless centralisation of control, power and government in Edinburgh, which is why we need to protect our media.
Context
The question arises from concerns about the effectiveness of government support for local media, which is seen as a vital pillar of local democracy.
Julia Lopez
I certainly agree, and we have been putting forward that strategy, but it is a very dynamic market. We are now seeing challenges to local reporting from artificial intelligence, and we are considering how we can protect some of these publications, because we agree that they are such an important part of our local democracy.
Session: Local Journalism
View All Questions -->
A new threat to search and rescue response times is emerging due to poor industrial relations between Bristow's management and its staff. Will the Minister call in the management and make it clear that the Government expects them to treat their search and rescue staff with respect?
Context
The MP is concerned about deteriorating industrial relations between Bristow's management and its staff, which are impacting response times.
Anthony Browne
Good industrial relations are vital for effective operation, and the MCA will keep this in mind during its review. The Minister agreed to meet Bristow's management just this morning.
Session: Helicopter Search and Rescue
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has he had with helicopter search and rescue operators on the adequacy of response times?
Context
The MP is concerned about the adequacy of response times for helicopter search and rescue services.
Anthony Browne
The Maritime and Coastguard Agency is conducting an analysis of incident data to examine changes in demand since the launch of UK's second generation search and rescue aviation procurement. The review is ongoing, and no recent discussions have been held on this point.
Session: Helicopter Search and Rescue
View All Questions -->
What would the Secretary say to Members whose local magistrates court had 1,954 criminal cases waiting at the end of December 2023? Is such a backlog acceptable?
Context
Carmichael questioned the acceptability of a backlog of 1,954 criminal cases in local magistrates courts.
Alex Chalk
Case loads in magistrates courts are lower than during the pandemic, but there's pressure in Crown courts. We will invest more resources: Nightingale courts, judges, legal aid to recover the system while holding fast to principles.
Session: Court Case Backlogs
View All Questions -->
What recent assessment has been made of the potential implications for policies due to the case backlog in criminal and civil courts?
Context
Carmichael asked about the potential impacts of case backlogs in criminal and civil courts.
Alex Chalk
We remain committed to reducing outstanding case loads. We have extended Nightingale courtrooms, allocated £220 million for modernisation and repair, and funded unlimited sitting days including 107,700 in the recent financial year.
Session: Court Case Backlogs
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Radio Teleswitch Service Switch-off: Scotland
08 April 2025
Responding: Miatta Fahnbulleh
Main Concerns
["The radio teleswitch service switch-off is scheduled for 30 June, affecting rural communities, particularly those off the gas grid. Despite extensions made previously, a hard deadline remains due to the obsolescence of the system. Hundreds of thousands of RTS meters remain across the UK, with many in Scotland's rural areas."]
Specific Asks
["The MP asks for clarity on how the Government plans to drive faster meter replacement and whether all energy suppliers will participate in the 'spring sprint'. He also requests information about Ofgem’s consultation results on new rules to protect customers from being worse off under their replacement tariffs."]
Marine Renewables Industry
16 January 2025
Responding: Michael Shanks
Main Concerns
['The debate highlights the importance of Government support for the marine renewables industry, particularly in Scotland. It mentions a forthcoming University of Edinburgh report indicating that marine energy could contribute £37 billion gross value added to Scotland’s economy by 2050 and create up to 62,400 jobs.']
Specific Asks
['The lead MP calls for further Government signals and support to help the industry reach commercialisation. He references the positive impact of previous commitments like ringfenced pots for tidal stream generation in past allocation rounds.']
Coastguard Helicopter Services
14 January 2025
Responding: Mike Kane
Main Concerns
["The service in Sumburgh, part of Alistair Carmichael's constituency, has been highly regarded due to its heroic incidents. In November 2023, a memo suggested increasing the response time from 15 minutes to 60 minutes for helicopters stationed at Sumburgh and Stornoway, leading to significant public concern."]
Specific Asks
['Alistair Carmichael asks for confirmation that the review of the UKSAR2G procurement will indicate a return to a 15-minute response time or else a campaign to save this service may be necessary.']
Fishing Industry
28 November 2024
Responding: Daniel Zeichner
Main Concerns
["The fishing industry faces significant challenges including annual negotiations with the EU and Norway, which are described as 'crazy' for their year-by-year nature. Data-deficient stocks result in automatic precautionary quota cuts of at least 25%, impacting valuable species like ling and lemon sole. The lack of investment in fisheries science has led to diminished data quality, affecting quotas. There is a shortage of crew due to strict visa requirements, especially for boats within UK territorial waters. Offshore wind projects are also encroaching on fishing grounds. Cornwall's fishing industry is vital for food security, jobs, and tourism. The EU-UK negotiation process has led to a £20 million reduction in fishing opportunities for the Cornish fishing fleet over the past two years. There have been instances where quota reductions were too abrupt for fishers to adjust to, such as when the pollack quota was set at zero last year without warning, leading to compensation for Cornish fishermen."]
Specific Asks
['The lead MP asks the Minister to outline priorities for upcoming negotiations and highlight the role of fisheries science. He requests engagement with the industry to ensure their voice is heard in the review of the trade and co-operation agreement, aiming to improve access to UK waters post-2026. The Government needs to ensure a long-term approach to fishing quotas based on scientific evidence that balances food production with environmental protection and supports sustainable practices. There is also a need to protect heritage industries like the Fal oyster farms from sewage dumping and to have wider consultation when planning for floating offshore wind projects.']
Fuel Poverty — [Sir Roger Gale in the Chair]
06 November 2024
Responding: Michael Shanks
Main Concerns
['A household in fuel poverty commits more than 10% of its income to maintain a satisfactory heating regime, with extreme fuel poverty defined as over 20%. In Scotland in 2022, some 791,000 households were fuel-poor and by 2022 the figure for extreme fuel poverty had risen to 472,000. In Orkney and Shetland, 31% of households live in fuel poverty compared to a Scottish average of 24%. The MP highlighted that winters are longer, darker, and colder with off-gas grid heating predominantly relying on electricity, oil or solid fuel.']
Specific Asks
['The Government needs to provide meaningful action fit for the needs of the different parts of the United Kingdom. It was also mentioned that an isles tariff should be considered to help those who host major energy developments. The roundtable discussions need to progress and details shared with constituents.']
Space Sector: Government Support
04 September 2024
Responding: Chris Bryant
Main Concerns
['The UK space sector has grown rapidly since its inception, with SaxaVord spaceport in Shetland set to be a significant player. However, there is competition between different parts of the sector, which could impact future success. The spaceport secured £10 million in convertible loan funding from the Government and needs further support to complete infrastructure for potential launches. There have been successful engine tests at SaxaVord but recent issues with Rocket Factory Augsburg highlight the need for robust procedures.']
Specific Asks
["The Minister should reaffirm the Government's commitment to supporting SaxaVord spaceport as it moves towards its first vertical launch in Europe. The UK must capitalise on its advantageous position by improving the national space strategy and fostering better cooperation between the UK and Scottish Governments."]
Financial Conduct Authority: Accountability
01 May 2024
Responding: Bim Afolami
Main Concerns
['The FCA failed to act on warning signs in a Ponzi scheme case, leading to multiple victims losing hundreds of thousands of pounds. Constituents faced significant legal costs and compensation limits. Staff morale is poor, with many earning below the minimum living standard. The performance assessment framework is outdated and unfair, causing a toxic work environment.']
Specific Asks
['The Minister should address staff pay issues, cost of living adjustments, staff representation, outdated performance grading models, and the disability pay gap in correspondence.']
Exclusive Economic Zone: Maritime Safety
17 April 2024
Responding: Guy Opperman
Main Concerns
["The incident on June 11, 2020, involving the Alison Kay fishing boat and a Spanish-owned German-registered vessel, highlights reckless behaviour by fishermen that could lead to injury or death. A similar incident in October 2023 involved a Lerwick-registered whitefish boat and a French-registered longliner, with the latter deliberately altering course towards collision. The MCA's report was forwarded to the French authorities but no response has been received since October. There is a need for better co-operation between agencies like the MCA and Scotland's Marine Directorate."]
Specific Asks
['The Minister should raise these incidents at diplomatic or ministerial levels, ensuring prosecuting authorities understand our concern. I ask for a streamlined process of reporting with an individual designated within the MCA to receive reports, and for better co-operation between agencies responsible for fisheries management issues and fishery protection.']
Defined-Benefit Pension Schemes
17 January 2024
Responding: Paul Maynard
Main Concerns
['Alistair Carmichael is concerned about the regulation of defined-benefit pension schemes, specifically highlighting issues with BP and Shell pension funds. He points out that decisions affecting these pensions should be in the best interests of beneficiaries but fears conflicts arise when trustees must prioritize company financial interests over those of retirees. The funding ratio of the BP pension fund stands at 132%, and yet it refused to pay a discretionary increase recommended by trustees, causing significant distress among pensioners who believe their contractual promises are being broken.']
Specific Asks
["Carmichael urges the Government to reinforce the requirement that trustee boards must be demonstrably independent, with a majority of members being truly independent experts rather than company employees. He also asks for clarification on how trustees balance beneficiaries' interests against those of companies or insurance providers managing pension funds."]
Copper Wire Telecoms
13 December 2023
Responding: John Whittingdale
Main Concerns
['I am concerned about the decision to switch off the copper wire network by December 2025. The private companies are focusing on what matters to them rather than the needs and wishes of their customers, especially in rural communities. This is exacerbated by the lack of resilience in the digital system, as seen during catastrophic weather events when people lost access to electricity and communication. I am concerned about the implications of switching from traditional telephone lines to internet-based services. Many people do not have a backup plan for power outages or internet disruptions, which can affect their ability to communicate in emergencies. Around 1.7 million people use personal alarms and fall detectors that operate over analogue networks, and these devices will be at risk if the switchover is not managed properly. There may also be an increase in criminality through the selling of devices at inflated prices or charging for unnecessary work.']
Specific Asks
['The Government needs to step up, take charge and ensure that the switchover from analogue to digital communications is done properly within the given timeframe. The Minister should address the concerns of rural communities regarding the reliability and resilience of fibre-optic systems during power outages. We need a campaign from the Government to inform people about what is happening with the switchover, and we should consider stretching the timescale for this change beyond December 2025. We also need back-up plans for when the internet goes down, specific interventions in rural areas, and clearer information on how vulnerable individuals can cope with extreme weather.']
Falkland Islands: Sovereignty
08 September 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Jackdaw and Rosebank Oil and Gas Fields
03 September 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Bluetongue Virus in Livestock
03 September 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Rewiring the State
02 September 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Prime Minister has set out priorities to address 40 years of overly centralised decision making and over-privatisation, which have stripped power and resources away from communities. The Governmen...
Direction of Government
01 September 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Iran Conflict: Ceasefire
09 July 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Maritime and Coastguard Agency
08 July 2026
General Debate
Led by this MP
Mr Carmichael highlighted the concern regarding the management of the Maritime and Coastguard Agency, specifically noting proposed changes to payments for coastguard rescue officers that could impact ...
Farming Road Map and Profitability Review
24 June 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Middle East: Economic Response
21 May 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Processed Russian Oil Products: Sanctions
20 May 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Attendance
53.1%
52 of 98 votes
Aye Votes
39
39.8% of votes
No Votes
13
13.3% of votes
Abstentions
46
46.9% of votes
11 Sep 2026
VOTED AYE
Closure motion
Ayes: 293
Noes: 218
Passed
11 Sep 2026
VOTED AYE
Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill: Second Reading
Ayes: 270
Noes: 286
Failed
10 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Social Housing Bill [Lords]: Reasoned Amendment to Second Reading
Ayes: 77
Noes: 292
Failed
09 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Plant Health, Seeds, Seed Potatoes and Plant Propagating Material (Ame...
Ayes: 371
Noes: 100
Passed
08 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Health Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 140
Ayes: 79
Noes: 300
Failed
08 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Health Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 142
Ayes: 108
Noes: 357
Failed
08 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Health Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 143
Ayes: 106
Noes: 302
Failed
08 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Health Bill: Report Stage: Amendment 1
Ayes: 162
Noes: 297
Failed
07 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Health Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 6
Ayes: 77
Noes: 317
Failed
07 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Health Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 145
Ayes: 170
Noes: 316
Failed
04 Sep 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Motion to sit in private
Ayes: 1
Noes: 79
Failed
02 Sep 2026
VOTED AYE
Representation of the People Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 65
Ayes: 166
Noes: 346
Failed
02 Sep 2026
VOTED NO
Representation of the People Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 67
Ayes: 105
Noes: 410
Failed
02 Sep 2026
VOTED AYE
Representation of the People Bill: Report Stage: New Clause 88
Ayes: 85
Noes: 427
Failed
02 Sep 2026
VOTED AYE
Representation of the People Bill: Third Reading
Ayes: 411
Noes: 102
Passed
01 Jul 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Employment Tribunal (Extension of Time Limits) (Miscellaneous Amendments and...
Ayes: 322
Noes: 107
Passed
01 Jul 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) (Amendment...
Ayes: 318
Noes: 107
Passed
01 Jul 2026
VOTED AYE
Taxation (Energy and Vehicles) Bill Committee: New Clause 2
Ayes: 80
Noes: 281
Failed
01 Jul 2026
VOTED AYE
Taxation (Energy and Vehicles) Bill Committee: New Clause 4
Ayes: 173
Noes: 282
Failed
01 Jul 2026
VOTED AYE
Taxation (Energy and Vehicles) Bill Committee: New Clause 5
Ayes: 177
Noes: 308
Failed
24 Jun 2026
VOTED NO
Customs (Tariff and Miscellaneous Amendments) (No. 4) Regulations 2026
Ayes: 323
Noes: 160
Passed
24 Jun 2026
VOTED AYE
Draft Carbon Budget Order 2026
Ayes: 332
Noes: 94
Passed
24 Jun 2026
VOTED AYE
Draft Climate Change Act 2008 (International Aviation and International Shipp...
Ayes: 329
Noes: 94
Passed
24 Jun 2026
VOTED AYE
Draft Climate Change Act 2008 (Credit Limit) Order 2026
Ayes: 330
Noes: 93
Passed
23 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition day: Defence spending and readiness
Ayes: 108
Noes: 307
Failed
23 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition Day Motion: Defence spending and readiness - Prime Minister's Amen...
Ayes: 294
Noes: 110
Passed
23 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition Day: Puberty blockers
Ayes: 112
Noes: 283
Failed
22 Jun 2026
VOTED AYE
Armed Forces Bill Report Stage: New Clause 4
Ayes: 164
Noes: 311
Failed
22 Jun 2026
VOTED NO
Armed Forces Bill Report Stage: New Clause 11
Ayes: 104
Noes: 391
Failed
22 Jun 2026
VOTED AYE
Armed Forces Bill Report Stage: New Clause 22
Ayes: 74
Noes: 323
Failed
22 Jun 2026
VOTED AYE
Armed Forces Bill Report Stage: Amendment 11
Ayes: 171
Noes: 322
Failed
17 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Security (State Threats) Bill: Allocation of Time motion
Ayes: 233
Noes: 94
Passed
17 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Security (State Threats) Bill Committee: Amendment 3
Ayes: 85
Noes: 317
Failed
17 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Security (State Threats) Bill Committee: Amendment 8
Ayes: 143
Noes: 249
Failed
17 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Security (State Threats) Bill Committee: Amendment 13
Ayes: 135
Noes: 258
Failed
17 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Security (State Threats) Bill Committee: New Clause 3
Ayes: 144
Noes: 244
Failed
16 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill Remainin...
Ayes: 77
Noes: 255
Failed
16 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill Remainin...
Ayes: 151
Noes: 258
Failed
16 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill Remainin...
Ayes: 162
Noes: 246
Failed
16 Jun 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Clean Air Zones Central Services (Fees) (England) (Amendment) Regulatio...
Ayes: 262
Noes: 86
Passed
24 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Opposition Day: Protections for children from online harms
Ayes: 69
Noes: 279
Failed
23 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: Amendment 1
Ayes: 161
Noes: 272
Failed
23 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 2
Ayes: 156
Noes: 273
Failed
23 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 3
Ayes: 77
Noes: 280
Failed
23 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill Committee: New Clause 3
Ayes: 73
Noes: 256
Failed
23 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Third Reading
Ayes: 361
Noes: 84
Passed
11 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Marit...
Ayes: 362
Noes: 107
Passed
11 Feb 2026
VOTED NO
Local Government Finance Report (England) 2026-27
Ayes: 277
Noes: 143
Passed
11 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Referendums Relating to Council Tax Increases (Principles) (England) Report 2...
Ayes: 279
Noes: 90
Passed
04 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) Order 2026
Ayes: 392
Noes: 116
Passed
9
PMQs Asked
152
Ministerial Questions Asked
343
House of Commons Debates Involved
23
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
98
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1457 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+146% above average
This MP:
9
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+1034% above average
This MP:
152
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
+814% above average
This MP:
23
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+6958% above average
This MP:
343
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-23% below average
This MP:
53.1
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Alistair Carmichael's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.