Commons Sense

House of Commons · Adjournment Debate

SEND Provision Derbyshire 2025-02-12

12 February 2025 · 17 other contributors

Opened by Linsey Farnsworth Lab Amber Valley

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Linsey Farnsworth raised concerns about send provision derbyshire 2025-02-12 in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Concerns raised about SEND provision in Derbyshire due to an Ofsted report and survey results indicating widespread failings and poor ratings.
  • Families in Amber Valley face long waiting times, insufficient mainstream school provision, and difficulties obtaining EHCPs, leading to missed education opportunities.
  • Derbyshire County Council has an unspent SEND budget of 16 million over six years and faces systemic failure in communication and support for families.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Linsey Farnsworth Lab Amber Valley

I am grateful for the opportunity to bring forward this debate. The Labour Government have inherited a broken system of special educational needs and disabilities provision, which has been under-invested in by 14 years of Tory governance. In Derbyshire, the county council demonstrates 'widespread and/or systemic failings' according to an Ofsted report published in November 2024. The SEND provision in Amber Valley is rated poor by 88% of respondents in a survey I conducted. This includes long waiting times, insufficient mainstream school provision, and problems obtaining EHCPs. Families are experiencing delays and inadequate support leading to missed education opportunities for their children. There has been systemic failure evidenced by the unspent SEND budget of £16 million over six years and the poor communication from Derbyshire County Council. My constituents face a daily struggle for timely assessments and care plans, with some resorting to legal challenges due to unmet needs and high costs.

Other contributors (17)
  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Early diagnosis and intervention are crucial in addressing the issues raised by the hon. Member.

  • John Whitby Lab Derbyshire Dales

    The Ofsted report highlights a chaotic SEND operation with unresponsive communication from Derbyshire County Council.

  • James Naish Lab Rushcliffe

    The average waiting time for neurodevelopmental assessments in Nottinghamshire is 54 weeks, indicating a systemic issue requiring urgent Government attention.

  • Catherine Atkinson Lab Derby North

    Delays and lack of funding contribute to the crisis state of SEND provision as described by the Education Secretary.

  • Amanda Hack Lab North West Leicestershire

    Funding disparity between schools and across local authority areas hinders consistent quality in SEND provision.

  • Jon Pearce Lab High Peak

    Committed to securing better support for families in High Peak facing similar issues.

  • Adam Thompson Lab Erewash

    Echoed the dire situation of SEND provision and lack of communication between families and local authorities, citing specific cases of children missing out on necessary education due to bureaucratic delays.

  • Natalie Fleet Lab Bolsover

    Highlighted examples from Bolsover residents facing severe challenges in accessing SEND services despite available funding being unused by the local council.

  • Samantha Niblett Lab South Derbyshire

    SEND provision in Derbyshire has reached crisis point with a significant underspend and failed Ofsted inspections, causing immense stress for families.

  • Louise Jones Lab North East Derbyshire

    Hundreds of emails from constituents about the terrible state of SEND provision in Derbyshire due to chronic mismanagement by Conservative-led council.

  • Jonathan Davies Lab Mid Derbyshire

    SEN makes up a significant portion of my postbag and confirms widespread failings identified by Ofsted report published before Christmas.

  • John Whitby Lab Derbyshire Dales

    Supported the lead MP’s concerns regarding SEND funding and its impact on children in Derbyshire.

  • Catherine Atkinson Lab Derby North

    Reaffirmed the need for better support systems for children with special educational needs, aligning with the lead MP's call for action.

  • Amanda Hack Con North West Leicestershire

    Added her voice to the debate, emphasising the importance of addressing SEND issues effectively in local areas.

  • James Naish Con Rushcliffe

    Emphasised the need for integrated care boards and partnerships to address systemic failings and support SEND provision more effectively.

  • James Naish Con Amber Valley

    Nottinghamshire has empty classrooms due to the shift in demographics, but we need more nursery places. Could those spaces be repurposed for SEND provision?

  • Catherine McKinnell Lab Newcastle upon Tyne North

    My hon. Friend raises an important point; funding has been announced to create early years places and capital funding will be allocated to local authorities to utilize all available space for SEND provision.

Government Response

The Government acknowledge the challenges faced by families with children who have special educational needs and disabilities (SEND). We are committed to ensuring that every child receives the support they need, regardless of where they live. The Department for Education has already provided additional funding to local authorities including Derbyshire County Council to address some of these issues. This includes a £50 million investment specifically aimed at improving SEND provision across England. Moreover, we have launched a national review into waiting times for assessments and EHCPs, aiming to streamline processes and ensure timely interventions. We are also working closely with local authorities like Derbyshire to identify areas where additional support is needed and to address the systemic issues highlighted by Ofsted. The Government will continue to monitor progress in Derbyshire and provide necessary resources to help bring about meaningful change. The Government acknowledges the systemic issues highlighted, including the lack of consistency and communication failures. An improvement notice was issued on January 14th to address these concerns, prompting Derbyshire county council to develop a priority impact plan within two weeks. However, there is scepticism due to previous unfulfilled plans since 2018. The Government pledges to review SEND services across the country and has allocated an extra £1 billion towards improving SEND provision in the Budget. This funding aims to address systemic failings and support children with special educational needs more effectively. The Government recognises the ongoing challenges in SEND provision across Derbyshire. We are working closely with local authorities to improve services, including providing additional funding for school places, enhancing training for staff, and promoting collaboration between education, health, and social care providers. The Department has also launched a review of SEND policies and practices to address systemic failures identified by Ofsted reports. While there is more work to be done, we are committed to ensuring that all children with special educational needs receive the support they need. The Minister acknowledged the importance of improving the special educational needs and disabilities system across England, expressing a commitment to ensuring all children receive appropriate support. She highlighted that over 1.6 million children in England have SEND, with an increasing number requiring support each year. The minister noted that recent inspections of Derbyshire County Council's SEND provision revealed significant failings, necessitating urgent action from the local area partnership. She emphasised ongoing efforts to reform and improve the SEND system through initiatives such as appointing a strategic adviser on SEND and establishing expert advisory groups. The Government are committed to working with education sector leaders, practitioners, children, families, and partners to ensure better support systems. The minister addressed specific concerns raised by MPs regarding funding, inspections, and timelines for EHCPs (Education Health Care Plans), acknowledging delays in issuing plans within statutory timeframes but committing to improving response times and the overall process for parents and young people seeking support. We acknowledge the challenges families face when securing support for children with special educational needs and disabilities. The Department is committed to working with Derbyshire county council, school leaders, and sector partners to improve inclusive education within mainstream settings. £740 million of high needs capital has been announced for 2025-26 to create new places in both mainstream and special schools. We are determined to utilise the available space efficiently to provide specialist places where needed. The Government will continue to monitor progress closely with a SEND adviser appointed by the Department for Education, working collaboratively with NHS England’s adviser to challenge and support Derbyshire county council and the integrated care board in driving improvements. Despite current challenges, we remain confident that with determination, we can deliver better outcomes for children and young people with SEND.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy