Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Coalfield Communities 2025-02-06

06 February 2025 · 35 other contributors

Opened by Adam Jogee Lab Newcastle-under-Lyme

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Adam Jogee raised concerns about coalfield communities 2025-02-06 in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Adam Jogee highlighted the historical significance and current challenges of coalfield communities in the UK.
  • The minister acknowledged the loss of jobs, social facilities, and community identity due to coal mine closures between 1985 and 1997.
  • The government committed to supporting former mining communities through concrete actions while respecting their heritage.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Adam Jogee Lab Newcastle-under-Lyme

Adam Jogee, the Member of Parliament for Newcastle-under-Lyme, opened the debate by highlighting the rich history and importance of coalfield communities in the United Kingdom. He cited specific examples from his constituency, such as the Silverdale colliery and the Diglake colliery disaster commemorations. Jogee emphasised the need for government support to focus on the future opportunities and investment required for these communities, rather than just reflecting on their past.

Other contributors (35)
  • Toby Perkins Lab Chesterfield

    Perkins agreed with Jogee that while it is important to remember the coalfield's history, what people in the coalfields want today is a sense of ambition for their future. He called on the Government’s industrial strategy to recognise the unique contribution these communities can make and focus on a bright future.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Shannon congratulated Jogee on securing the debate and emphasised the importance of a joint UK strategy to protect coalmining towns and villages across the United Kingdom, highlighting strong industrial connections with coal mining in his constituency as well.

  • Carolyn Harris Lab Neath and Swansea East

    Harris pointed out that many constituents enrolled in the British Coal staff superannuation scheme are disappointed about not receiving the same justice as their former colleagues in the mineworkers pension scheme. She called for urgent action to bring parity to this situation.

  • David Mundell Con Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale

    Mundell agreed with Harris about the need for justice in pension schemes and emphasised that communities often want regeneration and support from both London and Edinburgh Governments.

  • Sharon Hodgson Lab Washington and Gateshead South

    Highlights severe health inequalities in coalfield communities, noting an average life expectancy one year less than national average. Urges proper support for these communities.

  • Luke Akehurst Lab North Durham

    Notes that high-quality manufacturing jobs attract respected workforces and argues for more companies like Nissan in former coalmining areas to provide opportunities.

  • Ian Lavery Lab Blyth and Ashington

    Describes his personal connection with mining, referring to the need for continued support for coalfield communities through various campaigns and initiatives. Highlights the social deprivation and poverty in these areas and calls for investment in regeneration.

  • Grahame Morris Lab Easington

    Acknowledges past Conservative Government policies that have left coalfield communities grappling with austerity. Discusses the importance of righting historical wrongs, such as pension justice, and emphasises the potential for economic growth through green initiatives.

  • Jade Botterill Lab Ossett and Denby Dale

    Thanks Adam Jogee for securing the debate and expresses pride in seeing colleagues speak passionately about their communities. Criticises Conservative under-investment and emphasises the importance of celebrating social, economic, and cultural contributions of coalfield areas.

  • Kenneth Stevenson Lab Airdrie and Shotts

    Stevenson supports further regeneration of coalfield communities using modern educational and employment techniques. He cites a report indicating that Ayrshire and Lanarkshire have the lowest job rates for working-age people, highlighting deep-seated inequality due to 14 years of Conservative government policies.

  • Linsey Farnsworth Lab Amber Valley

    Farnsworth emphasises justice for coalfield communities and pensioners. She discusses the recent increase in pensions for members of the mineworkers pension scheme, but notes that members of the British Coal staff superannuation scheme still await similar benefits.

  • Josh Newbury Lab Cannock Chase

    As an MP from Cannock Chase with a mining heritage, the speaker supports reviewing BCSSS surplus sharing agreements. He highlights infrastructure needs and regeneration issues, emphasising the importance of community identity and local investment in coalfield communities.

  • Leigh Ingham Lab Stafford

    The speaker supports a review of the BCSSS to ensure financial security for its members. She calls for transparency on timescales and urges the Government to clarify the process for constituents seeking clarity.

  • Josh MacAlister Lab Whitehaven and Workington

    Supporting a review of BCSSS, the speaker emphasises the historical significance of coal mining in west Cumbria. He advocates for economic revival that generates a renewed sense of purpose and pride.

  • Amanda Hack Lab North West Leicestershire

    She pays tribute to miners who lost their lives in mining disasters and highlights the importance of preserving industrial heritage. She supports the restoration of railway lines for economic support, mentions the Autumn Budget's reversal on mineworkers pension scheme injustice, and calls for justice for members of the BCSSS.

  • Jo White Lab Bassetlaw

    She expresses the sense of injustice among coal workers who were missed out when the Chancellor announced benefits for mineworkers. She highlights two Bassetlaw residents whose contributions and struggles are overlooked, urging the Government to act urgently on their behalf.

  • Luke Akehurst Lab North Durham

    He discusses the tragic history of coal mining disasters in his constituency and praises the uplift in pension payments for former miners. He calls for a swift transfer of investment reserve from BCSSS to its members, emphasising the need for strategic economic regeneration.

  • Jo Platt Lab/Co-op Leigh and Atherton

    She congratulates her fellow MPs on securing the debate and emphasises the importance of preserving historical structures as part of identity and connection to past. She mentions her personal experience with industrial heritage and regeneration efforts.

  • Adam Jogee Lab Newcastle-under-Lyme

    The debate highlights the decline and loss of industry in towns, particularly focusing on the impact of the closure of mines. Adam Jogee emphasises the need for fair funding allocation based on community needs and supports greater devolution of power to local leaders. He calls for a focus on economic development, regeneration, and connectivity, advocating for increased support for existing businesses rather than expecting large-scale industrial investments.

  • Elaine Stewart Lab Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock

    Stewart discusses the historical decline of coalfield communities and highlights the need for meaningful action. She calls on the Government to reinstate support that was previously provided by previous administrations and emphasises the importance of focusing on health disparities and economic inactivity. She also mentions her constituency's low employment rate, high dependency on welfare benefits, and lack of educational qualifications among its residents.

  • Toby Perkins Lab Chesterfield

    Perkins talks about the impact of coal mining on Chesterfield’s community and economy. He mentions the loss of educational opportunities due to union closures and calls for a strategic plan for re-energising former coalfield areas, highlighting the potential role these communities can play in the green revolution.

  • Rachel Taylor Lab North Warwickshire and Bedworth

    Taylor discusses the historical significance of coal mines to her constituency, acknowledging their closure's impact on local economies. She emphasises the importance of addressing pension injustices for former miners and highlights ongoing deprivation in her area compared to national averages.

  • Brian Leishman Lab Alloa and Grangemouth

    The speaker acknowledges the positive measures such as handing over the mineworkers’ pension scheme to ex-coalminers but highlights ongoing issues including addiction, health problems, transport links, and high suicide rates. He emphasises the negative impact of austerity and recent job losses in Grangemouth. The MP supports investment in the Coalfields Regeneration Trust.

  • Louise Jones Lab North East Derbyshire

    The speaker discusses the lasting effects of mining closures on communities, emphasising social cohesion issues and contempt shown by previous governments. She highlights ongoing efforts to improve infrastructure such as roads, public transport, youth facilities, and support for high streets. The MP campaigns for better connections through rail links and improved living standards.

  • Michael Wheeler Lab Worsley and Eccles

    The speaker acknowledges the historical importance of coal mining in his constituency and highlights ongoing challenges such as lower earnings, higher unemployment, and worse health outcomes. He supports government actions like reinstating funds to the Coalfields Regeneration Trust and implementing the Employment Rights Bill.

  • Jodie Gosling Lab Nuneaton

    She thanks her colleague for bringing up this issue and discusses the historical impact on Nuneaton, noting that people earn less and live shorter lives than national averages. She emphasises the need for support in addressing ongoing infrastructure issues such as unadopted roads and contaminated land.

  • David Chadwick LD Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe

    He reflects on the impact of Margaret Thatcher's policies on Welsh mining communities and calls for investment in former coalmining towns to address economic disparities. He also highlights ongoing concerns about miners' pensions and the need for remediation of coal tips.

  • David Simmonds Con Kingston upon Hull East

    Emphasised the need to recognise the historical impact of coal mining, including its economic benefits and environmental drawbacks. Cited his great-grandfather's experiences and the infrastructure investments made during Thatcher's government as lessons for future transitions.

  • Grahame Morris Lab Easington

    Criticised the lack of notice given before mine closures in Easington, comparing it to more successful transitions in Germany. Highlighted the sudden loss of jobs and lack of support from the government.

  • Luke Akehurst Con Ashfield

    Suggested that the failure to deliver on economic regeneration for mining areas contributed to the loss of Conservative MPs in those regions at the last election. Pointed out successful interventions by past governments and noted varying degrees of success across different coalfields.

  • Rachel Taylor Lab Dover

    Criticised the government for not standing up for mining pensioners who did not receive justice in their pension schemes. Highlighted the importance of local authority involvement and the need to address environmental risks posed by coal spoil heaps.

  • Michael Wheeler Con Cannock Chase

    Asked if the Minister agrees that economic growth should include every community and person, particularly those in coalfield towns. He emphasised that people should feel the benefits of growth.

  • Jim McMahon Lab Heywood and Middleton

    Responded to Michael Wheeler's question by agreeing with him and highlighting Greater Manchester’s success while stressing the importance of social opportunities for everyone to benefit from economic growth. He also mentioned plans regarding mineworkers' pensions, devolution, and funding for coalfield communities.

  • Grahame Morris Lab Easington

    Asked if the Minister would consider a proposal by the Coalfields Regeneration Trust seeking £500 million in capital investment over five years to create industrial space, aiming to support economic growth and community wealth building.

  • Jim McMahon Lab Heywood and Middleton

    Reaffirmed commitment to ensuring coalfield communities realise their full potential. He agreed to look at the Coalfields Regeneration Trust’s proposal and promised a follow-up in writing. Emphasised the importance of devolution, town planning support, and funding for coalfield areas from Newark-on-Trent to Wrexham.

Government Response

Acknowledged the thoughtful contributions from MPs about their constituencies. Highlighted the loss of jobs, social facilities, and community identity due to coal mine closures between 1985 and 1997. Emphasised the government's commitment to support former mining communities through concrete actions while respecting their heritage.

Shadow Response

None

He congratulates the MP who secured the debate but does not provide a detailed response on supporting coalfield communities. Emphasised the importance of economic growth that includes everyone, highlighted progress on mineworkers' pensions, promised urgency in addressing Orgreave, acknowledged devolution as crucial for empowering coalfield communities, and committed to expanding mayors’ powers.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy