Commons Sense

House of Commons · General Debate

Covid-19

16 March 2020 · 110 other contributors

Opened by Matthew Hancock Con Bexhill and Battle

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Matthew Hancock raised concerns about covid-19 in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.

Key points

  • Minister of State for Health and Social Care outlined measures to control coronavirus spread, advising symptomatic individuals and their households to isolate for 14 days.
  • Government plans to enhance testing capabilities, boost NHS resources, and introduce emergency legislation to maintain essential services during workforce shortages.
  • Minister clarified self-isolation guidelines, NHS shielding policy for over-70s with underlying health conditions, and discussed expanding PPE supplies.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Matthew Hancock Con Bexhill and Battle

The Minister of State for Health and Social Care outlined a series of measures aimed at controlling the spread of the coronavirus. He emphasised that these actions are necessary to protect lives and safeguard those most vulnerable, including advising people with symptoms or living in households where someone is symptomatic to stay home for 14 days without going out even for essentials unless it is for exercise while maintaining a safe distance from others. Additionally, he advised against all unnecessary social contact and travel, encouraging working from home when possible. The Government also plans to further increase testing capabilities, boost NHS resources by purchasing more ventilators, introduce the coronavirus emergency Bill to maintain essential services during workforce shortages due to illness, and enhance public communication efforts.

Other contributors (110)
  • Matthew Hancock Con Bexhill and Battle

    The Minister advised that those with symptoms or living in households where someone is symptomatic should stay home for 14 days without going out even for essentials unless it is for exercise while maintaining a safe distance from others. He further instructed against all unnecessary social contact and travel, encouraging working from home when possible. The Government also plans to increase testing capabilities significantly, ramp up NHS resources by purchasing more ventilators, introduce emergency legislation enabling essential services to continue during workforce shortages due to illness, and enhance public communication efforts.

  • Jon Ashworth Lab Dewsbury

    The speaker, Jon Ashworth, paid tribute to NHS and social care staff during the pandemic, expressed concerns about clarity of purpose and Government effort required for combating the virus. He raised several questions regarding advice for those unable to work from home, details of shielding elderly individuals, support for vulnerable people with specific health conditions, transparency in evidence informing the UK’s strategy, lessons learned from other countries' containment policies, testing capacity and community testing, vaccine development funding, manufacturing capacity for antivirals, NHS capacity including PPE supply and intensive care unit beds, non-emergency elective treatment suspension, ventilator numbers, ECMO bed capacity, requisition of private sector equipment, and financial support measures such as sick pay and universal credit changes.

  • Peter Bottomley Con Worthing West

    Bottomley expressed concern about the destruction of medicines due to patient deaths and requested a review on drug availability. He also raised issues regarding business closures for those above retirement age and sought assurances that no one would be evicted unnecessarily during the crisis.

  • Philippa Whitford SNP Central Ayrshire

    Whitford inquired about the reasons behind the UK's initial approach to the pandemic, specifically regarding herd immunity. She sought clarification on Government advice concerning mass gatherings and testing strategies. Additionally, she questioned guidance for individuals over 70, care workers visiting homes or care facilities, provision for socially vulnerable groups like homeless people, and funding support for devolved nations.

  • Commends the NHS and presses the Secretary of State on testing requirements, clarity in advice for over-70s and conditions under which testing is required.

  • Matthew Hancock Con South West Norfolk

    Clarifies self-isolation guidelines: seven days for individuals living alone and 14 days for entire household. Emphasises prioritising tests to those who need them most, highlights the NHS shielding policy for over-70s with health conditions.

  • Ed Miliband Lab Doncaster North

    Calls for unprecedented economic measures to support businesses and workers affected by public health measures announced today. Suggests guaranteeing wages through government and employer collaboration.

  • Jeremy Hunt Con South West Surrey

    Welcomes tough measures but asks for clarity on closing clubs, cinemas, restaurants, and testing policies. Questions if shielding applies to over-70s without existing health conditions.

  • Rosena Allin-Khan Lab Tooting

    Expresses concern about protective equipment shortages in the NHS, staff testing, and transparency of plans. Requests immediate provision for PPE and testing for symptomatic staff.

  • Steve Brine Con Winchester

    Discusses support among headteachers for keeping schools open but raises concerns about staffing shortages due to illness. Asks about relaxing student-staff ratios and defining key workers during the crisis.

  • Liz Kendall Lab Leicester West

    Asked the Health Secretary for reassurance about his plans for social care, particularly focusing on workforce issues. Highlighted over 120,000 vacancies and half of home care workers being on zero-hours contracts.

  • Matthew Hancock 18:06:00

    Responded to concerns about social care by affirming ongoing work with local authority leaders. Acknowledged the importance of testing for frontline workers and emphasised efforts to increase test availability. Stressed that the government is working to get home tests or equipment for bedside testing.

  • Luke Evans Con Hinckley and Bosworth

    Congratulated the Secretary of State on the tone adopted in discussing the virus. Asked when people who recover can return to work, noting the impact on the economy.

  • Munira Wilson Lib Dem Twickenham

    Asked for clarification regarding testing policies for frontline healthcare and social care workers, highlighting concerns about stretched services and unnecessary self-isolation.

  • Greg Clark 18:06:00

    Expressed sympathy and admiration towards NHS staff and others dealing with the virus. Pressed Secretary of State on transparency regarding scientific evidence used for testing policies and questioned changes in test availability.

  • John Cryer 18:06:00

    Raised concerns about constituents on zero-hours contracts or self-employed facing potential repossession and homelessness without income support. Highlighted the need for a minimum income guarantee from the government.

  • Dean Russell 18:06:00

    Asked whether people can walk pets while self-isolating, clarified that it is acceptable to go outside but avoid others. Also inquired about guidance for volunteers to prevent virus spread through volunteering activities.

  • Ian Murray Lab Edinburgh South

    Questioned the legality of advising businesses to close without mandatorily doing so, highlighting the impact on insurance claims by such businesses.

  • Yvette Cooper Lab Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley

    Asked for reassurance that the government's testing objective aligns with WHO guidelines. Pressed for targets on daily new tests and expressed concerns about GPs self-isolating without test availability.

  • Harriett Baldwin Con West Worcestershire

    Inquired whether the current test confirms no infection, and asked if immunity builds up after contracting the virus, seeking clarity on medical confirmation of immunity.

  • Pat McFadden Lab Wolverhampton South East

    Stressed the need for stronger global leadership both in health and economic response to a crisis that requires international coordination.

  • Karen Bradley Con Staffordshire Moorlands

    Echoed concerns about pubs and restaurants, asked for firm advice on closure to prevent businesses from losing insurance claims.

  • Ben Bradshaw 18:06:00

    Inquired about the government's timeline in starting to buy extra ventilators and how many more are required currently.

  • Jeffrey M. Donaldson DUP Lagan Valley

    Expresses concern over lack of clarity regarding funding consequentials for Northern Ireland following the Chancellor's special measures announcement.

  • Bernard Jenkin Con Harwich and North Essex

    Asks the Secretary of State to thank local community groups mobilising in their communities. Urges them to be empowered to make decisions without waiting for instructions.

  • Anna McMorrin Lab Cardiff North

    Questions the availability and timeframe of testing kits as per WHO advice, asking when these will become available and how many are needed.

  • Nickie Aiken Con Cities of London and Westminster

    Commends the Secretary of State for his work during the crisis. Raises concern over reports of local pharmacies hiking up prices of products such as sanitiser and masks.

  • Hilary Benn Lab Leeds South and Leeds East

    Questions the Government's intention to test all those with symptoms at home and asks how tests will be prioritised.

  • Damian Collins Con Folkestone and Hythe

    Asks if the Government are considering creating an offence for malicious disinformation about coronavirus, and whether social media platforms should act against known sources of such disinformation.

  • Chris Stephens SNP Glasgow North East

    Proposes that supermarkets allow elderly people to have one hour a day when only they can shop for essentials. The Secretary of State discusses this proposal with the Environment Secretary.

  • Damian Green Con Ashford

    Asks about specific vulnerable groups, such as a mother concerned about her diabetic husband and pregnant teachers, asking if they are doing or should be doing the right thing.

  • Rachel Reeves Lab Leeds West

    Raises concern over self-employed individuals being asked to isolate without statutory sick pay support, urging for reconsideration on this issue.

  • Caroline Nokes Con Romsey and Southampton North

    Asks for reassurance regarding consular assistance and coordination with the Foreign Office for stranded constituents in countries with flight bans.

  • Louise Haigh Lab Sheffield Heeley

    Concerned about unprecedented pressure on food banks, asks if measures will be put in place to provide volunteers with protective equipment and if supermarkets can donate stocks to food banks.

  • John Baron Con Basildon and Brentwood

    Urges businesses to encourage employees to work from home and highlights the need for testing of emergency and public sector workers, especially for elderly and vulnerable individuals living alone.

  • Clive Efford Lab Eltham

    Asks for a plan for scaling back schools due to concerns raised by teachers regarding daily mass collections and potential infection risks. Discusses childcare responsibilities during closures.

  • Mark Pritchard Con The Wrekin

    Questions who takes the final decision in the event of a school needing to close, indicating it is the headteacher with discussions with regional schools commissioners.

  • Paula Barker Lab Liverpool Wavertree

    Asked when local government would receive additional ring-fenced funding for public health and when allocations for the new financial year would be provided.

  • Bob Seely Con Isle of Wight

    Expressed concern about isolated communities, particularly those dependent on ferry connections, during the pandemic and requested assurances regarding mutual aid, clear advice, and supply of medicine and equipment.

  • Afzal Khan Lab Manchester Rusholme

    Inquired why public health information had not been translated into other languages available on the NHS website despite the virus being present in the UK for over a month, seeking an update on translations and clarification on the languages being worked on.

  • James Cartlidge Con South Suffolk

    Suggested setting aside an hour at supermarkets for elderly people and those with small children to shop without competition from stockpilers, addressing concerns about scarcity in baby products.

  • Jess Phillips Lab Birmingham Yardley

    Highlighted issues faced by universal credit claimants like her brother due to the lack of job security and delayed payments through the benefits system during self-isolation periods.

  • Jacob Young Con Redcar

    Asked whether the Government would consider providing direct funds to regional mayors and combined authorities for affected businesses, emphasising the urgency of financial support.

  • Wes Streeting Lab Ilford North

    Suggested that due to the virus's high contagion in its early stages before symptoms appear, the Government’s strategy might be too reliant on responding to observable symptoms and recommended going further faster, particularly in London.

  • Bim Afolami Con Welwyn Hatfield

    Asked how the Government was learning from other countries that were ahead of the curve regarding virus management and the measures they have taken or neglected to take.

  • Meg Hillier Lab Co-op Hackney South and Shoreditch

    Expressed concern about severely overcrowded accommodation in which people will have to self-isolate, raising issues of short-term public health and long-term mental health crises.

  • Stephen Hammond Con Wimbledon

    Asked for guidance on whether at-home social care visits should continue or if alternative arrangements would be made to protect those being isolated.

  • Judith Cummins Lab Bradford South

    Asked about provisions for exams during school closures and measures in place for feeding children who receive free school meals when schools are closed.

  • Damian Hinds Con East Hampshire

    Suggested continuing work with platforms to ensure the primacy of official information, actively working against misinformation that can be misleading or dangerous.

  • Claudia Webbe Lab Hackney North and Stoke Newington

    Asked if the Government would take measures similar to Spain’s to secure private healthcare resources for public health needs, ensuring they do not prioritise profit over safety.

  • Rob Roberts Con Darwen

    Inquired about discussions with Welsh authorities regarding consistency of plans and messages during the pandemic and appealed for media platforms to realise their power in disseminating accurate information.

  • Ben Lake PC Ceredigion Preseli Pembrokeshire

    Asked if the Government had considered the possibility that some people might move from urban areas to rural ones, seeking assurance about additional resources for local health authorities in such cases.

  • Richard Graham Con Gloucester

    Proposed a conference call between NHS heads and MPs as done in Gloucestershire county last Friday to share information with constituents, suggesting this model could be adopted nationwide.

  • Alison McGovern Lab Birkenhead

    Asked for extra support for pharmacists and clarification on public health funding allocation timeline.

  • Bob Blackman Con Harrow East

    Inquired about the public health agenda promoting healthier lifestyles to minimize severe cases seen by NHS, especially mentioning smoking cessation.

  • Ruth Cadbury Lab Brentford and Isleworth

    Highlighted issues with 111 hotline scripts not being updated in real time, causing delays and confusion for call handlers.

  • Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Con North Cotswolds

    Asked the Government to coordinate volunteering organisations to help deliver necessities to isolated elderly and vulnerable people.

  • Inquired about the difference between the number of new cases currently and the number of tests available per day, highlighting the need for increased testing capacity.

  • Expressed admiration for public response to crisis and asked if there is an email address for businesses wishing to contribute to national ventilator effort.

  • Asked about financial support for children who rely on school lunches during potential closures and inquired about decisions regarding closing schools based on advice from other countries like Ireland.

  • Andrew Bowie Con West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine

    Paid tribute to staff at the Department of Health working on coronavirus response, and asked about future updates on discussions with airline industry regarding maintenance of routes important for the economy.

  • Tim Farron Lib Dem Westmorland and Lonsdale

    Encouraged people to have confidence in Government’s medical advice but also called for strong economic support measures, highlighting the impact on tourism and hospitality industries.

  • Paul Holmes Con Hamble Valley

    Complimented the Secretary of State's leadership during crisis and asked for specific guidance for parents with immunosuppressed children regarding school attendance.

  • Diana R. Johnson Lab Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham

    Asked about a national childcare policy to support key workers in the NHS, especially if schools are closed.

  • Inquired about support available for charities affected by coronavirus restrictions and called for measures ensuring they can continue providing essential services.

  • Called for child safeguarding to be a priority if schools close, suggesting discussion with the Schools Minister on this issue.

  • Andrew Griffith Con Arundel and South Downs

    Complimented manufacturing initiatives for ventilators and encouraged further support across health and social care systems.

  • Asked about measures to introduce rates relief and VAT delay, especially important for families and businesses affected by the crisis.

  • Jason McCartney Con Camberley

    Asked if the Chancellor should return to the House this week to clearly lay out measures available to support businesses and individuals affected by the coronavirus outbreak.

  • Apsana Begum Lab Poplar and Limehouse

    Asked how the Government will ensure people with disabilities continue to receive necessary care at home, given the draft of volunteers.

  • Neil O'Brien Con Harborough, Oadby and Wigston

    Inquired about steps being taken by the Government to increase availability of high-quality masks and protective equipment for NHS workers.

  • Stephen Doughty Lab Co-op Cardiff South and Penarth

    Requested clarification on measures to allow prescriptions over the phone or electronically, and relaxation of restrictions on medicine supply, such as enabling three-month prescriptions.

  • Asked for clarification regarding what constitutes a continuous cough in the context of self-isolation advice.

  • Peter Kyle Lab Hove and Portslade

    Questioned why pubs were left to customers to decide whether they should go or not despite being unsafe, as per new advice.

  • Complimented the Health Secretary's resilience and inquired about lessons to learn from Germany’s experience with coronavirus cases and deaths.

  • Mohammad Yasin Lab Bedford

    Inquired about advice for multi-generational households where self-isolation is not feasible due to multiple age groups and medical conditions present in the household.

  • Asked whether healthy individuals over 70, who are still willing and able to work, should be supported by the Government in doing so under current advice.

  • Alison Thewliss SNP Glasgow Central

    Inquired about measures to prevent stockpiling of infant formula and asked for guidance on directing breastfeeding support groups to the national helpline during this period.

  • Seema Malhotra Lab Co-op Feltham and Heston

    Requested a written communication from the Secretary of State and Chancellor detailing measures to support self-employed individuals and small businesses. Also inquired about financial support provided to local authorities.

  • Jerome Mayhew Con Broadland and Fakenham

    Asked for a contingency plan regarding the continuation of public examinations like GCSEs and A-levels on schedule.

  • Lilian Greenwood Lab Nottingham South

    Requested that all press conferences include BSL interpreters to ensure people with hearing impairments or who use British Sign Language can access important health information during the outbreak.

  • Christian Wakeford Con Bury South

    Asked whether testing will be extended to social care staff, police, and teachers to maintain frontline service operations.

  • Andrew Slaughter Lab Hammersmith and Fulham

    Inquired about the policy regarding schools’ closure and downsizing or changes in the approach during the outbreak.

  • Cat Smith Lab Lancaster and Fleetwood

    Asked for clarity on when public health budgets will be announced by the Secretary of State.

  • Stephen Kinnock Lab Aberavon Maesteg

    Asked the Secretary of State whether it is appropriate for private health providers to be charging the NHS £2.4 million a day for rental beds during this national effort, and inquired about steps being taken to ensure that private health providers are contributing appropriately.

  • Emma Hardy Lab Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice

    Inquired about the availability of electronic online sick notes through NHS 111 for those who need mortgage payment support during self-isolation.

  • Rupa Huq Lab Ealing Central and Acton

    Asked for measures to address inconsistencies in how 111 services divert patients, reduce unnecessary bureaucracy impacting GPs, and provided advice on allowing doctors more flexibility during consultations.

  • Navendu Mishra Lab Stockport

    Expressed concerns about healthcare staff on zero-hour contracts and their eligibility for statutory sick pay, asking the Secretary of State to take action if necessary to address these issues.

  • Stephanie Peacock Lab Barnsley South

    Asked whether stricter health and safety measures will be implemented at UK borders due to onward transmission within the country.

  • Alex Norris Lab Co-op Nottingham North and Kimberley

    Sought a willingness from the Secretary of State to reassess statutory sick pay arrangements, suggesting they may need adjustment.

  • Rushanara Ali Lab Bethnal Green and Stepney

    Asked for an update on actions taken to prevent the closure of Mildmay Hospital and measures against price hikes due to panic buying.

  • Bill Esterson Lab Sefton Central

    Questioned why Government is not instructing businesses in affected sectors, such as bars and restaurants, to close entirely as a precautionary measure under health advice.

  • Alistair Carmichael Lib Dem Orkney and Shetland

    Asked the Secretary of State for support from military assets to ensure effective transportation protocols are in place for medical evacuation in isolated regions like Shetland.

  • Abena Oppong-Asare Lab Erith and Thamesmead

    Inquired about actions taken regarding British citizens stranded on a Fred Olsen liner due to coronavirus concerns.

  • Matt Western Lab Warwick and Leamington

    Requested an update on measures being undertaken to increase the production of hand sanitiser, given current supply shortages observed in local councils.

  • Matthew Pennycook Lab Greenwich and Woolwich

    Sought more guarantees for essential food supplies for symptomatic individuals unable to leave their homes due to isolation requirements.

  • Helen Hayes Lab Dulwich and West Norwood

    Asked about measures being taken in case schools are forced to close, particularly focusing on the social care implications for families of students with special educational needs.

  • Naseem Shah Lab Bradford West

    Inquired about conversations had with religious institutions regarding burial practices and potential funeral arrangements in light of virus-related deaths.

  • Sam Tarry 18:06:00

    Asked the Secretary of State for Health about the modelling used in their strategy and questioned whether they were pursuing herd immunity.

  • Matthew Hancock 18:06:00

    Clarified that herd immunity is not part of their plan, denied pursuing it as a goal or strategy. Promised to publish the modelling being used.

  • Jeff Smith Lab Manchester Withington

    Asked for clarity on how testing will be expanded and which groups would be prioritised for testing.

  • Karen Buck 18:06:00

    Expressed concern about the ability of homeless individuals to self-isolate and requested assurances that everyone who is street homeless would have an opportunity to do so. Also asked if action would be taken to prevent more people from becoming homeless due to eviction.

  • Rachel Hopkins Lab Luton South and South Bedfordshire

    Asked about support for local charities that are facing difficulties due to the crisis, particularly regarding volunteer shortages and cancelled fundraising events.

  • Gavin Robinson DUP Belfast East

    Inquired about advice for a constituent who needs to travel from Belfast to London every month to collect medicinal cannabis for his daughter's treatment. Asked if three months' supply could be provided in case of future travel restrictions.

  • Alex Sobel Lab Co-op Leeds Central and Headingley

    Asked about the number of ventilators purchased by the Government, how many will be needed at the peak of the crisis, and whether everyone would have access to a ventilator.

  • Rosie Duffield Ind Canterbury

    Inquired about support for local charities that provide mental health services and are running out of funds due to the crisis.

  • Asked whether other Government Departments would adopt similar measures as IPSA in response to the crisis by having staff work from home with phone lines closed.

  • Chris Elmore Lab Bridgend

    Asked if former medical staff brought back to deal with the virus will be put on correct registers and have up-to-date qualifications and training.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Inquired about discussions with banks regarding mortgage payments and asked if there would be a three-month freeze on mortgage payments.

  • Clive Efford Lab Eltham and Chislehurst

    Asked for statements from other Secretaries of State to address issues raised by Members concerning their respective Departments.

Government Response

Clarifies self-isolation guidelines, emphasises prioritisation of testing resources, explains NHS shielding policy for over-70s with underlying health conditions. Discusses transparency in decision-making and the need to expand PPE supplies. Responded comprehensively, addressing concerns about social care workforce, testing policies for frontline workers, economic impacts, global coordination, insurance claims issues, and ventilator procurement. Emphasised the government's efforts to increase test availability and maintain a common UK message. Replied to multiple queries regarding testing, hospital capacity for isolated communities, translations of public health advice, benefits system, direct funds to regional mayors, strategy based on symptom visibility, learning from other countries’ experiences, social care guidance, exams during school closures, misinformation control, NHS resources acquisition, media platform responsibility, population shift in rural areas, and information sharing with MPs. Responded to various questions regarding public health funding, testing capacity, school closures, economic support measures, volunteer coordination, and childcare policies. Addressed concerns about business support, care provision for disabled individuals, personal protective equipment supply, prescription access, self-isolation guidelines, public safety advice regarding high-risk places like pubs and religious gatherings, guidance for multi-generational households, working conditions for those over 70, infant formula stockpiling prevention, financial support for local authorities, contingency plans for exams, communication needs of people with hearing problems, testing prioritisation for frontline workers, school closure policies, and public health budget announcements. Responded to each query, emphasising the Government's efforts to address issues related to private health providers, statutory sick pay, border safety measures, food supply concerns, hospital closures, and other aspects of public health during the coronavirus crisis. Clarified the Government's stance on herd immunity, promised to publish modelling being used. Addressed questions about homeless individuals' ability to self-isolate, testing expansion, support for local charities, medicinal cannabis supply, ventilator procurement, and mortgage payment discussions with banks.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy