← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
GP Funding: South-west England
25 June 2025
Lead MP
Martin Wrigley
Newton Abbot
LD
Responding Minister
Stephen Kinnock
Tags
NHSTaxation
Word Count: 12687
Other Contributors: 19
At a Glance
Martin Wrigley raised concerns about gp funding: south-west england in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Asks for additional funding to support current patient loads and prevent further staff reductions in GP practices across the South West.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
GPs receive £121.79 per patient annually, a figure practice managers describe as unfunded, unsustainable and unsafe. The Carr-Hill formula underrates deprivation and multimorbidity in the South West, leading to underfunding by up to 800 patients for some practices. Additionally, demand has increased post-pandemic while social care cuts have exacerbated the strain on GPs.
Adam Dance
Con
Yeovil
The MP highlighted the need for more GPs and better funding to ensure that everyone has access to safe healthcare within a week. He also raised concerns about the cancellation of bus services in Yeovil, making it difficult for vulnerable residents to reach medical centres. Highlights the issue of patients having to travel up to 30 miles for basic medication due to pharmacy closures in rural areas, stressing that this is unacceptable and requires more Government support. Invited the Minister to visit Ariel Healthcare in Chard, Somerset, and meet GPs regarding unfit-for-purpose buildings.
Brian Mathew
LD
Melksham and Devizes
The MP quoted an email from a GP in Melksham and Devizes regarding the challenges of working in rural areas, including financial pressures on surgeries and the need for better support.
Claire Young
LD
Thornbury and Yate
Supports the case for Three Shires medical practice, highlighting the importance of maintaining services in rural areas with poor public transport links.
Questions whether locums are being stepped into the ARR scheme due to shifts in GP work commissioning and highlights the discrepancy between training more GPs and finding them employment. He also welcomes multidisciplinary team building but questions if the ARR scheme alone solves workforce problems.
Luke Evans
Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Addresses the debate on primary care models, questioning the government's stance on phasing out GP partnerships in favour of a salaried model and the impact this would have given current funding cuts. Questioned the Government’s position on the GP partnership model, seeking clarity on future plans for this model. Asked about opportunities for newly qualified doctors and the potential use of overseas doctors in areas with high need.
Roz Savage
LD
South Cotswolds
Shines a spotlight on Sherston village, where the local GP surgery faces an uncertain future due to the lease expiring in 2027. The community supports a new purpose-built facility, but the integrated care board has not committed to funding it.
Simon Opher
Lab
Stroud
Reports that his practice is employing newly qualified GPs through the ARR scheme, providing extra appointments for the surgery.
West Dorset
Asked how the Government intend to help GP surgeries upgrade their facilities, highlighting that West Dorset's population is older than Japan’s.
Ian Roome
LD
North Devon
Patients in Lynton will soon have access to a GP due to local campaigning, but relying on community efforts highlights the challenges for marginalised communities. North Devon district hospital needs investment while ensuring south Devon patients can benefit as well.
Newton Abbot
Discusses the underfunding and mismanagement of GP services leading to long wait times for appointments. Emphasises the need for investment in early access to community care to relieve hospital burdens. Supports the call for fairer funding models for community pharmacies and echoes concerns about the 1,200 pharmacy closures since 2017, impacting rural areas particularly. Noted that cuts to ICB budgets are counterproductive to devolution efforts, citing a potential merger between Sussex and Surrey ICBs as an example.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Proposes incentives like student loan forgiveness for young medical students committed to staying in GP practices for five years.
Martin Wrigley
Lab
Worsley and Eccles South
Welcomed the announcement regarding changes to the Carr-Hill formula but noted that GP funding remains complex, with wage increases eroding budget increases.
Noah Law
Lab
St Austell and Newquay
Cornwall faces severe health inequalities, with high levels of deprivation, an older population, poor transport links, and the impact of its visitor economy. The Labour Government will top up general practice in poorest areas with £2.2 billion.
Tiverton and Minehead
Expressed concern about the unsustainable situation in Minehead, where one doctor serves 11,000 people.
Ashley Fox
Con
Bridgwater
Concerned that increased NHS funding risks being offset by higher national insurance contributions and inflation, leading to less funds available for GP services.
Stephen Kinnock
Lab
Aberavon
Discussed funding for GPs through various streams and announced a review of the Carr-Hill formula to ensure equitable distribution. Mentioned £82 million in ringfenced funding to recruit GPs, resulting in over 1,700 new hires. Intervened to inform about retiring 32 quality and outcomes framework indicators, freeing up £298 million for flexibility in GP practices and targeted cardiovascular disease prevention.
Steve Yemm
Lab
Mansfield
Acknowledges the 7% increase in GP contract funding but questions whether it is enough given rising costs and pressures on practices. The primary care utilisation and modernisation fund announced by the Government will deliver over £100 million for upgrades to 1,000 GP surgeries, benefiting practices like Sherwood Medical Partnership surgery in Forest Town, Mansfield.
Vikki Slade
LD
Mid Dorset and North Poole
Highlights the challenges GPs face with appointment times, reimbursement issues for blood tests, and the emotional strain of providing high-quality compassionate care under financial pressures. Asked about the responsibility for leasehold properties that require practice partners and how such practices can be taken over by ICBs or DHSC.
Will Stone
Lab
Swindon North
Emphasises the need to fund infrastructure for future GP practices as new housing developments increase population density.
Government Response
Stephen Kinnock
The Minister for Care
Government Response
Acknowledges the concerns raised about NHS funding in rural areas, particularly regarding general practitioners and primary care teams. He highlights the dedication of GPs despite working under challenging conditions and thanks them for their service. The Minister reiterates the Government's commitment to the health and wellbeing of constituents across the south-west. Acknowledged the ageing demographic in rural areas, noted investments including £102 million primary care utilisation fund to upgrade facilities. Emphasised progress on GP contract reforms and above-inflation pay rises. Recognised strengths of partnership model but acknowledged declining interest among GPs in entering partnerships. Stressed importance of devolving decision-making to local communities while setting national outcomes. Announced a review of the Carr-Hill formula to address funding disparities between affluent and deprived areas. Mentioned £82 million in ringfenced funding to recruit over 1,700 GPs through the additional roles reimbursement scheme. Discussed plans for placing overseas doctors in areas of need and improving primary care infrastructure with a new fund.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.