← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Public Confidence in the Police
09 September 2026
Lead MP
Jonathan Hinder
Responding Minister
Jo White
Tags
Policing & ResourcesCrime & Law Enforcement
Word Count: 10906
Other Contributors: 8
At a Glance
Jonathan Hinder raised concerns about public confidence in the police in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Hinder urges the Government to provide political leadership that sets clear priorities for policing, focusing on issues that matter to the public and ensuring that officers have the necessary support to deliver on these priorities. He also calls for a new Public Order Act to clarify what constitutes legitimate debate and what is simply someone being unpleasant, and for improvements to the police misconduct system to better address the needs of both officers and the public.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
Jonathan Hinder is concerned about the decline in public confidence in the police over the last decade and a half, as evidenced by crime surveys, victim satisfaction surveys, and polling trackers. He highlights the challenges faced by the police due to significant cuts in officer numbers, shifting policies on stop and search, and the rise in high-harm crime reports such as domestic abuse and sexual offences. He also notes the outdated data systems and the reduction in police visibility on the streets, which contributes to the public's perception of a lack of police presence and competence.
Adam Dance
Con
Yeovil
Adam Dance highlighted under-investment in Yeovil's police force, resulting in fewer officers and less funding, which has led to increased antisocial behaviour and business closures. He cited specific incidents such as a stolen police van and vandalism during a community event, and emphasized the need for a new custody suite and more investment. He also mentioned the lack of handcuffs for PCSOs, which affects their ability to detain suspects safely. Will commit to asking the Policing Minister to meet the local police force and discuss the custody unit issue in south Somerset.
Blake Stephenson
Con
Bedford
Blake Stephenson welcomed the Minister and the hon. Member for Pendle and Clitheroe for securing the debate. He highlighted issues such as the Henry Nowak murder and inappropriate use of non-crime hate incidents undermining public confidence in policing. He mentioned that only 8.5% of crimes were solved in the year to March 2026, with crime increasing by 10% and antisocial behaviour by 15%. He advocated for better use of technology and more police officers, and questioned the Minister about how to hold the Government to account on their commitments to neighbourhood policing. He also criticised the Government's early-release schemes for placing strain on police forces. Asked for assurance that neighbourhood policing officers will not be re-tasked with other work under the neighbourhood policing guarantee.
Gareth Thomas
Lab
Harrow West
Gareth Thomas highlighted the criticism of the police due to failures of other agencies in Harrow and called for closer scrutiny of funding. He also suggested that the Metropolitan police should receive more recognition in the funding formula for tackling national and international crime. Thomas criticised the contract given to Kingdom by Harrow council and urged the council to invest in additional police officers instead. He called for more government scrutiny of local authorities' performance in tackling antisocial behaviour and more funding for youth facilities and CCTV projects. Thomas raised concerns about the £1 billion real-terms funding cut for the Metropolitan police between 2010 and 2014 and asked for assurance that such cuts will not happen again. He also urged the Minister to allow the Metropolitan police to retain more of the proceeds from successful operations and sought an update on the effectiveness of the Online Safety Act 2023.
Gregory Campbell
DUP
East Londonderry
Does my hon. Friend agree that confidence in policing is often undermined by the public's use of finite clips on social media, which do not take account of what happened immediately before whatever incident is broadcast? Senior police officers and Government Ministers need to respond quickly in respect of the entire environment around the clip. More account needs to be taken of the environment in which clips that undermine confidence are used.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Jim Shannon paid tribute to the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) for their work in his constituency and highlighted the challenges they face, including rural crime and limited resources. He emphasized the need for more community policing, encouraging police officers to engage with schools and suggested the introduction of police cadets to build trust with young people. Shannon also expressed concerns about the PSNI's focus on non-threatening social media comments and street preaching while actual crime goes unaddressed, which undermines public confidence. He called for better funding and resources to ensure the PSNI can focus on core law enforcement. Jim Shannon agreed with Adam Dance's point about the need for more officers, noting that an increasing population should be matched with an increase in police numbers. Sought assurance for the Provisional Sinn Féin (PSNI) to receive necessary resources to combat terrorism in Northern Ireland effectively.
Luke Myer
Ind
Cleveland
Luke Myer thanked his hon. Friend for recognising the bravery of police officers in Cleveland, who have faced significant challenges due to a reduction of 220 officers since 2010, and called for an urgent review of the funding formula to prevent penalising high-deprivation areas.
Max Wilkinson
Lib Dem
Cheltenham
Concerned about the decrease in public confidence in the police despite a reduction in crime rates. Emphasised the importance of visible policing presence to deter antisocial behaviour and provide reassurance to women. Highlighted issues such as aggressive and misogynistic behaviour, domestic abuse, and the need for taskforces and partnerships to tackle violence against women. Questioned the Minister on the Hogan-Howe review and the need for resources in rural policing. Criticised the narrative of 'two-tier policing' and the misuse of free speech laws, calling for clarification on legal positions for police officers. Inquired about the alignment of boundaries for policing and regional governance in Cheltenham, questioning the Government's devolution agenda and the need for transparency.
unknown
Wendy Chamberlain, a former police officer in Lothian and Borders police, pointed out the challenge of continual role churn in the police service, which leads to a lack of community familiarity and mutual understanding between officers and residents, suggesting that culturally this is an issue the police service needs to address. Wendy Chamberlain discussed the role of elected representatives in maintaining public confidence in policing, citing her engagement with local officers regarding youth antisocial behaviour in North East Fife. She also highlighted the importance of addressing historical failures in police investigations to rebuild trust among survivors of Fayed and Harrods.
Government Response
Jo White
Government Response
Discussed the Government's plans to rebuild public confidence in policing through reforms including a new national police service, local policing guarantees, and increased funding. Mentioned the commitment to deliver 13,000 additional neighbourhood policing personnel by the end of this Parliament and highlighted a funding increase to police forces by £2 billion since the election. Emphasised the need for consistency in service delivery and the introduction of mandatory vetting standards for police applicants. Announced £100,000 for HMICFRS to expand the scope of its integrity inspections and £425,000 to develop an accredited regime on vetting. Also discussed the importance of continuous improvement in the investigation of rape and sexual offences, the establishment of specialist rape and sexual offence teams by December 2027, and the funding of the national online hate crime hub.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.