← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Football Spectator Attendance: Covid-19
09 November 2020
Lead MP
Jonathan Gullis
Responding Minister
Nigel Huddleston
Tags
EconomyTaxationEmploymentCulture, Media & SportBusiness & Trade
Word Count: 15042
Other Contributors: 16
At a Glance
Jonathan Gullis raised concerns about football spectator attendance: covid-19 in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
I ask the Government to allow spectators back into football stadiums with reduced numbers starting from December 2nd. I also call for the Premier League to contribute financially to support EFL clubs during these unprecedented times.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
I am concerned about the financial sustainability of English Football League (EFL) clubs due to the lack of match day revenue caused by pandemic restrictions. Clubs require £400 million in funding from their owners just to survive this season, with Port Vale alone losing an estimated £1.5 million in revenue since March. The debate highlights how football clubs have played a crucial role in supporting local communities during lockdowns and that the current position on fan attendance is muddled, inconsistent and unfair compared to other industries.
Alison McGovern
Lab
Birkenhead
The MP highlighted the frustration football supporters have felt over not being able to attend matches and expressed concern about the uneven treatment of football compared to other sports. She questioned why DCMS has been left hanging without a clear plan, despite SAGE's August advice warning against easing restrictions due to declining public trust and compliance issues. Made a brief intervention, stating 'And the working woman's!'.
Wirral South
Football is vital for Burnley's economy, as fans generate income for hotels, restaurants, and pubs. The club has taken a significant financial hit but remains committed to supporting the community. He urged the Government to treat football clubs like any other business by allowing them to determine how many fans they can safely welcome back based on their capacity.
Damian Collins
Con
Tunbridge Wells
The covid crisis has shown that football clubs in leagues one and two are community clubs. Without fan support, these clubs will fail financially. In the summer, the Government wanted football to return but failed to provide financial support or allow fans back into grounds. This is leading to clubs going bust before Christmas with up to 10 clubs unable to meet payroll in November. Community clubs have survived major historical challenges but may not survive due to lack of government support during the pandemic.
David Linden
Lab
Airdrie and Shotts
Acknowledges the frustration of 200,000 petition signatories, including those from his constituency. Highlights the economic impact of match day income for clubs like Celtic FC in Scotland. Raises concerns about the current impossibility and potential risks of returning fans to grounds due to the deadly second wave of covid-19. Suggests a regionalised tiered approach as seen in Scotland might be beneficial.
Imran Ahmad Khan
Lab
Morden
The first lockdown affected the UK premier league, costing £1 billion in lost revenue and negatively impacting leagues lower down with potential losses of up to £37 million if fans cannot return all season. The economic and social costs are significant; however, football should be allowed to continue with a responsible number of spectators while adhering to strict social distancing measures.
James Wild
Con
North West Norfolk
I support the safe return of fans to grounds as it affects clubs' finances and fan mental health. The current restrictions have led to significant financial losses for clubs like King's Lynn FC and Norwich City, which lost £12 million due to covid. I urge the Government to step in if the Premier League does not provide adequate support.
Julian Knight
Con
Solihull
Football clubs are the heart of communities and depend on ticket revenues. EFL clubs risk bankruptcy, with some at risk of missing November payrolls. Testing capacity must be increased to allow spectators back, along with smart solutions such as rapid testing, temperature checks, deep cleaning, and social distancing.
Karen Bradley
Con
Staffordshire Moorlands
Paying tribute to Port Vale and Stoke City, Karen Bradley highlighted their importance in community activities in Staffordshire Moorlands. She advocated for a one-size-fits-all approach post-lockdown to allow clubs with capacity to have more spectators, noting the financial impact on volunteer-run clubs like Leek Town. Emphasised the need for spectator sports in Formula 1 and grassroots sports as pipelines for elite athletes.
Kieran Mullan
Con
Bexhill and Battle
The MP discussed the impact of coronavirus on Crewe Alexandra FC and other local clubs, emphasising the community role of these football teams. He called for a roadmap from the Government to bring fans back safely and highlighted the need for support during financial uncertainty.
Richard Holden
Con
Basildon and Billericay
Mr Holden highlighted the financial struggles of lower-tier football clubs in his constituency, noting that revenues for some clubs have dropped by 85% due to the pandemic. He emphasised the importance of these clubs to their communities, mentioning Consett FC which supports over 1,000 children weekly and runs a BTEC education programme with over 100 students.
Ruth Cadbury
Lab
Brentford and Isleworth
Football is vital for many people's well-being, as shown by stories about Brentford Football Club fans struggling without matches. The club has been supportive of its fan base during the pandemic, helping those in need and raising money for a fan with cancer. The club thrives because it is at the heart of the community, supporting local businesses and creating jobs. Concise intervention emphasizing financial concerns. The MP suggested that there should be flexibility in implementing rules for stadiums based on their specific physical layouts, particularly given the new stadium design at Brentford football club which allows for controlled fan entry from various directions.
Sara Britcliffe
Con
Accrington
The MP highlighted the importance of football clubs in community life and expressed concerns about financial losses due to lack of fan attendance. She mentioned successful pilot events with up to 1,000 fans and urged the Government to support clubs by providing a roadmap for safely welcoming back spectators.
Scott Benton
Lab
Blackpool
I attended a pilot game at Bloomfield Road where Blackpool beat Swindon, noting that the safety measures were followed meticulously by fans. Attendance was around 1,000 out of a capacity of over 17,000, and it could have been increased to between 25% and 35%. Clubs found the cost of opening stadiums for such small numbers excessive, and financially viable attendance must be ensured.
Seema Malhotra
Lab Co-op
Feltham and Heston
Welcomed the constructive engagement of the English Football League in developing ground safety protocols for spectator attendance, emphasised football's role in communities, highlighted Brentford FC's support to local children and families during lockdown, expressed concern over financial pressure on clubs, particularly Brentford FC, called for clearer guidance from the Government.
Simon Fell
Con
Barrow and Furness
The Bluebirds, Barrow AFC, are facing significant financial losses due to the pandemic. Despite being promoted to the English Football League after 48 years, they cannot host spectators as planned. The club's community trust provides vital services to local schools and faces risks from the lockdown. Supporters want to return safely to matches post-lockdown.
Wera Hobhouse
Lib Dem
Bath
Bath City Football Club is a community asset that depends on match-day income. The game lacks vibrancy without spectators. Public health officials highlight uncontrolled spaces as the main issue, and there is need for Government to look into fan travel and organisation cooperation.
Government Response
Nigel Huddleston
Government Response
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Stringer. The number of petition signatures demonstrates the importance of football and sport in general. The Government's goal is to get fans back into stadiums as soon as it is safe. Football clubs are vital to communities across the UK and have supported their local areas during the pandemic. The government has provided extensive financial support for businesses, including sports clubs, through various measures such as tax reliefs, cash grants, employee wage support, business rates relief, and the furlough scheme. Sport England has contributed £210 million in national lottery and Government funding to support sport and physical activity during the pandemic, including a £35 million community emergency fund for sports clubs and exercise centres. The Football Foundation has introduced several funds to help clubs during these difficult times, including the match day support fund, pitch and club preparation funds. The government worked to get elite sports, such as the Premier League, back behind closed doors in June to ensure seasons were completed and revenue could flow again. However, rising infection rates across the country mean that reopening stadiums on 1 October was not feasible due to safety concerns regarding the entire fan journey from home to venue, including travel and contact points. The minister acknowledged challenges but emphasized that a one-size-fits-all approach may not be appropriate. The government is considering different approaches based on what other nations and countries are doing. Financial implications of the decision to delay reopening have been considered and support packages are being discussed with the Treasury. A unique £10 million deal was brokered with the national lottery for 66 clubs in the top two levels of the national league, allowing them to play behind closed doors. Pilots were successful and learning points will inform future decisions. Women's sport prioritisation is a condition for public money recipients. The government will continue working closely with sports entities to understand their latest thinking on returning spectators safely. Significant progress has been made since the pandemic began: elite athletes returned to training, competitive sport resumed behind closed doors, international athletes were welcomed under health protocols, and detailed guidance was set out for the safe return of spectators. The minister addressed various points raised by hon. Members including financial sustainability, loyalty of season ticket holders, distribution of money in football, revenue streams, financial stimulation provided by football to local economies, and owner support. The government is committed to supporting sport and getting spectators back into stadiums as soon as it is safe.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.