← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Nightclub Safety — [James Gray in the Chair]
08 November 2021
Lead MP
Tonia Antoniazzi
Gower
Lab
Responding Minister
Rachel Maclean
Tags
Women & Equalities
Word Count: 12460
Other Contributors: 15
At a Glance
Tonia Antoniazzi raised concerns about nightclub safety — [james gray in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
The Government must invest in making security checks a permanent feature across all clubs. Local authorities should utilise their licensing powers to ensure that clubs are safe places to go out. The Minister is asked how many people need to be spiked before the government acts and what discussions have been had with local governments to address this issue.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
There have been numerous incidents of drink spiking and attacks in nightclubs across the UK, including cases where needles were involved. In Swansea alone, police are investigating multiple incidents of drink spiking. The lack of comprehensive drinks testing leaves clubs vulnerable to these dangers. While some clubs like Sin City in Swansea have taken steps such as ordering 12,500 anti-spiking lids and offering free replacements for potentially spiked drinks, the lead MP worries about what will happen after media attention fades.
Florence Eshalomi
Lab Co-op
Vauxhall and Camberwell Green
Acknowledged the previous speaker's point but stressed the importance of educating young boys to respect women, suggesting that this education should start in schools to foster a respectful society. She raised concerns about drink spiking incidents in London, noting that the majority of victims are young women. Florence highlighted the impact on students' lives post-lockdown and emphasised that policing women's behaviour is not a solution to the problem. She also mentioned the tragic death of Sarah Everard and called for conversations with everyone to tackle misogyny and hate. We need to see more women and girls going out and supporting the full range of businesses in the night-time economy, but this will not happen until they feel safe.
A case was presented where an individual was spiked, but the police refused to examine CCTV evidence or test drinks, highlighting the need for serious consideration of such incidents and proper examination of evidence. Provided statistical context indicating that 5.2% of sexual assaults involve drugging, with the incidence being twenty-fivefold higher for women than men, emphasizing that addressing this issue is about protecting women from male attackers. Mr Davies raised concerns about misogynistic, sexist and racist commentary in Metropolitan Police WhatsApp groups and suggested a wholesale review to culturally change the Metropolitan police and education system.
Started the petition after discovering there was no law requiring nightclubs to search guests upon entry. She found that she had never been searched during her time as a student in Edinburgh and felt motivated to change this situation.
James Davies
Con
Agreed with Tonia Antoniazzi, citing anecdotal evidence of an increase in A&E cases related to university terms starting. He emphasised the importance of raising awareness through data-driven measures and consistency across the UK.
Jeff Smith
Lab
Manchester Withington
He questioned whether there are two phenomena occurring simultaneously: an increase in drink spiking incidents and a rise in needle-stick injuries. He suggested that both issues need attention, with the call for an inquiry into these situations.
Jess Phillips
Lab
Birmingham Yardley
The MP highlighted the long-standing issue of drink spiking, noting that it is not a new phenomenon with over 2,600 reports in 2019. She emphasized the fear among women about going out and the underreporting of violence against women and girls, estimating only 20% of cases are reported. The MP called for better security measures in nightclubs including robust search protocols, improved staff training, and high-quality CCTV. How many licensing committees are paying attention to violence against women and girls in relation to this issue?
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
We have had 21 incidents of spiking in the last month in Northern Ireland. The hon. Member agrees that all Administrations must agree a policy to protect women.
Lilian Greenwood
Lab
Nottingham South
The hon. Member supports the idea that authorities should listen to young women and hear what they want in order to change the behaviour of perpetrators rather than focusing on victim support alone. She agreed with Florence Eshalomi's concerns about women not being believed or dismissed when seeking help after spiking incidents, which discourages reporting and hinders evidence collection for better understanding of the problem.
Matt Western
Lab
Warwick and Leamington
Acknowledging the rise in incidents of spiking through needle injection, Matt Western highlights that there were 15 reports of alleged spiking with a sharp object in Nottinghamshire since October. He calls for multi-agency meetings involving local authorities, police, and universities to address this issue urgently.
James Gray
Con
North Wiltshire
Welcomed the comments made by Tonia Antoniazzi, emphasising the need for UK Government and devolved countries to work together on addressing nightclub safety.
The issue extends beyond nightclubs, involving house parties and schools as well. The Government needs to work more seriously with the police and other authorities on this wider context of violence against women and girls. The Alcohol Education Trust suggests there might be more incidences of drink spiking in house parties than nightclubs, asking how this will be reflected in the Government's strategy.
Rachael Maskell
Lab Co-op
York Central
There is a multi-agency meeting tomorrow in North Yorkshire involving universities, addressing spiking incidents. The availability of trauma services needs to be discussed due to underfunding and understaffing. She stated that drink spiking is an assault against women, noting underreporting of violence against women. She emphasised the need for immediate action and understanding of the issue.
Rushanara Ali
Lab
Bethnal Green and Stepney
There is a real need for capturing data on spiking incidents from universities, police, and health services. Some universities are not providing adequate support to those affected, particularly women. I agree that spiking by injection adds a health risk, especially regarding disease transmission. We need to address the issue at universities and ensure strict enforcement of convictions for perpetrators. The Minister needs to ensure that all nightclubs follow good examples and provide reassurance to families across the country about their safety.
Steven Baker
Con
Wycombe
I am concerned about the rise of spiking by injection, which is a grave assault against women. The police should treat it as one of the most serious crimes and ensure security staff at nightclubs are aware of its dangers. I support the call for action on this issue but also caution against blaming all men. The Minister should undertake a public information activity to make sure that potential perpetrators are aware of the gravity of offences related to violence against women and girls.
Wera Hobhouse
Lib Dem
Bath
Agreed with the previous speaker's comments, noting that while many men behave well and are decent towards women, there is a prevalent culture where women are not treated with respect leading to violent behavior. Ms Hobhouse highlighted the fear and trauma caused by drink spiking, especially for women. She cited a National Police Chiefs' Council report of almost 200 confirmed incidents in two months and over 2,600 reports between 2015 and 2019. Ms Hobhouse also mentioned that spiking test strips should be made freely available at venues and called for specific training for police and venue staff to identify signs of spiking. She intervened to express concern about potential fatalities due to the ongoing issue and questioned why action is often taken only after a tragic event occurs.
Government Response
Rachel Maclean
Government Response
The Minister outlined several actions being taken by the Government to address nightclub safety concerns, including ongoing investigations into spiking incidents, police reviews, and a £5 million fund aimed at preventing violence against women and girls in public spaces. She emphasized that premises have a responsibility to assess their security needs and that local licensing authorities can impose conditions such as entry searches when necessary. The Minister also mentioned existing initiatives like the night-time levy and safe space projects which help fund additional police officers and community protection measures. Additionally, she acknowledged the importance of tackling broader issues of violence against women and girls through a cross-Government strategy.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.