← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Black History Month — [Sir Graham Brady in the Chair]
28 October 2021
Lead MP
Bell Ribeiro-Addy
Clapham and Brixton Hill
Lab
Responding Minister
Robin Walker
Tags
Foreign AffairsBusiness & TradeBenefits & WelfareWomen & EqualitiesChildren & Families
Word Count: 14052
Other Contributors: 9
At a Glance
Bell Ribeiro-Addy raised concerns about black history month — [sir graham brady in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
The MP asks for the government to commit to putting black history into the curriculum and to address systemic issues through meaningful action rather than platitudes. She also requests that the Government take responsibility for institutional failures related to racial equality.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
The MP is concerned about the lack of recognition for black contributions in British history, citing a petition with over 260,000 signatures advocating for teaching Britain's colonial past as part of the curriculum. She highlights how not recognising oneself in history can impact identity and mentions examples of significant figures like Yvonne Conolly and C. L. R. James. The MP also raises issues related to systemic racism and the failure to implement recommendations from previous reports, such as those on racial disparities in youth custody.
Erith and Thamesmead
She highlighted several black British individuals who have made significant contributions to national history, emphasizing the importance of their achievements being recognized. She thanks her hon. Friend for putting forward the debate, acknowledging the increasing number of uncomfortable conversations about race following the murder of George Floyd. She also agrees that the Government needs to implement a race equality strategy and diversify the curriculum.
Apsana Begum
Lab
Poplar and Limehouse
My hon. Friend has mentioned some important, though depressing, statistics about the reality of things in the country today. To add to that, there are fewer than 200 black university professors among 23,000 in the UK. She agrees that this is a shameful figure and one that needs bold action from the Government.
Brendan O'Hara
SNP
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Celebrated the contributions of black people to society, acknowledged the need for reflection on racial injustice. Emphasised the importance of recognising lesser-known figures who have contributed to society without recognition. Highlighted Andrew Watson as a pioneer in football before Arthur Wharton and questioned certain historical narratives. Discussed the Scottish Government's efforts to tackle racism through education and funding programmes addressing inequality.
David Lammy
Lab
Tottenham
He pointed out that BAME youth custody has increased by 10% since his review was commissioned five years ago and criticized the government for stalling on implementing the recommendations from his report.
Diane Abbott
Ind
Hackney North and Stoke Newington
She congratulates her hon. Friend for securing the debate and references the Scarman inquiry from the early '80s, suggesting that if its recommendations had been addressed, today's situation on racial inequality might be different. Emphasised the significance of grassroots activism in the election of four black MPs in 1987, citing events such as the Brixton riots, Scarman report, and New Cross house fire. She highlighted that without these events and their aftermath, there would not have been the impetus for change leading to political representation. Abbott also discussed the ongoing issues faced by black communities including institutional racism, education disparities, employment barriers, and maternal health concerns. Emphasised that Black History Month should celebrate ordinary black men and women, such as nurses, factory workers, and bus drivers who contributed to the advancement of their communities. Is the Minister prepared to share his plans to address the disproportionate level of black exclusions from schools, which often leads to a school-to-prison pipeline. The intervention also includes asking for proposals on recruiting more black teachers and enabling them to rise up to become headteachers.
Dwyfor Meirionnydd
She highlighted the significance of John Ystumllyn, the first definitively recorded black person in north Wales, and the launch of the John Ystumllyn rose as a symbol to remember his life. She also mentioned that Welsh schools will now include guidance on the history of black, Asian and ethnic minority people in their curriculum. Liz Saville-Roberts noted the disproportionate number of black individuals imprisoned in Wales compared to white individuals.
Battersea
She congratulates her hon. Friend on their speech and suggests that implementing recommendations from multiple reports on racial inequality could make headway on the issue. She highlighted the importance of Black History Month, emphasising the achievements and challenges faced by black Britons. She mentioned several historical figures and organisations contributing to black history in the UK, such as Mary Prince, Mary Seacole, Lilian Bader, Olive Morris, John Archer, and those involved in the Bristol bus boycott. She advocated for the inclusion of black British history in the national curriculum and addressed ongoing inequalities in health, education, employment, immigration, and criminal justice. She supported Liz Saville-Roberts's speech, agreeing that telling a complete and accurate history is crucial to breaking the cycle of injustice. The Minister is urged to address the data showing that black Caribbean children are disproportionately likely to be excluded from school, controlling for all other factors. The intervention calls on the Minister to tackle this disparity affecting young black children.
Steven Baker
Con
Wycombe
Mr Baker highlighted the importance of acknowledging and celebrating black history as part of British history. He mentioned his role in CARFE, a group aimed at encouraging Conservative MPs to address racial issues. He praised Wycombe Museum for its efforts in promoting black history and acknowledged the contributions of Caribbean immigrants. Mr Baker also welcomed the Government's response to the Sewell report on race and ethnic disparities and called for educational inclusivity and disaggregation of the term 'BAME'. Will the hon. Lady give way? He intervened to remind the House about historical events such as the death of Cynthia Jarrett and the murder of Keith Blakelock, questioning whether civil disorder is an appropriate response to current issues. Welcoming what the Minister has said but also noting that he might face accusations of being 'woke'. The speaker asks how the Minister will respond to those who may accuse him of such, emphasizing the necessity and rightness of his policy.
Taiwo Owatemi
Lab
Coventry North West
Celebrated black trailblazers like Ira Aldridge and highlighted issues such as the ethnicity pay gap and higher exclusion rates for black students. Raised concerns about black maternal health, with black women four times more likely to die during childbirth.
Government Response
Robin Walker
Government Response
It is a great pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Graham. I congratulate the hon. Member for Streatham (Bell Ribeiro-Addy) on securing this important debate. She spoke passionately—as so many other Members have—about the importance of Black History Month. I welcome the contributions that we have heard. I also congratulate the Backbench Business Committee on granting the debate. Black history is extremely important to the Government. It has resonance across many different areas of policy. It is right, then, that all Departments should be responsible and accountable in debates such as these, which is why I am appearing today as the Minister for School Standards. I shall respond predominantly on matters regarding black history in education, as I am sure the hon. Lady will understand. As many hon. Members––including my hon. Friend the Member for Wycombe (Mr Baker) in his thoughtful speech––pointed out, there is a huge range of topics to cover, so where issues such as maternal health have been raised, I will write to colleagues in relevant Departments to ask for a response. In the case of the ethnicity pay gap, that will be the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, my hon. Friend the Member for Sutton and Cheam (Paul Scully). I will ensure that the relevant Ministers send responses on the broader issues. As we have heard, October is Black History Month in the UK, a time to celebrate the contribution of black communities and individuals over the centuries in shaping the dynamic and diverse country that we have today. Like the hon. Member for Streatham, I want black children in our schools to be proud to be black and proud to be British. Like the hon. Member for Coventry North West (Taiwo Owatemi), I want to ensure that we inspire the next generation to achieve their dreams. I take a personal interest in debates of this nature. One of my predecessors as Member for Worcester, who also happened to be my late father, campaigned alongside Jack Kennedy and Adlai Stevenson for civil rights in the United States and came to this House fresh from those campaigns at a time of critical change in the recognition of civil rights in that country. He continued to champion this important issue during his time as an MP and after. When I became Member of Parliament for Worcester in 2010 and met members of Worcester's Afro-Caribbean community, I was deeply touched to hear how much they valued some of his work in the constituency on their behalf. It was one of my greatest honours, for too short a time, to represent Basil D'Oliveira and his family. I was very glad that the city I represent marked his life not only with a magnificent civic service in 2012 but also posthumously by granting him the freedom of the city in 2018. Basil was a softly spoken, deeply unpolitical gentleman who became an unlikely hero in the struggle against apartheid, his role showing the cricketing world the true nature of South Africa's colour bar and helping to strengthen the sporting embargo. His example drew global attention to the fundamental unreasonableness of racist policy. In the words of Nelson Mandela when he met him, he did his bit. My younger constituents have also been an inspiration to me. Darian Murray-Griffiths, who until recently was one of my constituents, is one such person. I first met him as an 11-year-old boy after his proud parents reached out to me to encourage his interest in Parliament and history. I have since followed his progress closely and, as a student at Worcester sixth-form college, he made an eloquent and thoughtful speech at a Black Lives Matter event in the city. Such was the impact of his speech that he was invited to No. 10 to discuss it. I have no doubt that young people like him will further bring together diverse communities in modern Britain and make their own contribution to history. The Department has been clear that the national curriculum for history enabled black voices and experiences to be taught, whether it is events such as the Bristol bus boycott that had a national impact or the global impact of those soldiers across the former empire and Commonwealth who fought in both world wars. The recent anniversaries of the first and second world wars showed the greater awareness of black and minority ethnic contributions to both. For the first world war, that was aided by Government projects such as The Unremembered and No Barriers, alongside the promotion of figures such as Lieutenant Walter Tull. We have heard some fantastic examples of local history. The right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd (Liz Saville Roberts) spoke about the new rose that has been dedicated to John Ystumllyn—she will have to forgive my Welsh pronunciation—which I was fascinated to read about this morning. I congratulate the We Too Built Britain campaign for its work on that. We have heard about some very important figures who have been commemorated, such as the example originally given by the hon. Member for Erith and Thamesmead (Abena Oppong-Asare) of Yvonne Connolly, along with Betty Campbell in Cardiff; Olive Morris in Battersea; Ira Aldridge in Coventry; George Alexander Gratton in Wycombe; Arthur Wharton, the goalkeeper for Darlington; and, of course, Andrew Watson at Queen's Park F.C.—the hon. Member for Argyll and Bute (Brendan O'Hara) would not forgive me if I did not mention him. I want schools to look at local figures like those when they teach local history. The development of the model history curriculum is so important. We have already published the model music curriculum in March; this is non-statutory music curriculum guidance for key stages 1 to 3, developed by an independent panel of 15 specialists from across the UK. Diversity will be an important aspect of the model history curriculum, as we demonstrate how the content, themes and eras of the national curriculum can be brought to life by teaching them in an interconnected form throughout key stages. A diverse history can be taught because history is diverse. As so many Members have said today: black history is British history. This country has a lot to be proud of. Children should be taught all aspects of our shared history, and as we have heard in this debate, that includes both the good and the bad. We must teach about the contributions of people of all ethnicities, both men and women, who have made this country what it is today. The shared history of our country is one that is outward looking; a nation that has influenced the world and been influenced in turn by people from all over the world. It is people who have built the culturally rich country that we have today, and we are truly an example of the riches that diverse communities can bring to one another.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.