← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Future of the National Health Service — [Hannah Bardell in the Chair]
22 September 2021
Lead MP
Richard Burgon
Leeds East
Lab
Responding Minister
Edward Argar
Tags
NHSTaxationEmploymentNorthern IrelandStandards & EthicsMental Health
Word Count: 13567
Other Contributors: 12
At a Glance
Richard Burgon raised concerns about future of the national health service — [hannah bardell in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Burgon asks for an end to privatisation, ensuring NHS services are run as public services with no role for private companies on local health boards or in service provision. He also calls for a substantial pay rise for NHS staff to address the staffing crisis and improve morale.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Richard Burgon is concerned about the NHS Bill's potential to further privatise and marketise the healthcare system. He cites issues such as strict budget caps leading to rationing, increased private involvement, reduced accountability, and a lack of transparency in contract allocation. Additionally, he points out that the funding increase under the current government falls short of what is needed compared to previous levels.
Clapham and Brixton Hill
The NHS is overworked, understaffed, under-appreciated, and severely underpaid. The sell-off of 49 GP surgeries to Centene during the pandemic reveals a worrying trend towards privatisation. Bell Ribeiro-Addy fears the impact on her constituents from this takeover by an American health insurance giant. Emphasised that Conservative Ministers should focus on current NHS challenges rather than discussing past Labour achievements.
Chris Bryant
Lab
Rhondda and Ogmore
Chris Bryant highlighted the exhaustion of NHS staff due to the pandemic, citing examples of medical professionals working in intensive care units beyond their regular duties. He mentioned the backlog of patients waiting for treatment, particularly those who delayed seeking help due to fear of contracting covid. The speaker expressed concern about late-stage presentations of illnesses such as cancer and the increased cost burden on the NHS. Chris Bryant also pointed out staffing shortages across various medical disciplines including radiologists, oncologists, dermatologists, and diagnostic laboratories. An intervention asking about a specific point made by Margaret Greenwood, but no full speech was provided. Implored the Minister to address urgent issues without delay.
Chris Green
Con
Blackpool North and Cleveleys
The NHS needs to change continuously, not remain static since its creation in 1948. There is a need for legislation to keep up with societal changes and ensure patient values are at the centre of healthcare delivery. Chris Green highlighted England's lag behind other European countries in adopting new drugs and called for international collaboration in research and development. Suggested that hospital infrastructure should evolve with time, asking the Minister to consider Bolton Royal Hospital's needs for new facilities.
Jacqui Smith
Lab
Solihull
I am concerned about the long-term sustainability of the National Health Service and the impact of staff shortages on patient care. The NHS is facing unprecedented challenges, including an ageing population and the ongoing pandemic.
Liam Bailey
Con
Newcastle-under-Lyme
The government has made significant investments in the National Health Service to address long-standing issues such as staffing and infrastructure. I am pleased to see that these measures are beginning to bear fruit, with improved access to care in my constituency.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Emphasized the importance of the NHS, highlighted concerns about medication availability due to the Northern Ireland protocol, and called for prioritization of treatments and services. He mentioned that 910 medicines are currently unavailable in Northern Ireland and another 2,400 may be at risk. He also discussed health reconfiguration and the need for correct funding to secure the NHS's future.
Lisa Cameron
SNP
East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow
Commended the importance of prioritising and defending the NHS post-crisis, highlighted concerns about privatisation reducing accountability for local patients, emphasized the need for equality in access to medications across regions like Northern Ireland, and stressed the urgency of addressing the staffing and workforce crisis. Highlighted how artificial intelligence technology has reduced heart failure diagnostic waiting times in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, suggesting it as a best practice for others to emulate.
Blackley and Broughton
The NHS is under great strain due to staff shortages and a backlog of patients waiting for hospital treatment. The Health and Care Bill will lead to increased rationing of healthcare, embedding a postcode lottery into the NHS in England. Private companies should not have any say in how public money should be spent in the NHS. Asked the Minister to respond to a British Medical Association resolution that rejected the Health and Care Bill, citing issues such as workforce shortages and outsourcing.
Nusrat Ghani
Con
Wealden
I urge the government to take action on improving mental health services and addressing staffing shortages across primary and secondary care settings. The NHS is facing a critical shortage of healthcare professionals, which could jeopardise patient safety.
Paula Barker
Lab
Liverpool Wavertree
Paula Barker raised concerns about the Health and Care Bill, citing billions wasted on failed track and trace systems and PPE contracts. She emphasized the need for greater collaboration between health and social care services but expressed scepticism over the integration's potential impact on adult social care due to the current NHS backlog. She called for a pause in the implementation of integrated care boards until conflicts of interest are addressed and local government is fully involved.
Rachael Maskell
Lab Co-op
York Central
She highlighted the stark health inequality in her constituency and criticised the current government's approach, stating that public health must be prioritised to address growing demands on the NHS. Ms Maskell pointed out the surge in poverty due to recent policy changes such as national insurance contributions and removal of the £20 universal credit uplift, leading to poorer mental and physical health among constituents. She cited data showing a significant increase in private provision within the NHS since 2019-20 and emphasised that the system is imploding, with staff overwhelmed by the demands.
Tooting
Stressed the importance of properly funding and resourcing the NHS, highlighting issues such as skyrocketing waiting lists, cancelled routine operations, and high mental healthcare backlogs. Criticised the 2012 Lansley reforms for fragmenting the health service and introducing market elements that prioritise private companies over patients. Emphasised the exhaustion and burnout of NHS staff due to insufficient support from the Government.
Government Response
Edward Argar
Government Response
Defended the NHS Bill, acknowledging its importance while criticising opposition arguments. Emphasised the current legislation's alignment with NHS wishes and praised Lord Stevens' support for 85% of the bill. Addressed concerns about privatisation, highlighting Labour's past roles in accelerating private involvement. Reaffirmed commitment to workforce issues despite not taking direct responsibility for mental health. Offered meetings with MPs to discuss agenda for change and funding issues. Mentioned the government's £33.9 billion increase in NHS funding by 2023-24 and a £2 billion injection into elective recovery. Discussed Northern Ireland medicine supply challenges and the importance of technology in healthcare innovation.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.