← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
[Mr Laurence Robertson in the Chair]
12 January 2021
Lead MP
Fleur Anderson
Putney
Lab
Responding Minister
Vicky Ford
Tags
EconomyEmploymentBusiness & TradeChildren & FamiliesLocal Government
Word Count: 12897
Other Contributors: 7
At a Glance
Fleur Anderson raised concerns about [mr laurence robertson in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Will the Government publish the evidence base for nurseries being open and commit to reviewing transmission rates regularly? Will funding be provided for PPE and priority given for lateral flow testing and vaccination for early years staff and childminders? Will maintained nursery schools receive a business rates holiday? A new financial support package is needed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
The early years sector has felt like an afterthought during the pandemic. There is a £660 million shortfall in early years funding pre-pandemic, which worsened with inadequate and patchy government support throughout lockdown closures. Funding from councils received by nurseries is based on current occupancy levels instead of pre-covid levels, leading to significant financial losses. Early years settings have not been eligible for small business grants or the schools covid catch-up fund, further exacerbating financial issues.
Alex Sobel
Lab Co-op
Leeds Central and Headingley
Mr Sobel highlighted the struggles faced by early years settings during the pandemic, including lack of funding and support. He noted that many providers are at risk due to the current variant's increased transmissibility and government decisions. He shared concerns from childcare staff who feel unprotected and undervalued, with some feeling obliged to work despite health risks. Mr Sobel called for urgent action on vaccination, clear guidelines, adequate PPE, financial support based on pre-pandemic attendance, and recognition of the crucial role early years settings play in education and family stability. Asked the Minister for additional information on a timeline, noting that more details were provided during the debate than in written answers.
Bury South
The MP highlighted difficulties faced by early years settings during the pandemic, including financial pressures and decreased income. He called for scientific guidance to be provided to all Members of the House and prioritized vaccination for key workers in the sector. The MP also stressed the importance of funding support and advocated for solutions such as extending VAT holidays on PPE for private providers. Concerns were raised about the long-term viability of private nurseries and the need for greater prevalence of vaccines and testing in nurseries and child-minders. He emphasized the necessity for a meaningful funding review to ensure early years settings are world-class.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Jim Shannon highlighted the challenges faced by early years services in Northern Ireland during lockdown, noting that many charities and service providers struggled to adapt due to a lack of technological readiness. He cited concerns about missed vital support for vulnerable children and families, especially in areas like breastfeeding and parental mental health. Shannon noted that virtual offerings created an uneven playing field, with some families unable to be reached through online platforms, thus facing greater disadvantages.
Kate Green
Lab
Wirral West
Ms Green highlighted concerns over safety and funding for early years staff during the pandemic. She criticised the lack of scientific evidence backing the decision to keep settings open while primary schools closed, and urged for regular mass testing in these settings. She also raised issues regarding insufficient financial support for providers, such as absence cover and additional costs not covered by schools. Clarified whether occupational roles will be considered after the first four categories or after all nine categories laid out by the Government. Also expressed confusion about the sequencing of these considerations, specifically asking if it comes after the over-60s category.
Kate Osborne
Lab
Jarrow and Gateshead East
Ms Osborne highlighted the confusion caused by keeping nurseries open while primary schools moved to remote learning. She expressed concerns about social distancing difficulties and called for regular mass testing and prioritisation of early years workers in vaccine distribution. Ms Osborne also raised issues with funding, noting that 20,000 providers could face collapse without full funding of early-entitlement places. She highlighted the crucial role nurseries play beyond childcare, including emergency services during the pandemic.
Naseem Shah
Lab
Bradford West
The MP expressed concern over the Government's decision to keep early years settings open during a national lockdown. He cited expert opinions suggesting nurseries should be closed due to high transmission risks and the difficulty in social distancing with young children. The lack of regular testing and support for these settings, combined with unchanged funding models despite increased costs from the pandemic, were highlighted as major issues.
Steve Brine
Con
Hampshire North Test Valley
The hon. Member for Putney is congratulated on introducing the debate, and Steve Brine highlights that demand for childcare places is 21% lower than in 2019. He mentions a survey by the Early Years Alliance showing 56% of providers saying that basing fees on current occupancy would negatively impact them. Without government support, some big closures could occur by late spring. The lack of clarity around funding for self-isolating staff and closed bubbles is also noted as a challenge for nurseries. Childminders are particularly impacted by temporary closure due to positive tests. He urges an independent review of early years policy and funding.
Government Response
Vicky Ford
Government Response
The Minister thanked Members for their contributions and discussed the Government's commitment to supporting early years settings during the pandemic. She mentioned the Prime Minister's announcement to keep early years settings open, highlighting the low risk of transmission among pre-school children and the measures taken to ensure safety such as rapid testing and vaccine prioritisation for eligible staff. The Minister also addressed concerns about funding and attendance, stating that local authorities have been urged to monitor sufficiency issues closely.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.