← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Early General Election
17 October 2022
Lead MP
Catherine McKinnell
Newcastle upon Tyne North
Lab
Responding Minister
Brendan Clarke-Smith
Tags
NHSEconomyTaxationEnergy
Word Count: 13511
Other Contributors: 5
At a Glance
Catherine McKinnell raised concerns about early general election in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
I ask the government to call an early general election so that the public can decide on who should lead through this turmoil.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
I am concerned about the chaos in the current Government and the lack of public mandate for recent policy changes. The petition has received over 632,000 signatures. There are multiple crises facing the UK, including high inflation, fuel bills, NHS backlogs, economic turmoil, and political instability.
Pontypridd
Mr Davies-Jones argued that a general election is necessary due to the government's chaos and incompetence. He cited almost 1,000 signatures on a petition calling for change, noting the Prime Minister's mini-Budget as evidence of fiscal failure. He highlighted concerns over energy costs and pension funds, stating that constituents are worried about surviving winter because they cannot afford heating. Davies-Jones criticised the government's economic policies and called for an end to 12 years of failed Tory rule. Asked why neither of the First Ministers from Scotland and Wales have received contact from the Prime Minister since she took office, questioning her commitment to the Union.
Catherine West
Lab
Hornsey and Friern Barnet
Ms West criticised the Government's handling of the economy, particularly their tax cuts for the wealthy which led to increased mortgage costs. She expressed concern over rising child poverty and the failure of 'levelling up' policies in poorer areas. Ms West highlighted the impact on civil servants and institutions like the OBR during recent turmoil and advocated for a Labour government's energy policy, including a fossil fuel-free electricity system by 2030 to save households £475 per year. She also stressed the need for benefits and support for those in financial hardship. Suggested that Mr Farage's party tipping into the Conservative Party contributed to its split, questioning whether a general election is necessary.
Fleur Anderson
Lab
Putney
Fleur Anderson thanked the Chair of the Petitions Committee and supporters of an e-petition for a general election. She highlighted that over 633,000 people have signed the petition since July, with more than 500,000 signatures in just two weeks. She outlined concerns about the current government's handling of various crises including cost-of-living issues, energy prices, and economic policies, which she argued lack a mandate from the public. Pointed out that mortgage rates are increasing by an average of £500 across the country, with higher figures in her constituency. Argued that people signing petitions want a change in policies due to fiscal damage caused by current leadership.
Owen Thompson
SNP
Midlothian
Concerned about the instability and economic incompetence of the current government, Owen Thompson highlighted the impact on individuals struggling to make ends meet and businesses at risk due to soaring energy bills. He mentioned a cost of living event in Gorebridge where over 1,000 people from his constituency signed a petition for an early general election, now totaling 633,000 signatures. Thompson argued that the UK is not a presidential system but called for better democratic paths and acknowledged Scotland's mandate for a referendum on independence. Asked the Minister how Vladimir Putin caused mortgage rates to rise. Found it perplexing how the Prime Minister can change her mind quickly but does not allow Scotland to do so regarding constitutional decisions.
Ruth Jones
Lab
Newport West and Islwyn
Ms Jones highlighted the economic challenges caused by the Conservative government, including crashes due to unfunded tax cuts and rising costs for constituents. She argued that a change of Prime Minister and a general election are necessary. The e-petition under discussion has more than 630,000 signatures as of her statement.
Government Response
Brendan Clarke-Smith
Government Response
As the Government Minister responding to the debate, Brendan Clarke-Smith highlighted that families and businesses were facing significant financial challenges due to rising energy costs and inflation. He noted that interest rates worldwide have risen in response to global economic conditions. To address this crisis, the UK government took decisive action with a comprehensive package aimed at reducing peak winter energy bills from an expected £6,000 to a more manageable level through measures such as supporting families most affected by increased costs and cutting national insurance contributions for 28 million people, putting around £330 back in taxpayers' pockets. Clarke-Smith emphasized the importance of economic stability and growth, advocating for investment zones, accelerated road projects, and increased energy supplies to ensure future resilience against similar crises. He argued that a change in party leadership does not necessitate an immediate general election, citing historical precedents where Prime Ministers have continued without one until their term concluded naturally or a confidence vote was held. Clarke-Smith underscored the importance of the Government's focus on bringing economic and political stability to lower interest rates and restore confidence in sterling, emphasizing that a premature election could delay progress towards these goals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.