Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

City and Town Centres: Regeneration — [Martin Vickers in the Chair]

16 October 2024 · 23 other contributors · 13,961 words

Opened by Catherine Atkinson Lab Derby North

Responding minister: Alex Norris

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Catherine Atkinson raised concerns about city and town centres: regeneration — [martin vickers in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Catherine Atkinson expressed concern over the current state of city and town centres, noting issues such as empty shops and crime.
  • Atkinson called for a Government strategy on vacant shops and cross-Government coordination for town centre regeneration.
  • The minister emphasized the importance of localism and a partnership approach in town centre regeneration efforts.

Key requests to Government

Atkinson called for a specific Government strategy on vacant shops and cross-Government co-ordination of efforts to regenerate city and town centres. She also requested updates on the implementation of high street rental auctions and community right to buy, as well as assurances that auctions would include protections for vacant pubs.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Catherine Atkinson Lab Derby North

Catherine Atkinson expressed concern about the current state of city and town centres, highlighting issues such as empty shops, low footfall on most days except for special occasions like Remembrance Sunday, crime, and antisocial behaviour. She noted that seven in ten people judge the vitality of an area based solely on its high street. In Derby, over 80 shops are currently up for sale or to let, representing a 60% increase from two years prior.

Other contributors (23)
  • Amanda Martin Lab Portsmouth North

    Amanda Martin discussed the need for holistic approaches to regenerate forgotten high streets in Portsmouth North, citing issues like vacant shops, boarded-up pubs, and a lack of quality businesses. She emphasized the importance of cross-Government support for local authorities to repurpose buildings. Does the hon. Lady agree that we need some focused solutions for high street regeneration, including holistic approaches to changes in our communities, such as new GP surgeries, nurseries, pop-up markets, art studios, and facilities like public toilets? She also called for reforming business rates, enhancing local authority planning departments' capacity, cross-Government working with the Home Office and MHCLG, and updating planning systems.

  • Andrew Cooper Lab Mid Cheshire

    Town centre events are crucial for driving vitality and viability in declining areas. In his constituency, Northwich town council and various community groups partner to host a full year programme of events that boost footfall.

  • Andrew Pakes Lab Co-op Peterborough

    Andrew Pakes highlighted the decline of high streets in Peterborough, citing issues such as empty shops, antisocial behaviour and drug problems. He praised the city's heritage but noted that despite its potential, there has been a tough decade with cuts to local government and loss of major retailers like John Lewis and M&S. Pakes also thanked various organisations for their work on regeneration projects and urged the Government to provide clear messages and support for small businesses.

  • Angus MacDonald Lib Dem Inverness, Skye and Ross-shire

    Asked the hon. Member for her opinion on business improvement districts and their value in rejuvenating market towns and small cities across Britain.

  • Baggy Shanker Lab Co-op Derby South

    Despite challenges from local government cuts, the impact of lockdowns during the covid pandemic, and under-investment, Derby is now on an upward trajectory with a Labour Government, Mayor, and council. The city has a strong partnership between private and public sectors to deliver a cleaner, safer, and more prosperous future.

  • Bayo Alaba Lab Southend East and Rochford

    Bayo Alaba highlighted the importance of regenerating city centres like Southend's Hamlet Court Road, stressing the need to support local businesses and address issues such as antisocial behaviour that exacerbate declining footfall. He emphasized the role of high streets in providing opportunities for young people and fostering a circular economy.

  • Bradley Thomas Con Bromsgrove

    Mr Thomas expressed optimism about the future of town centres and emphasised the need for business rates reform to match changing retail habits. He advocated for local councils taking an active role in championing their towns as destinations for investment, creating local investment prospectuses, focusing on urban design as a catalyst for economic renewal, and fostering skills development.

  • Connor Naismith Lab Crewe and Nantwich

    Town centres are vital social fabrics needing proactive regeneration. The decline in Crewe town centre is partly due to online retail, but hospitality and leisure initiatives can drive improvement. Empty shop units and connectivity issues challenge local communities.

  • Darren Paffey Lab Southampton Itchen

    Southampton's economic hub benefits from green tech businesses; the Prime Minister's investment summit announcements are welcome. The city is looking at a devolution deal and needs clear process for accessing £63 billion investment.

  • David Simmonds Con Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner

    He highlighted the importance of local leaders in championing inward investment and praised business rate reliefs as crucial for high street regeneration post-COVID. He asked the Minister to provide a timetable for the next round of devolution and a deadline for retaining the 75% business rate relief.

  • Helen Grant Con Maidstone and Malling

    She argued that reducing business rates, not just reforming them, would incentivise businesses to set up in town centres like Maidstone, particularly independents and new start-ups. She also noted the need for a level playing field with e-commerce.

  • James Frith Lab Bury North

    The MP highlighted the importance of towns in the regeneration debate, focusing on Bury and its three key towns: Tottington, Ramsbottom, and Bury itself. He expressed concern about communities feeling ignored when decisions are made without their input. James Frith also discussed the need for self-determination and financial support from the government to address austerity-related issues such as special educational needs funding, road investment, and public services like bus networks. The MP called on the Minister to provide assurances that existing funding bids would not be affected by the general election and urged clarity on future funding commitments.

  • James Naish Lab Rushcliffe

    I was the leader of Bassetlaw district council. Following Wilko's collapse two summers ago in my constituency, I question whether £20 million for 55 towns will sufficiently address the social and economic functions of retail units in our town centres.

  • Jessica Asato Lab Lowestoft

    Jessica Asato highlighted the challenges faced by her constituency's high streets, including 96 empty premises out of 366 in Lowestoft and a bank closure in Beccles. She mentioned poor mobile connectivity and lack of evening buses and trains. However, she also noted positive signs of regeneration such as £24.3 million cultural quarter plans and the First Light festival.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    He provided a Northern Ireland perspective focusing on three towns: Newtownards, Comber, and Ballynahinch. Jim highlighted the importance of vibrant chambers of trade in these areas and mentioned concerns over the pause in city deals which could impact smaller towns. He emphasized the need for Government investment to sustain local businesses.

  • Jo Platt Lab Co-op Leigh and Atherton

    Agreed with the hon. Friend's points about regeneration, highlighted the decline of high streets in Leigh, Atherton, Golborne, and Tyldesley, and suggested giving local authorities powers to hold absent property owners accountable.

  • Jonathan Brash Lab Hartlepool

    Emphasised the problem of derelict commercial properties in Hartlepool, noting an arson attack on the old Odeon building, and advocated for greater powers to local authorities around compulsory purchase.

  • Louise Jones Lab North East Derbyshire

    Agreed with the hon. Friend's call for a strategy addressing empty shops and stressed the importance of public transport access for high street use.

  • Melanie Onn Lab Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes

    Melanie Onn discussed empty shops in her constituency, emphasizing the need for a national strategy to ensure healthy high streets. She praised initiatives such as the Horizon Youth Zone and the proposed transport hub but expressed concern about pedestrianising the marketplace, which local businesses worry could affect footfall. Onn also noted that large banks are leaving gaps that often remain unfilled or are filled with vape shops and barbers.

  • Melanie Ward Lab Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy

    Melanie Ward discussed the challenges facing Kirkcaldy's High Street, including a 25% vacancy rate and a decline of 14-22% in businesses since the pandemic. She called for effective partnerships to support local regeneration efforts and highlighted community initiatives like Love Oor Lang Toun.

  • Rachel Hopkins Lab Luton South

    She highlighted the loss of shops due to high overhead costs, particularly business rates, and welcomed Labour's plans to reform this system. Rachel praised local authorities' role in regeneration and mentioned significant work underway in Luton, including The Stage development project and plans for the Power Court area redevelopment involving Luton Town FC.

  • Tim Roca Lab Macclesfield

    Tim Roca addressed the impact of previous Government policies on Macclesfield, noting a decline in traditional retail jobs and closed stores. He mentioned issues like high business rates, out-of-town retail parks, and reduced bus links to villages. He supported efforts to reform business rates, devolve power, and improve connectivity.

  • Vikki Slade Lib Dem Mid Dorset and North Poole

    The regeneration of towns and cities must be approached from a local perspective. City centres have always changed over time, and if we want to avoid another decade of decline after the shocks of Brexit and COVID-19, we need the Government to invest resources and responsibilities to councils and communities. The Liberal Democrats advocate for a single pot of funding like with the shared prosperity fund to ensure long-term stability. They also support the replacement of business rates with a commercial land owner levy alongside an increase in digital services tax to boost investment and cut taxes for businesses. Concerns exist over unfettered permitted development leading to poor living spaces and lack of affordable housing infrastructure.

Government Response

Alex Norris

The minister highlighted the importance of localism in town centre regeneration, emphasizing the need for a partnership approach between national government and local authorities. He discussed various funding initiatives from previous governments and outlined the new Government's commitment to introduce a more allocative model with less central direction and more local decision-making. The minister also touched on safety concerns, business rates, banking hubs, and planning issues, committing to measures such as high street rental auctions and community right to buy.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy