Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Great Western Main Line

09 January 2024 · 10 other contributors · 9,006 words

Opened by Richard Graham Con Gloucester

Responding minister: Huw Merriman

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Richard Graham raised concerns about great western main line in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Mr Graham is concerned about the nationalisation of railways and highlights the success of private railway operators, including increases in passenger journeys, services, and revenue.
  • Mr Graham mentions ongoing train driver strikes and infrastructure failures by Network Rail in the Thames valley causing significant passenger frustration.
  • Mr Graham asks for renegotiation of train stop times at Gloucester station and encourages collaboration to improve services and infrastructure.

Key requests to Government

Mr. Graham asks for a renegotiation of train stop times at Gloucester station to potentially reduce journey times further and encourages continued collaboration between MPs, railway operators, the Department for Transport, and Network Rail to improve services and infrastructure.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Richard Graham Con Gloucester

Mr. Graham is concerned about the creeping nationalisation of railways since the pandemic and the lack of recognition for the success of private railway operators, including a 107% increase in passenger journeys, a 32% increase in services, and a 145% increase in revenue. He also highlights ongoing issues such as train driver strikes, which have led to significant passenger frustration. Additionally, he mentions the challenges posed by Network Rail's infrastructure failures in the Thames valley and expresses worry about the excessive taxpayer subsidy.

Other contributors (10)
  • Alex Chalk Con Cheltenham

    Mr. Chalk highlights improvements in his constituency, including a covered walkway, new waiting rooms, an accessible station footbridge with lifts, and additional car parking facilities.

  • Cherilyn Mackrory Con Truro and Falmouth

    Mackrory acknowledged the improvements made to Cornwall's rail network since 2019, including a half-hourly service between Plymouth and Penzance which has boosted passenger numbers. She highlighted the Night Riviera Sleeper service and its popularity for commuting to London. Mackrory also mentioned the £50 million levelling-up funding for the Mid Cornwall Metro project, expected to start in 2025-26.

  • Geoffrey Clifton-Brown Con North Cotswolds

    Welcomed the government's £5 billion investment in the Great Western route, noting that train cancellations have reached their highest level since records began 12 years ago. Highlighted issues such as flooding, signalling problems and delays caused by trains waiting at Reading station. Emphasised the importance of ticket office staff for elderly and those with additional needs.

  • Jonathan Edwards PC Carmarthen East and Dinefwr

    Jonathan Edwards inquired whether scrapping HS2's northern leg would free up capital money for electrification to Swansea, Carmarthen, and further west in Wales.

  • Siobhan Baillie Con Stroud

    Ms Baillie highlighted several local railway projects in Stroud, including the reopening of the Bristol Road Stonehouse line and improving step-free access at Stroud station. She also discussed improvements needed for the Cam and Dursley station, such as better shelters and increased service frequency. Ms Baillie commended GWR and Network Rail for their responsiveness and raised concerns about the prohibitive cost of rail fares from Stroud to London compared to other lines.

  • Stephen Morgan Lab Portsmouth South

    The Government's programme is failing to recognise the impact on organisations and passengers are being driven away due to unreliability and high costs. There were four incidents of damaged rail within eight days in November, raising concerns about the current state of the infrastructure.

  • Steve Double Con St Austell and Newquay

    Steve Double highlighted the importance of the Great Western main line to Cornwall, noting recent investment but also ongoing issues with reliability. He praised the half-hourly train service between Plymouth and Penzance and the Night Riviera Sleeper service, which is vital for the Cornish economy. He mentioned constituents' desire for improved mobile and wi-fi signals on trains. Double also discussed the Mid Cornwall Metro project, which aims to connect major towns in central Cornwall via rail, benefiting around 50% of economic activity there. He called on the Minister to expedite final funding approval so that work can commence next month with a target completion date of 2025.

  • Tan Dhesi Lab Slough

    Congratulates Valerie Vaz on securing the debate and highlights constituents' anger over reduced fast trains to Slough, a significant business hub. Calls for more fast trains to benefit local economies and urges the government to build the western rail link to Heathrow as its top infrastructure priority.

  • Theresa May highlighted significant improvements in railway services when companies are private, but expressed disappointment with recent issues faced by her constituents. She listed numerous disruptions and cancellations experienced on the Great Western Main Line due to various technical failures and maintenance works since December 2023. She called for better support from Network Rail to ensure reliable service.

  • Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem Bath

    Emphasised the importance of green transport for meeting net zero targets, highlighting issues with rail performance and fare increases. Criticised GWR's service quality and called for simpler ticketing systems and faster railway electrification.

Government Response

Huw Merriman

The Minister discussed the commitment to rail investment, addressing delays attributed to Network Rail assets at 67% between October 2022 and 2023. He mentioned an Office of Rail and Road investigation into poor train punctuality and reliability in the Wales and western region, with Network Rail working to identify causes and address them. The Minister also highlighted government investments including the £82 million sea wall project for the Dawlish rail route and the doubling of services between Bristol and Gloucester through the MetroWest programme. The Minister outlined steps being taken to improve connectivity on the Great Western Main Line, including £50 million levelling-up funding for Cornwall's Mid Cornwall Metro project and a commitment to a seven-day railway. He highlighted investments in rail electrification over the last decade and stressed the need for better performance.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy