Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Coastal Communities

08 September 2022 · 15 other contributors · 12,191 words

Opened by Sally-Ann Hart Con Hastings and Rye

Responding minister: Lia Nici

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Sally-Ann Hart raised concerns about coastal communities in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Coastal communities in the UK face challenges such as high deprivation, poor housing, low employment growth, and higher mortality rates.
  • Local authorities in coastal areas like Rother District Council and Hastings Borough Council received significantly less funding from the UK shared prosperity fund compared to inland areas.
  • The government highlights progress in levelling up coastal communities through initiatives such as gigabit broadband rollout and freeports, which have created and safeguarded thousands of jobs.

Key requests to Government

The Government should recognise the unique challenges faced by coastal communities and respond with meaningful policy action. I urge the creation of a dedicated Minister for Coastal Communities who can work across government departments to develop a national strategy for coastal areas and reinstate a cross-departmental working group for the coast.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Sally-Ann Hart Con Hastings and Rye

Coastal communities are integral to the UK's environmental, social, and economic well-being but face significant challenges including high levels of deprivation, poor-quality housing, low employment growth, and higher mortality rates. The coastal communities fund has been replaced with the UK shared prosperity fund, but many local authorities have received minimal funding compared to inland areas; for example, Rother District Council and Hastings Borough Council each received £1 million while other councils like Chorley in Lancashire received over £4 million and Cannock Chase received over £3 million. The challenges also include poor transport connectivity, low educational standards, skill shortages, high population transience, and disproportionately high levels of people claiming sickness and disability benefits.

Other contributors (15)
  • Alex Cunningham Lab Stockton North

    Alex Cunningham discussed the environmental and economic impact on coastal communities along the north-east coast due to declining catches of seafood. He mentioned that local fishermen had suffered a 90% drop in their usual hauls, with some catching only 10% of what they would normally catch. The issue is linked to chemical pollution, specifically pyridine. There are no fish in the sea off Teesside, highlighting an ecological disaster and questioning the usefulness of the coastal development fund for fishermen.

  • Anthony Mangnall Con Tiverton and Honiton

    Brixham and surrounding villages face challenges in healthcare, including GP shortages and poor access to dentists. Better bus routes are needed to encourage more people to use public transport. The all-party parliamentary group for shellfish aquaculture aims to increase opportunities within coastal communities while supporting sustainable food production.

  • Caroline Ansell Con South Cambridgeshire

    The MP focused on climate change adaptation and transport connectivity in coastal communities. She supported ambitious coastal defence schemes like Eastbourne's £100 million project, and called for road investment, high-speed rail connections, and Gatwick's second runway. Additionally, she emphasized the need for fairer funding formulas and VAT reduction to support social care and tourism.

  • Flick Drummond Con Mid Dorset and North Poole

    Coastal communities face diverse challenges, including poor digital connectivity and transport infrastructure. It takes longer to travel by train from London to coastal towns than to major cities like Manchester or Birmingham. Improving digital connectivity is a cost-effective way to encourage people to move to coastal areas.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Jim Shannon discussed coastal erosion issues in Strangford, citing research by Professors Andrew Cooper and Derek Jackson. He called for a coastal observatory to quantify challenges and develop strategic action plans using levelling-up funds. Shannon also noted higher levels of deprivation and an ageing population in coastal towns compared to inland areas. Asked the Minister to send details on the money allocated to Northern Ireland through the coastal communities fund.

  • Margaret Greenwood Lab Wirral West

    She expressed concern about the industrialisation of the Dee estuary due to the Prime Minister's announcement on lifting the moratorium on extracting shale gas, highlighting public opposition and environmental risks. She also raised issues regarding sewage pollution in coastal areas.

  • Natalie Elphicke Cons Dover and Deal

    Ms Elphicke highlighted the importance of coastal renaissance, citing research from the Housing and Finance Institute. She expressed concern over policies favouring big cities rather than coastal towns and villages in her constituency, which is crucial for Britain's gateway to Europe. She also noted that more than two-thirds of the most deprived small areas are in coastal communities, with nine out of ten being seaside places based on 2015 indices, while the latest figures show 25 out of 30 most deprived areas remain in coastal zones.

  • Peter Aldous Con Waveney

    Peter Aldous discussed Waveney's economic challenges, particularly in Lowestoft, where the fishing industry has declined over 40 years. He noted positive developments like CEFAS headquarters and East Coast College initiatives but highlighted funding disparities in education, local government, and enterprise zones that need addressing.

  • Richard Thomson SNP Dunbartonshire East

    Richard Thomson highlighted the economic challenges faced by coastal communities, including heavy reliance on tourism and seasonal labor. He mentioned Aberdeen's offshore wind farm project which powers the entire city but noted frustration with energy pricing structures preventing local benefits. Thomson also addressed Brexit impacts, particularly on Scotland's fishing industry with langoustine exports halving from 2010 to 2019. Funding disparities were pointed out, with Aberdeenshire receiving £8 million under the shared prosperity fund compared to over £23 million during EU structural funding periods. He advocated for English authorities' involvement in the North Sea Commission to address common challenges.

  • Robin Millar Con Aberconwy

    Robin Millar highlighted the beauty and challenges of Aberconwy's coastal community, noting the current energy crisis has compounded issues. He welcomed Government support to ease fears and protect jobs but emphasised the need for long-term sustainable solutions through clean energy projects such as tidal lagoons and nuclear power stations. Noted a contrast between investment for growth and taxation approaches, questioning whether there is agreement on this approach.

  • Rupa Huq Lab Ealing Central and Acton

    Order. There are actually quite a few more people standing than submitted to speak through the Speaker's Office, so I am afraid I will have to impose a time limit of three and a half minutes with immediate effect.

  • Sarah Owen Lab Luton North

    Criticised the dysfunction of the British state, overcentralisation and lack of economic growth in coastal communities. Highlighted the decline of fishing, shipbuilding, and port work jobs alongside the impact of austerity measures on social fabric. Pointed out that Conservative-held seaside towns are likely to be pushed into poverty due to cost of living crisis. Emphasised the need for levelling up policies and support for local regeneration plans.

  • Selaine Saxby Con North Devon

    Selaine Saxby highlighted the shortage of affordable housing in coastal areas due to an increase in short-term holiday lets and second homes. She noted that full-time workers in North Devon earn £13.29 per hour, significantly lower than the national average of £15.65. Property prices have increased by over 22% in her constituency, exacerbating the housing crisis. Agreed that the coastal communities fund was excellent and requested its return.

  • Steve Double Con St Austell and Newquay

    Representing a constituency with two coasts, the MP highlighted the challenges faced by coastal communities in Cornwall. He urged for a Minister for coastal communities to address issues such as economic diversification and unaffordable housing, specifically calling out the impact of holiday lets on local employment. Defended the government's actions on sewage discharge, stating it was the first government to take action on this issue.

  • Virginia Crosbie Con Ynys Môn

    Representing Ynys Môn, a unique and beautiful island with a seasonal tourist industry, Virginia Crosbie highlighted the economic challenges faced outside peak season. She mentioned low GVA rates, closed shops, high deprivation in Holyhead, and loss of major employers. She advocated for targeted support through regeneration projects like the £17 million bid for Holyhead town centre.

Government Response

Lia Nici

The Government has made progress towards levelling up coastal communities through initiatives like gigabit broadband rollout, fairer school funding formula, freeports opening, increasing the national living wage, recruiting more police officers, and further local devolution. The coastal communities fund invested £229 million into 369 projects from 2012 to 2019. More than 7,000 jobs have been created and 2,000 existing jobs safeguarded. Over £673 million of investment via the towns fund benefits coastal areas through towns deals worth up to £25 million each for 22 coastal towns including Whitby and Birkenhead. The future high streets fund is focused on renewing and refreshing high streets in coastal communities with a total funding of £149.7 million.

▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy