Commons Sense

House of Commons · Westminster Hall

Food and Farming: Devon and Cornwall

23 February 2022 · 13 other contributors · 13,676 words

Opened by Geoffrey Cox Con Torridge and Tavistock

Responding minister: Victoria Prentis

Summarised by AI from the official record, so it can contain mistakes.

At a glance

Geoffrey Cox raised concerns about food and farming: devon and cornwall in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.

Key points

  • Cox expresses concern over the impact of the Agriculture Act 2020 and post-Brexit trading changes on agriculture in Devon and Cornwall.
  • Cox raises concerns about the reduction of direct payments to farmers, potentially leading to a loss of 10,000 per farm.
  • Minister responds by acknowledging concerns and outlining new support schemes for farmers, including payment improvements and funds for resilience and investment.

Key requests to Government

Cox calls for greater investment in farmers and the creation of new markets for British produce around the world through a bold vision of a British agricultural export agency. He also urges the Government to ensure that policies are designed to lift farmers and support them in making the most of market opportunities, while maintaining a conviction at the heart of government regarding the importance of British farming.

How the debate unfolded

MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said.

Opened the debate

Geoffrey Cox Con Torridge and Tavistock

Cox is concerned about the unpredictability and uncertainty faced by agriculture in Devon and Cornwall due to the implications of the Agriculture Act 2020 and changes in trading relationships after Brexit. He highlights the significant proportion of Devon's economy that relies on food production and raises concerns over the reduction of direct payments to farmers, which could lead to a loss of £10,000 per farm without these payments. Cox also mentions the growing chorus of concern from industry bodies like the Tenant Farmers Association about current government plans, noting the potential impact on upland farming.

Other contributors (13)
  • Highlights the challenge of labour shortages in agriculture and emphasizes the need for recognition and reward of workers' skills. Mentions an example of a pig farm where thousands of pigs had to be killed due to lack of workforce.

  • Anthony Mangnall Con Twin towns

    I am concerned about the impact of recent changes to farm support payments on farmers in Devon and Cornwall. Many have experienced significant financial challenges due to delays in receiving payments. Discussed the need for DEFRA policies to align with productivity, environmentalism and future generations of farmers. Emphasised the role of farm shops in local communities during the pandemic and called for simpler schemes for small farmers. Highlighted the importance of increasing non-supermarket owned abattoirs to improve at-gate farm prices.

  • Daniel Zeichner Lab Cambridge

    Critiqued the government's handling of food production and farming policies, citing a lack of understanding and contradictory approaches. Highlighted issues with environmental land management schemes, labour shortages, water regulations, fishing concerns, and tenancy problems. Will the Minister give way?

  • Agrees with Clive Betts's speech, suggests a target of increasing self-sufficiency from 64% to 75% over the next decade.

  • Jim Shannon DUP Strangford

    Congratulates Clive Betts on initiating the debate, discusses farmers' income not keeping up with outgoings in Northern Ireland and calls for Government funding streams to be allocated to those who need them most, UK-wide.

  • Jonathan Gullis Lab Ealing Central and Acton

    I raised concerns about food supply chains and the need for greater resilience in the face of global challenges such as climate change. I advocated for government investment in local food production to reduce reliance on imports.

  • Luke Pollard Lab Co-op Plymouth Sutton and Devonport

    I thank the right hon. and learned Member for Torridge and West Devon for his speech, declaring an interest as my little sisters are farmers in north Cornwall. The Cabinet's gain has been our loss in farming debates due to lack of action from the Government despite wise words. I support British farming and the need for buying local more, aiming for a target of 75% by 2040. We should take back control of food policy focusing on high standards and environmental gains. Concerns arise about the Government's strategy to reduce farmers' numbers through larger farms and industrialised methods, which does not work in the south-west. I worry that trade deals undercut British farmers and betray them. The south-west contributes significantly to the national economy with £1.6 billion from agriculture and employs 60,000 people.

  • Melissa Stride LD Berwick-upon-Tweed

    I am concerned about the impact of farming on local communities and the environment in Devon and Cornwall. I highlighted the importance of sustainable agriculture practices to ensure long-term food security and ecological balance.

  • Neil Parish Con Tiverton and Honiton

    Expressed concerns about food security, emphasizing the importance of grain, chicken, sheep, cattle and dairy production in the UK. Raised issues regarding inadequate funding for farmers under new environmental schemes and potential inflation due to higher farming costs. Criticized the Home Office for slow action on labour policies and processors for failing to honor contracts with farmers.

  • Robert Courts Con Oxford West and Abingdon

    I spoke about the need for a comprehensive rural strategy that addresses issues such as infrastructure, broadband access, and skills training. I emphasised the importance of supporting young people to enter agriculture.

  • Simon Jupp Con East Devon

    Devon's farming sector is a key part of the regional economy, contributing £4.1 billion in value to UK food and farming output. The MP supports high animal welfare standards but highlights the need for clearer communication between farmers and the Government regarding environmental land management schemes and payment structures after single farm payments end.

  • Steve Double Con St Austell and Newquay

    I discussed the challenges faced by farmers in my constituency, including high input costs and labour shortages. I urged the government to provide more financial support and practical assistance to help local farms remain viable.

  • Tim Farron Lib Dem Westmorland and Lonsdale

    Tim Farron expressed concern about the transition from the Common Agricultural Policy to Environmental Land Management System (ELMS), highlighting potential income losses for farmers, threats to food security, and environmental degradation. He mentioned that 85% of farm profitability in the livestock sector comes from direct payments. Farron argued against policies that incentivise landowners to clear farmland, describing it as an outrage that rewards them financially while harming farming communities. Additionally, he criticised trade deals with countries having lower animal welfare standards and the impact of migration policies on the pig industry.

Government Response

Victoria Prentis

Addressed multiple points raised during the debate on food and farming in Devon and Cornwall. Acknowledged concerns about agricultural transition and assured support through improved payment schemes, new policies for tenant farmers, efforts to address issues in the pig industry, and the launch of three new exciting schemes open to farmers including the animal health and welfare pathway, farming resilience fund, and farming investment fund. Highlighted the importance of buying British products.

Get updates like this by email
▸ Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy