← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
IVF Provision
24 October 2023
Lead MP
Kate Osborne
Jarrow and Gateshead East
Lab
Responding Minister
Maria Caulfield
Tags
NHSTaxationForeign AffairsWomen & EqualitiesStandards & Ethics
Word Count: 12197
Other Contributors: 6
At a Glance
Kate Osborne raised concerns about ivf provision in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Osborne calls on the Government and NHS England to remove the additional financial barriers faced by same-sex couples in accessing IVF treatment. She requests a clear timeline for implementation and guidance from the women's health strategy, which promised to eliminate these discriminatory practices.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
As a mother who conceived through IVF, Kate Osborne is concerned about the discriminatory barriers LGBTQ+ couples face in accessing fertility treatment. She highlights that waiting lists have become longer and financial costs higher since her own IVF journey. The current requirement for same-sex couples to fund up to 12 rounds of artificial insemination privately before accessing NHS-funded treatment has been described as a 'gay tax.' According to the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, women should be offered three full cycles of in vitro fertilisation after two years of unsuccessful conception attempts. However, some ICBs still demand self-funding for up to 12 rounds, with only four out of 42 ICBs offering treatment without this requirement.
Erith and Thamesmead
Discussed the challenges faced by women and LGBTQI+ couples in accessing IVF treatments, highlighting the postcode lottery for NHS-funded fertility services. Emphasised the need to remove financial barriers for female same-sex couples. Quoted statistics: 86 clinical commissioning groups funded only one cycle of treatment; only four ICBs provide NHS funding for artificial insemination. Asked the Minister about conversations to update ICBs for robustness, apologised for intervening early but pressed on transparency of data publication and called for more action by ICBs beyond just publishing data.
Pontypridd
She highlighted the risk of unofficial sperm donors exploiting same-sex couples through social media, offering low-cost services without proper regulation or health checks. He highlighted the societal stigma around fertility treatments, noting that infertility is not seen as a disease or condition with equal weight to others. He emphasised the need for education in schools about fertility issues. The MP acknowledged the challenges of IVF provision and highlighted inconsistencies in NHS-funded cycles offered across the UK. She noted that her private Member's Bill, the Fertility Treatment (Transparency) Bill, aims to require providers to publish annual data on NHS-funded IVF cycles and additional treatments. The MP emphasised the need for better regulation and enforcement by the HFEA regarding add-on treatments and called for concrete action from the Government.
Hannah Bardell
SNP
Livingston
She congratulated the hon. Lady on securing the debate and pointed out that older members of the LGBT community have a limited window to become parents due to the late introduction of same-sex marriage legislation. She questioned whether the guidelines are based on infertility rather than recognising the unique nature and differences of various LGBT families. Ms Bardell praised the hon. Member for Jarrow and highlighted the unanimity in the debate about improving IVF standards across the UK, noting that Scotland sets a positive example but faces arbitrary limits on age for IVF treatment. She mentioned a report showing more women in their 40s than 20s are having children due to various factors like cost of living, career paths and lack of childcare. Expressed hope in the Minister's work and urged to accelerate efforts for female same-sex couples and the trans community to access better services, asked about surrogacy challenges faced by male same-sex couples across the UK. She raised awareness for endometriosis sufferers who face significant challenges with conception and highlighted the importance of including them in discussions about fertility treatment access.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Jim Shannon highlighted the disparity in IVF provision between Northern Ireland and mainland UK, noting that women in Northern Ireland face stricter BMI criteria to qualify for treatment compared to their counterparts on the mainland. He cited examples of constituents who had faced financial strain and emotional distress due to these restrictions. Shannon also pointed out that women in Scotland receive three rounds of NHS-funded IVF treatment, while those in Northern Ireland only get one round, if they do not have prior children. The MP urged the Minister to address these inequalities by working with the Department of Health in Northern Ireland.
Nickie Aiken
Cons
Ealing Central and Acton
Nickie Aiken highlighted the emotional strain and financial burden of IVF treatment, noting that one in seven couples struggle with fertility issues. She cited a constituent's experience of workplace discrimination after undergoing IVF and advocated for employer support through initiatives like the Fertility Workplace Pledge. Aiken also praised the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority for recent guidance on safe and cost-effective treatments.
Sarah Dyke
Lib Dem
Glastonbury and Somerton
She apologised for not attending the start of the debate and expressed concern about same-sex couples potentially turning to unsafe methods due to the current system. She mentioned that donors could have legal rights over children if they are not in a civil partnership, raising issues around health screening.
Government Response
Maria Caulfield
Government Response
The Minister announced plans to introduce secondary legislation allowing HIV-positive individuals with an undetectable viral load to donate gametes, and will address discriminatory definitions of partner donation. She emphasized the Government's commitment to improving IVF access for same-sex couples, ensuring no additional financial burden is required beyond NHS-funded cycles. Transparency tools have been introduced to track ICB compliance with NICE guidelines and provide public information on local IVF provisions. The Minister committed to urgent action by developing guidance for ICBs to address local inequalities in fertility treatment accessibility without delay.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.