← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
NHS Hysteroscopy Treatment — [Sir Mark Hendrick in the Chair]
31 January 2023
Lead MP
Lyn Brown
West Ham
Lab
Responding Minister
Maria Caulfield
Tags
NHS
Word Count: 9993
Other Contributors: 5
At a Glance
Lyn Brown raised concerns about nhs hysteroscopy treatment — [sir mark hendrick in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Lyn Brown urges the Minister to engage personally with this issue, ensure accurate data collection on pain during hysteroscopies, and provide independent oversight. She requests that the Minister emphasize the importance of offering women a choice of anaesthetic as part of the consent process from the outset.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Lyn Brown is concerned about the unnecessary pain and trauma women experience during hysteroscopies without proper pain relief. She cites specific incidents where patients endured excruciating pain, fell due to dizziness and broken bones, vomited after procedures, experienced severe bleeding, and faced lasting nerve damage. She also highlights that these experiences lead to a lack of trust in the NHS and discourage women from seeking necessary medical procedures.
Barbara Keeley
Lab
Worsley and Eccles South
I am appalled by the situation where NHS patients are not offered general anaesthesia for hysteroscopy procedures, unlike in private hospitals. A constituent was told local anaesthesia could be given if necessary but was advised against a general anaesthetic despite similar cases being treated differently in private settings. Emphasised the issue based on a constituent's experience, questioning why hysteroscopy is conducted without anaesthetic when other medical procedures cannot be performed under such conditions.
Feryal Clark
Lab
Enfield North
Ms Clark highlighted the traumatic experiences women undergo during hysteroscopy procedures, stressing that nearly 90% of women surveyed were traumatised by severe pain. She called for improved patient information and access to proper pain relief options before undergoing such critical diagnostic procedures.
Thurrock
The hon. Member for Thurrock agrees that there is a massive lack of information and different practices between private and public health sectors. She shares an anecdote where a friend was offered general anaesthesia in a London hospital, while the NHS often forces women to undergo painful procedures without proper care. Expressed frustration over the ongoing discussion about hysteroscopy procedures and emphasized the importance of informed consent. Noted that while some women experience less pain, a third face severe discomfort, which is not properly explained to them. Highlighted parallels with mesh implant cases where risks were not adequately communicated. Called for proper protocols and well-understood guidelines regarding pain relief and patient engagement before hysteroscopy procedures. Ms Doyle-Price intervened to highlight the urgency and desperation faced by women seeking medical care during critical times such as when they want to have a child, suggesting that the reported pain levels may be just the tip of the iceberg.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Supporting the debate, Jim Shannon highlighted that many women have experienced issues with hysteroscopy procedures. He noted that 70% of women who underwent hysteroscopies in English NHS hospitals reported extreme pain afterwards. Emphasising his personal connection to the issue, he shared his wife's experience and stressed the importance of ensuring effective pain relief and patient consent.
Rachael Maskell
Lab Co-op
York Central
Ms Maskell shared a powerful story about her constituent Jan, who experienced severe pain during a hysteroscopy procedure and was not informed of other anaesthesia options. She argued that women's voices are not being heard in healthcare, leading to significant suffering and lack of proper consent. I am grateful for the Minister's response. Will she include women from ethnic minority groups? Their experience of the health system is very different, so it is really important that their voices are heard in this discussion.
Government Response
Maria Caulfield
Government Response
Acknowledged the pain suffered by women during hysteroscopy procedures, highlighted progress on tariff issues, committed to meeting with patient groups, and discussed plans for better information provision through NHS website updates and women's health hubs. Mentioned a roundtable chaired by Professor Dame Lesley Regan and the Patient Safety Commissioner to address hysteroscopies.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.