Carmichael discussed the high incidence of fuel poverty in Orkney, Shetland, and Western Isles. He highlighted that residents face longer, darker winters and have limited access to gas grids. He suggested a social tariff with geographical variation and criticized Ofgem's current regulations for creating disparities in standing charges across regions. Carmichael emphasized the impact on those using prepayment meters who are financially strained. Alistair Carmichael questions why the approach to locational charging has not changed as we move towards renewable energy sources, where transmission losses do not apply.

Discussed the impact of cold temperatures, wind, and rain on isolated communities in the Highlands and Islands, emphasizing the need for constant heating due to harsh weather conditions. Emphasised the importance of fairness in Scotland's energy production revolution. Highlighted that despite producing substantial renewable energy, many residents face fuel poverty. Criticized the increase in standing charge by 138% since 2022 and higher transmission costs for those living in remote areas. Called for mandatory compensation for communities hosting green energy projects and questioned the fairness of higher charges for people who live near transmission lines. Ian Blackford emphasises the need for fairness in a universal energy market where people should not be penalised based on their location. He urges the Government to provide leadership and take action.

Jamie Stone supports the idea that keeping households warm can assist in recovery from illnesses like COVID-19. He argues that a well-insulated home not only prevents diseases but also contributes to better economic productivity by reducing absenteeism due to health issues. Agreed with the concept of fairness and the need to address the injustice faced by those living in remote areas who rely on more expensive heating solutions compared to those connected to the gas grid. It is fundamentally unfair that parts of the UK are being ripped off in terms of energy. The debate questions whether the Chancellor has factored this issue into the Budget.

Asked about the Minister's engagement and figures requested in advance.

The average fuel poverty gap increased by 66% between 2020 and 2023, with 3 million people in debt to energy providers. Only 2,900 houses benefited from the Great British insulation scheme, despite a target of 300,000. Older buildings and the lack of retrofit skills make insulation difficult in areas like the Highlands and Islands. The cost of living crisis is exacerbated by the absence of gas grid access, leading to higher energy costs. Kerry McCarthy inquires about the Government's analysis of household debt levels related to energy costs and seeks figures from the Minister for distribution through the House of Commons Library.

Noted that it is his constituents who are most affected by this issue, facing significant fuel poverty. Emphasized the need for mandatory community benefits from energy production and criticized the fairness of Scotland paying higher prices due to other parts' reliance on gas.