← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Independent Water Commission: Final Report
10 February 2026
Lead MP
Edward Morello
West Dorset
Lib Dem
Responding Minister
Emma Hardy
Tags
No tags
Word Count: 14290
Other Contributors: 14
At a Glance
Edward Morello raised concerns about independent water commission: final report in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
The Government must address the scale of the crisis by ensuring clear standards for river health, mandatory testing, visible ratings, and robust enforcement of existing environmental law. The new integrated regulator proposed in the White Paper must have teeth and be properly resourced. Water companies should be redesigned with public benefit as their core purpose.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
The public's confidence in the water sector has been severely damaged by years of sewage pollution, poor decision-making, lack of regulation, and a business model that rewards failure. In West Dorset alone, there were 4,200 sewage spills and nearly 49,000 hours of raw sewage discharge from storm overflows in 2024. The River Lim is ecologically dead, rare chalk streams are under severe pressure, and Atlantic salmon populations are threatened. Tourism worth £322 million annually and supporting over 5,000 jobs is at risk due to poor water quality.
Alison Bennett
Lib Dem
Mid Sussex
Will the Minister give way?
Amanda Hack
Lab
North West Leicestershire
Ms Hack addressed concerns raised by her constituents regarding sewage discharges and flooding in North West Leicestershire. She mentioned that the area has experienced significant rainfall, resulting in 15,000 hours of sewage discharge into waterways, impacting local residents' mental health. Ms Hack also highlighted a specific case where a resident collected sewer debris to demonstrate frustration with Severn Trent Water's practices. She welcomed the Government's White Paper on water regulation and called for reassurance that improvements will be made within four years.
Anna Dixon
Lab
Shipley
She highlighted the water pollution issues in Shipley and criticised Yorkshire Water for failing to invest adequately, leading to high bills and infrastructure damage. She welcomed the Labour Government's efforts and the Water (Special Measures) Act 2025, but expressed concerns over excessive dividends and debt levels. Dixon urged the Minister to address these issues and ensure that customers' money is properly used. Under the previous government, light-touch regulation left infrastructure crumbling. Asset mapping under new proposals will help know the state of infrastructure and whether investments are fixing leaks. Will the Minister assure the House that the regional planning for water catchments will have a strong citizen voice embedded in it, as well as drawing on evidence and expertise?
Blake Stephenson
Con
Mid Bedfordshire
He highlighted the need to clean up rivers and ensure a plentiful supply of clean water, especially in light of population growth and climate change. He expressed concern over the decline in freshwater species and the pollution affecting chalk streams. Blake questioned why the Government ignored amendments to protect these habitats, citing arrogance as a barrier to progress. Additionally, he was concerned about the speed of implementing Sir Jon Cunliffe's recommendations and potential impacts on water bills.
Charlie Maynard
Lib Dem
Witney
Blake primary school had to close due to sewage issues; bills have increased by 9.75%. The ultimate controller definition is crucial, but Ofwat has not acted properly regarding Thames Water's class A creditors.
Ellie Chowns
Green
North Herefordshire
Privatisation of water has led to poor service, increased bills, and significant pollution. Water companies have paid £85 billion in dividends since privatisation, accrued £65 billion in debt, and leaked over 1 trillion litres of water in 2024. Ellie Chowns argues that water should be brought into public ownership to work for the public good, as only 82% of British people want it.
Helen Maguire
Lib Dem
Epsom and Ewell
She reported on sewage leaks in the Rye brook, which feeds into the River Mole with excessive storm overflows. Maguire argued that privatisation is not working and called for mutually owned public benefit companies to end the sewage scandal.
Jeremy Corbyn
Ind
Islington North
Privatisation of water has been a disaster, resulting in £72 billion taken out of the industry. There is pollution and flooding, with agricultural run-offs devastating rivers like the River Wye. Thames Water frequently digs up roads causing road closures. Better river basin management and public ownership are needed.
Josh Newbury
Lab
Cannock Chase
Mr. Newbury expressed concern about the fragmented planning and ageing infrastructure in the water industry, citing more than 450,000 hours of discharge by Severn Trent alone in 2024. He welcomed proposals for a single integrated regulator and transparent monitoring but stressed the need for effective coordination among various stakeholders to address issues like flooding, sewage discharges, and pollution from agricultural run-off.
Lee Pitcher
Lab
Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme
He intervened to clarify that the all-party parliamentary water group operates independently within Parliament. Intervening to highlight that those working in water companies and farmers are often unfairly blamed for pollution issues. They work hard to prevent incidents, fix leaks, and improve the situation.
Rachael Maskell
Lab Co-op
York Central
The speaker highlighted the severe impact of pollutants on rivers in York, referencing specific hours of sewage releases and high levels of pharmaceutical contaminants. She advocated for stricter regulations based on European standards and urged for infrastructure modernisation to segregate rainwater from sewage. Additionally, Maskell called for better governance within Yorkshire Water and suggested moving water into public ownership.
Rachel Gilmour
Lib Dem
Tiverton and Minehead
The speaker criticised the government's water White Paper for not addressing the crisis adequately, highlighting the need for stronger regulations and funding for enforcement. She mentioned the significant rise in water bills and pollution issues caused by agricultural runoff and sewage works. The MP also expressed dissatisfaction with South West Water's response to flooding incidents.
Roz Savage
Lib Dem
South Cotswolds
Ms Savage highlighted the issue of sewage outflows in her constituency, stating that at least 16 sewage outlets are polluting local rivers. She criticised the privatised water model and called for a change in ownership of Thames Water to a public benefit or mutual company. She also pointed out four recurring failures in government approaches: lack of courage to address failing systems, overlooking nature-based solutions, misunderstanding farming's role, and failing to utilise citizen power.
Tim Farron
Lib Dem
Westmorland and Lonsdale
He expressed concern about the performance of water companies and the injustice in the water industry, highlighting over 3.6 million hours of sewage dumping in lakes, rivers, and seas in 2024, with Ofwat failing to enforce fines during a four-year period. He criticized collective bonuses for water companies despite poor river health and high service debt payments. In his constituency, there were 5,000 sewage discharge incidents and 55,000 hours of raw sewage pumped into waterways last year. Farron proposed merging regulatory bodies to create a powerful clean water authority and advocated for mutual ownership models in the industry.
Government Response
Emma Hardy
Government Response
She thanked the hon. Member for securing the debate, mentioned ongoing flooding issues in Somerset affecting around 300 properties, expressed concern over treatment of workers by unions, highlighted plans to transform the water sector through a White Paper, discussed the need for skills and appointments within regulatory bodies, proposed collaborative approaches to address agricultural pollution, emphasized regional planning and nature-based solutions, advocated for regulation reform, outlined measures to improve customer support including doubling social tariff support under WaterSure, encouraged the use of water meters, and addressed issues related to water security.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.