← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
[David Mundell in the Chair]
18 December 2024
Lead MP
John Whittingdale
Maldon
Con
Responding Minister
Stephanie Peacock
Tags
No tags
Word Count: 12802
Other Contributors: 15
At a Glance
John Whittingdale raised concerns about [david mundell in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
The Government should consider transitioning to alternative funding models such as subscription-based services once the majority of the population has access to IPTV. It is also necessary to discuss how core public service content, including radio and the World Service, can be funded outside of the licence fee system, potentially through general taxation.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
The funding of the BBC through the licence fee is becoming increasingly unsustainable. Since the last charter renewal, there has been an explosion in streaming platforms that invest heavily in content, leading to a decline in traditional broadcast television viewing, particularly among young people. The number of TV licences held fell by 500,000 over the past year, and this trend will likely continue as more viewers choose subscription-based services instead of paying for a TV licence.
Alex Mayer
Lab
Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard
Asked whether the current regional news coverage model, where programmes are recorded over 100 miles away from constituencies, is appropriate.
Redditch
I thanked the right hon. Member for Maldon for securing the debate, mentioning my background in relation to the Musicians' Union and BBC. I raised concerns about bias from all political parties regarding media appearances and funding of the BBC. I questioned whether a subscription model would be effective due to potential lower uptake leading to increased fees.
Fabian Hamilton
Lab
Leeds North East
The BBC World Service will enhance services to Syrian audiences through broadcast medium wave and FM following recent developments. This professionalism underscores the need for Foreign Office funding of the World Service.
Helen Whately
Con
Farnborough
Agrees with the need to discuss alternative funding models for the BBC, particularly as the traditional model becomes less viable. Suggests maintaining a distinction between core public service content and entertainment-based programming, potentially funded through general taxation and subscription services respectively.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Mr Shannon briefly intervened, mentioning that it was the King's speech. Jim Shannon highlighted positive aspects of the BBC, including its coverage of national events and comedy shows. However, he expressed concern about perceived bias in the BBC's reporting, citing examples such as Brexit coverage, Northern Ireland representation, political debates, cultural programming for Ulster Scots, and biased coverage of Israel and Hamas. He argued that public trust has eroded due to these biases and questioned the justification of a compulsory licence fee if the BBC fails to represent all parts of the United Kingdom impartially. Thanks the Minister for her positive response and raises concerns about people who do not have a BBC licence due to perceived bias. Suggests that improving complaint handling could encourage these individuals to renew their licences.
Julia Lopez
Con
Hornchurch and Upminster
My right hon. Friend recognises that the BBC's commercialisation faces opposition from other public service broadcasters who worry about the impact on their revenue streams, particularly from advertising. Expressed concern over people losing faith in the BBC due to reduced local journalism and high salaries for top stars, questioning whether the organisation is investing adequately in journalism as expected from a public service broadcaster. Ms Lopez asked Mr Glover if he would accept that fewer people are choosing to pay the TV licence fee, indicating a problem that needs addressing regardless of one's view on the licence fee. She briefly intervened, agreeing that perceived loss of public trust in the BBC is a fundamental challenge to its future. She pointed out the wider context involving state broadcasters from Russia and China. Ms Lopez questioned the Secretary of State's support for mutualisation, asking the Minister for more clarity on what this concept means in practice.
Liz Jarvis
Lib Dem
Eastleigh
She emphasised the importance of public service broadcasting, arguing against subscription models due to their exclusionary nature and potential harm to content diversity. She also advocated for full funding restoration for the BBC World Service through the Foreign Office budget.
Olly Glover
Lib Dem
Didcot and Wantage
Mr Glover highlighted the BBC's significant cultural and economic benefits, including its role in education, entertainment, and impartial reporting. He cited a KPMG report estimating that for every £1 of economic activity generated by the BBC, £2.63 of wider economic value is created. He also noted the importance of investigative journalism and the BBC World Service's critical role in providing information to repressive countries.
Patrick Hurley
Lab
Southport
The hon. Member discussed the importance of maintaining the BBC licence fee model, as it ensures access to both cultural and entertainment content. He raised concerns about trust in the BBC and suggested improvements for the Verify service to combat disinformation. The Member also supported increased funding for the World Service but proposed returning this funding to the Foreign Office to relieve financial pressures on domestic coverage. Additionally, he highlighted the importance of the BBC's role in supporting the creative economy and cultural output, advocating for a permanent charter system to support long-term stability.
Peter Prinsley
Lab
Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
He spoke in support of the BBC World Service, emphasizing its significance as a beacon for democracy with 318 million weekly listeners. He highlighted job losses and the loss of important broadcasts due to funding constraints and urged recognition of the World Service's vital soft power.
Salford
Ms Long-Bailey discussed the importance of the BBC, highlighting its role in informing and educating communities across the UK. She noted that the organisation's funding model ensures independence from business interests or advertisers, allowing it to provide content in the public interest rather than just sensationalism. Concerned about cuts to local journalism, she emphasised the need for accountability and rebuilding trust with the public. She also mentioned the BBC World Service's response during global emergencies such as those in Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, and Syria.
Richard Baker
Lab
Glenrothes and Mid Fife
One of the weaknesses of streaming companies is their lack of regional and national news coverage. BBC Scotland currently invests 99% of its licence fee revenue in Scottish programming, which must be protected.
Saqib Bhatti
Con
Meriden and Solihull East
Mr Bhatti highlighted the BBC's importance to Britain, noting that 91% of British adults use BBC services weekly. He expressed concern over declining licence fee uptake and revenues, questioning the sustainability of the current funding model. Mr Bhatti also raised issues of trust, the impact of AI and misinformation on the BBC's credibility, and the need for reform in response to changing media consumption habits. He asked what discussions the Minister is having with the BBC to ensure sustainable funding over the next decade.
Seamus Logan
SNP
Aberdeenshire North and Moray East
He expressed admiration for the BBC's role in providing reliable news during periods of conflict, highlighting challenges such as perceived lack of impartiality in editorial policy, over-reliance on high-profile talent, and issues related to unacceptable or illegal behaviour by employees. He proposed considering alternatives to the licence fee system that are more socially just.
Tom Rutland
Lab
East Worthing and Shoreham
Discussed the importance of safeguarding the BBC's unique role with a funding model that ensures independence and universal access. Highlighted challenges such as a 30% real-terms decrease in funding, additional financial responsibilities, and the need for a sustainable public funding model to ensure impartiality. He questioned whether the BBC's alleged political bias could be indicative of it getting something right, noting that both sides complain about the organisation.
Government Response
Stephanie Peacock
Government Response
Responded to points made by the shadow Minister and others, acknowledging support for the World Service. Discussed the challenges of adapting the BBC in a changing media landscape, noting that half of 16 to 24-year-olds do not watch broadcast TV weekly and more than two thirds of households subscribe to streaming services. Mentioned the Government's commitment to retain the licence fee until 2028 but will consider alternative funding models through the charter review process. Announced a £5 increase in the annual cost of a TV licence from April 2025, less than half as much as last year's increase. Emphasised the need for sustainable public funding to support BBC's vital work and announced expansion of simple payment plan to help households facing financial hardship.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.