← Back to Westminster Hall Debates
Family Farming in Devon — [Sir Mark Hendrick in the Chair]
03 December 2024
Lead MP
Geoffrey Cox
Torridge and Tavistock
Con
Responding Minister
Daniel Zeichner
Tags
Taxation
Word Count: 12511
Other Contributors: 7
At a Glance
Geoffrey Cox raised concerns about family farming in devon — [sir mark hendrick in the chair] in Westminster Hall. A government minister responded.
Key Requests to Government:
Cox asks the government to resume capital grants, provide more support for farmers affected by employer national insurance contributions and minimum wage increases, and implement the Fursdon review recommendations fully.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Cox is concerned about the financial hardships faced by family farms in Devon due to falling farm incomes, reductions in basic farm payments, and delays in environmental land management schemes. He cited specific figures such as a 68% drop in dairy farm business income and a £7,200 cap on delinked payments. The MP also highlighted the negative impact of reclassification of double-cab pick-up trucks and inheritance tax changes. Cox emphasized the importance of family farms to Devon's rural economy and heritage.
Caroline Voaden
Lib Dem
South Devon
Caroline Voaden highlighted the importance of family farms in South Devon, covering 1.2 million acres and employing over 20,000 people. She expressed concern about changes to inheritance tax and agricultural property relief, stating that 66% of English farms have a net value of more than £1 million. The NFU pointed out these figures are based on historical data and do not reflect the current state of the agricultural sector. Voaden cited local farmers who would be hit by the new tax, warning that many will sell land or wind down their businesses to reduce future liabilities. She emphasised the severe impact this policy could have on rural businesses and the entire farming community. The Liberal Democrat MP questioned whether the Treasury consulted DEFRA before implementing tax changes affecting farmers in the Budget.
Danny Chambers
Lib Dem
Winchester
Farming is a tough profession with unpredictable financial outcomes due to factors beyond farmers' control. Family farms are integral to the rural community, providing support for local schools and charity work, and maintaining curated landscapes that attract tourism. The speaker highlighted concerns about illegal meat imports through Dover, posing public health risks and threatening animal welfare standards in UK farming.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Jim Shannon highlighted the importance of food security and discussed inheritance tax on family farms, noting that falling revenues and profits are ploughed back into farms. He pointed out that many farmers will have to sell their land due to a 20% tax increase, impacting production and future generations' ability to take over the farm. Shannon also mentioned an expected 15-20% rise in food prices due to changes in national insurance contributions.
Mark Hendrick
Lab Co-op
Preston
Ordered the debate to continue after a Division in the House, reminding that other Members wish to speak and suggesting each Back Bencher should aim for five-minute speeches.
Rebecca Smith
Con
South West Devon
Ms. Rebecca Smith highlighted the challenges faced by family farms in her constituency, noting that farms are smaller and owned rather than tenanted compared to other areas. She raised concerns about agricultural property relief, environmental land management schemes impacting livestock numbers on Dartmoor, and the need for a working group on uplands. She called for flexibility in stocking rates and joined-up thinking among DEFRA and associated organisations.
Richard Foord
Lib Dem
Honiton and Sidmouth
Richard Foord highlighted the plight of farmers in mid and east Devon who are facing uncertainty due to inheritance tax changes. He cited a letter from a family farm near Cullompton, expressing their 150-year struggle to regain ownership only to face potential loss again. Foord also mentioned the Derryman family, emphasizing the hard work and contributions of farmers while questioning government figures on how many farms will be affected by the proposed tax changes.
Robbie Moore
Con
Keighley and Ilkley
Devon's family farmers, despite producing high-quality produce, face an average farm income £30,000 lower than the national average. The Conservative MP highlighted the importance of Government support for these farms but criticised recent changes such as delinking payments from the basic payment scheme and cutting capital grants, causing uncertainty and financial distress. Will the Minister correct me if I am wrong? When the Government introduced the £1 million cap, they did not look at the size of family farms that will be impacted. Surely they do not understand the value of an estate on death if they have not looked at the size of it, therefore how can they understand correctly the number of claimants who will be impacted?
Government Response
Daniel Zeichner
Government Response
Emphasised the government's commitment to a strong future for family farms by investing £5 billion into farming over two years, with £1.8 billion dedicated to environmental land management schemes. Addressed concerns about capital grants being oversubscribed due to high demand and explained measures taken regarding Dartmoor Land Use Management Group establishment, agricultural property relief changes affecting around 500 claims in 2026-27, double-cab pick-up tax based on a legal judgment by the courts, and work on developing a cattle vaccine for bovine tuberculosis eradication.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About Westminster Hall Debates
Westminster Hall debates are a chance for MPs to raise important issues affecting their constituents and get a response from a government minister. Unlike Prime Minister's Questions, these debates are more in-depth and collaborative. The MP who secured the debate speaks first, other MPs can contribute, and a minister responds with the government's position.