<-- Back to proposed bills

High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill

20 June 2022

Proposing MP
Aldridge-Brownhills
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, focusing on its importance for connecting key regions in the UK and improving rail capacity. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, addressing concerns about an underground station at Piccadilly and emphasizing the economic and environmental benefits of HS2. The statement addresses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, discussing its benefits and cost management. Wendy Morton discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and its implications for local communities and environmental considerations. Tan Dhesi criticizes the Conservative government's mismanagement of HS2 and rail services, highlighting budget cuts and service reductions. The statement discusses concerns over the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and calls for addressing issues such as community consultation, cost management, value for money, and environmental impacts. The statement discusses concerns regarding the High Speed Rail (HS2) project, particularly Phase 2b, and calls for a reassessment of its economic viability in light of changes due to the pandemic. The statement discusses the cancellation of the Golborne link in the HS2 project and its impact on Scotland's rail network. The statement discusses the cancellation of the Golborne link in Scotland as part of the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, highlighting concerns about devolution and legislative consent. Esther McVey rises to oppose the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, describing it as a costly and outdated project that no longer meets current needs. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and its potential impacts on Cheshire. The statement discusses concerns and support for High Speed Rail (HS2) project, particularly focusing on its impact on connectivity and economic development in Greater Manchester. The statement addresses political criticisms regarding the construction of Gateway House in Manchester. The MP discusses the closure of the Ashton-under-Lyne Metrolink line during HS2 construction and its negative impacts. The statement discusses the importance of the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill for enhancing railway capacity and supporting levelling up initiatives. The MP discusses the benefits of high-speed rail investment for Crewe, including job creation and improved connectivity. The statement discusses the importance of HS2 as a national priority for high-speed rail infrastructure investment. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and its importance for economic regeneration and infrastructure development in the UK. The MP discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, emphasizing its importance in improving connectivity and economic development in the north of England. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and its importance for levelling up and improving connectivity in Greater Manchester and the north-west. James Davies discusses the need for improved rail services along the North Wales Coast Main Line, emphasizing its importance for economic growth and connectivity with Northern Ireland and other parts of the UK. The MP expresses opposition to the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, questioning its necessity given the current state of railway usage and economic conditions. The MP is defending the HS2 high-speed rail project against criticisms that it is a waste of resources. Robert Largan defends the HS2 project, addressing myths about its necessity, cost, environmental impact, and benefits to local lines. The statement discusses the decision to scrap the Golborne spur of HS2, which affects James Grundy's constituency. The statement addresses the approval of a high-speed rail line from Crewe to Manchester without including a controversial Golborne spur in Wigan. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and its impact on Warrington and the broader North West region. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and expresses concerns over its current form, advocating for improvements in infrastructure, local transport links, and procurement practices. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill, addressing concerns about the project's financial cost, timeline, and environmental impact. The Minister is addressing concerns and providing updates on the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill. The statement addresses the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill and its recommendations for a surface station design over underground alternatives.

Action Requested

The speaker requests support for the Second Reading of the Bill, emphasizing its transformative impact on rail travel, economic growth, and levelling up efforts. She also highlights ongoing investments and environmental considerations.

Key Facts

  • The HS2 section from Crewe to Manchester will link Greater Manchester, the west midlands, and London.
  • It will halve journey times between Manchester and Birmingham and reduce the trip time from Manchester Piccadilly to London Euston to one hour and eleven minutes.
  • The integrated rail plan includes a £96 billion investment for Northern Powerhouse Rail.
  • 7 million new trees are planned in phase 1 of HS2, with a commitment to a 10% net gain in biodiversity for the Crewe-to-Manchester phase.
  • An underground station at Piccadilly would add around an additional £5 billion to the cost of the Crewe-to-Manchester scheme.
  • HS2 services between London and Glasgow are set to be available once the HS2 trains start running on to the conventional rail network.
  • The Government is considering alternatives within the £96 billion envelope for the integrated rail plan.
  • The HS2 train fleet will be designed and built by a Hitachi-Alstom joint venture located in Newton Aycliffe, Derby and Crewe.
  • HS2 is already supporting more than 26,000 jobs with many more expected from this Bill.
  • Pursuing the underground option at Piccadilly would result in a seven-year delay to HS2 reaching Manchester Piccadilly and an additional cost of around £5 billion compared to the surface station.
  • The Crewe North rolling stock depot will support the scheme’s operation.
  • HS2 Ltd has taken into account Cheshire's special environmental conditions, including salt extraction.
  • The Bill includes an additional stage for a specially appointed Select Committee to consider its private aspects.
  • The Golborne link section of the line runs from Hoo Green to the west coast main line south of Wigan.
  • Sir Peter Hendy’s Union connectivity review recommended reviewing alternative options for this section of the line.
  • HS2 Ltd is offering various methods of engagement including in-person events, webinars, a 24/7 helpline, and one-to-one appointments.
  • HS2, born under Labour government more than a decade ago, is becoming merely a ghost of its former self due to Tory mismanagement.
  • Department for Transport cuts amount to 10% on rail alone.
  • The cost of HS2 may rise to over £150 billion according to whistleblowers.
  • Cuts to Transport for the North's budget by 20%.
  • Labour is in favour of excellent alternative proposals from the Government regarding the Golborne link.
  • The Bill must deliver infrastructure for the north but could entrench the north-south divide.
  • The previous Labour Government invested billions of pounds in northern communities and rolling stock.
  • Labour wants to address rail capacity constraints on the west coast main line and reinvest any saved funding into local transport projects.
  • A future Labour Government will complete HS2 in full, including Northern Powerhouse Rail.
  • The Government has failed to revisit the economic case for HS2 post-pandemic.
  • The Phase 2b Bill will be subject to 20 substantive amendments, including removal of the Golborne link.
  • The proposed alternative railhead and maintenance base would save £650 million and create a levelling-up opportunity in north Staffordshire.
  • Golborne link is cancelled as part of the HS2 project.
  • Scottish Government supports HS2 on the basis of improved journey times and capacity.
  • Rail industry groups express disappointment over the cancellation, highlighting negative impacts on passengers and decarbonisation goals.
  • £3 billion extra funding is proposed for Scotland’s Parliament to spend on transport network improvements.
  • Wales will receive no consequential spending from HS2 despite its potential benefits.
  • The High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill was announced shortly before a confidence vote on the Prime Minister.
  • Scottish Ministers had already raised concerns about the Bill, which have gone unanswered.
  • Legislative consent from the Scottish Parliament is required for the Bill.
  • Since 2007, the Scottish Government has invested over £9 billion in rail infrastructure.
  • The Bill is highly contentious, especially for constituents in Tatton.
  • The original concept was developed by Lord Adonis in 2004.
  • Initial cost estimate was £37.5 billion, now up to £150 billion.
  • There are currently 1.3 million job vacancies in the UK.
  • The petition against HS2 saw 155,000 signatures.
  • More than 2,000 signatories were from Tatton constituency.
  • HS2 will damage five internationally protected wildlife sites, 639 local wildlife sites, 108 ancient woodlands and 33 legally protected scientific sites in Cheshire.
  • Only 1% of travellers will switch from planes to rail and only 4% from cars to rail.
  • The construction of HS2 alone will add 1.5 million tonnes of carbon to the atmosphere.
  • HS2 will free up slots on key parts of the current rail network.
  • The proposed Piccadilly station design would blight about half a million square metres of city centre land.
  • Business leaders in the Financial Times urge Ministers to revise the current design, which they call “hugely shortsighted.”
  • Revising the design could bring an additional £333 million per year in economic benefit.
  • Gateway House was built in the late 1960s.
  • Manchester City Council was Conservative-controlled for four years in the 1960s.
  • The Ashton-under-Lyne Metrolink line will be closed for at least two years during HS2 construction.
  • It connects communities from Ashton-under-Lyne to Piccadilly, serving over 60,000 people daily and linking to major venues like the Etihad stadium and Co-op Live arena.
  • The proposed shuttle service would operate between Ashton and New Islington with a depot at Ashton Moss estimated by TfGM to cost less than £200 million cited by the Minister.
  • The High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill is a significant milestone for HS2 in Parliament.
  • The project aims to increase railway capacity, not just speed up journeys from Manchester or Crewe to London.
  • It focuses on futureproofing the railways for decades to come.
  • Crewe has 7% of the rail workforce in England despite having just 0.1% of the population.
  • Alstom won a contract to build bogies for HS2.
  • A bid will be submitted for levelling up funding to transform car, pedestrian and cycle infrastructure around the station.
  • The economic case for large-scale high-speed rail investment is clear.
  • HS2 provides capacity benefits, reduces travel time, and aids in city regeneration.
  • Rail transport emits fewer carbon emissions per capita than other modes of transport.
  • There is a significant shortfall in the east midlands due to incomplete HS2 network proposals.
  • HS2 is seen as a once-in-a-century project.
  • Crossrail had its own teething problems but provided valuable lessons.
  • The Bill aligns with the Government's commitment to 'levelling up' the UK.
  • £96 billion investment in rail, described as biggest in UK history.
  • Connectivity issues between Warrington and Liverpool/Manchester highlighted.
  • HS2 will create job opportunities in Crewe but faces accessibility challenges for disabled individuals.
  • Concerns raised about the proposed underground through-station option for Manchester Piccadilly due to potential construction delays and costs.
  • MP supports Public Order Bill to prevent protests from hindering HS2 progress.
  • The project needs to be integrated into the network implemented by the Mayor of Greater Manchester.
  • There is a call for a new Metrolink station, Piccadilly Central, to be included.
  • HS2 between Crewe and Manchester aims to bring businesses, jobs, and prosperity to the region.
  • Poor regional rail services suppress economic growth and result in only 2% of commutes to northwest England being made by rail.
  • Signalling improvements, speed enhancements, infrastructure upgrades around Chester station, and electrification are required for the north Wales coast main line.
  • Sir Peter Hendy's Union Connectivity Review highlights links across the UK, including connections to Ireland and the continent.
  • The Crewe northern junction is important for sufficient connecting services to North Wales.
  • The MP encourages examining the possibility of upgrading the route via Warrington after the Golborne link decision.
  • The Bill extends high-speed rail further into more parts of the country.
  • The benefit-cost ratio was only 0.6:1.7 before recent cancellations.
  • Rail has lost a fifth of its passengers since the start of remote working options.
  • Villages and hamlets in Buckinghamshire have experienced severe disruption from HS2 construction, including road closures and farm damage.
  • The project is described as an important infrastructure initiative that will benefit the country in the long term.
  • Opposition Members are criticized for focusing on short-term interests over national priorities.
  • HS2 is primarily about improving rail capacity, not just reducing journey times.
  • HS2 opponents argue it is not necessary due to high-speed broadband.
  • The worst-case cost scenario for HS2 is about £5 billion per year.
  • Largan chairs the all-party group on mining and quarrying.
  • There are ongoing upgrades to the Hope Valley line in Largan's constituency costing £137 million.
  • The Golborne spur would have affected thousands of families and businesses in Lowton and Golborne.
  • It would have demolished the Enterprise Way industrial estate, costing hundreds of local jobs.
  • Byron wood and Lowton civic field—much-loved green spaces—would have been destroyed.
  • The high-speed rail line will go from Crewe to Manchester without including the Golborne spur.
  • Ted Thwaite, who passed away six months before the decision, was a long-time opponent of the Golborne spur.
  • Linda Graham's house was very close to the route and she fought against it despite political differences.
  • The campaign against the spur had cross-party support in Warrington but faced opposition from Wigan Council.
  • HS2 Golborne spur was opposed by local residents and borough council.
  • Government has put the HS2 Golborne spur on hold.
  • A family expecting to lose their house due to HS2 received assurance from the government regarding safeguarding measures review.
  • £42 million is being invested in Warrington for public transport improvements through buses.
  • The integrated rail plan will invest in trains in a way that has never happened before in the north of England.
  • The statement is about the High Speed Rail (Crewe - Manchester) Bill.
  • Only one UK-based firm has been shortlisted for £2.5 billion-worth of track and tunnel systems.
  • Labour wants more public contracts to go to British companies, including small construction businesses and national corporations.
  • The National Audit Office noted in 2020 that HS2 was over budget and behind schedule.
  • HS2 currently employs 26,000 people.
  • More than 6,000 responses were received during the environmental consultation of the Bill.
  • The delivery of the Crewe to Manchester section is scheduled for 2035 to 2041.
  • £10 million additional funding will be provided for the HS2 community and environment fund and business/local economy fund.
  • A four-platform overground station was proposed at Manchester Piccadilly in January 2013.
  • The Government commissioned a Bechtel report to consider the case for an underground station but concluded it remained more expensive.
  • In June 2020, HS2 was commissioned to investigate alternative station designs.
  • By September 2020, the scope of the study for a like-for-like comparison between surface and underground stations was agreed upon.
  • The study concluded in August 2021 and recommended proceeding with a surface station design.
  • A six-platform surface station at Piccadilly is intended to be confirmed by depositing the Bill in January.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy