<-- Back to proposed bills
Elections Bill
07 September 2021
Type
Bill Debate
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The statement discusses the Elections Bill, focusing on measures to ensure election security and integrity through new anti-fraud provisions. Chloe Smith is addressing concerns about voter ID requirements in the Elections Bill. The statement discusses measures within the Elections Bill aimed at combating electoral fraud and ensuring secure voting methods, while also addressing support for voters with disabilities. Chloe Smith addresses concerns about differences between Westminster's and other regions' electoral policies, particularly regarding EU nationals voting rights. The statement discusses updates to voting rights for EU citizens and proposes changes to electoral law enforcement and political finance. Rosie Winterton is urging for progress in the debate on the Elections Bill. Rosie Winterton discusses the Elections Bill and its impact on voter participation. Cat Smith debates the Elections Bill, arguing against the introduction of voter ID requirements. Rosie Winterton discusses concerns about the Elections Bill and its potential impact on voter disenfranchisement. David Davis discusses the issue of mandatory voter identification and its potential impact on democracy. Rosie Winterton is addressing concerns about the Elections Bill and its voter ID scheme. Rosie Winterton is addressing concerns about the Elections Bill, which she considers detrimental to democracy. William Wragg discusses the Elections Bill, highlighting its importance for protecting democracy and addressing issues related to voter identification. Rosie Winterton discusses the Elections Bill, focusing on clauses related to photo ID requirements for voting and joint campaigning by registered parties and third parties. The statement discusses issues related to election integrity, including personation, postal voting restrictions, and electoral expenses. The statement discusses concerns about the Elections Bill and its implications for voter participation and electoral integrity. The statement addresses concerns about the Elections Bill and its potential impact on voter participation. Maria Miller discusses the Elections Bill and highlights support for measures protecting candidates from intimidation and improving polling accessibility, while also calling for further consideration of election campaign lengths and candidate eligibility criteria. Clive Lewis critiques the Elections Bill for failing to address real issues in democracy and instead making it harder for people to vote through measures like voter ID requirements and restrictions on trade union campaigning. Steven Baker supports parts of the Elections Bill but calls for further measures to prevent electoral fraud. Martin Docherty raises concerns about the Elections Bill, specifically regarding voter identification requirements, assistance for excluded groups, and regulation of expenditure. The statement supports the Elections Bill which aims to strengthen UK election integrity by requiring photographic ID for voting at polling stations. Rosie Winterton is opposing the Elections Bill, arguing that it undermines democracy and disenfranchises voters. The MP discusses the potential impacts of clause 23 of the Elections Bill on democracy and political participation, arguing it gives too much power to the government. The statement discusses the Elections Bill and its implications on voter identification requirements. Alberto Costa welcomes the Government's proposals in the Elections Bill that enshrine voting rights for certain EU citizens in local elections in England and Northern Ireland, as well as police and crime commissioner elections. The statement addresses the debate on the Elections Bill regarding voter identification requirements. Rosie Winterton discusses concerns over the Elections Bill, focusing on voter ID proposals and their impact on democracy. The statement discusses concerns over the Elections Bill's impact on democracy and the Electoral Commission's independence. The MP discusses concerns over electoral fraud and its impact on democracy, focusing on postal voting systems. Aaron Bell discusses the need for electoral reforms to prevent voter fraud and ensure accurate voting procedures. The speaker discusses the need for voter identification to prevent electoral fraud and restore public confidence in the electoral system. The statement discusses concerns over the Elections Bill and its potential impact on democratic processes in the UK. MP Fleur Anderson is discussing concerns about the Elections Bill and its potential impact on voter disenfranchisement. The statement discusses the introduction of photo ID requirements for voting to prevent electoral fraud, referencing Northern Ireland's experience. Robin Walker is defending the Elections Bill and its measures to protect election integrity, drawing on experiences in Northern Ireland.
Action Requested
The speaker proposes updating electoral security measures to prevent voter fraud, emphasizing the need for these changes in light of past incidents like the Tower Hamlets scandal. The bill aims to introduce photo ID requirements among other steps to secure elections without impacting turnout negatively.
Key Facts
- £32 million additional funding was provided for election delivery during the pandemic.
- Over 5,000 volunteers were sourced to support electoral teams.
- The Tower Hamlets mayoral contest in 2014 was declared void due to corrupt and illegal practices.
- Schedule 1 of the Bill includes a widespread and broad-based list of identification types accepted for voting.
- The Bill includes proposals that were trialled in 2019 where 2,000 people were turned away due to lack of proper ID.
- Of the 2,000 turned away, 700 did not return to vote.
- 98% of people already hold identification that will be required by the scheme.
- The free local voter card is available for those without other acceptable forms of ID.
- Northern Ireland has a similar system in place.
- The Bill introduces new limits on postal votes and proxy voting.
- Stealing someone's vote through intimidation or deception is made an offence.
- Returning officers are required to support a wider range of voters with disabilities.
- The 15-year limit on voting rights for British citizens living abroad is removed.
- Parts of the devolution settlements apply to electoral policy.
- The Bill will look at measures applying UK-wide for parliamentary elections.
- The Liberal Democrats take two opposite positions regarding expatriate voting rights.
- Part 2 of the Bill updates voting rights for EU citizens who were resident before December 31, 2020.
- Local voting and candidacy rights will be granted on a reciprocal basis with individual EU member states for those moving to the UK after EU exit.
- The Bill introduces a strategy and policy statement for the Electoral Commission subject to parliamentary approval.
- Third-party spending is restricted to UK-based entities and registered overseas electors above a £700 threshold.
- Any change to the list of legal entities eligible to register as campaigners will be subject to affirmative procedure.
- The Minister has been speaking for 33 minutes.
- Many Members want to contribute to the debate.
- The Elections Bill is criticized for its potential to restrict voter participation.
- 3.5 million people do not have access to valid photo ID.
- Some groups, such as disabled, older, younger people, and those without financial means, are disproportionately affected by the photo ID requirements.
- The Elections Bill contains no details on how local authorities will roll out voter ID.
- Voter ID pilots were conducted in only 10 local authority areas in England, with only one area trialing the type of ID required by the Government.
- There have been four cases of voter impersonation fraud in the past 10 years from 243 million votes cast.
- Studies show voter ID requirements disproportionately affect voters from ethnic minority backgrounds.
- The Bill undermines the independence of the Electoral Commission, which is seen as political interference in election regulation.
- The legislation aims to strengthen an already Government-majority Speaker’s Committee on the Electoral Commission.
- Since 2014, there have been 30-odd allegations and three prosecutions for primary voter fraud in postal votes.
- No election outcomes have been influenced by the aforementioned cases of voter fraud.
- The Joint Committee on Human Rights has warned that introducing voter ID may have a discriminatory effect on protected groups.
- The voter ID scheme is described as an illiberal idea in pursuit of a non-existent problem.
- There is no evidence supporting the need for such radical policy changes.
- Winterton argues that the bill will disenfranchise millions and entrench more powers with the Executive.
- The Elections Bill is seen as a measure more appropriate for the Republican party than in the UK.
- There are between 2 million to 3 million people without necessary identification to vote.
- About 9 million people are not registered to vote.
- The Elections Bill is described as a curate’s egg of a bill.
- Pre-legislative scrutiny by a Speaker’s Commission could have helped iron out issues.
- There are concerns about the list of acceptable forms of ID in schedule 1.
- Clause 1 proposes requiring photo ID at polling stations.
- Clause 25 deals with joint campaigning by registered parties and third parties.
- 91-year-old constituent gave up driving license due to housebound status.
- Constituent with multiple disabilities has never had a passport or driving license.
- Clause 1 aims to address personation in elections.
- Clause 2 restricts perpetual postal voting rights to three years.
- A new offence is introduced for handling postal votes.
- There have been convictions related to postal vote farming.
- The speaker had a trial on election expenses legislation which led to the clarification of candidate authorisation requirements.
- The Bill introduces new barriers to democratic participation.
- There were only 33 cases of polling station irregularities in an election with over 32 million ballots cast in 2019.
- Electoral fraud data details three convictions for in-person personation since 2014.
- The Elections Bill aims to introduce voter ID requirements despite a lack of evidence for mass voter fraud.
- Concerns are raised that this policy could disenfranchise many voters and weaken election oversight.
- The speaker emphasizes the importance of encouraging wider participation in elections.
- The Elections Bill introduces a sanction to protect candidates from abuse in person or online.
- Two out of three women in the UK cited fear of abuse or harassment as a reason for not pursuing a career in politics.
- Miller supports extending tactile voting device requirements to broader accessibility measures.
- Election campaigns have been extended due to rewriting laws to include bank holidays and weekends.
- The Elections Bill is criticized for not addressing issues like the first-past-the-post electoral system, lack of public access to a constitution, or underrepresentation in the House of Lords.
- About 2.1 million people could be excluded from voting due to lack of recognisable photo ID.
- There were only 34 allegations of impersonation out of 58 million votes cast during the 2019 general election.
- Baker welcomes provisions in the Bill related to postal votes, proxy votes, voter ID, and undue influence.
- He cites examples of misuse of postal votes and foreign nationals voting unintentionally.
- Baker advocates for a digital fingerprint technique to ensure unique voting without a national database.
- The MP suggests protecting those making objections to electoral roll entries from intimidation.
- Martin Docherty is addressing the Minister for the Constitution and Devolution about concerns with the Elections Bill.
- The bill introduces voter identification requirements which Martin Docherty believes duplicates existing ID numbers.
- He highlights the difficulties faced by the Gypsy, Traveller, and Roma community in obtaining specific local authority IDs.
- He mentions the need to regulate unincorporated associations that may be used to fund political organizations and undermine democracy.
- The Bill requires voters to show an approved form of photographic identification at polling stations.
- A proposed voter card will be available from local authorities free of charge.
- Postal vote handling by party campaigners is banned under the Bill.
- Electoral sanctions are introduced to protect campaigners and elected officials from intimidatory or abusive behaviour both in person and online.
- The Bill is seen as an affront to democracy.
- A coalition of 19 Welsh organisations released a joint statement on voter ID proposals.
- The Welsh Government are allowing 16 and 17-year-olds to vote for the first time in Senedd elections.
- Clause 23 hands Ministers power to create conditions or remove certain bodies from participating in the electoral process.
- The spending limit for non-party campaigners is lowered to £700, effectively disqualifying many groups.
- There was a court case overturned due to postal vote harvesting and personation in Tower Hamlets.
- Voter ID laws are described as successful and implemented by a Labour Government.
- The Electoral Commission suggested 3.5 million people could be affected, but this number is now outdated.
- 99% of ethnic minority people have identification allowing them to vote under the Bill.
- At least 2.1 million people without photo ID may miss their chance to vote according to the Electoral Reform Society.
- The Bill aims to enshrine voting rights for EU citizens in England, Northern Ireland, and Wales.
- Bilateral agreements have been made with Spain, Portugal, Luxembourg, and Poland for mutual voting rights.
- Costa met the secretary-general of the Greek Ministry of Foreign Affairs to discuss potential bilateral agreements.
- The Government's proposals for voter identification seek to solve a problem which they have failed to demonstrate exists.
- In the pilot carried out by the Government in 2019, of the 2,000 people who were turned away from polling stations, 700 did not return.
- The Electoral Commission said that two thirds of voters would have more confidence in voting system security if there was a requirement to show voter ID.
- The introduction of photographic voter ID will cost taxpayers £120 million over 10 years.
- According to Cabinet Office figures, 42% of people without photo ID would not apply for a voter ID card.
- There was just one conviction for personation out of more than 59 million votes cast in the 2019 election.
- The Bill is seen as a threat to the independence and accountability of the Electoral Commission.
- The Speaker’s Committee on the Electoral Commission now has a majority of MPs from the governing party.
- Joanna Cherry asks for an update on how many out of the 47 recommendations by the Committee on Standards in Public Life will be accepted.
- Keighley constituency is deemed at high risk of electoral fraud.
- One in five reports of electoral fraud come from West Yorkshire.
- Changes include shortening the time someone can register to vote by post, prohibiting political campaigners from handling postal votes, and limiting proxy voting.
- In 2017, approximately 1,000 people in Newcastle-under-Lyme were disenfranchised during the general election due to incompetence.
- A constituent felt insulted by administrative failure and wrote to the council chief executive about it.
- The Bill ensures that individuals vote once without duress or fraud.
- Free ID will be provided for all voters.
- The constituency has seen proven electoral fraud with local politicians convicted of offences.
- Postal vote rates in certain wards exceed the national average significantly.
- Council installed CCTV cameras at polling stations due to concerns about personation.
- In 2008, three Peterborough Labour candidates were convicted for electoral fraud involving postal ballots.
- The Elections Bill is estimated to cost £120 million over the next 10 years.
- More than 1,000 people were denied votes in pilot schemes due to lack of ID.
- There are just three cases of voter fraud under investigation out of numerous local by-elections held between January and March 2020.
- The Bill is seen as making voting more difficult for marginalized groups.
- Civil rights groups like the American Civil Liberties Union warn UK Government policies will harm democracy.
- Age UK warns that compulsory photo ID could make 4% of over-70s less likely to vote, equivalent to 360,000 people.
- Labour Ministers supported the measure at its introduction, stating it would prevent electoral abuse without disadvantaging honest voters.
- Satisfaction levels with the electoral process are slightly higher in Northern Ireland than elsewhere in the UK.
- The Electoral Commission reported that 83% of voters in Northern Ireland found it very easy to participate in elections in 2019.
- The Bill includes a new requirement for political parties to declare assets and liabilities over £500.
- 98% of people across age groups have access to accepted forms of photographic ID.
- Devolution means different election arrangements exist for devolved and reserved elections.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy