<-- Back to proposed bills

Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill [Lords]

24 November 2020

Proposing MP
Cheltenham
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement addresses the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill and its amendments, emphasizing the importance of private international law agreements in resolving cross-border legal disputes. The statement discusses the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill and its amendments focusing on criminal offences and a sunset clause. The statement discusses the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill and addresses concerns about parliamentary scrutiny and consultation requirements for extending the power of the legislation. Alex Chalk discusses the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill and its importance in a post-Brexit context for resolving international disputes. The statement discusses the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill and its provisions for incorporating international conventions into domestic law. The MP discusses opposition to clause 2 of the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill, which grants broad powers for delegated legislation. The statement discusses the support for the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill [Lords] and its importance amidst Brexit. The statement discusses the challenges and risks associated with the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill in the context of Brexit. The statement discusses the Private International Law (Implementation of Agreements) Bill and its amendments, highlighting its importance in implementing international agreements like the Hague conventions and the Singapore mediation convention.

Action Requested

Alex Chalk proposes accepting Lords amendments 1A and 1B, and confirms the government's intention to join the Lugano convention as soon as possible to ensure there are no gaps post-Brexit implementation period. The Bill aims to facilitate smoother resolution of international disputes for both individuals and businesses.

Key Facts

  • Private International Law (PIL) includes rules on jurisdiction, applicable law, recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments, and co-operation between courts.
  • PIL agreements help resolve cross-border legal disputes more efficiently and reduce costs.
  • The Government aims to join the Lugano convention without any gap post-Brexit implementation period.
  • The Bill contains two substantive clauses related to implementing Hague conventions and future PIL agreements via secondary legislation.
  • Lords amendment 4A limits the power so that it cannot create criminal offences punishable by prison sentence, but allows for lesser offences like updating address information for maintenance decisions.
  • Amendments include a five-year sunset period with extendable reviews through affirmative statutory instruments.
  • The Bill can be extended more than once, but requires parliamentary approval.
  • The Singapore convention on mediation is mentioned as a future implementation target.
  • Consultation requirements are added for making regulations under the Bill.
  • Labour supported the principle of the Bill.
  • Clause 1 gives effect to international treaties in domestic law through primary legislation.
  • Clause 2 was reinstated by the Government despite opposition.
  • Clause 1 gives effect to key international conventions in domestic law.
  • Clause 2 allows for future agreements to be implemented via secondary legislation, which Labour opposes due to constitutional concerns.
  • The House of Lords Constitution Committee and the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee both oppose clause 2.
  • Labour remains disappointed that clause 2 has been reintroduced.
  • Clause 2 grants extensive future law-making powers to the Executive.
  • Amendments include a five-year sunset clause for clause 2.
  • Private international law is crucial for business contracts, litigation after accidents abroad, family matters involving child abduction and alimony enforcement.
  • Lugano and Hague are fundamental international agreements affecting many in the UK.
  • The bill comes as a result of Brexit with approaching deadlines for legal agreements.
  • The Bill involves parliamentary scrutiny of orders made pursuant to private international law treaties.
  • A compromise has been reached regarding order-making powers after initial proposals faced significant opposition.
  • The Minister introduced a five-year sunset clause for the orders, albeit renewable.
  • The Bill allows for the seamless re-implementation of three Hague conventions (1996, 2005, 2007) and the timely implementation of the 2007 Lugano convention.
  • Consultations will take place before extending powers or implementing any agreement, ensuring transparency and a thorough explanation to Parliament.
  • The Bill aims to reduce differences in treatment for British citizens in different parts of the world.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy