<-- Back to proposed bills

Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill

04 November 2020

Proposing MP
Epping Forest
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

Eleanor Laing discusses Lords amendment 4B regarding family reunion and unaccompanied asylum-seeking children, noting its engagement of financial privilege. The statement addresses the need for a review of immigration rules as part of the government's broader migration system changes following EU withdrawal. MP Holly Lynch is discussing the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill and specifically Lords amendment 4B regarding family reunion for unaccompanied child refugees. MP Tim Loughton is speaking in support of a Lords amendment regarding the replacement for the Dublin family reunion scheme, which allows vulnerable unaccompanied children to reunite with family members. The statement discusses the impact of the loss of Dublin regulation rights for family reunification and the need for safe legal routes for immigration. The statement addresses the debate on Lords amendment regarding child refugees, specifically discussing the current rules that do not provide sufficient support for children and teenagers seeking to rejoin family members in the UK. The statement addresses issues related to the safety and legality of routes for asylum seekers entering the UK. The MPs discuss the importance of maintaining safe and legal routes for refugees to enter the UK, addressing concerns about family reunions and protection for vulnerable individuals. The statement discusses the UK's approach to immigration and resettlement policies post-Brexit, focusing on the need for a global migration system rather than a two-tier system.

Action Requested

Laing states that if Lords amendment 4B is agreed to, she will cause the customary entry waiving Commons financial privilege to be entered in the Journal. She also mentions that consideration of the message from the House of Lords is happening forthwith as per a Programme Order on October 19.

Key Facts

  • Lords amendment 4B relates to family reunion and unaccompanied asylum-seeking children.
  • The Government plans to bring forward legislation next year to reform their broken asylum system.
  • Since 2010, the UK has granted protection and other leave to more than 44,000 children seeking protection.
  • The current rules apply alongside Dublin for EU members.
  • A review of the migration system is part of a general stock-take.
  • Key elements of the Government’s future border and immigration system include skilled workers routes and social security co-ordination.
  • Further delay would put at risk ending free movement by the end of the transition period.
  • The Dublin regulations will end in December 2020.
  • Between 2016 and 2018, an average of 547 people annually used family reunions under the Dublin III provisions to come to the UK.
  • Safe Passage has pledged more than 1,400 places for unaccompanied child refugees in Europe.
  • The Greek Government has been appealing for international help since last October.
  • The Lords amendment was defeated in the House by 320 votes to 242.
  • Lord Dubs has been leading the charge on this issue.
  • The Government's proposed amendment commits to reviewing safe and legal routes without providing a specific timeline or details for replacement schemes.
  • A young teenage boy from Greek islands would struggle under rule 319X due to strict evidential requirements and financial barriers.
  • Some 7,400 refugees have been issued family reunion visas in the year ending March 2020 but only from outside the EU.
  • More than 30 councils across the country have offered places to over 1,400 refugees.
  • Bilateral agreements replacing Dublin features are months or years away.
  • There is no prospect of a negotiated settlement with the EU by the end of December.
  • The domestic immigration rules for family reunion are more restricted compared to Dublin.
  • The Government's proposed review will look at safe and legal routes to sanctuary but it is not an immediate alternative to the Lords amendment.
  • A 14-year-old boy in Paris has absconded due to fears of changing rules, risking dangerous journeys with smugglers or traffickers.
  • From 2015, there was a doubling of unaccompanied children and young people coming into UK care under the Children Act 1989.
  • Rasoul Iran-Nejad, Shiva Mohammad Panahi, their daughter Anita (8), son Armin (6), and baby Artin (15 months) lost their lives attempting to cross the English channel.
  • Since 1999, 292 people have died crossing the channel to the UK with numbers increasing since 2013.
  • The Home Secretary was reportedly considering ideas like obstacles in the channel and offshore migrant centres on Ascension Island.
  • Tim Farron criticises the overreaction to refugee numbers and emphasises the importance of safe routes.
  • Jim Shannon expresses concerns about long-term detention of mentally ill people highlighted by cases ASK and MDA in 2019.
  • Shannon mentions the need for protection for at-risk adults and families, including children who have lost parents.
  • Local authorities are already caring for over 5,000 unaccompanied asylum-seeking children—146% more than in 2014.
  • The government will look to negotiate with individual European Union countries if a reciprocal agreement cannot be reached with the EU as a whole.
  • Government amendments (a) to (c) were made in lieu of Lords amendment 4B.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy