<-- Back to proposed bills
Fisheries Bill [Lords]
01 September 2020
Type
Bill Debate
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The Fisheries Bill aims to give the UK control over its waters and fisheries policy following EU exit, addressing issues like unfair quota allocation under the Common Fisheries Policy. The Fisheries Bill aims to provide powers for managing UK fisheries independently from EU policies, focusing on sustainability and addressing historical injustices. Nigel Evans sets a time limit for contributions during the debate on the Fisheries Bill. Luke Pollard discusses the Fisheries Bill, emphasizing the importance of sustainable fishing practices and support for fishers affected by the pandemic. The MP discusses the Fisheries Bill, focusing on job creation in coastal communities and sustainable fishing practices. Luke Pollard discusses safety at sea for fishermen, quota allocations under zonal attachment, and calls for government action to support British fisheries. Neil Parish supports the Fisheries Bill, which aims to give the UK independent control over its fishing policy after leaving the EU. Deidre Brock moves to decline Second Reading of the Fisheries Bill [Lords], arguing it fails to secure a long-term sustainable future for the fishing industry. Deidre Brock discusses concerns about the Fisheries Bill's impact on devolved powers in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. The discussion focuses on concerns regarding the Fisheries Bill and its impact on UK fisheries post-Brexit. The statement discusses the Fisheries Bill and its importance for the UK fishing industry post-Brexit, emphasizing safety, sustainability, fair distribution of quota, and support for fishing ports. Robert Goodwill discusses the UK's departure from the EU and its impact on fisheries, highlighting the opportunities for UK fishermen post-Brexit. The statement discusses concerns about the Fisheries Bill and its impact on smaller UK fishing fleets, emphasizing environmental protections and fairer distribution of fishing quotas. The statement addresses the challenges faced by coastal communities and the fishing industry in the UK due to political decisions and policies like the Common Fisheries Policy. The MP discusses the Fisheries Bill's impact on coastal communities and fishery management. The speaker discusses the Fisheries Bill and criticizes the SNP's stance on the legislation. MP Alistair Carmichael discusses the Fisheries Bill, addressing its importance and the need for consensus across Parliament. The MP discusses the threats facing UK fisheries, including overfishing, climate change, human rights abuses, and the need for sustainability in fishing practices. The statement discusses the Fisheries Bill's objectives and its impact on coastal communities in North West Norfolk, highlighting concerns about changes to fishing regulations and the need for sustainable practices. Plaid Cymru is critiquing the Fisheries Bill [Lords] for failing to support Welsh fishing communities adequately. Andrew Bowie discusses the impact of the Common Fisheries Policy on Scottish fishing communities and supports the Fisheries Bill. The statement discusses the Fisheries Bill and its potential impact on coastal communities and the fishing industry. The speaker supports the Fisheries Bill and discusses its importance for rebuilding fishing fleets and supporting coastal communities. The MP discusses the Fisheries Bill, focusing on opportunities for sustainable fisheries management post-Brexit and the importance of local control. Nigel Evans discusses the Fisheries Bill and its importance in re-establishing UK control over fishing waters post-Brexit. The speaker discusses the Fisheries Bill and its implications for UK fisheries, emphasizing the need to rebuild trust with fishing communities and address concerns about sustainable practices. The MP is supporting the Fisheries Bill which aims to give the UK control over its fishing waters and improve sustainability. The statement discusses the Fisheries Bill's impact on UK fisheries, focusing on repatriation of control over territorial waters, exclusive zones for UK fishing vessels, sustainable practices by small-scale fisheries, and quota fairness. Nicholas Fletcher discusses the Fisheries Bill, highlighting its importance in restoring UK's control over fisheries and protecting British fish stocks. MP Chris Loder speaks in support of the Fisheries Bill, which aims to remove automatic fishing rights for foreign vessels and supertrawlers from UK waters. The MP discusses issues related to the Fisheries Bill and its impact on the Lowestoft and East Anglian fishing industry, emphasizing the need for investment in infrastructure and sustainable practices. Nigel Evans discusses the Fisheries Bill, focusing on its impact on Leigh-on-Sea fishermen and advocating for changes to support smaller vessels. The statement discusses issues related to the Fisheries Bill, focusing on the impact of fishing policies on coastal communities, sustainability of marine resources, and the need for fairness in quota distribution. The speaker closes the debate on the Fisheries Bill and discusses its importance and progress. The statement discusses the progress and voting on the Fisheries Bill [Lords] in the UK Parliament.
Action Requested
The Bill proposes granting powers for the UK to manage access to its exclusive economic zone, set fishing quotas based on scientific evidence, implement environmental measures, and exclude foreign vessels as necessary. It also sets out principles and objectives for future fisheries management plans.
Key Facts
- The seafood sector employs about 33,000 people across the UK.
- The UK fleet receives just 10% of the overall quota for Celtic sea haddock but should receive around 50% based on zonal attachment analysis.
- The Bill provides powers to exclude foreign super-trawlers through licence conditions.
- The Bill includes clauses ending automatic access to UK waters for EU vessels.
- Clauses propose powers to introduce technical measures for fisheries and aquatic animal health.
- Grant payments will be made available to fishermen to invest in gear that enables more selective fishing.
- Six-minute contribution limit for non-Front-Bench MPs.
- The time limit may be reduced further during the debate.
- Fishing matters greatly to Plymouth with 1,000 jobs in the city.
- Recreational fishing is larger than commercial fishing in GDP terms.
- UK imports two thirds and exports two thirds of fish trade.
- The Bill is described as a framework that centralizes powers with the Secretary of State.
- Labour’s jobs in coastal communities amendment proposes a new national landing requirement where two-thirds of fish caught under UK quota must be landed in UK ports, potentially creating more jobs.
- Small boat fleets have 6% of quota but provide two-thirds of jobs; reallocation of even 1-2% of total catch could increase what small boats can catch by 25%.
- Progress is being made towards making fishing safer but much work still needs to be done.
- Fishers should wear lifejackets with personal locator beacons standard.
- Remote vessel monitoring and CCTV will help ensure compliance with the law.
- Foreign boats in UK waters should adhere to the same safety standards as UK boats.
- Labour proposes a phased draw-down period for quota reallocation rather than rushing it.
- Not all British fishers fish in British waters, preserving access to distant waters is necessary.
- The new fisheries agreement was meant to be concluded by 1 July but is two months late.
- The Fisheries Bill will give Ministers and devolved Administrations power over fishing policy after more than 45 years of EU control.
- In 2015, EU vessels caught 683,000 tonnes in UK waters compared to only 111,000 tonnes by UK vessels in EU member states’ waters.
- About 70% of fish and 85% of shellfish caught in the UK is exported to EU countries, but the same amount is imported from non-EU sources.
- The Fisheries Bill comes from the unelected House of Lords.
- Lord Hain stated that no EU agreement by the end of 2020 means UNCLOS governs access to UK waters.
- Historical access for foreign fleets will be part of the new framework post-Brexit.
- The Bill does not provide a genuine framework.
- There are major concerns about how quotas will be divided among four nations.
- The UK Government will act as both poacher and gamekeeper in fisheries decisions.
- Sheryll Murray has 25 years of experience in fishing.
- The Bill aims to ensure sustainable management of UK waters for future generations.
- Clause 18 on national landing requirement must be removed to avoid denying the industry economic benefits.
- Remote electronic monitoring is not required if a flexible and adaptive fisheries management plan can be designed collaboratively.
- Merchant Navy Day is being observed.
- The Gaul sank on February 8 and 9, 1974 with a loss of 36 lives, described as the worst single-trawler tragedy.
- Six men from North Tyneside were among those lost in the Gaul tragedy.
- Under-10-metre boats currently receive around 6% of quota.
- For every job in the catching sector, there are approximately nine jobs on land.
- The protection jetty at North Shields is being repaired using European fisheries fund money.
- Fishing communities need investment for repair and regeneration.
- Nye Bevan famously stated, 'This island is made mainly of coal and surrounded by fish.'
- The UK's departure from the EU will create opportunities for UK fishermen.
- No one could argue against the benefits of Brexit for fishermen, according to Goodwill.
- Ted Heath's decision to join the European Union was influenced by British fishing interests in Icelandic waters at the time.
- Fish stocks do not respect 200-mile exclusive economic zones and need sustainable catch agreements between the UK and EU.
- The Bill underpins the sustainability of UK seas.
- Seven years ago, campaigners called for redistribution of UK fishing quotas to support smaller fleets.
- Four major quota holders are owned by families listed on The Sunday Times rich list.
- Foreign-owned companies control 50% of the English fishing quota.
- Six fishers lost their lives in fishing accidents last year.
- Coastal communities need investment, regeneration, and better transport links.
- Smaller vessels are often family-run firms vital to UK fishing industry.
- Fishers feel abandoned by successive Governments due to prioritization of big commercial producers.
- 80% of fish is usually exported, but the COVID-19 crisis disrupted exports.
- Kent's Operation Lorry Park scheme may threaten fresh seafood supply.
- The Marine Conservation Society supports Labour’s sustainability amendments.
- UK currently fails 11 out of 15 indicators under the marine strategy.
- Fisheries Bill facilitates local fisheries management.
- North Cornwall coast has unique stock conditions different from other parts of the UK.
- The Bill opposes electronic pulse fishing methods.
- Marine protected areas will support seagrasses for carbon reduction goals.
- The Scottish Fishermen’s Federation believes the Fisheries Bill offers a once-in-a-generation chance for UK fishermen.
- Fergus Ewing, the SNP Minister, recommends legislative consent in the Scottish Parliament but SNP Members oppose the Bill's Second Reading.
- The speaker advocates that voting against the Bill would hinder Scottish fishermen and coastal communities.
- This is the sixth Parliament with a fisheries Bill.
- The Scottish nationalists have tabled a reasoned amendment, which is regrettable.
- The fishing industry would benefit from proper visa policies for non-EEA nationals.
- There are concerns about safety incidents involving foreign vessels threatening UK boats.
- Gill-netters contribute significantly to plastic pollution in the seas.
- Overfishing quotas are set above scientifically recommended sustainable levels.
- Restoring fish populations would lead to £244 million a year for the industry and create more than 5,000 jobs.
- Less than 1% of journeys conducted by UK fishing fleets are monitored.
- Supertrawlers spent nearly 3,000 hours fishing in UK marine protected areas in 2019.
- In the first six months of this year, supertrawler operations had reached 5,590 hours.
- Taking back control of UK waters was a reason for supporting Brexit.
- Amendments passed in the Lords change the fisheries objectives in clause 1.
- The National Federation of Fishermen’s Organisations warned that these amendments could create a more rigid system worse than the CFP.
- Local firms like Lynn Shellfish and John Lake Shellfish operate with about 70 vessels along the coast, contributing to the local economy.
- There are concerns over regulatory plans for a new shrimp permit by-law without recognition of historical track records.
- The Wash fishery order expires in 2022 and there are no plans for extension.
- Powers exist within the Bill to license foreign vessels in UK waters and tackle supertrawlers.
- An apprenticeship scheme is proposed to replenish retiring fishermen over five to ten years.
- Only 9% of the fish and shellfish caught in Welsh waters are landed by Welsh vessels.
- Under-10 metre vessels make up around 95% of the Welsh fishing fleet.
- The Bill fails to address the variability of catches due to climate change.
- The size of the Scottish fishing fleet has declined from 800 to 400 boats between 1992 and 2004.
- EU vessels fish six times more in UK waters than UK vessels fish in EU waters.
- The Fisheries Bill establishes UK-wide fisheries objectives and a joint fisheries statement setting out policies to achieve these objectives.
- Fleetwood voted to leave the European Union hoping for a revival of the fishing industry.
- The “jobs in coastal communities” clause passed in the Lords mandates that two thirds of UK-caught fish be landed in UK ports, creating up to 76 jobs with every £1 million of fish landed.
- Greenpeace revealed that supertrawlers spent 5,500 hours fishing in protected marine areas this year.
- Fishers in under-10 metre boats represent 79% of the fleet but hold only 2% of the quota.
- Brixham is the most valuable port in England.
- There has been a 29% decline in the fleet since 1996 and a 60% decline in fish landed in the UK since 1973.
- The Government supports fishermen through various funds such as the seafood innovation fund, maritime and fisheries fund, covid fisheries fund, fisheries response fund, and domestic seafood supply scheme.
- The Fisheries Bill aims to create a sustainable future for UK fisheries post-Brexit.
- Local fishing industries, such as those in Northern Ireland and Wales, are highlighted for their unique characteristics.
- The Bill grants equal access for all UK vessels to fish throughout UK waters.
- The Fisheries Bill is the first of its kind since 1973.
- It aims to prevent over-fishing by relinquishing the EU common fisheries policy.
- Enforcement may require actions like fines, impounding assets, or even military intervention.
- Concerns are raised about managing British waters around overseas territories such as Gibraltar and Cyprus.
- Super trawlers spent nearly 3,000 hours fishing in UK MPAs in 2019.
- Greenpeace reported that super trawlers increased their fishing in UK MPAs during the covid-19 lockdown.
- The Bill lacks detail on banning industrial super trawlers from UK MPAs and supporting greener technologies.
- The Fisheries Bill is crucial for Scotland with 62% of UK waters and 64% of UK catch being in Scottish hands.
- Constituents in Angus primarily fish for crab and lobster using creels, unencumbered by foreign boats or quotas.
- Scotland receives €108 million from the European maritime and fisheries fund.
- The area within the UK’s 12-mile limit should be an exclusive zone limited to UK fishing vessels only.
- Small boats have less impact on the marine ecosystem compared to large boats.
- Quotas need to ensure fair opportunities for those who actually fish.
- The Fisheries Bill will restore UK's position as an independent coastal state.
- The bill aims to end automatic access of EU vessels to British waters.
- It will protect biodiversity in some of the richest seas globally.
- There are concerns about foreign trawlers overfishing British waters.
- 12,000 fishermen play a vital role in UK food supply chains.
- The EU common fisheries policy has constrained UK fishermen for 40 years.
- The number of working fishermen in the UK fell by 40% since the mid-1990s.
- The Margiris, a supertrawler capable of catching 250 tonnes of fish a day, was trawling UK waters.
- More than 92% of Scottish fishermen believe leaving the EU and the common fisheries policy is beneficial.
- Northern Ireland has called for remote electronic monitoring to address concerns over non-UK flagged vessels landing in foreign ports.
- The Fisheries Bill aims to revive the Lowestoft and East Anglian fishing industry.
- No East Anglian representative is on the project board for the inshore fisheries project.
- A workshop for low-impact vessels has not yet taken place in the region.
- Powerful companies may resist changes, but the status quo must be unacceptable post-Brexit.
- The Blue Marine Foundation calls for reform of the current fixed-quota allocation system.
- The Government are consulting on the distribution of additional quota before 1 January.
- Leigh-on-Sea fishermen have been waiting for real benefits from leaving the EU.
- Small under-10-metre vessels have been badly treated for too long.
- Councillor Paul Gilson believes a management team for each fishery area would be valuable.
- Illegal harvesting of shellfish has caused issues in Southend’s coastline.
- More independent scientific surveys are needed to improve sustainability.
- The quota system needs reforming to rectify previous inequalities.
- Local fishermen have successfully promoted local fish through social media and advertising during the pandemic.
- Fishing is worth between £6 billion and £8 billion.
- The UK will become an independent coastal state from 2021.
- Labour Members aim to land more UK fish caught in UK waters in UK ports.
- Small fishers represent 79% of the UK fishing fleet but hold only 2% of the quota.
- Commercial fishing is the most dangerous peacetime occupation in the UK.
- The Fisheries Bill is a framework Bill providing powers regardless of negotiation outcomes.
- It includes collaboration with devolved Administrations, giving them more management powers than ever before.
- Funding for fisheries across the UK’s nations will be maintained throughout Parliament as per manifesto commitment.
- New domestic funding schemes allow for port development and training.
- Tourism in coastal communities has been supported over the summer.
- The House divided with Ayes 49, Noes 326.
- Question agreed to for the Bill being read a Second time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy