<-- Back to proposed bills

Trade Bill

20 July 2020

Proposing MP
Chelsea and Fulham
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement discusses a new clause that would allow named public authorities to share information for facilitating trade-related functions of Ministers. The statement discusses new clauses and amendments to the Trade Bill aimed at enhancing transparency, accountability, and safeguards in international trade agreements. Greg Hands is addressing the Trade Bill, focusing on new clause 5 and its aim to ensure data usage for trade continuity and border management. The Minister is addressing concerns about continuity agreements, particularly highlighting differences with Japan and commitments to enhanced scrutiny processes. Greg Hands is addressing concerns about parliamentary scrutiny of new trade agreements and defending the government's approach to transparency and oversight. Greg Hands discusses the Government's stance on transparency in trade agreements and the potential implications of proposed new clauses regarding parliamentary scrutiny and vetoes. Bill Esterson discusses amendments to the Trade Bill regarding social, environmental, and democratic concerns. The speaker discusses the importance of parliamentary scrutiny in international trade agreements and criticizes the current system for lacking adequate engagement with stakeholders such as trade unions. Bill Esterson discusses the threats posed by Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) and other clauses in international trade agreements that could undermine public services like the NHS. He also highlights concerns about the impact of such agreements on UK farmers. Stewart Hosie is addressing flaws in the Trade Bill and advocating for amendments to ensure devolved consent, protection of NHS, preservation of food standards, and parliamentary scrutiny. Stewart Hosie discusses the importance of maintaining high food standards and protecting healthcare services in trade agreements. The MP discusses concerns over the Trade Bill's potential impact on food standards and environmental regulations, urging the government to maintain existing bans on imported products that do not meet UK standards. Robert Courts is discussing new clause 11 of the Trade Bill, which would prohibit importing agricultural goods unless they meet UK production standards. Caroline Lucas is addressing new clause 9 of the Trade Bill, which aims to ensure UK trade agreements align with climate and environmental goals. The statement discusses the UK's approach to trade deals, particularly focusing on the import ban of chlorinated chicken and the importance of traceability in the food supply chain. The statement discusses the Trade Bill and its implications for Welsh exports and trade relationships, particularly with the European Union. The MP addresses concerns about the Trade Bill and reassures constituents that existing food standards will be maintained. The speaker discusses the importance of parliamentary scrutiny in the development of independent UK trade policy post-Brexit. The statement discusses the scrutiny and approval process for trade deals under the Trade Bill, emphasizing the need for Parliament to have more say before FTAs are signed. The statement discusses the Trade Bill and its importance for protecting UK industries such as agrifood and agriculture, while also addressing the need for checks and balances to prevent executive overreach. MP Neil Parish discusses the importance of agriculture and fisheries in UK trade deals and welcomes the establishment of the trade and agriculture commission. The statement discusses concerns about the Trade Bill, particularly regarding parliamentary scrutiny and protections for food standards, NHS, workers' rights, and environmental safeguards. The MP is addressing concerns about the potential impact of the Trade Bill on the NHS and public health data. The MP discusses the importance of protecting British farming standards in future trade agreements. Greg Hands discusses the Trade Bill, focusing on continuity trade agreements and food standards. The statement discusses concerns about protecting the NHS from international competition, safeguarding environmental and food safety standards in trade deals, and ensuring proper scrutiny of future trade agreements. The MP discusses concerns over the Trade Bill's potential impact on food safety, environmental standards, car safety, NHS protection, and parliamentary oversight. The MP discusses the Trade Bill's impact on trade and food standards, highlighting new clauses 5 and 6 as important for balancing efficient trade with protection of constituents' interests. Greg Hands addresses the Trade Bill, emphasizing its role in maintaining continuity with EU trade agreements and establishing a Trade Remedies Authority. MP Bill Esterson proposes amendments to ensure imported agricultural goods meet UK standards and protect public health services from international trade agreements. Greg Hands is addressing amendments to the Trade Bill regarding information sharing and data protection.

Action Requested

Greg Hands is moving for the clause to be read a second time, allowing specified public authorities to disclose information for the purpose of supporting trade-related ministerial functions.

Key Facts

  • The new clause specifies that certain public authorities can disclose information to assist in trade-related functions.
  • The clause lists the Secretary of State, the Minister for the Cabinet Office, strategic highways companies, and port health authorities as specified public authorities.
  • A person receiving information under this clause may only use it for facilitating trade-related public authority functions and must obtain consent from the disclosing authority to further disclose the information.
  • New clause 1 requires a Minister to lay a report before Parliament before the UK ratifies a new free trade agreement.
  • New clause 8 would ensure that HMG has a duty to restrict market access to healthcare services, including medicines and medical devices.
  • New clause 9 aligns the UK’s trade policy with its climate and environmental agenda.
  • Government has concluded 20 continuity agreements with 48 countries, accounting for £110 billion of UK trade in 2018.
  • These agreements represent 74% of the trade with countries where continuity was sought before the withdrawal agreement.
  • The government aims to have a world-leading border by 2050.
  • The Government has published 20 reports, five of which have been debated in the other place without any motion of regret.
  • CRAG allows Parliament to block trade deals through debates and votes.
  • The Japan agreement will be an enhanced free trade agreement based on the EU's existing agreement with Japan.
  • The Government has committed to laying final impact assessments once trade negotiations have concluded.
  • The Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 provides rigorous checks on government powers for negotiating and ratifying new agreements.
  • For new trade agreements, the Government will work closely with scrutiny committees in both Houses, providing confidential briefings as appropriate.
  • New clause 12 proposes a review of free trade agreements every five years after entry into force.
  • New clause 18 seeks to give Parliament and the devolved legislatures binding votes on or vetoes over international agreements.
  • The Government have regular dialogue with the International Trade Committee.
  • The Trade Bill is seen to have serious shortcomings regarding social, environmental, and democratic aspects.
  • Ministers can make changes to retained EU law in a Committee of 17 MPs with a maximum debate of 90 minutes over up to 10 years.
  • Only half of the 40 agreements covered by the Bill have been signed.
  • The Bill aims to establish a voting mandate on international trade agreements.
  • Trade unions are excluded from some ETAGs that were not set up for scrutinizing trade deals.
  • NDAs prevent consultation and analysis of texts by limited ETAG memberships.
  • ISDS clauses allow companies to sue governments over policy changes.
  • Standstill and ratchet clauses prevent the return of privatised public services to public ownership.
  • US President seeks full market access for products including NHS medicines.
  • Northern Ireland producers export 75% of their agrifood products.
  • The Trade and Agriculture Commission is advisory, not regulatory.
  • The Trade Bill lacks a statutory obligation for UK Government to seek consent from Scottish Ministers before exercising powers in devolved areas.
  • Previous Trade Bill provisions allowing regulation-making powers without consent were removed but similar issues remain.
  • New clause 4 would give devolved Assemblies and the Scottish Parliament authority over trade negotiations affecting their competences.
  • New clause 7 would affirm the UK’s rights under the SPS agreement.
  • It prohibits importing food from countries with lower standards than those in the UK.
  • New clause 8 ensures a duty to restrict market access for healthcare services, including medicines and medical devices.
  • The MP supported new clause 2 of the Agriculture Bill.
  • Over 400 NHS and senior public health professionals have signed an open letter demanding legal guarantees in post-Brexit trade legislation.
  • In Fleur Anderson's constituency, 39% of jobs are identified as being severely impacted by a no-deal Brexit or bad deal with the EU.
  • New clause 11 seeks to ban imports unless produced under UK standards.
  • It is already illegal in UK law to import products like chlorine-washed chicken or hormone-treated beef.
  • The amendment would prevent dynamic alignment and could kill trade deals with developing countries.
  • New clause 9 requires ratification or implementation of international trade agreements not to restrict UK’s ability to pursue climate and environmental goals.
  • The Trade Bill is criticized for failing to align with post-Brexit objectives and current crises like climate change, nature conservation, and the pandemic.
  • Thousands of people have contacted the Minister expressing concern about food standards.
  • The Government has established a commission to listen to farmers' concerns.
  • There is an import ban in place prohibiting the entry of chlorinated chicken into the UK.
  • Craig Williams represents one of the largest agricultural communities in the country.
  • The CRAG procedure provides for scrutiny and accountability in trade deal negotiations.
  • Trade was worth £17.5 billion for Wales in 2019.
  • More than 60% of Welsh exports are destined for the European Union.
  • Welsh food and drink exports were worth more than £530 million in 2018.
  • The CRAG process allows Parliament to vote on trade deals.
  • The Trade Bill does not remove the UK's current food standards.
  • Hormones and chlorine in food are banned now and will remain banned.
  • Existing food law, including retained EU law, will be rolled over when the transition period ends.
  • From January 2021, the UK will begin developing its own independent trade policy.
  • New clause 4 proposes parliamentary scrutiny of free trade agreements with a yes/no vote on negotiating objectives and final draft agreements.
  • The EU Parliament has historically taken a yes/no vote on draft FTAs prior to signature.
  • The CRAG process implemented in 2010 by Labour is described as inadequate.
  • A letter from the Chair of the Trade Development Department Committee to the Secretary of State on 18 June highlights the lack of detailed arrangements for FTA scrutiny.
  • Japan has offered a quick deal, but it will not be treated as a roll-over for scrutiny purposes under current legislation.
  • The Trade Bill is seen as an opportunity to protect UK industries like agrifood and agriculture.
  • There are concerns about executive overreach that need addressing in the Bill.
  • Northern Ireland's fishing industry needs support from the Trade Bill to grow outside EU regulations.
  • Some Members advocate for new clauses 4 and 7 to strengthen protections.
  • The trade and agriculture commission is led by Tim Smith.
  • The MP urges the Government to maintain commitments on environment, animal welfare, and trading visions as stated in their manifesto.
  • The Bill does not mention climate or environmental concerns.
  • The Trade Bill lacks parliamentary scrutiny of future trade deals.
  • Constituents worry about potential US trade deal leading to lower food standards.
  • Labour calls for legal guarantees protecting NHS, food standards, workers' rights, and environmental protections.
  • Over 60% of Jarrow constituency voted to leave the EU in 2016.
  • The NHS has not been properly funded for over a decade due to austerity measures.
  • Research by Global Justice Now estimates the value of UK health data at about £10 billion annually.
  • The Trade Bill is described as a continuity Bill designed to give confidence to businesses exporting to various countries.
  • The MP opposes amendments tabled regarding standards, arguing they are anti-trade measures that could harm exporters and trade opportunities.
  • Under the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act, MPs already have powers to scrutinise international treaties.
  • The Trade Bill is about continuity trade agreements vital for British farmers and businesses.
  • Food standards will be transferred from EU law to British law, ensuring they remain unchanged without parliamentary approval.
  • The lifting of the ban on British beef exports to America is worth £66 million.
  • The government intends to join the Agreement on Government Procurement as an independent party on substantially the same terms as EU membership.
  • UK businesses will have access to public procurement opportunities worth some £1.3 trillion per year through GPA membership.
  • The Trade Remedies Authority will ensure continuity of remedial action for industries like Stoke-on-Trent’s ceramics.
  • The US has triple the number of road deaths per million compared with the UK due to differences in car safety standards.
  • New cars sold in the EU will have collision avoidance systems for pedestrian protection.
  • Constituents are concerned about parliamentary oversight over future trade agreements.
  • New clause 11 ensures that imported agricultural goods meet UK standards on animal health, welfare, environmental protection, food safety, hygiene, traceability and plant health.
  • New clauses 5 and 6 are seen as strengthening the Bill by creating a balance between efficient trade and protection of constituents' interests.
  • Factories in Stafford produce Perkins engines, generators for General Electric, and JCB tractors that rely on international supply chains.
  • The Bill aims to provide long-term trading opportunities while ensuring short-term certainty during uncertain times.
  • Food standards remain a concern with some Members supporting new clause 4 due to potential lowering of standards.
  • The Minister provided personal assurances regarding food safety, animal welfare, and environmental standards not being compromised.
  • The Bill aims to secure continuity with up to 40 EU trade agreements.
  • A Trade Remedies Authority is established to protect UK businesses and jobs from unfair trading practices.
  • The Bill provides access to a £1.3 billion global market in government procurement.
  • Amendments would require imported agricultural goods to meet UK animal welfare, environmental, plant health, food safety standards.
  • New clause aims to protect public health services like the NHS from restrictions imposed by international trade agreements.
  • Devolved governments' consent is required for regulations made under section 2(1) that fall within their competence.
  • Amendment 6 allows HMRC to share information with Ministers of the Crown rather than just the Secretary of State.
  • Amendment 8 specifies Ministerial functions relating to trade analysis, including traffic, goods, services flow, impact assessment, and measure design.
  • Amendment 9 seeks to clarify the interaction between the power to share information and data protection legislation.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy