<-- Back to proposed bills

Domestic Abuse Bill

06 July 2020

Proposing MP
Louth and Horncastle
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement addresses amendments to the Domestic Abuse Bill to include children who witness or experience the effects of domestic abuse as victims. The statement discusses new clauses proposed for the Domestic Abuse Bill aimed at enhancing protections and support for victims of domestic abuse. The Domestic Abuse Bill aims to address domestic abuse by recognizing its impact on children and enhancing protections in legal proceedings. The minister addresses concerns about the impact of internet pornography on violence against women and girls, and discusses efforts to eliminate a perceived defence for perpetrators of serious harm in cases involving rough sex. The statement addresses proposed amendments to clarify legal principles regarding consent to serious harm for sexual gratification and introduces a pilot scheme to support migrant victims of domestic abuse. The statement discusses the need for evidence-based reforms regarding support for victims of domestic abuse, particularly focusing on migrant victims and those with specific immigration statuses. The statement addresses the issue of providing support to victims of domestic abuse who have no recourse to public funds, highlighting the barriers these individuals face and the impact on their ability to seek safety and justice. The statement discusses the potential removal of the 'no recourse to public funds' condition for individuals seeking assistance. Jess Phillips discusses amendments to the Domestic Abuse Bill aimed at protecting victims who lack recourse to public funds and expanding duties on local authorities and relevant public bodies to provide domestic abuse services. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its importance for victims up and down the country. The speaker discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and supports amendments aimed at strengthening protections for victims and addressing repeat perpetrators. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its amendments, focusing on cross-party cooperation and addressing issues like child protection, housing support, and threats of disclosing private photographs. The statement discusses the need to review emergency regulations during the COVID period and their impact on women, emphasizing the necessity of supporting migrant women victims of domestic abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill, highlighting its importance in resolving long-standing legal and social issues related to domestic abuse. The statement addresses the issue of ensuring women in abusive relationships have access to safe and legal abortion care remotely. The statement discusses amendments and additions to the Domestic Abuse Bill aimed at protecting children and improving support for victims. The statement addresses concerns about the Domestic Abuse Bill and its impact on victims in Northern Ireland, highlighting discrepancies between UK legislation and that of Northern Ireland. The statement addresses the need for gender neutrality in the Domestic Abuse Bill and emphasizes the importance of classifying parental alienation as a form of domestic abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its implications for victims of domestic violence. Victoria Atkins discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and related amendments. The statement discusses the need for equal treatment and support for all domestic abuse victims, regardless of their immigration status, and calls for updates on the pilot scheme's progress towards ratifying the Istanbul convention. The speaker discusses new clause 28 of the Domestic Abuse Bill which enables access to home abortions for women in abusive relationships, raising concerns about potential coercion and abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill, focusing on its progress and the need for further improvements, particularly in relation to migrant women facing domestic abuse. The statement addresses concerns and amendments related to new clause 28 of the Domestic Abuse Bill, focusing on issues of abortion and brain injuries caused by domestic abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its aim to address domestic abuse through legislation. The statement discusses amendments to the Domestic Abuse Bill regarding press anonymity for survivors. The MP discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and emphasizes the importance of addressing sexual violence within domestic abuse contexts. The MP discusses new clause 34 of the Domestic Abuse Bill which aims to strengthen revenge pornography laws by making it illegal to threaten to share intimate images without consent. The statement discusses support for victims of domestic abuse, including those with insecure immigration status. The statement discusses amendments to the Domestic Abuse Bill aimed at better supporting children affected by domestic abuse and ensuring adequate funding for community-based services. The statement discusses concerns about new clauses in the Domestic Abuse Bill that could negatively impact victims of domestic abuse, particularly women. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its impact on children who witness abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its implications for victims of abuse, including provisions for funding, protecting children, and addressing same-sex relationships. The speaker discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill, focusing on new clauses that aim to protect children affected by domestic abuse and remove a legal defence for abusers. The MP discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill, highlighting its importance in ending the 'rough sex defence' and tackling gender-based violence. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its potential impact on victims of domestic abuse in the UK. The speaker discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and emphasizes its importance in protecting children who are hidden victims of domestic abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its provisions for supporting victims of domestic abuse, including a new £1.5 million pilot project for migrant victims. The minister is delivering the winding-up of the Domestic Abuse Bill's Report stage and discussing cross-Government collaboration on the bill. The statement discusses various amendments proposed in the Domestic Abuse Bill, including new clauses addressing women's support programmes, police data sharing, and abortion measures during the pandemic. Victoria Atkins is discussing the Domestic Abuse Bill and summarizing its importance for victims of domestic abuse. The statement discusses new legislation enabling courts to prohibit parties from cross-examining witnesses in person if it would diminish evidence quality or cause significant distress. Victoria Atkins introduced a new clause to the Domestic Abuse Bill that addresses consent in cases where serious harm is inflicted for sexual gratification under specific sections of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. The statement discusses amendments made to the Domestic Abuse Bill, including provisions related to court procedures and consent in serious harm cases. The Minister is moving the Domestic Abuse Bill for its Third Reading, highlighting significant progress in providing better support and protection for victims of domestic abuse. The statement addresses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its importance in providing better protection and support for victims of domestic abuse. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and its importance in reforming family private law. The statement is about expressing gratitude for the progress made on the Domestic Abuse Bill, acknowledging cross-party cooperation, and recognizing the ongoing challenges in addressing domestic abuse.

Action Requested

The minister proposes that the new clause be accepted and read for a second time, thereby including children in the definition of victims of domestic abuse under the bill.

Key Facts

  • The amendment aims to broaden the definition of a victim of domestic abuse to include children who witness or experience the effects of such abuse.
  • A child is considered related to a person if they are their parent or have parental responsibility, or if they are relatives as defined by section 63(1) of the Family Law Act 1996.
  • Government proposes several new clauses addressing various aspects of domestic abuse legislation.
  • New clauses include provisions for special measures in family proceedings, prohibition of cross-examination in civil proceedings, lifetime press anonymity for survivors, screening for brain injuries, specialist services for perpetrators and victims, and legal protections for immigrant survivors.
  • The amendments seek to strengthen existing laws and introduce new measures to enhance protection and support for domestic abuse victims.
  • 2.4 million people experience domestic abuse.
  • New clause 15 recognizes children exposed to domestic abuse as victims.
  • More than 1,200 submissions were received for a panel reviewing family court procedures involving domestic abuse.
  • Cross-examination in person is prohibited across all courts if likely to diminish witness evidence or cause significant distress.
  • The increase of internet traffic related to pornography is concerning at a rate of 11.6%.
  • Cases involving rough sex are often perceived as having a defence, leading men to avoid convictions or receive reduced sentences.
  • The Minister pays tribute to the family of Natalie Connolly for their hard work in this area.
  • New clause 20 aims to make it clear that consent to the infliction of serious harm and death is not a legal defence.
  • The destitution domestic violence concession (DDVC) supports migrant victims with certain partner visas.
  • A £1.5 million pilot programme, the support for migrant victims scheme, has been launched to address immediate needs of migrant victims.
  • We are coming to the Dispatch Box with an open heart and acknowledge the need for evidence-based reform.
  • People on visitor visas, such as a six-month visa, have made financial representations to the Home Office.
  • The Southall Black Sisters provided evidence to the Joint Committee on this issue.
  • A pilot programme is being launched to ensure immediate access to support for victims.
  • Further announcements about implementing the pilot are expected in summer.
  • The pilot project will launch in autumn.
  • The MP cites examples from police officers across the country highlighting difficulties in safeguarding victims without recourse to public funds.
  • West Midlands Police Public Protection Unit spent £23,161 on temporary accommodation out of police force funding last year.
  • The Government's draft guidance admits that no recourse to public funds is a barrier for women escaping domestic abuse.
  • The proposal aims to bring people forward confidently.
  • Individuals would not be penalised under this temporary change.
  • New clause 25 would insert a non-discrimination clause into the Bill.
  • New clause 23 would expand duties on local authorities and relevant public bodies to provide domestic abuse services.
  • Over 70% of domestic abuse victims receive support in community-based services rather than refuges.
  • A community worker in Merseyside supports 776 complex cases with only four staff members.
  • New clause 24 seeks decisive action to protect children living with domestic abuse by reviewing the pro-contact family court culture.
  • The Domestic Abuse Bill has returned for its Report stage and Third Reading.
  • Two amendments are welcomed: new clause 15 on children affected by domestic abuse and measures against the rough sex defence.
  • Concerns raised about migrant women's uncertain immigration status being used as a form of abuse.
  • Since the beginning of lockdown, 35 women and children have been murdered by partners or ex-partners.
  • New clauses 32 and 33 aim to address the gap in managing repeat abusers.
  • There is no systematic approach to monitor and tackle repeat perpetrators.
  • The statement welcomes the inclusion of new clauses that give greater protection to children who witness abuse and commit to housing victims of abuse.
  • New clause 20 ends the so-called rough sex defence, a cross-party solution.
  • Refuge's campaign 'The Naked Threat' highlights that one in seven young women have been threatened with sharing intimate or sexual images.
  • The Government considers undertaking a public consultation on making permanent the current measure allowing home use of early medical abortion pills up to 10 weeks’ gestation.
  • Hon. Friend the Minister has introduced new clauses 16, 17 and 18.
  • Pilot projects will provide data on supporting migrant women victims of domestic abuse.
  • There is a consensus around finding a way to treat migrant victims as victims first.
  • The speaker welcomes measures to bring family court procedures in line with criminal court protections.
  • Proposed new section 85H specifies that the qualified legal representative appointed by the court is not responsible to the party seeking cross-examination.
  • The abolition of the consent defence in new clause 4 addresses long-standing legal issues settled largely by the case of Brown.
  • New clause 28 would allow women in abusive relationships to obtain abortion medication remotely if deemed necessary by a doctor.
  • The Abortion Act 1967 currently restricts access to legal abortion care to licensed premises only.
  • During the covid pandemic, regulations were put in place allowing telemedicine for early medical abortions up to 10 weeks of pregnancy.
  • Three quarters of child safeguarding cases involve domestic abuse.
  • A third of domestic abuse begins during pregnancy.
  • 831,000 children live in households with domestic abuse.
  • About half the residents in refuges are children.
  • There has been a 15% rise in 999 emergency calls relating to domestic abuse in Northern Ireland during the past three months compared with the same period last year.
  • The progress of the Domestic Abuse Bill leaves glaring omissions in legislative protection for victims in Northern Ireland, including no statutory gender definition and no provision for a domestic abuse commissioner or office.
  • Two thirds of victims of domestic abuse are women and one third are men according to the Office for National Statistics.
  • The Government's statutory guidance includes parental alienation and preventing contact as examples of domestic abuse.
  • There are thousands—hundreds of thousands—of parents who do not have any relationship with their children due to parental alienation.
  • Lie detector tests, unreliable and criticized in entertainment programmes like 'The Jeremy Kyle Show', are being proposed for use in serious cases.
  • The Bill seeks to provide support and protection for victims of domestic abuse.
  • New clause 28 aims to allow women in abusive relationships to access care without putting themselves at risk.
  • Telemedicine has reduced illegal and unsafe abortions during the pandemic.
  • The amendments address the rough sex defence, review by the Director of Public Prosecutions, and victim anonymity.
  • New clause 20 is seen as a solution addressing these issues.
  • The Minister acknowledges the need for data collection for elder abuse victims.
  • The Bill includes many landmark changes, though specifics are not listed due to time constraints.
  • Amendment 46 would ensure a representative for Wales holds a seat on the commissioner’s advisory board to reflect Welsh circumstances.
  • Data from the Metropolitan police shows there were 13,600 repeat victims of domestic abuse in the year up to September 2019.
  • New clause 28 relates to enabling access to abortions for women in abusive relationships via telephone consultations.
  • A consultant argues that distinguishing between false claims of abuse and genuine situations is difficult over the phone.
  • There have been cases where pills issued via telemedicine were taken beyond recommended gestation limits, including one case at 18 weeks.
  • The Domestic Abuse Bill aims to change life for hundreds of thousands of women facing domestic abuse.
  • Migrant women encountering domestic abuse need significant support and protection.
  • New clause 26 would give migrant women who survive domestic abuse the right to remain in this country.
  • New clause 27 would prevent sharing data between Government agencies such as the police and Home Office.
  • The Government intends to launch a public consultation on the topic of abortion related to new clause 28.
  • Amendments (a), (b), and (c) were tabled to highlight flaws in new clause 28, specifically regarding gestation limits and surgical abortions.
  • Research shows that 64% of women prisoners had suffered from a brain injury, with 62% of those injuries resulting from domestic violence.
  • Home is where many people experience hate and pain due to domestic abuse.
  • In two thirds of cases, victims are women, though men can also be victims.
  • Cohabiting women are almost three times more likely to suffer from domestic abuse than married or civil partnership women.
  • New clause 3 calls for the Government to review sentences for domestic abuse crimes.
  • The Bill lacks provisions for press anonymity for domestic abuse survivors.
  • New clause 19 would ensure survivors receive the same guarantee of press anonymity as those who report sexual assault, which has been in place since 1992.
  • Naming survivors can discourage them from reporting and put their wellbeing at risk.
  • The MP tabled two amendments focusing on sexual violence in domestic abuse contexts.
  • Police and crime commissioners regularly commission sufficient services for victims of sexual violence, but local NHS services often fail to meet expectations.
  • No recourse to public funds renders many at-risk individuals powerless and increases their chances of being preyed upon by abusers or falling into destitution.
  • The Bill aims to increase awareness of domestic abuse and support victims.
  • New clause 34 addresses the issue of threats to share intimate images without consent.
  • Refuge research finds that one in 14 adults (four and a half million people) have experienced such threats.
  • Speaker mentions three women working in her constituency on domestic abuse issues.
  • Supports new clause 22 for insecure immigration status victims.
  • Praises the government's pledge of £1.5 million for a pilot scheme.
  • Children affected by domestic abuse need proper support and recognition.
  • New clause 15 includes children in the definition of domestic abuse.
  • Community-based services for child victims need funding under any new statutory duty.
  • Northern Ireland figures released today show a 15% increase in domestic abuse cases over the past three months.
  • Joleen Corr, a 27-year-old woman from Downpatrick, died after being propelled down stairs by her abuser.
  • New clause 28 is criticized for potentially giving abusers more power to keep victims at home and away from help.
  • Up to 30% of children live in a household where abuse is taking place.
  • Charlie Webster's personal experience inspired the campaign to amend the definition of domestic abuse.
  • New clause 15 recognises a child as someone under 18 years old for the purpose of the amendment.
  • More than 100,000 children in the UK have parents with leave to remain but no recourse to public funds.
  • Only 5% of refuge vacancies are accessible due to housing benefit restrictions.
  • Family Help in Darlington is one of the UK’s first women’s refuges, providing support since 1976.
  • Rydal Academy, a primary school, has a high concentration of children from homes where abuse occurs and seeks to implement local perpetrator programmes.
  • Between 2010-11 and 2018-19, central Government funding for children and young people’s services fell by £2.2 billion.
  • Some 831,000 children in England are living in households that have reported domestic abuse.
  • New clause 15 provides that references to victims of domestic abuse include children who see, hear or experience the effects of abuse.
  • Amendment 35 proposes mandating police forces to record misogyny as a hate crime where they are not ordinarily doing so.
  • 26 women and girls have been killed since the start of the lockdown in March.
  • SASHA (support, advice, safety, help and aid) has been set up in Totnes constituency.
  • The Bill aims to end the 'rough sex defence' and ensure perpetrators cannot escape justice for horrific crimes.
  • The Bill Committee heard evidence from charities like Women's Aid and Welsh Women's Aid.
  • Migrant women face unique barriers in seeking support due to immigration status.
  • More than half of police forces in England and Wales share victims' details with the Home Office for immigration control purposes.
  • Domestic abuse currently costs society at least £66 billion a year.
  • The analysis by the Children’s Commissioner shows that 831,000 children in England are living in households that report domestic abuse.
  • In 2018-19, domestic abuse was identified as the most common additional factor of need in social care assessments for children.
  • Services in the speaker's constituency have informed her that the commissioner has made a tremendous difference in ensuring resources reach frontline workers.
  • The Domestic Abuse Bill is described as groundbreaking UK legislation.
  • Gorwel provides support for up to 500 victims of domestic violence and homelessness weekly across north Wales.
  • The Government have provided over £1 million through the tampon tax fund for migrant victims without recourse to public funds.
  • Seven Departments are currently working on the Domestic Abuse Bill.
  • There were over 2 million people experiencing domestic abuse in England and Wales each year.
  • Two women a week are killed by partners or ex-partners in England and Wales.
  • The government's support for migrant victims scheme will be announced in summer.
  • The framework of the support for migrant victims scheme aims to be published ahead of Lords Second Reading.
  • The Government's programme already helps around 2,500 women under the DDVC.
  • There is ongoing judicial review regarding police data sharing for immigration purposes.
  • A public consultation will be conducted on making permanent home use of early medical abortion pills up to 10 weeks' gestation.
  • The new clause applies where rules of court provide for the making of a special measures direction.
  • Rules of court must assume diminished quality of evidence and participation if P is or at risk of being a victim of domestic abuse by listed persons in subsection (3).
  • Victims of specified offences are eligible for access to special measures in civil proceedings.
  • The legislation enables court directions prohibiting in-person cross-examination if evidence quality would be diminished or significant distress caused.
  • A legal representative can be appointed by the court when a party is prevented from cross-examining a witness personally due to a direction under section 85F.
  • Legal representatives must follow guidance issued by the Lord Chancellor regarding their role in such proceedings.
  • The new clause amends sections under the Offences Against the Person Act 1861.
  • Exceptions are provided for cases involving specific sexually transmitted infections where consent was given knowing the infection status.
  • A review must be conducted within 12 months of the Act being passed.
  • Amendments made to define 'family proceedings' in the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984.
  • Amendments introduced to include provisions on consent not being a defence in serious harm cases.
  • The amendments are consequential on new clauses inserted by NC15, NC17, and NC20.
  • The Bill has undergone two Second Reading debates before reaching Third Reading.
  • It took over three years of work for the Bill to reach this stage.
  • The Bill now recognises the impact of domestic abuse on children living in abusive households.
  • Research by the Government Equalities Office will address concerns about harms from pornography.
  • Government will publish a White Paper on sentencing reform later in the year.
  • The Bill aims to ensure that the phrase 'It’s only a domestic' is consigned to history books.
  • There are approximately 2.4 million victims of domestic abuse annually in England and Wales.
  • A £1.5 million pilot scheme will be launched to support migrant victims who do not qualify under existing mechanisms.
  • The Domestic Abuse Bill is a major reform of family private law.
  • It includes changes to procedures in the family court which have taken time to implement.
  • The Bill addresses non-fatal strangulation, filling a legal gap previously present under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861.
  • Thanks are extended to Ministers, Labour shadow Front-Bench Members, and Members across the House for their contributions.
  • Progress has been made since the Home Affairs Committee’s report on domestic abuse two years ago.
  • Tributes are paid to my hon. Friend the Member for Canterbury (Rosie Duffield) for her bravery in speaking out about domestic abuse.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy