<-- Back to proposed bills

Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill - Sitting 7

18 June 2020

Proposing MP
Gainsborough
Type
Public Bill Committee

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement discusses a new clause in the Bill that requires an annual report on the impact of immigration provisions on seasonal agricultural workers in the UK. Holly Lynch discusses the impact of new immigration plans on UK agriculture, emphasizing the reliance on EU migrant workers in sectors like dairy farming, poultry farming, and horticulture. The statement discusses the implementation and expansion of a seasonal worker pilot scheme for UK farms to address labour shortages. MP Holly Lynch moves a new clause requiring the Government to publish a report detailing the associated rights of the Common Travel Area within 30 days of the Act being passed. The statement discusses the Government's commitment to maintaining the Common Travel Area (CTA) arrangements between the UK and Ireland, including rights for British and Irish citizens. The statement addresses the engagement on a point regarding immigration and social security coordination following interventions by other MPs. The statement discusses the proposed annual report from the Migration Advisory Committee on the impact of immigration policies on the higher education sector. The statement discusses challenges faced by universities due to changes in immigration policies following Brexit and the impact of the coronavirus pandemic. The statement addresses the impact of EU programmes and immigration policies on international students in the UK. The statement addresses concerns about the impact of Brexit on short-term business visits and visa requirements for UK nationals traveling to the EU, particularly focusing on the creative industries such as music. The MP discusses the current system for business visitors to the UK and addresses concerns about future immigration rules post-Brexit. The speaker discusses concerns about the new tier-2 procedures and their impact on businesses, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises, and requests for an annual MAC report to be debated in Parliament. The statement discusses the new points-based immigration system being introduced by the UK government post-Brexit. Edward Leigh is proposing new clause 58 which would provide automatic settled status for all looked after children in care and those entitled to care leaving support, removing the requirement for local authorities to apply to the EU Settlement Scheme. The statement addresses concerns about EU-protected looked-after children and care leavers who need to regularise their immigration status before the end of the transition period. Edward Leigh is thanking members of the Public Bill Committee for their courtesy and announcing that he will not see them again after the Committee reports.

Action Requested

Holly Lynch is proposing that the government commission an annual report from the Migration Advisory Committee to assess the impact of the Act on the number of seasonal agricultural workers and food security. She also highlights issues with the current pilot scheme for seasonal agriculture workers, suggesting it needs improvement to address labor shortages post-transition period.

Key Facts

  • Significant numbers of EEA nationals are employed in agriculture on both permanent and seasonal bases.
  • The Pick for Britain scheme had 35,000 applications but only 16% of applicants opted to interview after initial application.
  • The pilot scheme allows for 10,000 visas when 70,000 would be closer to the agreed number required.
  • FLEX (Focus on Labour Exploitation group) has raised concerns about worker exploitation in tied visas and debt bondage under future schemes.
  • The Royal Association of British Dairy Farmers estimates that 56% of dairy farmers in the UK have employed EU workers.
  • Around 22,800 EU migrants make up the workforce in poultry farming.
  • The NFU reports that 99% of all harvesters in the UK come from Europe.
  • The seasonal worker pilot admits non-EU migrant workers to work in edible horticulture for up to six months.
  • In March last year, the Government announced a nationwide pilot with an initial quota of 2,500 places.
  • On February 19th, the annual quota was increased from 2,500 to 10,000 places.
  • The new clause aims to ensure clarity on the scope of 'reciprocal rights' of the Common Travel Area.
  • It requires a report specifying the scope of reciprocal rights under the CTA, retained EU rights and benefits, and the correlation between them.
  • The Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission highlights that the EU Settlement Scheme is enshrined in law through the withdrawal agreement, while the CTA relies on an informal gentlemen's agreement.
  • The Common Travel Area (CTA) allows free movement between the UK, Ireland, Isle of Man, Guernsey, and Jersey.
  • Both Governments signed a CTA memorandum of understanding on May 8, 2019.
  • Clause 2 ensures Irish citizens can enter and remain in the UK without requiring permission, except in limited circumstances.
  • The Minister has engaged in a fairly constructive manner.
  • The SNP's hon. Member for Cumbernauld, Kilsyth and Kirkintilloch East raised points of concern.
  • A desire and unanswered questions remain regarding the topic.
  • The UK higher education sector attracts international students contributing £26 billion to the economy.
  • In 2017-18, universities reported a £4.3 billion deficit in research income.
  • There were 485,645 international students enrolled at UK universities in 2018-19.
  • The impact assessment suggests up to 25,000 fewer EU higher education students by academic year 2024/25.
  • Tuition fee income is estimated to increase between £1 billion and £2 billion over the first five years of the policy.
  • The review should encompass student and staff recruitment.
  • Universities are under immense pressure due to the coronavirus pandemic.
  • Visa processing centres remain closed.
  • Proposes extending the window of visa validity from three months to six months.
  • Suggests waiving tier-4 visa fees for one year only.
  • Asks to consider making online study compatible with the graduate route.
  • The UK is one of the world’s leading destinations for international education with around 140,000 EU domiciled and 340,000 non-EU domiciled students enrolled in higher education institutions.
  • The Higher Education Statistics Agency reports a 10% increase in the number of international students between 2014-15 and 2018-19.
  • A new graduate route will be launched in summer 2021 to allow international graduates to remain in the UK for two years post study.
  • The Government is negotiating a reciprocal agreement with the EU that would allow UK citizens to undertake some paid business activities in the EU without a work permit on a short-term basis.
  • The creative sector contributes over £100 billion a year to the UK economy and employs over 3 million people according to the Confederation of British Industry.
  • The music industry has long attracted world-class artists, but visa issues could cause major disruption if not resolved by the end of the transition period.
  • Visitors can stay in the UK for up to six months and participate in various activities like conferences, research, training, maintenance, installations, audits, knowledge transfer, creative and sporting events.
  • Non-visa nationals such as Canadians, Australians, Japanese, and New Zealanders are already allowed to engage in these activities without a visa.
  • The Government is engaged with stakeholders to understand how the rules can be simplified and improved post-free movement.
  • The new tier-2 procedures are causing significant apprehension among businesses.
  • Multiple industry bodies have expressed concerns about accessing necessary labour under the new system.
  • Hospitality, tourism, food and drink, agriculture, fishing, manufacturing, engineering, logistics, financial services, social care, and education sectors are particularly affected.
  • The new points-based system will treat everyone alike based on skills and contributions.
  • Skill thresholds below those in the tier 2 system are being reduced.
  • Resident Labour Market Test is abolished to reduce bureaucracy for employers.
  • Shortage occupation lists recognise certain occupations needing workers through immigration.
  • New clause 58 would provide automatic settled status for children in care and those entitled to care leaving support.
  • Local authorities would no longer have to apply on behalf of these children to the EU Settlement Scheme.
  • "Children in care" includes those living with foster parents, in residential homes, or similar settings.
  • There are an estimated 5,000 looked-after children and 4,000 care leavers who need to apply for status before December 2020.
  • Local authorities identified just 3,612 EU/EAA/Swiss looked-after children as of January 2020, with only 404 having settled their status.
  • The process involves local authorities identifying eligible children, communicating with them, and providing necessary data to the Home Office for automatic granting of settled status.
  • Edward Leigh thanks the Whip and other Committee members.
  • Mr Stringer is chairing the Committee this afternoon.
  • The Committee intends to report after which Edward Leigh will not see Committee members again.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy