<-- Back to proposed bills
Domestic Abuse Bill - Sitting 9
16 June 2020
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The statement addresses amendments to the Domestic Abuse Bill, specifically focusing on Clause 66 and New Clause 13 related to homelessness for victims of domestic abuse. Karen Buck is addressing the Domestic Abuse Bill, focusing on new clause 16 which aims to amend the Housing Act 1996 to prioritize accommodation for victims of domestic abuse who are homeless. Karen Buck discusses new clause 13 which aims to provide more stringent housing support for individuals fleeing domestic abuse. Karen Buck discusses the importance of workplace support for victims of domestic abuse. The statement discusses the Government's role in supporting employers who wish to help employees affected by domestic abuse and proposes a consultation on workplace support for victims of domestic abuse. The statement addresses an amendment proposing separate statutory guidance for teenage relationship abuse. The statement addresses the need to include younger individuals in the definition of domestic abuse under the Domestic Abuse Bill. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill and the impact of domestic abuse on young people under the age of 16. The statement addresses an amendment to include misogyny as a hate crime and requires police forces to record relevant crimes involving hostility based on sex. The statement addresses the issue of whether misogyny should be recognised as a hate crime and the necessity of gathering data on this matter. The statement addresses the territorial extent and short title of the Domestic Abuse Bill, as well as introducing new clauses for consequential amendments to the Sentencing Code. Karen Buck is discussing new clauses related to preventing consent from being used as a defence in cases of domestic abuse. Karen Buck is proposing amendments to provide anonymity for victims of domestic homicides and survivors of domestic abuse during criminal proceedings. The statement discusses the 'rough sex defence' loophole in UK law where perpetrators claim consensual violence during sexual activity, leading to lesser charges or lighter sentences for female victims. The statement discusses the need to address legal loopholes that allow perpetrators of sexual violence to claim consent in cases where serious harm or death occurs. Karen Buck discusses new clause 14 of the Domestic Abuse Bill which aims to grant anonymity in press coverage for survivors of domestic abuse. The statement addresses concerns about the normalisation of dangerous and degrading acts within intimate relationships and the need for legal clarity to prevent defendants from justifying violent deaths through consent. Karen Buck is discussing new clauses related to domestic homicide cases and the requirement for personal Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) consent in certain circumstances. The statement discusses issues related to criminal justice procedures for bereaved families and proposed changes in new clauses of the Domestic Abuse Bill. The MP discusses the principle of protecting the anonymity of victims of sexual assault and domestic abuse in court proceedings, emphasizing the need for careful consideration when extending these protections to other types of offences.
Action Requested
Karen Buck supports Government amendment 40, which is consequential on amendment NC16. She also discusses new clause 13, proposing changes to the Housing Act 1996 to update definitions and requirements regarding domestic abuse and homelessness.
Key Facts
- Amendment 40 is consequential on amendment NC16.
- New Clause 13 amends Part 7 of the Housing Act 1996.
- The clause updates the definition of 'domestic violence' to 'domestic abuse'.
- It removes the requirement for a person to be vulnerable in order to have priority need due to domestic abuse.
- Since the Homelessness Reduction Act 2017 was implemented in April 2018, more than 200,000 households have had their homelessness prevented or relieved.
- New clause 16 will automatically give domestic abuse victims priority need for accommodation without requiring further vulnerability assessment.
- The shared accommodation rate exemption for victims of domestic abuse was announced in the spring Budget.
- New clause 13 aims to strengthen housing support for survivors of domestic abuse.
- Last year, nearly 2,000 households fleeing domestic abuse in England were not provided with a safe home due to not being considered priority need cases.
- The APPG’s amendment would guarantee automatic priority need and a legal right to a safe home for anyone applying due to domestic abuse.
- The Government's amendment requires the application to be made directly by the individual experiencing abuse, raising concerns about manipulation by perpetrators.
- The amendment seeks to include employer support in the Domestic Abuse Bill.
- It focuses on providing guidance to employers regarding support for victims, including provisions for paid leave.
- The Public Bill Office is thanked for its work behind the scenes.
- The Government expect all employers to show compassion when faced with cases of domestic abuse.
- Employers’ Initiative on Domestic Abuse provides guidance for employers.
- Public Health England, in partnership with Business in the Community, offers a domestic abuse toolkit online.
- Statutory sick pay may be available if an employee is suffering from physical injury or psychological harm due to domestic abuse.
- The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy launched a review of support in the workplace for victims of domestic abuse ending September 9, 2020.
- The amendment would place a duty on the Secretary of State to publish separate statutory guidance on teenage relationship abuse.
- The guidance must address sufficient levels of local authority service provision for victims and perpetrators.
- It must be published within three months of the Act receiving Royal Assent and reviewed bi-annually.
- The current Bill defines domestic abuse as taking place between persons above the age of 16.
- According to the NSPCC, 25% of girls aged 13 to 17 have reported physical relationship abuse.
- The Children’s Society found that 25% of young people worked with had experienced physical abuse in relationships, and 57% had experienced emotional abuse.
- The Bill's definition states parties must be aged 16 or over for domestic abuse.
- Clause 66 of the Bill relies on this definition for statutory guidance.
- Relationships education will cover healthy relationship characteristics from primary school onwards.
- Misogyny is considered the root cause of violence against women and girls.
- The amendment would require all police forces to record misogyny as a hate crime.
- Sex was the motivation for more than half of the hate crimes reported by women last year.
- Some 42% of BAME women aged 14 to 21 reported unwanted sexual attention at least once a month.
- The Law Commission was tasked with reviewing current hate crime legislation starting in March last year.
- The review aims to gather views through events across England and Wales.
- Clause 66(3) states that guidance must take account of the fact that most victims of domestic abuse are female.
- The majority of the Bill's provisions apply to England and Wales or England only.
- Some limited provisions extend to Scotland and Northern Ireland.
- Part 6 extends criminal courts' reach in each part of the UK.
- New Clause 15 amends the Sentencing Code by adding references to domestic abuse protection orders.
- New clause would prevent consent from being used as a defence in cases involving serious injury or death due to domestic abuse.
- The Crown Prosecution Service requires consent from the Director of Public Prosecutions for charging less than murder in homicide cases with domestic abuse injuries.
- Immediate family consultation and legal advice provision before the Director's decision on charges below murder.
- New clause 11 aims to provide anonymity for victims in domestic homicides where sexual activity is involved.
- New clause 14 provides lifetime press anonymity for survivors of domestic abuse during criminal proceedings.
- The new clauses create an offence with fines up to level 5 on the standard scale for breaching these protections.
- Natalie Connolly was killed by John Broadhurst who claimed she had consented to rough sex.
- The 'rough sex defence' has led to lesser convictions or sentences for perpetrators in many cases.
- There have been 67 recent cases of individuals being killed during so-called consensual violent sexual activity, with 60 victims being female.
- In the past five years, 18 women and girls have been killed in claimed consensual violent sexual activity.
- We Can’t Consent To This found 115 cases of women who had been injured in non-fatal assaults claiming consensual sex.
- Prosecutors declined to pursue charges against a man accused of sexual assault due to fears he would claim it was consensual, citing lengthy legal proceedings and difficulty in disproving consent.
- Pre-existing case law (R v. Brown) makes it clear that a person cannot consent to injury or death during sex, but this defence works in 45% of cases where men kill women during sex.
- New clause 14 seeks anonymity in press coverage for survivors of domestic abuse.
- The Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO) lacks specific guidelines for journalists on how to report domestic abuse cases.
- Victims named in the press are less likely to report domestic abuse, according to RISE charity in Karen Buck's constituency.
- New clauses 4 and 5 aim to address the issue of consent in violent deaths but may not have the intended effect.
- The law of homicide is complex, requiring careful consideration to avoid unintended consequences.
- The case Crown v. Brown established important legal principles that need clarification.
- New clauses 6 and 7 require personal DPP consent in cases of domestic homicide for charges or pleas less than murder.
- The Bribery Act 2010 is the only recent example where such a consent function applies.
- The Crown Prosecution Service handles high volumes of serious and complex casework nationwide.
- Family liaison officers operate within guidance but their effectiveness depends on individual calibre, kindness, and empathy.
- New clause 6 addresses consent of the DPP at charge time but could face practical challenges due to time constraints and evidentiary rules.
- New clause 10 aims to prevent defendants from arguing victim consent in cases but is not limited to such situations.
- Reporting restrictions under new clauses 11 and 14 aim to protect deceased victims' reputations and living complainants, respectively.
- The press sometimes suggests that courts overreach themselves in imposing reporting restrictions.
- There is a public interest justification in taking exceptional interference when allegations of sexual violence are involved.
- The Government will set out its approach on the 'rough sex' issue for Report.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy