<-- Back to proposed bills
Domestic Abuse Bill - Sitting 5 (Morning)
10 June 2020
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
MP Peter Bone is proposing amendments to Clause 13 of the Domestic Abuse Bill, changing the requirement for the Commissioner to report annually to Parliament instead of the Secretary of State. The MP discusses amendments related to the domestic abuse commissioner's accountability and independence in reporting. Peter Bone is discussing the independence of the domestic abuse commissioner's role. The statement discusses the Domestic Abuse Bill, specifically clause 13 and the role of the domestic abuse commissioner. The statement addresses amendments and clauses related to the duty to cooperate with the commissioner under the Domestic Abuse Bill. The statement discusses Clause 19 of the Domestic Abuse Bill, which introduces domestic abuse protection notices and orders designed to provide comprehensive and flexible protection for victims. The speaker discusses the new Domestic Abuse Protection Orders (DAPOs) and Domestic Abuse Prevention Notices (DAPNs), highlighting their importance in protecting victims from abusive relationships. MP Jess Phillips discusses concerns about the Domestic Abuse Protection Order (DAPO) scheme, particularly regarding its implementation by police forces and potential impact on victims. Peter Bone is offering assistance during the parliamentary session due to the absence of officials and lack of box notes. Peter Bone discusses several amendments aimed at ensuring that domestic abuse protection measures also cover the workplace, not just the home. The statement discusses expanding the Domestic Abuse Prevention Orders (DAPO) to cover workplaces due to cases of domestic abuse spilling over into professional environments. The statement discusses the lack of consideration for violence against women and girls in the workplace and calls for improvements in workplace safety measures. The statement discusses concerns about excluding workplaces from protections for victims of domestic abuse under the Domestic Abuse Bill. The statement discusses the Government's consideration of including workplaces in domestic abuse protection notices and orders. Peter Bone is discussing Clause 21 of the Domestic Abuse Bill, which pertains to the considerations a senior police officer must take before issuing a notice under the bill.
Action Requested
Peter Bone is requesting that the Committee support amendments 45 and 46, which would require the Domestic Abuse Commissioner to report directly to Parliament rather than the Home Office. This change aims to ensure the commissioner's independence and ability to hold government accountable.
Key Facts
- Amendment 45 changes the requirement for the Commissioner to submit an annual report to the Secretary of State to a requirement to report annually to Parliament.
- Amendment 46 includes provisions that require the Commissioner to lay copies of every annual report before Parliament, ensuring no material is included that might jeopardise safety or prejudice investigations.
- The amendments aim to address concerns raised in prelegislative scrutiny about the independence of the Domestic Abuse Commissioner.
- Amendment 45 proposes changing the recipient of the commissioner’s annual report from 'Secretary of State' to 'Parliament'.
- Amendment 46 aims to prevent material that could jeopardise safety or prejudice investigations/prosecutions in the report.
- There are two ongoing formal processes involving allegations of abusive behavior against the Home Secretary.
- The commissioner's role involves giving voice to disempowered people in society.
- There will be times when the commissioner needs to conflict with Home Office policy on issues such as migrant women, legal aid, and law enforcement experiences.
- Reporting to the Home Office is seen as a complex relationship due to its numerous officials.
- Clause 13 has been changed so that it is the commissioner who must arrange for a copy of her report to be laid before Parliament.
- The change follows recommendations from the Joint Committee and aims to provide more independence to the commissioner.
- Previous statements by Ms Jacobs and Zoë Billingham indicate confidence in their relationship with the Home Office.
- The amendments clarify references to 'the Common Council' in clauses 14 and 57 relate to its capacity as a local authority.
- Clause 14 deals with the duty to co-operate with the commissioner for public authorities listed in subsection (3).
- Public bodies are expected to act on fully reasoned recommendations by the commissioner.
- Responses to public consultation highlighted confusion over existing protective orders.
- DAPOs bring together elements of non-molestation, occupation, restraining, and domestic violence protection orders.
- Protection notices can be issued by police for up to 48 hours.
- Victims or other persons can apply directly for a DAPO with court leave.
- The new system requires abusive behaviour rather than violent behaviour as a precondition for orders.
- Criminal sanctions are introduced with the power of arrest for breaches of the order.
- There is a two-year pilot in various areas to assess the effectiveness of criminalising breaches.
- Joint Committee raised concerns about difficulties in operating current domestic violence protection orders.
- Police forces across England and Wales have varying levels of usage of DVPNs and DVPOs, ranging from three to 229 per force.
- Costs for DAPO applications are a concern; police currently pay £205 for an application and £515 for contested hearings.
- Olive Craig stated that the cost is one reason why police do not use these orders frequently.
- Peter Bone offers assistance when the Minister is struggling due to the absence of officials and box notes.
- The suggestion is made to revisit specific points in the session for better clarity.
- Amendments include 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, and 66.
- The amendments aim to give discretion for considering the workplace when issuing domestic abuse protection notices or orders.
- In 2016, four women were murdered at their workplaces by men.
- Andrew Burke killed Cassie Hayes, his ex-partner's new girlfriend, at a Tui travel shop in Southport.
- Rachel Williams suffered much of her abuse in the workplace and was restricted from working with male colleagues or cutting men’s hair.
- 47.3% of respondents to a TUC survey said their partner physically turned up at their workplace.
- 43.6% reported being stalked outside their workplace.
- Three quarters of women who experience domestic violence are also targeted at work.
- Three women were murdered at work last year due to violence against women and girls.
- The Health and Safety Executive lacks specific guidance for violence against women and girls at work.
- DAPO currently covers homes and travel but not workplaces.
- A quarter of people meet their partner at work.
- Domestic abuse-related stalking and harassment cases make up more than 60% of cases heard at magistrates courts.
- More than one third of all reported stalking and harassment takes place at work or at home.
- The Employers’ Initiative on Domestic Abuse aims to help businesses take steps to assist employees suffering from domestic abuse.
- Clauses 19 to 23 relate to emergency notices issued by senior police officers for a short period of up to 48 hours.
- Clause 21(2) requires the police to consider opinions of other people working on premises before issuing restrictions.
- Clause 21 requires the welfare of any child potentially affected by domestic abuse to be considered.
- Police must take reasonable steps to find out the victim's opinion before giving a notice but do not need their consent.
- The police officer must also consider the opinions of other residents personally connected to the perpetrator if conditions relate to shared premises.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy