<-- Back to proposed bills
Finance Bill - Sitting 1
04 June 2020
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
Siobhain McDonagh is proposing an amendment that would require the Government to review the impact of income tax rates for the 2020-21 tax year. The statement discusses the Finance Bill's provisions for setting income tax rates and the starting rate limit for savings income for 2020-21. The speaker discusses the scrutiny of the Finance Bill and proposes an amendment to assess the impact of income tax on different households during economic downturns. The MP is discussing concerns about the Finance Bill, including issues of equality, climate emergency, and the need for oral evidence. The MP discusses the impact of maintaining the corporation tax rate at 19% on Treasury revenues and NHS funding during the COVID-19 pandemic. The statement discusses the Government's decision to maintain the corporation tax rate at 19% instead of reducing it to 17%, with the aim of balancing economic growth and public financial sustainability. The statement discusses the Finance Bill's provisions regarding car tax for the tax year 2020-21 onwards, including clauses related to determining appropriate percentages. The statement discusses changes to company car tax (CCT) rates and emissions testing procedures in the UK. Clause 10 exempts care leavers’ apprenticeship bursary payments from income tax. The statement addresses the issue of apprenticeships and their availability for young people during and after the coronavirus pandemic. The statement discusses an amendment to exempt all social security benefits from income tax, highlighting inconsistencies in the current system and questioning its complexity and fairness.
Action Requested
The amendment requests the Government to lay before Parliament a review within six months of Royal Assent, examining the effect on taxation revenue and on annual income for households below average income and high-net worth individuals as defined by HMRC.
Key Facts
- The amendment would require a Government review within six months of Royal Assent.
- The review must consider the impact on taxation revenue and different income levels.
- The review will examine effects on households below average income and high-net worth individuals.
- Income tax raised more than £190 billion in 2018-19.
- Clauses 2 and 3 set income tax rates at 20%, 40%, and 45% for basic, higher, and additional rates respectively.
- Clause 4 maintains the starting rate limit for savings at £5,000 for the 2020-21 tax year.
- Approximately 95% of savers will pay no tax on their savings income in 2020-21.
- The Resolution Foundation estimates GDP will contract between 10% and 24% due to the outbreak of covid-19.
- Over the past 10 years, the poorest 10% of households have lost 11% of their income since 2010; for households with children, this rises to 20%.
- Ethnic minority households will be more adversely affected by policy changes than white households, with an average loss above 5% of net income for black households, compared to about £1,000 for non-disabled families.
- The Finance Bill Committee met physically without remote options.
- There are concerns about health risks due to close contact during long meetings.
- The MP highlights longstanding economic inequalities affecting women, ethnic minorities, and disabled people.
- Amendments will be tabled focusing on equality, the environment, and fairness.
- Corporation tax rate has been maintained at 19%.
- The Government initially planned to reduce it further but backtracked.
- The current rate is lower than that of many advanced economies according to Resolution Foundation.
- Cutting corporation tax was intended to provide £6 billion for the NHS.
- There are concerns about the impact on Treasury revenues due to businesses struggling during the pandemic.
- Corporation tax rate remains at 19% instead of reducing to 17%.
- Clauses 5 and 6 of the Finance Bill legislate for this change in rate.
- Additional tax receipts forecasted to raise about £33 billion across the forecast period.
- R&D expenditure credit increased from 12% to 13%.
- Relief for business investment in non-residential structures and buildings increased from 2% to 3%.
- 15.8 million women are currently employed, a record high.
- Wages of the lowest earners have risen by 11% more than inflation over four years.
- The statement covers provisions for car tax in the Finance Bill for the tax year 2020-21 onwards.
- Clauses related to determining appropriate percentages for cars are under discussion.
- CCT rates will be extended until April 2025.
- WLTP is used for new cars first registered after April 6, 2020.
- There are around 900,000 company car drivers in the UK.
- The benefit raises approximately £2.3 billion per annum.
- NEDC procedure applies to cars first registered before April 6, 2020.
- Clause 10 exempts care leavers’ apprenticeship bursary payments from income tax.
- Care leavers aged 16 to 24 in England receive a £1,000 bursary for starting an apprenticeship.
- The clause ensures that care leavers can benefit by the full amount of the bursary without any deductions.
- Coronavirus could significantly affect the number of apprenticeships available.
- The minimum wage rate for apprenticeships is considered staggeringly low.
- The Government has been leaning into the issue through the levy.
- The amendment seeks to exempt all social security benefits from income tax.
- Exempting taxable social security benefits would cost around £5.9 billion in 2020-21, with 95% attributable to the state pension.
- Only new Scottish benefits that top up or replace an existing taxable benefit will be liable for tax under the fiscal framework agreement.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy