<-- Back to proposed bills

Parliamentary Constituencies Bill

02 June 2020

Proposing MP
Doncaster Central
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement discusses the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill aimed at updating and equalizing parliamentary constituencies by maintaining 650 seats. The statement addresses the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, which aims to update constituency boundaries for more equal representation. The statement discusses changes to the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill aimed at improving boundary review processes. The statement discusses the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its provisions regarding electoral quota tolerances and boundary reviews. Rosie Winterton is addressing concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its impact on constituency sizes and boundaries. Cat Smith discusses concerns about the accuracy of voter registration data due to the coronavirus crisis and urges the use of recent general election data from December 2019 for boundary reviews. The MP discusses aspects of the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, including the benefits of longer review cycles and concerns about executive power. The speaker discusses concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its impact on Scottish representation in the House of Commons. The speaker is discussing concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, particularly regarding the number of Scottish seats and the power to set electoral boundaries. The MP discusses the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and the need for a review of constituency boundaries. The MP discusses concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, focusing on the variance limit for constituency sizes and the lack of parliamentary oversight over boundary changes. Rosie Winterton is addressing the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and reducing the speaking time for subsequent speakers due to multiple interventions. Rosie Winterton discusses concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its potential impact on constituencies. The debate centres on the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, focusing on the variance percentage for constituency boundaries and concerns about splitting communities. The statement discusses the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill which aims to ensure fair representation through equal-sized constituencies. The MP supports the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill which aims to update and equalize parliamentary boundaries, ensuring every vote counts equally. The speaker discusses the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its impact on electoral boundaries, emphasizing transparency, public confidence in the process, and the importance of retaining parliamentary approval. Rosie Winterton discusses concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its impact on constituencies, community identity, and regional boundaries. The speaker discusses concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its impact on representation in Wales. The speaker discusses the need for more Members of Parliament to cover devolved areas and reviews the proposed changes to constituency boundaries under the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill. Rosie Winterton is discussing the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, focusing on issues of constituency equality and the impact of automatic boundary changes. The statement addresses support for the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and emphasizes the importance of equal representation and up-to-date data. Rosie Winterton discusses concerns about the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill, particularly regarding the impact on representation in devolved nations and the restrictive electoral tolerance. The statement discusses support for the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill which aims to equalise parliamentary boundaries and ensure that every vote counts equally. The statement discusses support for the Parliamentary Constituencies Bill and its implications on electoral fairness and stability.

Action Requested

The government proposes amending the existing legislation to retain 650 parliamentary constituencies, ending the 2018 boundary review without implementation, and ensuring regular, thorough, and impartial boundary reviews moving forward. The purpose is to reflect demographic changes and ensure each vote carries equal weight.

Key Facts

  • The Bill aims to deliver updated and equal parliamentary boundaries based on current demographics.
  • The last implemented update of Westminster constituencies was based on electoral data from the early 2000s.
  • There are 1.2 million extra people on the registers across all four nations since the last boundary review.
  • The Parliamentary Constituencies Bill aims to update constituency boundaries.
  • An eight-year boundary review cycle is proposed in the Bill.
  • The next boundary review timetable is slightly shortened by three months to two years and seven months.
  • The Bill improves the timing of public hearings during boundary reviews.
  • Boundary Commissions can now consider prospective local government boundaries formalised in legislation but not yet used in an election.
  • Orders in Council will automatically implement proposed constituencies without parliamentary debate or approval.
  • The permitted tolerance in electoral quota has been in place since 2011.
  • The current law allows four protected constituencies to diverge from the quota due to geographical circumstances.
  • Boundary commissions use a 10% tolerance range for constituency electorates.
  • Over 50% of proposals for constituencies in England were adjusted based on feedback during the most recent boundary review.
  • The Parliamentary Constituencies Bill aims to establish 650 equal and updated constituencies.
  • Two previous boundary reviews were shelved, costing £7 million for the 2013 review and an estimated £8 million for the 2018 review.
  • Winterton welcomes the Government's decision to retain 650 MPs instead of reducing them to 600.
  • The December 2019 register saw a spike in voter registration with over 1 million people registering.
  • Electoral returning officers are concerned about impacts of coronavirus on the December 2020 registers.
  • Using December 2020 data could delay boundary commissioners' work until May 2021.
  • The Bill gives boundary commissioners more flexibility to use local government and ward boundaries.
  • Labour welcomes the move to hold reviews every eight years.
  • Some changes proposed before the 1997 election were beneficial for certain MPs but detrimental to others.
  • The Isle of Wight argument resulted in two proposed seats previously.
  • The Bill proposes reviewing constituency boundaries.
  • Current constituencies have been unchanged since the speaker was 15 years old.
  • Some Scottish constituencies face a reduction of two or three seats based on proposed electoral quotas.
  • Rural Scotland faces significant travel challenges for MPs to conduct duties.
  • The Scottish Parliament has both constituency and regional Members.
  • Scotland would likely lose two or three seats based on current electoral quotas.
  • Clause 7 sets an enumeration date of December 2020 which may be outdated due to upcoming elections.
  • Clause 2(3) removes parliamentary procedure for boundary changes, transferring power to the Cabinet Office.
  • Moray's constituency has an electorate of over 71,000.
  • The last boundary change was made two decades ago when the speaker could not vote.
  • The Government proposes reviewing boundaries every eight years.
  • The Bill proposes a variance limit of plus/minus 5% for constituency sizes.
  • Concerns are raised about splitting long-established communities and eroding local identities due to narrow margin limits.
  • There is a push for parliamentary oversight over the boundary commissions' changes.
  • Use of electoral register from 1 December 2020 may lead to inaccuracies due to pandemic impacts, suggesting use of 2019 data instead.
  • The speaking time is reduced to four minutes after the next speaker.
  • The Bill aims to remove parliamentary scrutiny from boundary reviews.
  • Winterton is concerned that removing scrutiny could lead to detrimental changes.
  • London, which has seen population growth but low voter registration, may see a reduction in seats.
  • The Organisation for Security and Co-operation in Europe recommends a variance of 10%.
  • Building constituencies on wards leads to splitting communities due to ward sizes being too large.
  • In Leeds, eight constituencies exist with one seat covering only a third of the geographical area.
  • The Bill aims to resolve discrepancies in constituency sizes ranging from half as many voters in one town compared to another.
  • The difference between the smallest and largest constituencies is about the size of Leeds city (675,000 people).
  • A 10% electoral tolerance would give more flexibility to keep communities together within coherent boundaries.
  • The Conservative party manifesto pledged updated equal parliamentary boundaries.
  • The Bill maintains 650 seats instead of reducing to 600.
  • Historical and community ties are important in boundary reviews.
  • The electoral register being considered is from 20 years ago.
  • The Bill will create a new political map for the UK that will last through at least the next two general elections.
  • Using smaller building blocks like polling districts can help in creating constituencies based on actual towns and communities.
  • The Bill proposes reverting to 650 Members of Parliament.
  • There are concerns about strict adherence to numbers over community identity.
  • Regional boundaries affect constituency formation.
  • The proposals will likely see a reduction to about 31 seats in Wales.
  • The Electoral Reform Society Cymru is critical of the proposals.
  • The Senedd has faced a decade of cuts due to the current UK Government and coalition before.
  • The speaker supports increasing the number of parliamentary constituencies to 650.
  • Montgomeryshire, represented by the MP, is one of the largest geographical constituencies with a small electorate.
  • The Electoral Commission estimates up to 9 million potential electors are not on the electoral roll.
  • The Parliamentary Constituencies Act 1986 provides sparse directions to the Boundary Commission.
  • Basingstoke's population increased from 13,000 in the 1940s to 83,000 currently.
  • New Office for National Statistics data estimates six new constituencies will be generated in the south-east region of the UK.
  • The Parliamentary Constituencies Bill aims to provide clarity on national and local levels.
  • One person one vote is important but so is equality in representation.
  • There are significant variations in constituency sizes within Derbyshire, ranging from a deficit of 10,000 people to a surplus of nearly 9,000 people compared to the speaker's own constituency.
  • The Bill risks putting further strain on the integrity of the Union by reducing the number of parliamentary constituencies in devolved nations while increasing English seats.
  • The Government refused to compromise on a 5% electoral tolerance, which experts argue is restrictive and damaging.
  • Previous reviews based on an arbitrary number of 600 constituencies cost taxpayers £700 million.
  • Parliamentary Constituencies Bill aims to update and equalise parliamentary boundaries.
  • The Bill ensures that every vote counts equally on the basis of 650 constituencies.
  • There is a plus or minus 5% tolerance level for constituency sizes, effectively a total of 10% variation.
  • The two specific protected seats are small Scottish seats.
  • The government's programme aims to ensure equal weight for every vote across the United Kingdom.
  • Eight years is deemed the right amount of time for communities to be stable and for MPs to develop connections with their constituencies.
  • The amendment was negatived in a division, with 137 Ayes and 265 Noes.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy