<-- Back to proposed bills

Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill

18 May 2020

Proposing MP
Epping Forest
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

Eleanor Laing informs the House that Mr Speaker has not selected any of the reasoned amendments for the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill which aims to end free movement of people from the EU and establish a new points-based immigration system. The MP criticizes the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill for its proposed salary threshold of £25,600, arguing it devalues essential workers during a public health crisis. Eleanor Laing is discussing the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, which aims to end free movement of people from the EU. MP Stuart McDonald criticizes the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill for its negative impact on public health, economic recovery, and social justice. The statement addresses the balance between immigration control and welcoming essential skills needed in Britain, focusing on the NHS visa system and the rights of EEA nationals. The statement discusses the need to build a new consensus on immigration post-Brexit and criticizes the current Bill for not setting out a new system and extending the hostile environment. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill and its implications on immigration policy, particularly focusing on the treatment of illegal migrants in detention centres and the impact of the bill on key workers and the NHS. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, which aims to create a new points-based immigration system after Brexit. The statement discusses the UK's new points-based immigration system following Brexit, emphasizing its focus on attracting skilled workers and supporting economic growth in key sectors. The statement discusses opposition to the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, focusing on the complexities of immigration policy and the importance of having a flexible system that accounts for various factors such as business needs, job opportunities for British citizens, and social cohesion. The speaker discusses concerns over the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, particularly regarding its impact on EU citizens in key sectors like healthcare, and the potential negative effects on cultural industries such as live music. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, focusing on ending free movement for EU citizens and establishing a new immigration system that treats all foreign workers equally. The speaker discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, expressing disappointment with its approach to ending free movement without offering a fair alternative and frustration that it does not address current needs such as healthcare staff. Eleanor Laing addresses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, focusing on its implications for key workers and the health and social care sector during the pandemic. The statement addresses concerns over high levels of immigration and its impact on Britain's services and economy. The speaker criticises the UK's immigration rules and their impact on families. The statement addresses concerns about the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill. Eleanor Laing discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, which aims to replace the EU's free movement rules with a points-based system for immigration. The speaker opposes the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, arguing it undermines democracy and human rights. Eleanor Laing discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, addressing its aims to end free movement across borders and restore trust in the immigration system. The statement discusses concerns about the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, particularly its ambiguity and potential impact on various sectors of the economy. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill which aims to end free movement from the EU and establish a new points-based immigration system. The statement addresses concerns about the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, focusing on issues related to immigration control, rights for UK and Irish nationals, and the treatment of EU citizens post-Brexit. Eleanor Laing discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, which aims to establish a new points-based immigration system in the UK. The statement criticizes the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill for its negative impact on essential workers and migrants. The MP discusses the need for a controlled immigration system post-Brexit, addressing concerns about social care workers, NHS staff, and international students. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, focusing on its implications for immigration control and fairness. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, which aims to end free movement of people from the EU and establish a new points-based immigration system. The statement addresses concerns about the potential negative impacts of the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill on various sectors, including social care, hospitality, retail, and food processing, due to labour shortages caused by immigration policy changes. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill and its aim to create a fairer and more skilled-based immigration system. The statement discusses the negative impacts of ending free movement for EU citizens post-Brexit, particularly focusing on the economic and social contributions of migrant workers in Scotland. Rob Roberts discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, focusing on its role in creating a fairer and more modern immigration system that supports key industries and responds to labour market needs. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill which aims to implement a points-based immigration system and improve border security. The statement addresses concerns about the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill and its impact on migrant workers in healthcare and social care. The statement discusses the Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill, which aims to establish a new points-based immigration system for the UK post-Brexit. The statement discusses the voting process for the Second Reading of a Bill.

Action Requested

There is no specific action requested in this statement, as it is purely informative regarding the status of the bill's reasoned amendments.

Key Facts

  • Mr Speaker has not selected any of the reasoned amendments.
  • The Home Secretary is called to move Second Reading.
  • The Bill ends free movement from 1 January 2021.
  • EU settlement scheme has seen over 3.5 million applications, with over 1.3 million concluded.
  • Irish citizens will continue to have specific rights in the UK under common travel area arrangements.
  • A fast-track NHS visa is introduced for qualified staff needed during the pandemic.
  • £1.5 billion allocated for adult and children’s social care in this financial year.
  • Nick Thomas-Symonds is requested to speak.
  • The Bill contains nine clauses.
  • 69% of EU migrants working in the UK would be ineligible under the new visa rules.
  • 40,000 nursing vacancies exist in England's NHS.
  • An average care worker earns £19,104 annually.
  • There are 115,000 EU national workers in the care system.
  • The Bill aims to end free movement of people from the EU before the transition period ends on December 31, 2020.
  • There are concerns about processing delays in the settled status scheme and closed visa application centres due to the pandemic.
  • Small businesses need to become tier 2 sponsors by January or face inability to sponsor new employees.
  • The Bill is criticized for making it harder to recruit NHS and social care staff.
  • More than 100,000 NHS workers are prevented from sponsoring their families due to Home Office financial requirements.
  • Employers have less than four months to adapt to new immigration bureaucracy during a public health crisis.
  • The proposed NHS visa system is highlighted for its importance in addressing healthcare worker shortages.
  • There are over 3 million EEA nationals living legally in Britain with promised legal status protection.
  • British citizens living in the EU face issues securing their rights, as noted by the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster's letter to the European Commission.
  • The cost of a citizenship application in the UK is approximately £1,330, which is higher than other western nations such as Canada and Australia.
  • More than half of NHS and careworkers who died from coronavirus were born abroad.
  • The EU free movement rights end in December after Brexit happened in January.
  • A quarter of a million careworkers have come from abroad, with half from Europe.
  • The Government's White Paper proposes a £25,000 salary threshold for overseas workers.
  • Illegal migrants can be held indefinitely, with some detained for up to 1,002 days.
  • About 25,000 individuals are detained each year for immigration purposes.
  • Anna's story exemplifies human trafficking victims treated as criminals without due process.
  • The Bill aims to create a points-based immigration system.
  • Extending visas for frontline NHS workers is mentioned.
  • Concerns are raised about restrictions affecting careworkers and other low-paid essential workers.
  • Immigration is essential to culture, economy, and way of life in the UK.
  • The new system prioritizes skilled workers including scientists, doctors, nurses, engineers, academics, and innovators.
  • Wales has a high dependence on sectors such as steel and manufacturing with skill shortages within specific industries.
  • The Bill abolishes freedom of movement.
  • There are around 890,000 British nationals affected in the EU.
  • Ministers propose £25,600 as a proxy level for skill, which Abbott deems absurd.
  • The Bill does not address ending the NHS surcharge or no recourse to public funds system.
  • The Bill represents an important step in taking back control over immigration policy.
  • Factors considered include business needs, job opportunities for British citizens, obligations to refugees, housing market impact, and social cohesion.
  • The term 'low-skilled' is used across multiple Governments and political parties.
  • Three quarters of the speaker's constituents voted to remain in the EU.
  • The Government is concerned about Henry VIII powers granted by the Bill.
  • Organisations in the music industry are pressing for an EU-wide touring visa for musicians and their support staff.
  • Musicians earn on average £23,000 a year.
  • The Bill reflects concerns of the British people and ends free movement.
  • There will be no automatic route into the UK for foreign workers with few formal qualifications.
  • A single, consistent and firmer approach to criminality in the immigration system is introduced at the end of the transition period.
  • The Bill is seen as failing to protect rights of British citizens in EU member states.
  • Royal Society warns about loss of access to European skills and knowledge.
  • UK Government plans could make it harder for employers to hire needed workers.
  • 99% of applications under the EU settlement scheme have been granted settled or pre-settled status.
  • The Bill is seen as undermining public services, particularly health and social care.
  • Macmillan's analysis shows a detrimental effect on the health and social care system due to the proposed immigration policy.
  • Social care workers need clarity about specific measures to protect their workforce from the new immigration rules.
  • About 640,000 immigrants arrived in Britain last year.
  • The net figure of immigration was around 200,000.
  • Trevor Phillips stated that mass migration risks igniting racial conflict due to 'liberal self-delusion'.
  • Large-scale migration into low-skilled occupations has fivefold negative effects including displacement of investment in technology and holding down wage levels.
  • Families face restrictive income requirements of £18,600 per year plus additional amounts for each child.
  • The cost of immigration health surcharges is set to rise by over 50% in October.
  • Nine out of ten visa applications from Pakistan, India or Bangladesh are refused.
  • The UK has ended freedom of movement.
  • EU migrants contribute £2,300 more to the public purse each year than the average adult.
  • There are 25,000 people locked in detention without any limit for how long, only 37% were eventually deported.
  • Eleanor Laing voted to leave the EU.
  • The Bill aims to end discrimination against non-EU immigrants.
  • During the pandemic, NHS staff have come from overseas.
  • A points-based system will be used to decide who can live and work in the UK.
  • The Bill will provide guidance and support for small businesses during implementation.
  • The Bill is seen as flawed due to its timing during a global pandemic.
  • It includes extensive Henry VIII powers which allow retrospective changes to legislation.
  • The Windrush generation was retrospectively affected by similar policies in 2014.
  • The Bill fulfils pledges made to end free movement across borders.
  • It aims to restore trust in the UK's immigration system.
  • A points-based immigration system will mirror other countries of the free world.
  • Employers need sufficient notice to plan for seasonal labour and skill requirements.
  • The Bill is criticized for offering more questions than answers.
  • It does not address the situation for sectors such as care, construction, and creative industries post-coronavirus crisis.
  • The MP argues that immigration occurs when a country's labour market needs people to support an ageing population.
  • The Bill aims to end EU freedom of movement and establish a points-based immigration system.
  • The MP believes this will help restore public confidence in border control.
  • The Labour party is criticised for supporting open borders.
  • The Bill aims to control UK borders and end uncontrolled immigration.
  • Rights are reaffirmed for UK and Irish nationals to work, reside, and access benefits in each other’s jurisdictions.
  • Concerns are raised about amending the settlement scheme to allow dual citizenship for family members of British citizens.
  • The DUP supports a compassionate approach to refugees from countries affected by terrorism, war, or persecution.
  • The Immigration and Social Security Co-ordination (EU Withdrawal) Bill establishes a points-based immigration system.
  • Doctors and nurses from around the world will receive fast-track entry through the new NHS visa with three to five-year work visas.
  • Irish citizens will retain their current rights to live and work in the UK post-Brexit.
  • The Bill is criticised as not fit for purpose.
  • 43% of Leicester East residents were born outside the UK compared to 10% nationally.
  • A Health Service Journal study found that 66% of NHS workers who died from COVID-19 were not born in the UK.
  • The MP calls for guaranteeing indefinite leave to remain for family dependants of migrant NHS workers.
  • Over 100,000 hate crimes were reported in 2018.
  • The MP spoke about a woman from Zambia who had worked in the NHS for nine years but could not get settled status.
  • 3.5 million people have already applied for settled status under the scheme for EU nationals.
  • The MP supports fast-track visas and extensions for doctors, nurses, and health workers.
  • Universities are increasingly reliant on international student fees.
  • Income thresholds for immigration have been lowered from £30,000 to £25,600.
  • A seasonal worker visa is introduced for certain occupations such as farming.
  • Over 1.3 million European citizens have achieved settled status in the UK.
  • The Bill includes Henry VIII powers which allow for significant changes to immigration rules without parliamentary oversight.
  • Labour Members are described as unwilling to address the concerns of communities that they took for granted.
  • Migrants play a critical role in healthcare and social care during the coronavirus crisis.
  • The Bill delivers on the commitment made during the Brexit referendum to end free movement of people.
  • It establishes a framework for a new points-based immigration system that is fair, robust, and adaptable to economic needs.
  • The current debate reflects changing attitudes towards immigration since the 2016 referendum.
  • Home Office figures reveal that at the end of March, 493,800 applications to the EU settlement scheme for children had been received.
  • Only 11% of looked-after children have secured status according to the Children’s Society.
  • The ruling in the High Court on May 7th stated that denying families access to welfare safety net breaches Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
  • The Bill aims to deliver a more measured approach to immigration reflecting the will of Stoke-on-Trent North's voters.
  • Immigrants contribute significantly to the economy, society, and culture.
  • Visa extensions were announced for those seeking employment in the NHS during the pandemic.
  • Applicants for the NHS visa receive reduced fees and fast-tracking with increased points.
  • The Bill simplifies processes for workers in understaffed sectors.
  • A fast-track visa route is being implemented for elite researchers and specialists in STEM fields.
  • The Scottish pension-age population is growing while the working-age population declines.
  • EU nationals add £10,400 to government revenue and over £34,000 to GDP each year in Scotland.
  • John Ross Jr's company relies heavily on staff from Poland, Latvia, Czech Republic, and Estonia.
  • The UK is a leader in banking, pharmaceuticals, and research and development.
  • Non-EU net migration has reached its highest level since 2004.
  • The Bill includes provisions for an NHS visa and specialist fast-track visas for doctors and nurses.
  • The Bill introduces a points-based immigration system.
  • Dover is fewer than 21 miles away from France.
  • People traffickers can charge up to £4,000 to bring individuals into the UK illegally.
  • The NHS relies on 29% of doctors working in hospitals and 12% of overall health care workers being from overseas.
  • Four out of five employees from EEA countries working full time in social care would be ineligible to work under the £25,600 salary threshold proposed by the government.
  • NHS trusts had to pay just short of £163,000 in immigration skills charges in the last financial year.
  • The Bill is a framework for a single global points-based migration system.
  • The Migration Advisory Committee's key recommendations include reducing the general salary threshold from £30,000 to £25,600 and moving the skills threshold from degree to A-level.
  • Over 3.5 million applications have been received through the European settlement scheme with more than 3 million decisions made.
  • Remote voting period has now finished.
  • The House divided: Ayes 351, Noes 252.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy