<-- Back to proposed bills
Agriculture Bill - Sitting 9
03 March 2020
Type
Public Bill Committee
At a Glance
Issue Summary
The statement discusses the Agriculture Bill's Clause 9 and 11, addressing modifications to the basic payment scheme and the phasing out of direct payments. The statement discusses the power to make de-linked payments under the Agriculture Bill, which removes the requirement for farmers to farm land in order to receive payments. The statement addresses concerns about the de-linking of direct payments from farming activities under the Agriculture Bill, focusing on the potential negative impacts on farmers during the transition period. The statement discusses amendments to the Agriculture Bill regarding de-linked payments and lump sum options for farmers during the transition from direct payments under the Common Agricultural Policy. The statement discusses amendments to Clause 17 of the Agriculture Bill to change the reporting frequency for UK food security from every five years to annually. The MP discusses concerns about food security and self-sufficiency in the UK post-Brexit, highlighting the need for stronger measures in the Agriculture Bill. MP Graham Stringer is proposing amendments to include considerations of global resource sustainability and food poverty in the Agriculture Bill. The MP is discussing missed opportunities to strengthen clause 17 of the Agriculture Bill regarding food insecurity reporting. MPs discuss the inclusion of global food security and household food insecurity indicators in a report related to the Agriculture Bill. The statement addresses the issue of food insecurity in the UK and proposes an amendment to ensure consistent measurement and reporting on food insecurity trends. The statement discusses the proposed amendment to enshrine household food insecurity measurement and reporting in law, expanding the definition of food security beyond global availability. Daniel Zeichner discusses concerns regarding clause 22 of the Agriculture Bill, focusing on data collection and anonymity issues within the agri-food supply chain. The Minister is addressing concerns about the scope and implications of data collection requirements under Clause 22 of the Agriculture Bill.
Action Requested
The government plans to simplify the current basic payment scheme by removing unnecessary bureaucracy and intends to introduce minor simplifications in 2020. For future years, they aim to further simplify the rules for the 2021 scheme and reduce farmers' payments starting in 2021 with higher reductions initially applied to higher payment bands.
Key Facts
- Clause 9 provides power to modify legislation governing the basic payment scheme.
- The government plans minor simplifications in 2020, including removing paperwork for young farmer schemes.
- Reductions to direct payments will start in 2021 with maximum reductions set for higher payment bands.
- The clause provides the Secretary of State with the power to make regulations to enable de-linked payments in England.
- De-linked payments will replace the basic payment scheme for all farmers in England once introduced.
- Alternative enforcement mechanisms will be introduced before direct payments are de-linked.
- Clause 13 outlines a seven-year agricultural transition period during which direct payments will be phased out.
- Amendment 74 would make receipt of lump sum de-linked payments conditional on transitioning to more sustainable farming practices or making land available for new entrants.
- The Government has proposed offering farmers the option of taking a one-off lump sum payment, subject to affordability considerations.
- De-linked payments will replace the basic payment scheme for all farmers in England.
- Clause 12 introduces de-linked payments during the agricultural transition period.
- Clause 13 provides regulations allowing farmers to opt for a one-off lump sum payment.
- Lump sums are intended to help older farmers retire and new entrants acquire land.
- Amendment 7 seeks to change 'five years' to 'year' in Clause 17.
- The original amendment was tabled by Fiona Bruce.
- Stakeholders and previous Bill Committee members warned about the lack of food security provisions.
- The UK produces only 61% of its own food today, down from 74% around 30 years ago.
- An adviser suggested that the UK should follow Singapore's example in agriculture, which is seen as concerning by the MP.
- There is cross-party support for amending the Agriculture Bill to produce annual reports on food security instead of every five years.
- Amendment 75 proposes adding consideration for global resource sustainability.
- Amendment 76 seeks to include reporting on food poverty and progress towards the UN SDG 2.
- Amendment 75 would help with specifying food security targets.
- The Environmental Audit Committee’s January 2019 report highlighted significant food insecurity in the UK.
- There are now more food banks than McDonald’s outlets in the UK.
- Amendment 75 relates to including indicators on global food security in the report.
- Amendment 76 focuses on reporting on household food insecurity as part of the UN sustainable development goals.
- The Government plans to use a range of statistics, from global UN data to UK national statistics for the report.
- Amendment 62 aims to give certainty about measuring household food insecurity.
- The first data on food insecurity will be available in 2021.
- The amendment would require yearly reports on food insecurity trends and actions to address it.
- Amendment 62 would enshrine household food insecurity measurement and reporting in law.
- The amendment expands the definition of food security to include access to affordable food.
- The Government's commitment does not ensure continuous future measurements or parliamentary scrutiny.
- Daniel Zeichner runs the all-party parliamentary group on data analytics.
- The House of Commons Library briefing suggests that data would normally be published in anonymised form.
- There is concern about tracing data back to individuals despite anonymity efforts.
- The clause aims to provide clarity on who might be required to provide information related to agriculture and food safety.
- A draft proposal must first be sent to all relevant parties before data requirements are imposed.
- Supply chain members have at least four weeks to notify the Secretary of State if they disagree with a data request.
- The clause allows for data collection from actors potentially far removed from the farm gate under certain circumstances.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy