<-- Back to proposed bills

High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill: Revival

02 March 2020

Proposing MP
Epping Forest
Type
Bill Debate

At a Glance

Issue Summary

The statement addresses the revival of the High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill, also known as phase 2a of HS2. Andy McDonald is discussing the High Speed 2 (HS2) rail project, addressing concerns about costs, governance, transparency, environmental impact, and the need for public support. Bill Cash is seeking assurances from the Minister regarding the review of phase 2a of the High Speed Rail project along with phase 2b. The statement discusses the High Speed Rail (HS2) project and its benefits for the West Midlands region, particularly Crewe. The statement discusses opposition to the High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill and highlights issues related to compensation claims and unresolved negotiations for affected constituents. Eleanor Laing addresses concerns regarding the High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill and its impact on constituents in her constituency. The statement addresses the High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill and discusses commitments to oversight and control of the HS2 programme, including phase 2a. Eleanor Laing is addressing concerns and benefits related to the High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill, including compensation timelines and cost estimates.

Action Requested

The motion seeks to revive the Bill by allowing it to pass through all its stages in the current session and move to the House of Lords for further consideration. This ensures that progress already made is preserved and allows affected parties to continue legal processes with pending changes intact.

Key Facts

  • The High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill, also known as phase 2a of HS2, extends the railway from Birmingham to Crewe.
  • Over 300 petitions were received during the Select Committee stage, leading to two additional provisions being promoted and agreed upon in spring 2019.
  • Siemens is investing £250 million to establish a new rail factory in Goole.
  • HS2 costs have risen from £57 billion to £80 billion and are rumoured to exceed £100 billion.
  • Carillion received a valuable HS2 contract despite its financial difficulties.
  • The Oakervee review recommends HS2 as an integrated part of the railway system, extending to northern cities and Scotland.
  • Phase 1 of HS2 received Royal Assent in February 2017 but has not progressed due to budget issues.
  • The proposed phase 2a is estimated to cost £6.6 billion.
  • Sir John Armitt will review phase 2b with terms of reference already provided.
  • Phase 2a would connect HS2 to the west coast main line further north at Blakenhall, south of Crewe.
  • The motion seeks revival of the High Speed Rail (West Midlands - Crewe) Bill.
  • Crewe is a railway town with significant expertise in the rail industry.
  • HS2 is expected to create thousands of skilled jobs in Crewe during construction.
  • Network Rail estimates that delivering capacity increases through weekend closures would take almost 30 years and result in less benefit than HS2.
  • The cost of HS2 is approximately £4.4 billion per year over two decades.
  • Network Rail spends around £6 billion annually on maintaining and upgrading the rail network.
  • Mr and Mrs Tabernor have been waiting years for a resolution regarding their farmhouse demolition.
  • Ingestre Park Golf Club has not received a reasonable agreement from HS2 after five years of negotiations.
  • House sales in Hopton, Marston and Yarlet are in limbo due to unresolved compensation claims.
  • The Prime Minister acknowledged the need for compensation payment and an overhaul of HS2 Ltd's management.
  • HS2 is facing opposition due to inadequate compensation and delays.
  • Laing supports the Government's infrastructure plans but emphasizes the need for immediate resolution of issues affecting her constituents.
  • She seeks assurance on delivering promised compensation to residents impacted by HS2.
  • The Prime Minister has committed to getting a firm grip on the HS2 project.
  • An additional £500 million Beeching reversal fund has been officially launched.
  • The Government intends to invest heavily in bringing back rail routes and stations across all parts of the UK.
  • The Prime Minister stated on 11 February that treatment of people and communities by HS2 Ltd must improve.
  • Landowners are required to receive 90% of HS2 Ltd’s valuation within three months of receiving a claim or date of possession, whichever is later.
  • The latest cost estimate for the full network is between £72 billion and £98 billion in 2019 prices.
  • The Government is spending £48 billion between 2019 and 2024 on the conventional rail network.
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy